Factors Influencing Health Insurance Enrollment and Its Impact on Outpatient Service Utilization in Saudi Arabia: Insights from the National Saudi Family Health Survey

INTRODUCTION

The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia provides health care services free of charge to its citizens (1). Non-Saudis who are working in the governmental sector have similar access to health care. However, the government realized that this model is unsustainable in the long run, especially with an increased number of expatriates who make up a large proportion of the population (41.6% in the year 2022), and with the increased demand for health care services (2,3). Consequently, there was an inevitable need for health care reform to ensure the continuity of providing adequate health care services (3). The decision-makers decided to transition towards the National Health Insurance model. The first step was taken by the passage of the Council of Cooperative Health Insurance Law in 1999, which established a mandatory health insurance scheme Cooperative Health Insurance (CHI) in 2002 for private sector employees, who were mostly expatriates (4). The scheme aimed to relieve the financial burden on the public sector by forcing private sector employers who form 67.9% of the workforce in Saudi Arabia to cover health care costs for their Saudi employees (22.3%) and non-Saudis (77.7%). This scheme will push the private sector employees to private health care providers to get their health services (5,6).By definition, health care services are the medical services provided by health care professionals to treat, protect or promote the health and well-being of the people; it includes hospital care (emergency care, outpatient clinics, admissions, diagnostic measures), primary health care services, physicians and clinical services, dental services; besides home health care, other residential health services, prescribing drugs, durable and nondurable medical products (7).

The Ministry of Health (MOH) in Saudi Arabia is responsible for public health care services and other governmental sectors, such as the National Guard and educational health facilities, in addition to the private sector which also provides health care services (8). According to the reports published by the MOH in 2022, the number of visits to the health care facilities in the public sector (hospitals and primary health care centers) accounted for 78.6 million (61%), while it reached 20.4 million (16%) in other governmental sectors and 29.5 million (23%) in the private sector (8). The number of visits has been accepted as a quantification of the utilization of health care services (9). According to the theoretical model of health service use provided by Andersen in 1973, the factors determining the extent of health care utilization can be grouped under three main categories; “predisposing factors” represented by the demographic characteristics such as age and gender and attitude of the individual; the “enabling factors” described by the availability and accessibility of health care providers, and the “needs” which are the Symptoms or health issues prompting individuals to seek medical attention (10). In the past few decades, the Gulf Cooperation Countries (GCC), including Saudi Arabia, have witnessed rapid growth in health care investments, in the form of health care facilities, medical complexes (hospitals providing secondary and tertiary care), and medical cities or groups of hospitals providing comprehensive services (11). Meanwhile, the government of Saudi Arabia introduced the Cooperative Health Insurance Law that demands insurance coverage for all employees in private companies. The strategy aimed to ease the challenge experienced by offering free health care services to the residents of the country. This strategy is offering medical coverage to more than eleven million insured people in Saudi Arabia through 27 insurance companies (12).

In Saudi Arabia, the health insurance was started in 2006 and its implementation is separated into three phases as part of the country’s broader health care reforms under Vision 2030. The first phase included coverage for employees of large companies employing 500 or more individuals, gradually extending to smaller businesses, and eventually covering all employees including Saudis and non-Saudis in the private sector(13). The second phase of the Cooperative Health Insurance scheme is intended to cover those working in the government sector. The third phase is intended to be extended to cover short-term for non-Saudi workers and visitors (e.g., tourists) this phase was still pending (14). Currently, the implementation of the health insurance is in the second phase.

There are three types of health insurance in Saudi Arabia: firstly, the government-funded health care which covers the health services in public facilities provided to the Saudi population and non-Saudis working in the government sector (15). Secondly, is employer-sponsored health insurance where the employer in the private sector takes the responsibility of payment for enrollment and renewal of insurance for the employees of both citizens and expatriates (16). According to the General Authority for Statistics in 2023, this type of insurance covered 37.5% of total the adult population aged 15 and above (20.5% for citizens and 53.6% for expatriates) (17). Thirdly, private health insurance which is available to citizens and expatriates that are paid by individuals to extend their health services benefits. In addition to international students, tourists and Pilgrims must be covered by health insurance before the entrance to the country (18).

