Experiences of psycho-oncological counselling to support mental health in South Australians diagnosed with cancer

1.1 Purpose/objectives

Despite sustained investment in cancer prevention, education, support and treatment, more than a million Australians are either receiving treatment, or have survived cancer, with 150,000 diagnosed with cancer annually.¹ Living with cancer presents multiple psychosocial challenges to patients and people in their supporting relationships.^2–5 Influential psychosocial care considerations during the cancer journey include experiencing fear, anxiety, and depression, fatigue, pain, or cognitive impairment, sexual dysfunction, social isolation, or employment and financial issues.³ Among these considerations, mental health features prominently, with a 32% prevalence of psychological conditions in cancer patients.⁶

Beyond improving quality of life generally, psychosocial care promotes treatment compliance, reduces or prevents anxiety and depression symptoms, and helps patients manage their diagnosis and its consequences.⁶ Programs designed to support patients managing the psychosocial sequelae of cancer are increasingly available, with counselling-based interventions linked with improved coping, quality of life, and distress alleviation.^{7, 8} Despite being broadly implemented, and current evidence supporting efficacy and satisfaction of psycho-oncological support groups, research focusing on individual psycho-oncological counselling remains scarce, even in the context of patient-oriented medicine.^9–12 Individual psychological support can be more appropriate for people who prefer one-on-one support, or who have limited capacity (or comfort) to participate in structured group sessions. The benefits of individual therapy, compared to support groups, are largely unreported from perspectives of cancer patients, highlighting a key knowledge gap in psycho-oncological care.⁹

Cancer patients emphasise that as the diagnosis restructures their life, they expect counselling to help with managing new problematic situations, and their capacity to express support needs to professional caregivers.⁷ In one case of a crisis and supportive counselling service, focusing on these needs helped meet support expectations for 84% of clients.⁷ Similarly, evaluation of individual outpatient psycho-oncological counselling identified four factors that shape patients’ experience: distress management, service access challenges, service benefits, and the therapeutic encounters.⁸ However, by focusing on early counselling phases only⁸, rather than the completed experience,⁷ we are offered an incomplete picture of client perceptions of psycho-oncological support services.

Pairing qualitative and quantitative description of client support experiences further builds this picture through measuring mental health changes associated with service access. Studies show the need to record baseline mental health indicators of distress, anxiety, and depression, though can neglect to re-assess post-intervention indicators.¹³ The crucial role of psycho-oncological counselling is supported by a large randomised multisite trial for cancer patients with major depression. Patients who received individual psycho-oncological counselling in conjunction with oncological care reported significantly improved mental health and quality of life, with eight-times greater the likelihood (AOR=8.5, 95%CI5.5-13.4) of halved depression symptoms at 24 weeks if receiving counselling.¹⁴ At 12-months post-counselling, this included lower depression, anxiety, pain, and fatigue, and significantly improved quality of life.¹⁴ As cancer patients present with symptoms ranging beyond depression, counselling services need to encompass a variety of causes and levels of distress.

1.2 Psycho-oncological counselling service

The Psycho-oncological Counselling Service (PCS) available via Cancer Council South Australia supports people directly or indirectly affected by cancer, including patients, partners, carers, family, friends, and colleagues. It is accessed by calling an information line (13 11 20) and requesting or being referred to the PCS. Counselling is offered at any cancer stage, at diagnosis, during and after treatment, to advanced cancer care, bereavement, and survivorship. One-hour counselling sessions are provided free of charge in-person or as telehealth sessions (e.g., telephone, videocall).

Confidential counselling sessions provide support strategies in multiple domains: 1) managing negative thoughts; 2) understanding and expressing emotions helpfully; 3) identifying and clarifying necessary decisions and choices; 4) communicating with family and friends about concerns; 5) finding new ways to manage stress, set goals and achievement strategies; and 6) discussing realistic hope support in managing grief. The PCS is staffed by qualified counsellors eligible for Australian Psychological Society, Australian Association of Social Workers, or Psychotherapy and Counselling Federation of Australia membership. Given the important role of the PCS in South Australia’s psycho-oncological care ecosystem, its regular evaluation is essential to ensuring that high-quality supportive counselling is available.

1.3 Aims

This study aimed to describe perceptions of clients accessing community psycho-oncological counselling designed for people directly or indirectly affected by cancer, and to describe changes in clients perceived psychological distress, depression, and anxiety from pre-to post-counselling. It was anticipated that counselling supports positive mental health, and that changes in these indicators would be seen. The study also classified PCS users to identify which aspects of the service contributed to its effectiveness.

