Abstract
We explored the relation between age at menarche, parity and age at natural menopause with 249 metabolic traits, measured using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), in up to 65,487 UK Biobank women using multivariable regression (MV), Mendelian randomization (MR) and a male negative control (parity only). Older age of menarche was related to a less atherogenic metabolic profile in MV and MR, which was largely attenuated when accounting for adult body mass index. In MV, higher parity related to complex changes in lipoprotein-related traits; these were not observed in male negative controls and were imprecisely estimated in MR. In MV and MR, older age at natural menopause was related to lower concentrations of inflammation markers, but inconsistent results were observed for LDL-related traits due to chronological age-specific effects. Our findings support a role of reproductive traits on later life metabolic profile and provide insights into identifying novel markers for the prevention of adverse cardiometabolic outcomes in women.
What is new?
Markers of women’s reproductive health are associated with several common chronic conditions. Whilst some attempts have been made to explore the extent to which these associations are causal, metabolites could act as mediators of the relationship between reproductive markers and chronic diseases.
Older age of menarche was related to a less atherogenic metabolic profile in multivariable regression and Mendelian randomization, however, this was largely attenuated when accounting for adult body mass index.
In multivariable regression, higher parity related to complex changes in lipoprotein-related traits. Whilst these were not observed in male negative controls, suggesting a potential causal effect in females, they were not replicated in the Mendelian randomization, possibly due to imprecise estimates.
Older age at natural menopause was related to lower concentrations of inflammation markers in both multivariable regression and Mendelian randomization. Consistent results were observed for LDL-related traits when stratified by chronological age.
Implications
Given that the age at menarche results were largely attenuated to the null when accounting for adult BMI, it is likely that age at menarche itself may not causally relate to the metabolic profile.
These results, particularly for parity and age at menopause, could contribute to identifying novel markers for the prevention of adverse cardiometabolic outcomes in women and/or methods for accurate risk prediction. For example, consistent with other studies, higher parity was associated with unfavourable (e.g. higher number of particles and lipid content in VLDL and higher glycine) changes in the metabolic profile. Similarly, older age at menopause was related to higher lipid content in HDL particles and lower systemic inflammation, as proxied by GlycA.
Competing Interest Statement
DAL reports receiving support from several national and international government and charity research funders, and grants from Medtronic Ltd for work unrelated to that presented here. GLC and MCB declare that they have no competing interests.
Funding Statement
This research is supported by the University of Bristol and UK Medical Research Council (MRC) (MC_UU_00011/6, all authors), the European Unions Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 733206 LifeCycle (GLC and DAL), the University of Bristol Vice-Chancellors Fellowships (MCB), the British Heart Foundation (AA/18/7/34219, MCB and DAL and CH/F/20/90003, DAL) and the UK National Institute of Health Research (NF-0616-10102, DAL). The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript. This publication is the work of the authors and all authors will serve as guarantors for the contents of this paper.
Author Declarations
I confirm all relevant ethical guidelines have been followed, and any necessary IRB and/or ethics committee approvals have been obtained.
Yes
The details of the IRB/oversight body that provided approval or exemption for the research described are given below:
UK Biobank received ethical approval from the Research Ethics Committee (REC reference for UK Biobank is 11/NW/0382). The current analysis was approved under UK Biobank Project 30418 and 81499.
I confirm that all necessary patient/participant consent has been obtained and the appropriate institutional forms have been archived, and that any patient/participant/sample identifiers included were not known to anyone (e.g., hospital staff, patients or participants themselves) outside the research group so cannot be used to identify individuals.
Yes
I understand that all clinical trials and any other prospective interventional studies must be registered with an ICMJE-approved registry, such as ClinicalTrials.gov. I confirm that any such study reported in the manuscript has been registered and the trial registration ID is provided (note: if posting a prospective study registered retrospectively, please provide a statement in the trial ID field explaining why the study was not registered in advance).
Yes
I have followed all appropriate research reporting guidelines and uploaded the relevant EQUATOR Network research reporting checklist(s) and other pertinent material as supplementary files, if applicable.
