Defining an Ageing-Related Pathology, Disease or Syndrome: International Consensus Statement

Emma Short, Ian M. Adcock, Bilal Al-Sarireh, Ann Ager, Ramzi Ajjan, Naveed Akbar, Michael A. Akeroyd, Ghada Alsaleh, Ghada Al-Sharbatee, Kambiz Alavian, Winfried Amoaku, Julie Andersen, Chrystalina Antoniades, Mark J. Arends, Sue Astley, Denize Atan, Richard Attanoos, Johannes Attems, Steve Bain, Konstantinos Balaskas, Gabriel Balmus, Manohar Bance, Thomas M. Barber, Ajoy Bardhan, Karen Barker, Peter Barnes, Gemma Basatemur, Adrian Bateman, Moises Evandro Bauer, Christopher Bellamy, Edwin van Beek, Ilaria Bellantuono, Emyr Benbow, Sunil Bhandari, Rahul Bhatnagar, Philip Bloom, Dawn Bowdish, Melissa Bowerman, Melanie Burke, Roxana Carare, Emma Victoria Carrington, Jorge Iván Castillo-Quan, Peter Clegg, James Cole, Carlo Cota, Paul Chazot, Christopher Chen, Ying Cheong, Gary Christopher, George Church, David Clancy, Paul Cool, Francesco Del Galdo, Mayank Dalakoti, Soumit Dasgupta, Colleen Deane, Devesh Dhasmana, Stefan Dojcinov, Monia Di Prete, Huaidong Du, Niharika A Duggal, Toby Ellmers, Costanza Emanueli, Mark Emberton, Jorge D. Erusalimsky, Laurence Feldmeyer, Alexander Fleming, Karen Forbes, Thomas C. Foster, Daniela Frasca, Ian Frayling, Daniel Freedman, Tamas Fülöp, Georgina Ellison-Hughes, Gus Gazzard, Christopher George, Jesus Gil, Richard Glassock, Rob Goldin, John Green, Robyn Guymer, Hasan Haboubi, Lorna Harries, Simon Hart, Douglas Hartley, Sebri Hasaballa, Christin Henein, Maggie Helliwell, Emily Henderson, Rakesh Heer, Kristofer Holte, Iskander Idris, David Isenburg, Juulia Jylhävä, Ahmed Iqbal, Simon W. Jones, Rajesh Kalaria, Venkateswarlu Kanamarlapudi, Werner Kempf, Alexandra J. Kermack, Jemma Kerns, Albert Koulman, Adnan H. Khan, James Kinross, Katarina Klaucane, Yamini Krishna, Harinderjit Singh Gill, Edward Lakatta, Ezio Laconi, Alpar Lazar, Christiaan Leeuwenburgh, Samantha Leung, Xuan Li, Ian van der Linde, Luísa V. Lopes, Antonello Lorenzini, Andrew Lotery, Pedro Machado, Sarah Mackie, Paolo Madeddu, Andrea Maier, Krishna Mukkanna, Pinelopi Manousou, Oonagh Markey, Claudio Mauro, Barry McDonnell, Reinhold J. Medina, Soma Meran, Claudia Metzler-Baddeley, Ignor Meglinksi, Neta Milman, Christina Mitteldorf, Ruth Montgomery, Andrew Conway Morris, Beda Mühleisen, Abhik Mukherkee, Andrew Murray, Scott Nelson, Anna Nicolaou, Alexander Nirenberg, Simon Noble, Lisa S. Nolan, Meritxell Nus, Canh Van On, Victor Osei-Lah, Mandy Peffers, Antony Palmer, Donald Palmer, Laura Palmer, William Parry-Smith, Graham Pawelec, Shahaf Peleg, Ranmith Perera, Andrew Pitsillides, Christopher J. Plack, Franze Progatzsky, Sonja Pyott, Kaukab Rajput, Sameera Rashid, J. Arjuna Ratnayaka, Sudhira A.B. Ratnayake, Manuel Rodriguez-Justo, Arianna Carolina Rosa, Andrew Rule, Gareth J. Sanger, Ian Sayers, Andrew Saykin, Dinesh Selvarajah, Jaswinder Sethi, Cathy Shanahan, Shai Shen-Orr, Carl Sheridan, Paul Shiels, Kastytis Sidlauskas, Sobha Sivaprasad, Judith Sluimer, Gary Small, Peter Smith, Rebecca Smith, Sarah Snelling, Ioakim Spyridopoulos, Ramasamy Srinivasa Raghavan, David Steel, Karen P Steel, Claire Stewart, Keeron Stone, Selvarani Subbarayan, Mark Sussman, Jonas Svensson, Vyshnavi Tadanki, Ai Lyn Tan, Rudolph E. Tanzi, Amanda Tatler, Adriana A. S. Tavares, Tengku Amatullah Madeehah Tengku Mohd, Ana Tiganescu, James Timmons, Jeremy Tree, Drupad Trivedi, Emmanuel A. Tsochatzis, Dialechti Tsimpida, Elisabeth J Vinke, Anna Whittaker, Neeru A. Vallabh, Kristin Veighey, Zoe C. Venables, Venkat Reddy, Meike W. Vernooij, Chris Verschoor, Manlio Vinciguerra, Vesna Vukanovic, Vladyslav Vyazovskiy, James Walker, Richard Wakefield, Adam J. Watkins, Anthony Webster, Caroline Weight, Birgit Weinberger, Susan L. Whitney, Rosalind Willis, Jacek M. Witkowski, Leonard L.L. Yeo, Tham Yhi Chung, Emma Yu, Michael Zemel, Stuart R.G. Calimport, Barry L. Bentley
doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.02.24312951