2.1 Participants

Study involvement was open to all clients referred to the counselling service between 01/12/2018 and 31/03/2020. Overall, 115 participants were recruited prior to their first appointment, of which 28 participants (82% female) completed post-counselling follow-up measures. Attrition is noted in the discussion, though responders and non-responders were similar in gender, client type and cancer type, and the number of counselling sessions attended. However, non-responders were significantly younger and reported significantly higher initial distress, compared to the responder group (Table 1).

Prior to counselling, clients were administered the Distress Thermometer, and the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) by the counsellor. The distress thermometer, a single item that screens patients for distress level, rated from 0 (no distress) to 10 (extreme distress), has been extensively used with oncology patient populations.^{15, 16} The HADS, is a 14-item self-report screening tool for assessing emotional distress, state anxiety and depression in clinical and non-clinical populations, with sound psychometric properties in detecting anxiety and depression.^{17, 18} Items are scored on a four-point scale with total scores per subscale ranging from zero to twenty-one, with higher scores indicating higher levels of anxious of depressive state. After their final session, participants received a mailed paper copy or emailed link to the follow-up survey measures including the distress thermometer and HADS, and qualitative prompts from previous research.⁷ Developed to describe cancer patients’ perceived outcomes of a counselling service, this 25-item 15- minute survey focused on prior expectations, perceived benefits, and outcomes achieved by attending the service⁷ (Appendix A).

2.2 Procedure

Research ethics approval was obtained from the Cancer Council Victoria Human Research Ethics Committee (CCVIC HREC: 1808). On first contacting Cancer Council SA Information Service, and having study involvement described to them, participants completed separate verbal informed consent for participation prior to referral to the PCS. The study process was modelled on a Cancer Council SA evaluation. Information Service nurses informed clients of the ongoing study and the process for collecting information via a script. A distress thermometer reading was also recorded, to control for the natural variation in symptomatic distress between initial call with the nurses and the first counselling appointment.

Demographic information, recorded by nurses to a client database, was extracted for those clients who consented to participate. Data were collected in this way to minimise participant and counsellor burden. At their first counselling session, participants were reminded of the study, and the distress thermometer and HADS were administered.

Following the final counselling session (as identified by their counsellors), participants completed post-counselling measures either in the room once the counsellor had departed, or by return mail to the researchers. The 25-item post-counselling survey took 15 minutes to complete

2.5 Data analysis

Descriptive data analysis included the use of frequencies, chi-square, and paired sample t- tests. Analyses were conducted only on cases with complete data for target variables, and this was done using SPSS v.23. Thematic analysis of qualitative data was conducted using a realist approach to report participant experiences and meanings as described. This followed open and axial coding of brief open-ended responses using a custom Excel worksheet.¹⁹ Qualitative analysis followed Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative research guidelines.

3.1 Participant demographics

Table 1 shows participants were mostly female, averaged 50-60 years of age, and predominately cancer patients (responders=67.9%, non-responders=51.7%) or family members (responders=17.9%, non-responders=27.6%). Participants averaged over 2 counselling sessions, primarily relating to breast (responders=35.7%, non-responders=19.5%%) or bowel (responders=10.7%, non-responders=17.2%) cancer types.

3.2 Mental health indicators

Changes in state distress, depression, anxiety, and overall mental health impairment were assessed via HADS scores. Participants reported significantly lower general distress following receipt of counselling sessions through the counselling service, a result which was not affected by the number of sessions completed: 1 session (M±SD=4.9±3.1), 2-3 sessions (M±SD=2.3±2.1), or 4+ (M±SD=3.1±2.3) (F(2, 25) = 2.45, p = .109).

3.3 Supportive conversations

Participants were asked if they had intimate supportive conversations with other people concerning their or their family member’s cancer illness. Of the 23 (82.1%) who responded that they had, four (14.3%) indicated they spoke to one to two people, seven (25%) indicated three to four, five (17.8%) spoke to four or five people, and four (14.4%) indicated eight or more. Most indicated they had spoken with family and close friends (n = 20, 71.4%), health staff (n = 11, 9.3%), friends or acquaintances (n = 6, 21.4%), workmates (n = 4, 14.2%), fellow patients (n = 3, 10.7%), and others (n = 2, 7.1%).

3.4 Client expectations

Clients were reported their service expectations prior to counselling. Four key themes were identified in clients’ expectations of the counselling service: no expectations, help dealing with feelings and emotions, specific strategies for coping, and better understanding. Clients often expressed practical expectations regarding engaging with the service. Responses focused on the need for strategies for dealing with mental health issues, such as alleviating depression, managing cancer support, processing diagnoses and related stressors (e.g., medication side effects). Seeking help to deal with emotions and feelings was also a common reason for accessing the service, including processing feelings about diagnoses, to expressing feelings in a safe and supportive therapeutic environment: I wanted to be able to say things out loud that I could not share with my family about fear and death.To discuss my concerns with a person with knowledge of cancer issues but who had no vested emotional interest in me.A listening ear. An opportunity to explore my feelings regarding my situation.To being supported in a safe environment and freely discuss what I was feeling.