Previous research in Saudi Arabia showed that individuals with health insurance had higher utilization of health services than the uninsured ones, especially routine check-up services (19), periodic preventive services (12), inpatient and outpatient services, visits to the emergency room (ER) (20) and dispensing medicines (21). Alrabiah and colleagues found that health insurance increased adherence to treatment and a positive perception of the quality of received services (22). Moreover, research indicated that insured individuals utilize outpatient services more frequently due to easier accessibility and the availability of a wide range of medical services (23). Despite the wide coverage of the effects of health insurance on the utilization of health care services, the literature does not give adequate attention to important characteristics of respondents that may affect the association between insurance enrollment on health-seeking behavior (19). For example, in Saudi Arabia, 41.6 % of the population are non-Saudi skilled and unskilled workers and their dependents (2) and existing studies lack exploration into the discrepancies between these two groups regarding enrollment in health insurance and utilization of health care services. This affects the understanding of possible differences in access to health care services, which can offer an exciting subject for research and investigation. Further, research study including more unexplored factors can provide a comprehensive understanding of the effect of health insurance on the utilization of health services by various demographic groups (19). By informing policy development, such insights can lead to targeted interventions aimed at improving health or health insurance literacy and increasing insurance coverage (24) and in the long term this may enhance health outcomes. In light of ongoing health care system reforms in Saudi Arabia (25), research is needed to pinpoint areas that require improvement and guide the development of more effective policies to enhance health care utilization and overall health outcomes in the country. Thus, the current study aims to identify the factors of health insurance enrollment and estimate the effect of health insurance on the utilization of outpatient services emphasizing the discrepancies between Saudi and non-Saudi populations.

This research is driven by the need to understand the relationship between health insurance enrollment and outpatient service utilization in Saudi Arabia, within the recent health care reforms, focusing on shifting from government-funded health care to health insurance systems, primarily targeting expatriates. This transition addresses the rising demand for medical services due to population growth and a significant expatriate community and should focus on health insurance literacy among workers and individuals. Understanding the factors influencing health insurance enrollment is crucial for policymakers to design effective interventions that promote increased insurance coverage and utilization of outpatient services.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This study used the data from the 2018 Saudi Family Health Survey (FHS). The FHS is a household survey classified under education and health statistics conducted by the General Authority for Statistics (GASTAT). This survey consists of 12,827 samples in total collected from all the 13 administrative areas in Saudi Arabia. The survey used a pre-designed validated questionnaire that had been adopted form the World Health Organization (WHO)’ Health Survey (WHS).

The survey contains questions about household’s demographic characteristics of the interviewed individuals (age, sex, nationality, education level, marital status, number of family members, monthly income, employment status and residence), health status (self-rated health condition and any chronic diseases) and the health insurance status (whether insured or not). A representative sample for the whole population in Saudi Arabia was interviewed by trained personnel using the pre-designed questionnaire (26). The data from the survey was requested officially from the sponsor of the data in the government of Saudi Arabia, represented by GASTAT. The authority provided data in Excel format that included the relevant variables for the current study. The data were translated into English and coded to facilitate statistical analysis using the SPSS ver. 26 program.

DATA ANALYSIS

Data were summarized as frequency distribution, mean and standard deviation. Chi-squared test was carried out to test the association between the study participant’s characteristics and health insurance enrollment. An Independent sample t-test was used to examine the significance of the difference in the number of visits to health care facilities between the insured and uninsured groups. We included only outpatient care utilization in this analysis due to the availability of this in the data. Binary logistic regression was conducted to find out the predictors of health insurance enrollment. Poisson regression was employed to determine the factor associated with health care service utilization. The variables which showed significant association with the outcome variable (utilization of health services in terms of number of visits) were included in the regression analysis. Multicollinearity was assessed for the included independent variables, and the Variance Inflation Factor (VIF) values were found to be less than 5, indicating that multicollinearity is not present significance level 5% (P value<0.05) was considered for statistical tests.