Abstract

Background Around the world, individuals are living longer, but an increased average lifespan does not always equate to an increased healthspan. With advancing age, the increased prevalence of ageing-related diseases can have a significant impact on health status, functional capacity, and quality of life. It is therefore vital to develop comprehensive classification and staging systems for ageing-related pathologies, diseases and syndromes. This will allow societies to better identify, quantify, understand, and meet the healthcare, workforce, wellbeing, and socioeconomic needs of ageing populations, while supporting the development and utilisation of interventions to prevent or to slow, halt or reverse the progression of ageing-related pathologies.

Methods The foundation for developing such classification and staging systems is to define the scope of what constitutes an ageing-related pathology, disease or syndrome. To this end, a consensus meeting was hosted by the International Consortium to Classify Ageing-Related Pathologies (ICCARP), on February 19th, 2024, in Cardiff, UK, and was attended by 150 recognised experts. Discussions and voting were centred on provisional criteria that had been distributed prior to the meeting. The participants debated and voted on these. Each criterion required a consensus agreement of ≥70% for approval.

Results The accepted criteria for an ageing-related pathology, disease or syndrome were:

  1. Develops and/or progresses with increasing chronological age.

  2. Should be associated with, or contribute to, functional decline, or an increased susceptibility to functional decline.

  3. Evidenced by studies in humans.

Conclusions Criteria for an ageing-related pathology, disease or syndrome have been agreed by an international consortium of subject experts. These criteria will now be used by the ICCARP for the classification and ultimately staging of ageing-related pathologies, diseases and syndromes.

Competing Interest Statement

Listed in the manuscript, pp.9-11.

Funding Statement

This project was supported by a Longevity Impetus Grant from Norn Group.

Author Declarations

I confirm all relevant ethical guidelines have been followed, and any necessary IRB and/or ethics committee approvals have been obtained.

Yes

I confirm that all necessary patient/participant consent has been obtained and the appropriate institutional forms have been archived, and that any patient/participant/sample identifiers included were not known to anyone (e.g., hospital staff, patients or participants themselves) outside the research group so cannot be used to identify individuals.

Yes

I understand that all clinical trials and any other prospective interventional studies must be registered with an ICMJE-approved registry, such as ClinicalTrials.gov. I confirm that any such study reported in the manuscript has been registered and the trial registration ID is provided (note: if posting a prospective study registered retrospectively, please provide a statement in the trial ID field explaining why the study was not registered in advance).

Yes

I have followed all appropriate research reporting guidelines, such as any relevant EQUATOR Network research reporting checklist(s) and other pertinent material, if applicable.

Yes

Footnotes

  • Author list updated to include full names and affiliations.

Data Availability

All data produced in the present study are available upon reasonable request to the authors.