Yes
Footnotes
↵* Joint first authors
We have made substantial changes to the manuscript to facilitate visualisation of results. This encompasses changing Figure 2 to forest plots to facilitate comparison between multivariable and Mendelian randomization (IVW) results for non-derived metabolites. Measures that are derived or related to lipoprotein subfractions have been moved into supplementary text (Supplementary figures 1, 7 and 11). The description of results also takes this format and structure. We performed further analyses to investigate reasons underlying discrepant findings between multivariable and MR estimates for some metabolic measures. These analyses were restricted to the eight clinical chemistry biomarkers matching measures in the NMR platform to maximise statistical power since they have been measured in the full UK Biobank sample. First, we hypothesised that discrepant findings were related to differences in the sample used for multivariable regression, which excludes women with missing data on age at menopause (hereafter ‘selected sample’), and two-sample MR, which includes women even if they are missing data on age at natural menopause (hereafter ‘full sample’). To test that, we compared estimates from multivariable regression on the selected sample to MR on both the selected sample and full sample. In agreement with our hypothesis, multivariable regression and MR estimates for LDL-cholesterol and related traits (i.e. apolipoprotein B and total cholesterol) are comparable when restricting to the selected sample. In contrast, for albumin, discrepant results were related to differences between multivariable regression and MR rather than between selected and full sample (Supplementary Figure 15). Second, given women with missing data at age at menopause are typically pre-menopausal and younger, we explored age-stratified multivariable and MR estimates, which revealed a strong effect modification by chronological age on the association of age at menopause and LDL-c and related traits: in younger women (≤ 50 y), later age at menopause is related to lower LDL-cholesterol, while the opposite is true for older women (> 58 y) (Supplementary Figure 15).
Data Availability
Access to UK Biobank data can be obtained under registration and application to the Access Management System (AMS) (https://www.ukbiobank.ac.uk/enable-your-research/register). GWAS summary data for reproductive traits is publicly available as detailed in Supplementary table 4.
Abbreviations
- Ala
- Alanine
- ApoA1
- Apolipoprotein A1
- ApoB
- Apolipoprotein B
- ApoB_by_ApoA1
- Ratio of apolipoprotein B to apolipoprotein A1 Cholines Total cholines
- Clinical_LDL_C
- Clinical LDL cholesterol
- DHA
- Docosahexaenoic acid
- DHA_pct
- Ratio of docosahexaenoic acid to total fatty acids
- Gln
- Glutamine
- Gly
- Glycine
- GlycA
- Glycoprotein acetyls
- HDL_C
- HDL cholesterol
- HDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in HDL
- HDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in HDL
- HDL_L
- Total lipids in HDL
- HDL_P
- Concentration of HDL particles
- HDL_PL
- Phospholipids in HDL
- HDL_TG
- Triglycerides in HDL
- HDL_size
- Average diameter for HDL particles
- His
- Histidine
- IDL_C
- Cholesterol in IDL
- IDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in IDL
- IDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in IDL
- IDL_C_pct
- Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in IDL
- IDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in IDL
- IDL_FC_pct
- Free cholesterol to total lipids ratio in IDL
- IDL_L
- Total lipids in IDL
- IDL_P
- Concentration of IDL particles
- IDL_PL
- Phospholipids in IDL
- IDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in IDL
- IDL_TG
- Triglycerides in IDL
- IDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in IDL
- Ile
- Isoleucine
- LA
- Linoleic acid
- LA_pct
- Ratio of linoleic acid to total fatty acids
- LDL_C
- LDL cholesterol
- LDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in LDL
- LDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in LDL
- LDL_L
- Total lipids in LDL
- LDL_P
- Concentration of LDL particles
- LDL_PL
- Phospholipids in LDL
- LDL_TG
- Triglycerides in LDL
- LDL_size
- Average diameter for LDL particles
- L_HDL_C
- Cholesterol in large HDL
- L_HDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in large HDL
- L_HDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in large HDL
- L_HDL_C_pct
- Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in large HDL
- L_HDL_FC
- L_HDL_L Total lipids in large HDL
- L_HDL_P
- Concentration of large HD particles
- L_HDL_PL
- Phospholipids in large HDL
- L_HDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in large HDL
- L_HDL_TG
- Triglycerides in large HDL
- L_HDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in large
- L_LDL_C
- Cholesterol in large LDL
- L_LDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in large LDL
- L_LDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in large LDL
- L_LDL_C_pct
- Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in large LDL
- L_LDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in large LDL
- L_LDL_FC_pct
- Free cholesterol to total lipids ratio in large LDL
- L_LDL_L
