Abstract
To determine whether prevalence of Coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid-19) is modulated by meteorological conditions, we herein conducted meta-regression of data in large U.S. cities. We selected 33 large U.S. cities with a population of >500,000. The integrated numbers of confirmed Covid-19 cases in the country to which the city belongs on 14 May 2020, the estimated population in 2019 in the country, and monthly meteorological conditions at the city for 4 months (from January to April 2020) were obtained. Meteorological conditions consisted of mean temperature (F), total precipitation (inch), mean wind speed (MPH), mean sky cover, and mean relative humidity (%). Monthly data for 4 months were averaged or integrated. The Covid-19 prevalence was defined as the integrated number of Covid-19 cases divided by the population. Random-effects meta-regression was performed by means of OpenMetaAnalyst. In a meta-regression graph, Covid-19 prevalence (plotted as the logarithm transformed prevalence on the y-axis) was depicted as a function of a given factor (plotted as a meteorological datum on the x-axis). A slope of the meta-regression line was significantly negative (coefficient, −0.069; P < 0.001) for the mean temperature and significantly positive for the mean wind speed (coefficient, 0.174; P = 0.027) and the sky cover (coefficient, 2.220; P = 0.023). In conclusion, lower temperature and higher wind speed/sky cover may be associated with higher Covid-19 prevalence, which should be confirmed by further epidemiological researches adjusting for various risk and protective factors (in addition to meteorological conditions) of Covid-19.
Introduction
Higher temperature and ultraviolet (UV) index in Northern Europe have been reported as the most important meteorological protective factors for the transmission of influenza virus.1 On the other hand, a recent study in China suggests that higher temperature and UV radiation may not be associated with a decrease in the epidemics of Coronavirus disease 2019 (Covid-19).2 To determine whether prevalence of COVID-19 is modulated by meteorological conditions, we herein conducted meta-regression of data in large U.S. cities.
Methods
We selected 33 large U.S. cities with a population of >500,000 in 2010 from the U.S. Census Bureau (http://www.census.gov). The integrated numbers of confirmed Covid-19 cases in the country to which the city belongs on 14 May 2020 from the Johns Hopkins Coronavirus Resource Center (https://coronavirus.jhu.edu), the estimated population in 2019 in the country from the U.S. Census Bureau, and monthly meteorological conditions at the city for 4 months (from January to April 2020) from the National Weather Service (https://www.weather.gov) were obtained (Table 1). Meteorological conditions consisted of mean temperature (F), total precipitation (inch), mean wind speed (MPH), mean sky cover, and mean relative humidity (%). Monthly data for 4 months were averaged or integrated. The Covid-19 prevalence was defined as the integrated number of Covid-19 cases divided by the population. Random-effects meta-regression was performed by means of OpenMetaAnalyst (http://www.cebm.brown.edu/openmeta/index.html). In a meta-regression graph, Covid-19 prevalence (plotted as the logarithm transformed prevalence on the y-axis) was depicted as a function of a given factor (plotted as the meteorological data on the x-axis).
Results
Results of the meta-regression were summarized in Table 2. A slope of the metaregression line was significantly negative (coefficient, –0.069; P < 0.001; Figure 1, upper panel) for the mean temperature (indicating that Covid-19 prevalence decreased significantly as the mean temperature increased) and significantly positive for the mean wind speed (coefficient, 0.174; P = 0.027; Figure 1, middle panel) and the sky cover (coefficient, 2.220; P = 0.023; Figure 1, lower panel) (indicating that Covid-19 prevalence increased significantly as the mean wind speed and the sky cover increased).
Discussion and Conclusion
The present meta-regression suggests that temperature may be negatively and wind speed/sky cover may be positively associated with COVID-19 prevalence. Higher sky cover is probably related to lower UV radiation. Our recent preliminary study of Japanese prefectural data suggests that temperature and UV index may be negatively associated with COVID-19 prevalence,3 which could strengthen the present findings. Despite the association of lower temperature and UV index with the influenza transmission,1 no association of temperature and UV radiation with the COVID-19 epidemics has been reported,2 however, which may be denied by the present results of the association of lower temperature and higher sky cover with higher COVID-19 prevalence. In conclusion, lower temperature and higher wind speed/sky cover may be associated with higher Covid-19 prevalence, which should be confirmed by further epidemiological researches adjusting for various risk and protective factors (in addition to meteorological conditions) of Covid-19.
Data Availability
The datasets generated during and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.