Small Hands, Big Ideas: Exploring Nurturing Care Through Beatrice Alemagna’s “What is a Child?”

2.3.1 Thematic analysis

The analysis began with the development of a framework for thematic classification. Keywords and phrases associated with each domain were curated based on foundational texts, perinatal care guidelines, and literature on early childhood development. To ensure comprehensive coverage, two AI tools were used to expand the keyword list, identifying synonyms and related terms to capture variations in language and context: ChatGPT o1 (OpenAI 2024) and Claude 3.5 Sonnet (Anthropic 2024). Forum responses were then scanned for the presence of these keywords, and each response was assigned to one or more themes based on keyword occurrence, as described in (Claudia Ravaldi et al. 2023). The process was repeated independently using both AI platforms to validate consistency, achieving 100% concordance across iterations.

2.3.2 Quantitative analysis

Thematic scores were then calculated by counting the frequency of keywords for each response, and these scores were normalized by expressing keyword occurrences per 1,000 words to account for variations in response length. Aggregated scores for each theme were then analyzed to generate insights into the distribution and emphasis of the nurturing care domains. Two complementary metrics were used: proportional representation, which compared the total keyword occurrences for each theme to the overall keyword count, and normalized density, which highlighted the prevalence of thematic content across responses.Quantitative data analysis was conducted using Stata BE 18 (StataCorp) after anonymizing and importing the forum responses, which were downloaded from the Moodle LMS platform (moodle.org). Categorical data were reported as frequencies and percentages and compared using the chi-squared test, while continuous data were reported as mean values with standard deviations (SD) or medians [quartiles] and compared using t-tests or Kruskal-Wallis and Dunn tests for non-parametric comparisons, with statistical significance set at p < 0.05. Open-ended responses were coded and categorized using MAXQDA 2018, linking thematic categories to their corresponding nurturing care domains, and these quantified scores were integrated with the qualitative themes to identify patterns and variations. Data visualization, including proportional representations and normalized densities, was conducted using Tableau Desktop 2024.3 and Stata BE 18, offering a comprehensive view of the thematic emphasis within the dataset.

3.1.a The Power of Metaphors in Conveying Complex Ideas

The poetic and metaphorical language of What is a Child? emerged as a central feature in the forum discussions, with participants reflecting on how its vivid imagery and evocative style facilitated the understanding of complex caregiving concepts. The metaphors employed in the book were not merely illustrative but acted as bridges between abstract theoretical ideas and the lived experiences of caregiving. These reflections underscore the potential of metaphors to translate nuanced aspects of nurturing care into accessible and impactful tools for both professional and personal growth. Participants frequently emphasized how specific imagery in the book resonated deeply on both intellectual and emotional levels. The phrase “gentle eyes,” for example, stood out as a succinct yet profound encapsulation of responsive caregiving. One participant explained:

"Alemagna writes, ‘children’s ideas are sometimes huge (…) they make their mouths open wide and say AH,’ but also, ‘children want to be listened to with wide-open eyes,’ and ‘to console them, gentle eyes are needed.’ These phrases reflect the creation of a climate of trust and listening, where the child feels welcomed and encouraged to express themselves."

This metaphor was widely interpreted as a call to action for caregivers to embody a mindful and attentive presence. The participant reflecting on this metaphor connected it directly to their daily practice, emphasizing the importance of moving beyond routine caregiving tasks to prioritize relational and emotional dimensions. By fostering a space where children feel seen and heard, caregivers can cultivate a sense of safety and encouragement that supports both immediate and long-term developmental outcomes. Other metaphors elicited reflections on the emotional and physical safety central to nurturing care. One participant explained:

"We also find attention to children’s physical environments in the phrase ‘children have small things, just like them: a small bed, small colorful books, a small umbrella,’ which reflects adults’ consideration for children and their need for objects suited to their size."

This observation highlights the duality of caregiving as both a practical and emotional endeavor. While the original metaphor stems from a physical representation of comfort, participants connected it to broader concepts of safety and nurturing. This emphasis on creating supportive environments is particularly relevant in contexts of vulnerability, where physical and emotional security are paramount. The forum also revealed that metaphors acted as “emotional mirrors,” prompting participants to introspect about their own caregiving experiences. For example, one participant noted:

"Children are like sponges. They absorb everything: nervousness, bad ideas, the fears of others. They seem to forget, but then it resurfaces in their school bags, under the covers, or in front of a book."

This reflection connects directly to the principles of responsive caregiving and self- regulation, demonstrating how metaphors can facilitate a deeper awareness of the caregiver’s role not just in action but in emotional presence.

Metaphors therefore transcended their textual origins to become tools for professional reflection. By linking abstract concepts to tangible images and personal experiences, the book helped participants reframe their understanding of nurturing care. This capacity to evoke reflection through metaphor was particularly significant in enabling professionals to connect theoretical principles with their own caregiving practices, thereby enhancing their ability to provide holistic and empathetic care.