Clients with no expectations included those who simply reported no expectations, and those whose expectations were limited by their uncertainty around how effective counselling would be for them. This centred-on time constraints, and doubting counselling effectiveness: I didn’t think it would be helpful as I was too busy working…I really did not know what to expect going into it, but felt it was important to try it out.I was unsure how helpful it would be. When my son was first diagnosed, I paid for professional counselling, and was asked many questions which I did not think were relevant.

These expectations of the counselling service were fulfilled for most clients (n = 26, 92.8%). When asked how satisfied they were with their experience with the counselling service, 12 (42.8%) were more than satisfied,12 (42.8%) were satisfied, two (7.6%) were rather satisfied, with two (7.6%) responding they were disappointed. Satisfaction with the counselling experience related to the counsellor and the comfort realised through the therapeutic alliance: She was a good listener, patient, helpful and supportive.The therapist that I met with was lovely and supportive and empathetic and understanding.She helped me to understand that it would help my son and his daughter, by looking after my own wellbeing…. I am grateful for her experience, her warm accepting manner, listening, helpful understanding of families.

Clients expressed themes of comfort, particularly regarding normalisation through the commonality of experiences shared amongst cancer sufferers: Always made me feel secure and good about myself and that I was progressing even though it was slow, it was steady, and that I would win in time.…basically, I felt some of my feelings were normalised, and that helped.

Techniques and strategies for coping were also particularly satisfying aspects of the counselling process: I learned some very useful and unexpected techniques to help me cope with life in general, cancer in particular.Good advice with some practical suggestions to meet my needs at different stages.Counselling really helped me reset and activate some helpful things to do, e.g., acupuncture, general self-care, and asking for help.

Two clients who expressed that their expectations were not met did not comment further.

3.5 Benefits of counselling

Participants indicated how they had benefited from counselling using a predefined list of commonly expected outcomes derived from previous literature.⁷ The most reported benefits were opportunity to practice talking about my life situation (n = 21, 77.8%) and an increased understanding of their reactions and feelings which they experienced during the process of their (or their family member’s) cancer illness (n = 20, 74.1%). Feeling that the counsellor saw them as a person (n = 18, 66.7%), feeling more initiative (n = 11, 40.7%), and feeling less fear (n = 10, 37%) were also commonly reported benefits. Several participants indicated feeling an increased distance from their situation (n = 5, 18.6%), appreciating the joys of everyday life from a more profound perspective (n = 5,18.6%), and becoming less fatigued (n = 5, 18.6%) after participating in counselling. Other benefits (n = 2, 7.1%) expressed by clients included feeling more prepared for the reality of cancer and feeling lighter.

3.6 Managing everyday situations

Clients were asked whether the counselling helped them to manage typical daily life situations. Most respondents indicated that it did (n = 21, 77.8%), with 11 (57.9%) indicated it was much better, and eight (42.1%) indicating somewhat better (9 participants gave no response). When asked for a clear example of a situation in which counselling had benefited them, clients described situations relating to three themes: coming to terms with their situation, grieving loved ones, and the use of psychological skills taught to them by the counsellors. Coming to terms reflected clients taking their diagnosis one step at time, gaining comfort with their diagnosis, not delaying treatment to wait for new approaches, and the emotional release associated with counselling: Prior to counselling I often became overwhelmed, teary, and emotional as I thought of my circumstance. Being able to discuss the issues seems to have given me the emotional release I needed.

Another commonly mentioned theme, grieving loved ones, was based on statements made around being able to talk about death and loss openly, fear of losing a spouse/partner, being able to think about lost loved ones, and being able to view aspects of the past differently following counselling sessions: I was able to talk about death in the open and the chance I may become a widow earlier than I ever imagined. After I said it out loud it stopped going around in my head as much - the fear was less.

3.7 Other beneficial activities

Clients were asked if there was anything else they had done since their first counselling session which had helped them. Two main themes were identified: accessing further services, and increased spirituality. Further service access was common, particularly seeking further physical and mental therapy for cancer-specific side effects, such as the physical impacts of chemotherapy, and further cancer-specific anxiety treatment. Spiritualty was reflected in increased practises or renewal of traditional faiths, and adoption of alternative modalities such as mindfulness practice, ‘talking’ to lost loved ones, naturopathy, and massage. Other comments regarding the counselling experience emphasised gratitude for the counsellors and the free support they provide.