ETHICAL CLEARANCE

This study was based on the use of secondary data from the FHS, which was conducted, commissioned, funded, and managed in 2018 by GASTAT, who was in charge of all ethical procedures.

RESULTS

Table 1 describes the demographic characteristics of the respondents, categorized according to nationality. Out of all respondents (n=8,276), 76.8% were Saudis. The proportion of the male population was higher among the non-Saudis (69.1%) than Saudis (50.6%). The highest proportion (55.80%) of the respondents were from the 26-59 age group. The respondents from this age group were 78.8% among non-Saudis and 58.7% among Saudis. Only 22.3% of total respondents had higher education, either a university qualification or a postgraduate degree. Approximately 23.3% of Saudis and 19.1% of non-Saudis had such educational qualifications.

Almost half of the respondents (48.0%) were employed, with a higher percentage among non-Saudis (75.9%) than Saudis (39.5%). Regarding the monthly income, a higher proportion of non-Saudis (59.6%) than Saudis (22.6%) had the lowest monthly income (<5,000 SR). One-half (64.8%) of the respondents were married, with a higher percentage of non-Saudis (73.4%) than Saudis (62.2%). One-quarter (26.2%) had health insurance and the health insurance enrollment was higher among non-Saudis (72.8%) compared to Saudi (12.1%). The majority of the Saudis (87.7%) and non-Saudis (96.8%) perceived their health status as good or very good. Chronic diseases (mostly diabetes and hypertension) were reported by 28.8% of the Saudis and 14.4% among non-Saudis. Among the Saudi respondents (48.8%) and non-Saudi respondents (76.5%) made at least one health care visit during the past 12 months. The average number of visits among Saudis were two visits with IQR=1.00-2.00, and in non-Saudis were one visit with IQR= (0.00-1.00).

Table 2 presents the health insurance enrollment based on the characteristics of the respondents. The health insurance enrollment was significantly associated with the sex of the respondents, with a higher rate of enrollment among male (32.5%) respondents compared to females (18.5%). A similar association between sex and health insurance enrollment was observed among respondents from the non-Saudi and Saudi groups. The health insurance enrollment was higher in those who aged 26-59 years (31.4%). The employed had a higher health insurance enrollment rate than the unemployed (36.4% vs 12.4%). It was observed that the percentage of the insured was significantly higher among those with lower monthly income <5,000 (36.5%). Among Saudi and non-Saudi, the highest percentage of insurance enrollment was for the income group 5000-<10000 and 15000-<20000 respectively. Marital status, education level and chronic disease were significantly associated with the health insurance enrollment.

The average number of health care visits during the past 12 months by nationality and other characteristics are shown in Table 3. The mean number of visits was significantly higher among Saudis (mean±SD; 1.73±1.351) than non-Saudi (0.92±1.139). The mean value was higher in females (mean±SD; 1.71±1.349) compared to males. In both Saudi and non-Saudi populations, the elderly group (<60 years) had higher average health facility visits compared to adult (26-59 years) and (18–25) groups. The mean values were significantly higher among lower education level in Saudis and non-Saudis (mean±SD; 1.64±1.336) than the higher education level (mean±SD; 1.54±1.336). In both Saudis and non-Saudis, the mean values of the number of visits were significantly higher among those with high monthly income (+20,000 SR) (mean±SD; 1.96±1.453) compared to low-income groups. This were significantly higher among the divorced & widowed (mean±SD; 1.83±1.310) than the married and never married groups. The values were found to be higher among those who had no insurance (mean±SD; 1.69±1.368) and those who had chronic disease (mean±SD; 1.92±1.346), which applies to both Saudis and non-Saudis. The average number of visits were significantly lower for those who perceived their general health as being very good (mean±SD; 1.40±1.325) compared to those who rated their health as bad (mean±SD; 2.50±1.231). We found similar differences in the number of visits according to the perceived health status group among Saudi and non-Saudi populations.

