ABSTRACT
Background Lower limb vascular trauma (LLVT) represents a significant public health challenge due to its potential to cause complex injuries that are difficult to manage, leading to increased morbidity, mortality and healthcare costs.
Objective to investigate the incidence, lethality, population characteristics, and economic burden of LLVT in Brazil, the largest country in South America, from 2008 to 2023.
Methods We used data from DATASUS (Department of Information and Informatics of the Brazilian Public Health System), which is the world’s largest public health system database. Our analysis focused on LLVT cases surgically treated in Brazil from 2008 to 2023. The study focused on demographic distribution, sex proportion, age groups, regional variations, hospital stays, intensive care unit (ICU) stays, lethality rates and financial expenditures.
Results The study encompassed 20,349 LLVT cases and found a decrease in the number of cases over the years. LLVT was predominantly seen in males (70%), with an average patient age of 39.68 years. The Northeast and North regions registered the highest incidence, while the Southeast had the lowest. Most patients had a short hospital stay, averaging two days. The majority of patients did not need to be admitted to the ICU, and those who did stayed for an average of 4.48 days. The lethality was 5.96%, with bilateral LLVT showing a slightly lower mortality rate than unilateral cases. The total expenditure over 16 years, inferred by the amount passed on to SUS, totaled 9,537,664 USD, indicating a substantial economic impact.
Conclusion LLVT has a significant impact on public health, mainly because it affects the economically active population, with a high risk of death or mutilating sequelae. Although there has been a general decrease in incidence, the persistence of high costs and high lethality rates indicate the need for targeted preventive measures. Future studies must investigate the causes and potential improvements in managing LLVT in Brazil.
INTRODUCTION
Limb trauma is a major public health concern due to its significant impact on the health of those affected, which can lead to social, professional, and psychological damage. Much of the initial understanding of limb injuries comes from the time of the Great Wars. During this period, up to 50% of trauma cases (1,2) involved limb injuries, with the majority caused by penetrating wounds (81% from explosions and 17% from firearm injuries) (1).
In civilian populations, extremity injuries are mainly caused by falls (which account for 50-60% of lower limb injuries), industrial/professional accidents, and road crashes (3).
The worldwide literature widely agrees that vascular traumas are more prevalent in young males (4). Vascular injuries represented about 2% of all trauma cases (5), with LLVT corresponding to 18.5% of vascular traumas (4,5). The LLVT lethality is up to 29% (6). On average, patients with LLVT spent 6 days in the ICU, while those with upper limb vascular traumas spent 4.5 days (4,5). No population-based studies have determined the healthcare costs associated with lower limb vascular traumas.
It is important to note that this information is from studies in developed countries in the northern hemisphere, so it can not be extrapolated to developing or underdeveloped countries, let alone the global population. This is particularly true in less developed countries, where traffic accidents and violence rates are generally higher (7,8).
Brazil, the largest country in Latin America, is a developing nation and has just over 200 million inhabitants (9). The Brazilian health system (SUS - ‘Sistema Único de Saúde’) is considered the largest in the world, as anyone in the Brazilian territory has the right to be treated in this system. Recent statistics indicate that 71% of Brazilians rely exclusively on the SUS (10). All the data collected by the SUS, such as procedures, diagnoses, hospitalizations, outcomes, and demographic characteristics, is publicly available on DATASUS (Departamento de Informação e Informática do SUS), an online portal (11).
This study aimed to analyze data from the DATASUS on the incidence, lethality, demography, costs, and hospitalization time of LLVT in Brazil to present the context of LLVT in a non-developed country.
METHODOLOGY
Study Period, Data Source, and Extraction
Data was collected from DATASUS (11). The analysis focused on vascular trauma procedures of the lower limbs performed from 2008 to 2023. The total population analyzed in this study does not precisely correspond to the entire population of Brazil since some individuals use private health services, which are not accounted for in DATASUS. However, it can be inferred that the study’s total sample is greater than 140 million, corresponding to those who exclusively rely on the public health system (SUS) (10). The statistical calculations considered a population of 140 million individuals.
Automated Data Extraction Process
The data collection process was automated utilizing a Python-based protocol (version 2.7.13; Beaverton, OR, USA) developed by our IT department. The extraction was performed on a Windows 10 system, using Selenium WebDriver (version 3.1.8; Selenium HQ) and Pandas (version 2.7.13; Lambda Foundry, Inc. and PyData Development Team, NY, USA) for data segregation and refining on the DATASUS platform.