3.1.b Collective Care and the Role of the Community

The forum discussions underscored the importance of collective care, revealing how professionals interpreted caregiving as a shared responsibility. This theme aligns with the principle that "it takes a village to raise a child," a concept central to nurturing care frameworks (C. Ravaldi 2024). Participants reflected on how the illustrations and text of What is a Child? highlighted the interconnectedness of caregivers and their communities, prompting a re-evaluation of caregiving as a collaborative endeavor rather than an individual task. One participant wrote:

"Parents also need support in facing parenthood, as can happen with those children described in the book as ‘difficult, unbearable, (…) who break plates, bowls, and everything else.’ Parents too need a caregiver to support them through responsive care in this journey, so that they, in turn, can do the same for the child."

This insight illustrates a paradigm shift for many professionals, who often work within systems that emphasize individual responsibility in caregiving. In this case, the book acted as a catalyst for recognizing the broader relational networks that contribute to a child’s development, including extended family, peers, and community support structures. The participant’s reflection also emphasizes the duality of caregiving, where supporting the parent is equally essential for fostering the child’s well-being. This perspective is particularly relevant in the context of perinatal care, where the burden on primary caregivers—often mothers—is disproportionately high, leading to burnout and reduced caregiving efficacy. By highlighting the need for caregivers to be cared for themselves, the discussion reframes caregiving as a reciprocal and collective endeavor. Another participant expanded on this notion:

"A child who grows without us noticing gives me the sense that someone sufficiently competent was there to ensure their growth wasn’t made difficult or burdensome."

This reflection underscores the critical role of caregivers in providing consistent and competent support, enabling children to thrive without undue stress or obstacles. Participants emphasized that this form of caregiving often requires a network of relationships, including family members, educators, and peers, working collaboratively to support the child. This insight aligns with the nurturing care framework’s emphasis on creating environments where children feel secure and supported in their development. Discussions revealed that professional settings often neglect the broader relational networks that influence caregiving outcomes, focusing instead on the immediate caregiver-child dyad. Participants noted that fostering a collaborative approach, involving extended family and community resources, could significantly enhance caregiving practices, particularly in resource-constrained environments. Such reflections highlight the importance of creating not only a direct bond between caregiver and child but also a wider ecosystem of care, ensuring that children receive the comprehensive support necessary for their growth and well-being.

The relational focus of What is a Child? also invited introspection about participants’ roles within these caregiving ecosystems. Several professionals commented on the need to model collaborative practices in their own work, creating environments where both families and caregivers feel supported. Discussions frequently returned to the metaphorical "village," which participants viewed as essential not only for children but for caregivers themselves. One professional shared:

"It is a well-established truth that ‘to raise a child, it takes a village.’ Children change, just as the world of a woman, a man, a couple, or a caregiver is literally turned upside down as they face the new reality of parenthood. They should be guaranteed the opportunity to invest their efforts in a way that is sustainable for them."

This reflection highlights a critical dimension of collective care: the well-being of the caregivers themselves. Participants discussed how their own professional networks—or lack thereof—shaped their capacity to deliver nurturing care. The forum thus became a space for mutual support, as participants shared strategies for building and sustaining their own "villages."

Finally, the discussions touched on systemic barriers to collective caregiving, such as cultural expectations, economic constraints, and policy gaps. While the book inspired idealistic visions of interconnected caregiving, participants acknowledged the practical challenges of implementing these ideals. As one participant noted:

"It is also necessary to promote good healthcare and efficient access to the services needed. The book mentions ’children with glasses, in wheelchairs, with braces on their teeth,’ highlighting how not everyone has the same opportunities for adequate care, creating significant inequalities."

These discussions around collective care revealed the book’s transformative potential to inspire reflections on caregiving networks, both personal and professional. By reframing caregiving as a shared responsibility, the book challenged participants to envision more inclusive and supportive systems, while also acknowledging the barriers that remain. This theme underscores the importance of integrating relational and community-based approaches into the nurturing care framework, highlighting both opportunities and challenges for systemic change.

3.1.c Understanding the Temporality of Care

Forum discussions revealed deep reflections on the temporality of care, a concept explored in What is a Child? through its dual emphasis on children as "complete in the moment" while simultaneously "constantly evolving." This temporal duality emerged as particularly significant for understanding how nurturing care principles adapt across developmental stages. The book’s treatment of temporality prompted participants to reflect on three key dimensions: individual developmental rhythms, intergenerational impact and the dynamic nature of caregiving. Some participants emphasized how the text encouraged recognition of each child’s unique developmental pace:

"The importance of time in child development and growth: each is a small human being with their own needs and pace, unique and different, which caregivers must respect and support without forcing, while constantly providing guidance and support.”

This reflection emphasizes the book’s ability to prompt consideration of individualized care approaches that honor each child’s developmental trajectory. The text also sparked consideration of how present care shapes future outcomes. As one participant observed:

"Children who decide not to grow up will never grow. They will have a mystery within them. Even as adults they will be moved by small things: a ray of sunshine or a snowflake.”