The regression analysis results examining the factors influencing the enrollment of health insurance are presented in Table 4. The likelihood to be enrolled in insurance was 27 folds in non-Saudis (OR=27.127; 95% CI=22.985-32.017) compared to Saudis. Males were found to be more likely to be insured by two folds (OR=2.090; 95% CI=1.700-2.569). The higher-income individuals (15,000-20,000 SR) were two times (OR=1.860; 95% CI, 1.453-2.380) more likely to enroll in the insurance scheme compared to low-income individuals (<5,000 SR). Also, when compared to those with below primary school education level; the odds to be insured was almost four folds in those with higher education (undergraduate and above) level (OR=3.584; 95% CI, 2.815-4.563). The likelihood of those who perceive health as being good was two folds (OR=2.767; 95% CI, 1.350-5.668) more likely to have insurance compared to those who perceive health as bad. We found that being never married decreased the odds to be enrolled in insurance compared to being married respectively.

The regression analysis findings on the factors of the utilization of health services are presented in Table 5. We found health insurance enrollment was negatively associated (Coefficient = -0.107, P<0.01) with the utilization of outpatient health services. Insured individuals had lower utilization compared to uninsured individuals. The male population had lower utilization of services compared to the female population.

If we compared those individuals with a lower monthly income (<5,000 SR), the utilization of health services was higher among individuals with higher monthly income (20,000 SR or more) (coefficient = 0.388 95% CI= 0.321; 0.456). It was found that never-married individuals have higher health care services utilization (Coefficient = 0.161 95% CI= 0.107; 0.215) compared to married individuals. People suffering from chronic conditions had higher utilization of health services compared to people who had no such conditions.

We conducted separate regression models for Saudi and non-Saudi populations to further examine the association between health insurance enrollment and utilization of services among these two distinct populations. In both population groups, health insurance enrollment was associated with lower utilization of health services.

DISCUSSION

The study highlighted the determinants of health enrollment and the association of health insurance status with the utilization of outpatient health care services in Saudi Arabia. We found that non-Saudi nationality, higher monthly income, male sex, married marital status, higher education level and good perceived health status led to health insurance enrollment. Further, the factors that increased the utilization of outpatient services were being Saudi, female, with high monthly income, never married, having chronic diseases and perception of bad health status. We found respondents having health insurance were less likely (OR=-0.107) to utilize outpatient services compared to those who don’t have insurance.

STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS

The main strength of the study is based on nationwide data including a representative sample from all geographic regions of Saudi Arabia. Further strength could be the application of multiple regression models in this study for identifying possible determinants of insurance enrollment and association between health insurance enrollment and health care utilization while adjusting for confounders. However, due to cross sectional nature of the FHS, one inherited limitation in that this study is unable to conclude any causal relationships. Another limitation of the study is the recall bias when reporting the health care utilization (1 year) and other information by the respondents. We were able to access only FHS 2018 data for this study while a recent version of the dataset is released by the General Authority for Statistics after completion of the analysis. We were unable to include inpatient care utilization in our analysis due to the unavailability of this information in the dataset we received from the GASTAT. These limitations should be considered while interpreting and using the findings of this study.

CONCLUSIONS

The study investigated the determinants of health insurance enrollment and the utilization of health care services in Saudi Arabia and found that non-Saudi, males, having high income, and higher level of education, and perceived good health status are more likely to be enrolled in health insurance. Factors increasing utilization of outpatient services were being female, having a high monthly income, being never married, having chronic diseases, and the perception of bad health. However, health insurance was associated with lower utilization of outpatient services. Consequently, policymakers should take more targeted measures that address the challenges and opportunities associated with health insurance enrollment and health care service utilization. Introducing targeted interventions oriented toward improving health insurance literacy and understanding insurance benefits for the insured population could be helpful to improve the current level of health service utilization. These measures could involve creating a robust education campaign and enhancing health services accessibility to diverse population groups. To guarantee every resident has equitable access to health care, we strongly suggest the development of a health insurance program based on a different financing solution. Future research can be aimed at proving the long-term effectiveness of health insurance in ensuring diversified types of health service (e.g. including inpatient and primary health care) and impact on quality, and health outcomes for whole populations.

DECLARATIONS