Procedure Selection on the Platform
The data on trauma was collected using ICD-10 codes (S00-S99 and T00-T98). It was then filtered by specific procedures: ‘Surgical treatment of bilateral traumatic vascular injuries of the lower limbs’ and ‘Surgical treatment of unilateral traumatic vascular injuries of the lower limbs’, associated with the following codes: 0406020442, 0406020450, 0406020507 and 0406020515. This filtering allowed the focus only on records related to lower limb vascular injuries caused by trauma. Neither amputations nor medically treated LLVT were included in this analysis.
The extracted information included the annual number of procedures, distribution by region, patient demographics (age and gender), length of hospitalization, ICU days, lethality and financial reimbursements. Financial data in Brazilian reais (R$) was converted to US dollars (U$) using the median exchange rate from 2008 to 2023, which was U$1 = R$3.2018 (12).
Data Compilation and Statistical Analysis
The data was compiled and organized in .csv format using Microsoft Office Excel 2019 (Redmond, WA, USA). The Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics (IBGE) obtained population data by age group (13). Statistical analyses were conducted using SPSS version 20.0 for Windows (IBM Corp, Armonk, NY). Linear regression assessed trends in upper limb vascular trauma across age groups. Chi-square and likelihood ratio tests were employed to evaluate regional variations in trauma incidents and lethality. A p-value of ≤ 0.05 was set as the threshold for statistical significance.
Ethical Approval
All data is anonymous and publicly available on the DATASUS online platform. Therefore, no informed consent from participants was necessary. This research received approval from the institution’s Research Ethics Committee (CAAAE 35826320.2.0000.0071).
RESULTS
A total of 20,349 cases of LLVT occurred in Brazil between 2008 and 2023 (16 years), affecting approximately 90 out of every 100,000 people per year. Of the cases, 18,433 (90.6%) were unilateral, and 1,916 (9.4%) affected both lower limbs. The incidence of LLVT decreased from 2008 to 2023. In unilateral LLVT, there was an average decrease of 2.6% per year (mean decrease per year = 0.974; [0.970, 0.979]; p-value < 0.001), and in bilateral cases, the average decrease was 4.7% per year (ratio of average decrease = 0.953; [0.934, 0.973]; p-value < 0.001).
The incidence of LLVT over the years of the study can be observed in Figure 1.
LLVT: Lower Limb Vascular Trauma.
Table 1 shows the values and percentage of unilateral and bilateral LLVT in the 5 regions of Brazil. It is observed that most of the LLVT occurred in the Northeast and Southeast regions. However, when comparing with population size, the highest proportion of cases was observed in the Northeast and North, with approximately 13 cases per 100,000 inhabitants, followed by the South with 12 cases per 100,000 inhabitants, and the Midwest with 10 cases per 100,000 inhabitants. The region with the lowest number of cases per population was the Southeast, with 7 cases per 100,000 inhabitants over 16 years.
LLVT: Lower Limb Vascular Trauma.
Males accounted for the majority of LLVT cases (75.4%): 73.6% of bilateral DVT cases and 75.6% of unilateral cases.
Figure 2 shows the distribution of unilateral and bilateral LLVT cases by age group. There is a peak in incidence between the ages of 20 and 24, followed by a gradual decline until approximately 45 years of age, remaining relatively stable until 70 years. The age group with the least LLVT occurrence is those under 14, followed by those over 65 years for unilateral and bilateral LLVT. The mean age of patients with LLVT was 39.68 years. Furthermore, 13.7% of bilateral LLVT cases occurred in the 0 to 14 age group, whereas only 4.1% of unilateral LLVT cases occurred in this age group (p-value < 0.001). However, in the other age groups, the proportion of unilateral LLVT cases was greater than bilateral cases.
LLVT: Lower Limb Vascular Trauma.
Figure 3 presents the number of hospitalization days for patients with LLVT. Most patients remained hospitalized for 2 days for both unilateral and bilateral LLVT.
LLVT: Lower Limb Vascular Trauma.
Patients with bilateral LLVT required fewer days of hospitalization compared to those with unilateral LLVT. The majority (43.4%) of patients with bilateral LLVT were hospitalized for 0 to 2 days, compared to only 30.8% of patients with unilateral LLVT (p-value < 0.001). In the unilateral LLVT group, the majority (40.6%) were hospitalized for 3 to 7 days. Only 7,0% of patients with bilateral LLVT, compared to 11.3% of those with unilateral LLVT, required hospitalization for 15 days or more (p-value < 0.001).