This observation highlights how early experiences influence lifelong emotional patterns, emphasizing the long-term implications of nurturing care. Finally, participants also reflected on how caregiving itself evolves over time:

"A child grows without us even noticing… slowly and silently, their body lengthens. A child is not a child forever.

One day they will change.”

This insight underscores how caregiving must adapt responsively to children’s changing needs while maintaining consistency in core nurturing principles. These discussions revealed how the book’s treatment of temporality helped professionals conceptualize nurturing care as both anchored in the present moment and oriented toward future development - a perspective that enriches understanding of how to implement responsive care across the developmental continuum.

3.1.d Fostering Transformative Dialogue

Forum discussions highlighted how What is a Child? encouraged parents and caregivers to reflect on their own emotions, past experiences, and caregiving practices. The evocative text and illustrations fostered a process of self-awareness, helping professionals and families alike to better understand the relational dynamics at play in caregiving. One participant shared:

"Children might pretend not to notice ’the parent’s tears in the shower,’ but they can perceive distress, sensing that something is wrong. It’s important to guide and support them in their growth, which is not only physical but also psychological."

Another noted:

"Browsing through the pages of this book, parents are confronted with situations they experienced and that their child is living in the present. This process stimulates awareness, helping them see their child for who they are, without projecting dreams and desires that belong to their own childhood."

Participants emphasized the need for empathy and emotional attunement, where the parent or caregiver becomes an active participant in the child’s developmental journey. The book’s narrative depth facilitated this process by enabling parents to revisit their childhoods and acknowledge how their past influences their caregiving. One professional reflected:

"The greatest value of this book is its ability to stimulate, on a preconscious level, a reworking of one’s own past. This helps the parent to emotionally attune to the child, creating a connection that makes caregiving more rewarding and fulfilling."

These reflections illustrate how storytelling can foster a deeper connection between parents and children, bridging gaps in understanding and creating spaces for mutual growth and healing. The book served as both a mirror and a guide, prompting adults to engage in a transformative process of self-discovery and emotional resonance with the children in their care.

Metaphorical understanding

The metaphorical language employed in "What is a Child?" serves as a bridge between theoretical knowledge and practical application. Research indicates that metaphor plays a crucial role in professional learning, particularly in fields such as healthcare where complex concepts must be understood and applied in real-world contexts. Several authors emphasize the importance of narrative techniques in enhancing understanding and engagement among learners, suggesting that metaphorical imagery can facilitate deeper cognitive connections. Research indicates that narrative techniques can significantly improve learners’ engagement and comprehension in educational contexts, particularly in health-related fields (Carrington, Allen, and Osmolowski 2007). Additionally, studies have shown that narratives in health promotion can enhance communication of knowledge and behavioral modeling, thereby fostering engagement and understanding (Kreuter et al. 2007). Building on this, the forum discussions surrounding the book revealed that metaphors like "gentle eyes" and children as "sponges" not only fostered personal reflection but also transformed theoretical concepts into actionable insights. This reflects the broader educational potential of metaphorical understanding, as emphasized by several authors, who highlight how structured narratives and symbolic imagery can facilitate the transfer of abstract knowledge into practical contexts (Romanchuk et al. 2023). Such approaches also resonate with findings on the effectiveness of narrative- based learning in promoting ethical understanding, bridging the gap between theory and practice in professional development contexts (Mawasi et al. 2022).

Visual-narrative engagement

The combination of visual and textual elements in "What is a Child?" created multiple entry points for professional learning. The quantitative analysis shows that different professional groups engaged preferentially with different aspects of the narrative—medical professionals focusing more on physical health representations (20.8% of their responses) while psychologists emphasized relational elements (21.0% of responses). However, the visual elements often prompted professionals to expand beyond their typical domain focus, supporting a more holistic understanding. Research indicates that visual literacy plays a crucial role in professional development, enabling practitioners to interpret and utilize visual information effectively in their practice (Zayeb, Aleidan, and Ali 2024). The book’s visual metaphors particularly supported engagement with complex concepts around safety and security (20.0% of total themes). As one participant observed: "The illustrations of ’small things for small people’ helped me understand environmental safety not just as physical protection but as emotional containment." This suggests that visual narratives can enhance understanding of abstract caregiving concepts, reinforcing the effectiveness of visual metaphors in professional learning environments.

Collaborative meaning-making

The forum discussions demonstrated how shared engagement with picture books can foster interprofessional dialogue and learning. The analysis shows that when discussing the same visual or textual elements, different professional groups often contributed complementary perspectives, enriching collective understanding. This aligns with research on the value of shared reading experiences in professional development, which highlights the importance of collaborative learning in healthcare settings (Jentoft 2021). Expert commentary from moderators often highlighted these moments of cross-professional insight. For example, when different professionals discussed the "sponge" metaphor, their diverse perspectives combined to create a more comprehensive understanding of child development. This suggests that picture books can serve as effective platforms for interprofessional education, facilitating dialogue and collaborative meaning-making among various healthcare professionals (Zaher et al. 2022).