Copyright 
The copyright holder for this preprint is the author/funder, who has granted medRxiv a license to display the preprint in perpetuity. All rights reserved. No reuse allowed without permission.
Back to top
Posted September 06, 2024.
Download PDF
Data/Code
Email
Defining an Ageing-Related Pathology, Disease or Syndrome: International Consensus Statement
Emma Short, Ian M. Adcock, Bilal Al-Sarireh, Ann Ager, Ramzi Ajjan, Naveed Akbar, Michael A. Akeroyd, Ghada Alsaleh, Ghada Al-Sharbatee, Kambiz Alavian, Winfried Amoaku, Julie Andersen, Chrystalina Antoniades, Mark J. Arends, Sue Astley, Denize Atan, Richard Attanoos, Johannes Attems, Steve Bain, Konstantinos Balaskas, Gabriel Balmus, Manohar Bance, Thomas M. Barber, Ajoy Bardhan, Karen Barker, Peter Barnes, Gemma Basatemur, Adrian Bateman, Moises Evandro Bauer, Christopher Bellamy, Edwin van Beek, Ilaria Bellantuono, Emyr Benbow, Sunil Bhandari, Rahul Bhatnagar, Philip Bloom, Dawn Bowdish, Melissa Bowerman, Melanie Burke, Roxana Carare, Emma Victoria Carrington, Jorge Iván Castillo-Quan, Peter Clegg, James Cole, Carlo Cota, Paul Chazot, Christopher Chen, Ying Cheong, Gary Christopher, George Church, David Clancy, Paul Cool, Francesco Del Galdo, Mayank Dalakoti, Soumit Dasgupta, Colleen Deane, Devesh Dhasmana, Stefan Dojcinov, Monia Di Prete, Huaidong Du, Niharika A Duggal, Toby Ellmers, Costanza Emanueli, Mark Emberton, Jorge D. Erusalimsky, Laurence Feldmeyer, Alexander Fleming, Karen Forbes, Thomas C. Foster, Daniela Frasca, Ian Frayling, Daniel Freedman, Tamas Fülöp, Georgina Ellison-Hughes, Gus Gazzard, Christopher George, Jesus Gil, Richard Glassock, Rob Goldin, John Green, Robyn Guymer, Hasan Haboubi, Lorna Harries, Simon Hart, Douglas Hartley, Sebri Hasaballa, Christin Henein, Maggie Helliwell, Emily Henderson, Rakesh Heer, Kristofer Holte, Iskander Idris, David Isenburg, Juulia Jylhävä, Ahmed Iqbal, Simon W. Jones, Rajesh Kalaria, Venkateswarlu Kanamarlapudi, Werner Kempf, Alexandra J. Kermack, Jemma Kerns, Albert Koulman, Adnan H. Khan, James Kinross, Katarina Klaucane, Yamini Krishna, Harinderjit Singh Gill, Edward Lakatta, Ezio Laconi, Alpar Lazar, Christiaan Leeuwenburgh, Samantha Leung, Xuan Li, Ian van der Linde, Luísa V. Lopes, Antonello Lorenzini, Andrew Lotery, Pedro Machado, Sarah Mackie, Paolo Madeddu, Andrea Maier, Krishna Mukkanna, Pinelopi Manousou, Oonagh Markey, Claudio Mauro, Barry McDonnell, Reinhold J. Medina, Soma Meran, Claudia Metzler-Baddeley, Ignor Meglinksi, Neta Milman, Christina Mitteldorf, Ruth Montgomery, Andrew Conway Morris, Beda Mühleisen, Abhik Mukherkee, Andrew Murray, Scott Nelson, Anna Nicolaou, Alexander Nirenberg, Simon Noble, Lisa S. Nolan, Meritxell Nus, Canh Van On, Victor Osei-Lah, Mandy Peffers, Antony Palmer, Donald Palmer, Laura Palmer, William Parry-Smith, Graham Pawelec, Shahaf Peleg, Ranmith Perera, Andrew Pitsillides, Christopher J. Plack, Franze Progatzsky, Sonja Pyott, Kaukab Rajput, Sameera Rashid, J. Arjuna Ratnayaka, Sudhira A.B. Ratnayake, Manuel Rodriguez-Justo, Arianna Carolina Rosa, Andrew Rule, Gareth J. Sanger, Ian Sayers, Andrew Saykin, Dinesh Selvarajah, Jaswinder Sethi, Cathy Shanahan, Shai Shen-Orr, Carl Sheridan, Paul Shiels, Kastytis Sidlauskas, Sobha Sivaprasad, Judith Sluimer, Gary Small, Peter Smith, Rebecca Smith, Sarah Snelling, Ioakim Spyridopoulos, Ramasamy Srinivasa Raghavan, David Steel, Karen P Steel, Claire Stewart, Keeron Stone, Selvarani Subbarayan, Mark Sussman, Jonas Svensson, Vyshnavi Tadanki, Ai Lyn Tan, Rudolph E. Tanzi, Amanda Tatler, Adriana A. S. Tavares, Tengku Amatullah Madeehah Tengku Mohd, Ana Tiganescu, James Timmons, Jeremy Tree, Drupad Trivedi, Emmanuel A. Tsochatzis, Dialechti Tsimpida, Elisabeth J Vinke, Anna Whittaker, Neeru A. Vallabh, Kristin Veighey, Zoe C. Venables, Venkat Reddy, Meike W. Vernooij, Chris Verschoor, Manlio Vinciguerra, Vesna Vukanovic, Vladyslav Vyazovskiy, James Walker, Richard Wakefield, Adam J. Watkins, Anthony Webster, Caroline Weight, Birgit Weinberger, Susan L. Whitney, Rosalind Willis, Jacek M. Witkowski, Leonard L.L. Yeo, Tham Yhi Chung, Emma Yu, Michael Zemel, Stuart R.G. Calimport, Barry L. Bentley
medRxiv 2024.09.02.24312951; doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.09.02.24312951
Twitter logo Facebook logo LinkedIn logo Mendeley logo
Citation Tools

Subject Area