Table 2 shows that most patients with LLVT did not require ICU admission (87,8% in bilateral LLVT and 82,3% in unilateral LLVT, p-value < 0.001). Among those requiring intensive care, the average number of days spent in the ICU was 4.48 days, among all patients with LLVT.
LLVT: Lower Limb Vascular Trauma.
Over the 16 years of the study, there were 1,212 deaths among patients with LLVT, corresponding to a lethality of 5.96%. The lethality of bilateral and unilateral LLVT were not statistically different, corresponding to 5.7% and 6%, respectively (p-value = 0.714).
Figure 4 presents the lethality across the five regions of Brazil. The region with the highest lethality was the Southeast (7.31%), followed by the South (5.76%), Northeast (5.71%), Midwest (5.09%), and lastly, the North (4.19%), showing a statistically significant difference (p < 0.001). Interestingly, the lethality of bilateral LLVT was higher than unilateral LLVT in only two regions of Brazil, the Southeast and South.
(p-value < 0.001). LLVT: Lower Limb Vascular Trauma.
The distribution of LLVT lethality by year is presented in Figure 5. The lethality of LLVT increased slightly over the years, with minor variations. In unilateral LLVT, there was an increase in lethality with a mean growth rate of 2.8% per year (lethality ratio of 1.028 per year [95% CI: 1.018, 1.039] and a p-value of <0.001). In bilateral LLVT, the increase in lethality was not statistically significant: lethality ratio of 1.021 per year [95% CI: 0.998, 1.044]; p-value = 0.080. Lethality for bilateral LLVT experienced greater fluctuations over the years, which can be explained by the smaller number of patients in this group.
LLVT: Lower Limb Vascular Trauma.
The expenditure on acute LLVT treatment for the Brazilian public healthcare system from 2008 to 2023 was $9,537,664 USD (dollars). The region that incurred the highest expense was the Northeast. Table 4 shows the expenditures by region in Brazil, total and per patient. The total expenditure per patient with LLVT was $469.70 USD. The region that spent the most per patient was the South ($545.53 USD per patient), while the region that spent the least was the Midwest ($390.99 USD per patient).
DISCUSSION
Lower limb injuries can affect four main functional components: nerves, vessels, bones, and soft tissues. Vascular injury is particularly serious, as it can lead to hemorrhages, limb loss, death, and other disabling complications (4). Therefore, the management usually involves promptly addressing the injury in patients who show signs of vascular injury, such as pulsatile tumor, expanding hematoma, or distal ischemia (14).
The main causes of LLVT are firearm injuries, contusions caused by falls or traffic accidents, and stab wounds (15,16). In Brazil, the leading causes of LLVT are unknown. A study from Latin America analyzed just one center in Brazil and showed that the main cause of vascular trauma in all body regions was firearm injuries (17).
Recent studies have reported a higher prevalence of LLVT in Brazil than in other countries. For example, the United States reported 4,265 cases of LLVT over five years (4,5), while Brazil recorded 7,242 cases during the same frame despite having an approximately 50% smaller population (9,18). In comparison, a Scottish population study reported only 80 cases of LLVT over eight years (2011-2018) (6), while Brazil had 10,584 cases during the same period. Even after adjusting for population size, Brazil experienced approximately three times more LLVT cases than Scotland (19).
This study also observed a decline in the incidence of LLVT from 2011 to 2018. A plausible hypothesis for this trend is Brazil’s reduced traffic and occupational accidents over the past two decades (20,21). Additionally, the SARS-COV-19 pandemic may have contributed to this decrease, as the numbers in 2020 and 2021 were lower than in previous years (22).
In terms of Brazil’s macro-regions, the Northeast and North showed the highest incidence of LLVT per capita, while the Southeast had the lowest. This distribution may reflect a higher prevalence of accidents and physical violence in the North, Northeast, and Midwest compared to the Southeast and South (23,24).
Over 70% of LLVT cases in Brazil occurred in males, which is consistent with global findings, where approximately 70% to 80% of cases occur in males (5,25). This aligns with the higher rates of traffic accidents and violence among males (26).
The average age of LLVT patients in Brazil was 39.68 years, consistent with other global studies reporting an average age range of 31 to 50 years (27,28). This demographic is more prone to traffic accidents and violence (26). Accidents, violence, and chronic diseases are significant public health issues impacting a country’s economy (29).