- Total lipids in large LDL
- L_LDL_P
- Concentration of large LDL particles
- L_LDL_PL
- Phospholipids in large LDL
- L_LDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in large LDL
- L_LDL_TG
- Triglycerides in large LDL
- L_LDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in large LDL
- L_VLDL_C
- Cholesterol in large VLDL
- L_VLDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in large VLDL
- L_VLDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in large VLDL
- L_VLDL_C_pct
- Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in large VLDL
- L_VLDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in large VLDL
- L_VLDL_FC_pct
- Free cholesterol to total lipids ratio in large VLDL
- L_VLDL_L
- Total lipids in large VLDL
- L_VLDL_P
- Concentration of large VLDL particles
- L_VLDL_PL
- Phospholipids in large VLDL
- L_VLDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in large VLDL
- L_VLDL_TG
- Triglycerides in large VLDL
- L_VLDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in large VLDL
- Leu
- Leucine
- MUFA
- Monounsaturated fatty acids
- MUFA_pct
- Ratio of monounsaturated fatty acids to total fatty acids
- M_HDL_C
- Cholesterol in medium HDL
- M_HDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in medium HDL
- M_HDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in medium HDL
- M_HDL_C_pct
- Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in medium HDL
- M_HDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in medium HDL
- M_HDL_FC_pct
- Free cholesterol to total lipids ratio in medium HDL
- M_HDL_L
- Total lipids in medium HDL
- M_HDL_P
- Concentration of medium HDL particles
- M_HDL_PL
- Phospholipids in medium HDL
- M_HDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in medium HDL
- M_HDL_TG
- Triglycerides in medium HDL
- M_HDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in medium HDL
- M_LDL_C
- Cholesterol in medium LDL
- M_LDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in medium LDL
- M_LDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in medium LDL
- M_LDL_C_pct
- Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in medium LDL M_LDL_FC Free cholesterol in medium LDL
- M_LDL_FC_pct
- Free cholesterol to total lipids ratio in medium LDL M_LDL_L Total lipids in medium LDL
- M_LDL_P
- Concentration of medium LDL particles
- M_LDL_PL
- Phospholipids in medium LDL
- M_LDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in medium LDL M_LDL_TG Triglycerides in medium LDL
- M_LDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in medium LDL M_VLDL_C Cholesterol in medium VLDL
- M_VLDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in medium VLDL
- M_VLDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in medium VLDL M_VLDL_C_pct Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in medium VLDL M_VLDL_FC Free cholesterol in medium VLDL
- M_VLDL_FC_pct
- Free cholesterol to total lipids ratio in medium VLDL M_VLDL_L Total lipids in medium VLDL
- M_VLDL_P
- Concentration of medium VLDL particles
- M_VLDL_PL
- Phospholipids in medium VLDL
- M_VLDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in medium VLDL
- M_VLDL_TG
- Triglycerides in medium VLDL
- M_VLDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in medium VLDL
- Omega_3
- Omega-3 fatty acids
- Omega_3_pct
- Ratio of omega-3 fatty acids to total fatty acids
- Omega_6
- Omega-6 fatty acids
- Omega_6_by_Omega_3
- Ratio of omega-6 fatty acids to omega-3 fatty acids
- Omega_6_pct
- Ratio of omega-6 fatty acids to total fatty acids
- PUFA
- Polyunsaturated fatty acids
- PUFA_by_MUFA
- Ratio of polyunsaturated fatty acids to monounsaturated fatty acids
- PUFA_pct
- Ratio of polyunsaturated fatty acids to total fatty acids
- Phe
- Phenylalanine
- Phosphatidylc
- Phosphatidylcholines
- Phosphoglyc
- Phosphoglycerides
- Remnant_C
- Remnant cholesterol (non-HDL, non-LDL -cholesterol)
- SFA
- Saturated fatty acids
- SFA_pct
- Ratio of saturated fatty acids to total fatty acids
- S_HDL_C
- Cholesterol in small HDL
- S_HDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in small HDL
- S_HDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in small HDL
- S_HDL_C_pct
- Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in small HDL
- S_HDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in small HDL
- S_HDL_FC_pct
- Free cholesterol to total lipids ratio in small HDL
- S_HDL_L
- Total lipids in small HDL
- S_HDL_P
- Concentration of small HDL particles
- S_HDL_PL
- Phospholipids in small HDL
- S_HDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in small HDL
- S_HDL_TG
- Triglycerides in small HDL
- S_HDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in small HDL
- S_LDL_C
- Cholesterol in small LDL
- S_LDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in small LDL
- S_LDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in small LDL
- S_LDL_C_pct
- Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in small LDL
- S_LDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in small LDL
- S_LDL_FC_pct
- Free cholesterol to total lipids ratio in small LDL
- S_LDL_L
- Total lipids in small LDL
- S_LDL_P
- Concentration of small LDL particles
- S_LDL_PL
- Phospholipids in small LDL
- S_LDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in small LDL