The management of traumatic vascular injuries is well-documented in the literature and can be performed using endovascular or traditional approaches. For lower limb injuries, hemodynamically stable patients with less complex injuries can undergo endovascular treatment using angioplasty balloons and covered stents. Furthermore, angiotomography is the preferred method for diagnosing LLVT. Moreover, arteriography can also be used to support treatment planning and provide access to endovascular repair.
Conventional open treatment of arterial injuries can be categorized into primary amputation, vessel ligation, and revascularization. Primary amputation is typically used for damage control in unstable patients or cases of complex polytrauma with multiple injuries. Vessel ligation suits non-essential vessels, such as smaller veins and arteries. Primary arteriorrhaphy is performed if possible when revascularization is indicated, but in most cases, contralateral venous bypass grafts are required. A study of 74 patients with femoral artery trauma showed that only one of them was eligible for arteriorrhaphy, while bypass revascularization was necessary in 62 cases (30). Another alternative sometimes used is endovascular surgery (31,32).
Most LLVT patients in Brazil required two days of hospitalization. In contrast, the average hospital stay in the USA was 5.9 days for patients under 60 (4) and 13 days for older adults (5) In Australia, the average was 8 days (28). However, these figures are not directly comparable due to potential confounding injuries influencing the duration of hospital stays.
Interestingly, more patients with unilateral LLVT required intensive care treatment compared to those with bilateral LLVT (17.7% versus 12.2%, respectively). This discrepancy may be influenced by additional trauma-related injuries rather than just the lower limb vascular injury alone. The average ICU stay was 4.48 days in Brazil, compared to approximately 6 days in the USA (4,5).
It was initially hypothesized that bilateral LLVT would have higher lethality due to its association with high-energy trauma. Surprisingly, the lethality for bilateral LLVT was slightly lower than for unilateral, with 5.74% and 5.98%, respectively.
Lethality was higher in the Southeast and lower in the North, contradicting expectations of higher lethality in regions with less healthcare access and higher accident and violence rates, such as the North (23,24). LLVT lethality in Brazil was slightly lower than in the USA (6% versus approximately 8%) (4,5). In Scotland, lethality was significantly higher (approximately 21% of LLVT cases) (6), while in Australia it was substantially lower (0.3% of cases) (28).
Over the years, LLVT lethality in Brazil increased from 5% to approximately 6.7%. This trend may correlate with a dramatic rise in homicide rates driven by inequality, increased firearm availability, and drug use (24). Additionally, trend analysis of hospitalizations due to traffic accidents in São Paulo from 2000 to 2019 showed an initial rise in hospitalization rates, followed by stabilization and, in some cases, a resurgence, particularly among motorcyclists (33).
To date, no study has specifically evaluated the costs associated with LLVT. In Brazil, total expenditures of SUS amounted to $9,537,664 over 16 years, representing a considerable cost per patient of $469. The Southeast region spent the most on LLVT per patient, consistent with the greater availability of complex examinations and treatments in this region (34).
LIMITATIONS
One of the limitations is the inability to define the exact population of the study. However, it is estimated to be greater than approximately 140 million, as this is the number of people who exclusively depend on SUS (10). Additionally, like any population-based database study, there is a risk of information bias since data relies on the records of healthcare professionals, which may result in underreporting of vascular traumas, especially if they are associated with other injuries.
In addition, the study did not consider LLVT managed with amputations or those managed clinically. However, it is known that the majority of LLVT are not managed clinically (35). Among those that are, they are rarely coded as “vascular trauma” in information systems based on clinical practice. Amputations are also a relatively uncommon method of managing LLVT (36). Consequently, the number of LLVT may have been slightly underestimated.
Finally, the costs assessed in this study may underestimate the total costs of treating LLVT since the reimbursement amount to SUS, defined by a fixed schedule, is based on what was presented in this research.
CONCLUSION
Despite observed declines in the incidence of LLVT in recent years, concerning levels of lethality persist, especially in the Southeast region. More studies are needed to evaluate the causes of vascular traumas in Brazil so that better prevention strategies can be implemented.
APPENDIX
Footnotes
This version of the manuscript has been revised to update the following: inclusion of improved statistical analysis of the results with comparison between groups and evaluation of statistically significant findings with P<0.001. Improved graphs and tables of the results.