- S_LDL_TG
- Triglycerides in small LDL
- S_LDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in small LDL
- S_VLDL_C
- Cholesterol in small VLDL
- S_VLDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in small VLDL
- S_VLDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in small VLDL
- S_VLDL_C_pct
- Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in small VLDL
- S_VLDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in small VLDL
- S_VLDL_FC_pct
- Free cholesterol to total lipids ratio in small VLDL
- S_VLDL_L
- Total lipids in small VLDL
- S_VLDL_P
- Concentration of small VLDL particles
- S_VLDL_PL
- Phospholipids in small VLDL
- S_VLDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in small VLDL
- S_VLDL_TG
- Triglycerides in small VLDL
- S_VLDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in small VLDL TG_by_PG Ratio of triglycerides to phosphoglycerides
- Total_BCAA
- Total concentration of branched-chain amino acids (leucine + isoleucine + valine)
- Total_C
- Total cholesterol
- Total_CE
- Total esterified cholesterol
- Total_FA
- Total fatty acids
- Total_FC
- Total free cholesterol
- Total_L
- Total lipids in lipoprotein particles
- Total_P
- Total concentration of lipoprotein particles
- Total_PL
- Total phospholipids in lipoprotein particles
- Total_TG
- Total triglycerides
- Tyr
- Tyrosine
- Unsaturation
- Degree of unsaturation
- VLDL_C
- VLDL cholesterol
- VLDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in VLDL
- VLDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in VLDL
- VLDL_L
- Total lipids in VLDL
- VLDL_P
- Concentration of VLDL particles
- VLDL_PL
- Phospholipids in VLDL
- VLDL_TG
- Triglycerides in VLDL
- VLDL_size
- Average diameter for VLDL particles
- Val
- Valine
- XL_HDL_C
- Cholesterol in very large HDL
- XL_HDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in very large HDL
- XL_HDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in very large
- HDL
- XL_HDL_C_pct Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in very large HDL
- XL_HDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in very large HDL
- XL_HDL_FC_pct
- Free cholesterol to total lipids ratio in very large HDL
- XL_HDL_L
- Total lipids in very large HDL
- XL_HDL_P
- Concentration of very large HDL particles
- XL_HDL_PL
- Phospholipids in very large HDL
- XL_HDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in very large HDL
- XL_HDL_TG
- Triglycerides in very large HDL
- XL_HDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in very large HDL
- XL_VLDL_C
- Cholesterol in very large VLDL
- XL_VLDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in very large VLDL
- XL_VLDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in very large VLDL
- XL_VLDL_C_pct
- Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in very large VLDL
- XL_VLDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in very large VLDL
- XL_VLDL_FC_pct
- Free cholesterol to total lipids ratio in very large VLDL
- XL_VLDL_L
- Total lipids in very large VLDL
- XL_VLDL_P
- Concentration of very large VLDL particles
- XL_VLDL_PL
- Phospholipids in very large VLDL
- XL_VLDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in very large VLDL
- XL_VLDL_TG
- Triglycerides in very large VLDL
- XL_VLDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in very large VLDL
- XS_VLDL_C
- Cholesterol in very small VLDL
- XS_VLDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in very small VLDL
- XS_VLDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in very small VLDL
- XS_VLDL_C_pct
- Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in very small VLDL
- XS_VLDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in very small VLDL
- XS_VLDL_FC_pct
- Free cholesterol to total lipids ratio in very small VLDL
- XS_VLDL_L
- Total lipids in very small VLDL
- XS_VLDL_P
- Concentration of very small VLDL particles
- XS_VLDL_PL
- Phospholipids in very small VLDL
- XS_VLDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in very small VLDL
- XS_VLDL_TG
- Triglycerides in very small VLDL
- XS_VLDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in very small VLDL
- XXL_VLDL_C
- Cholesterol in chylomicrons and extremely large VLDL
- XXL_VLDL_CE
- Cholesteryl esters in chylomicrons and extremely large VLDL
- XXL_VLDL_CE_pct
- Cholesteryl esters to total lipids ratio in chylomicrons and extremely large VLDL
- XXL_VLDL_C_pct
- Cholesterol to total lipids ratio in chylomicrons and extremely large VLDL
- XXL_VLDL_FC
- Free cholesterol in chylomicrons and extremely large VLDL
- XXL_VLDL_FC_pct
- Free cholesterol to total lipids ratio in chylomicrons and extremely large VLDL
- XXL_VLDL_L
- Total lipids in chylomicrons and extremely large VLDL
- XXL_VLDL_P
- Concentration of chylomicrons and extremely large VLDL particles
- XXL_VLDL_PL
- Phospholipids in chylomicrons and extremely large VLDL
- XXL_VLDL_PL_pct
- Phospholipids to total lipids ratio in chylomicrons and extremely large VLDL
- XXL_VLDL_TG
- Triglycerides in chylomicrons and extremely large VLDL
- XXL_VLDL_TG_pct
- Triglycerides to total lipids ratio in chylomicrons and extremely large VLDL
- bOHbutyrate
- 3-Hydroxybutyrate
- non_HDL_C
- Total cholesterol minus HDL-C