Supporting women, girls and people who menstruate to participate in physical activity – Rapid evidence summary

3.1.1. Barriers to physical activity in relation to the menstrual cycle

Two systematic reviews were identified with a focus on:

• Factors in a sports environment which could facilitate or hinder cyclically menstruating athletes’ healthy sports participation in relation to their menstrual cycles (Srinivasa Gopalan et al. 2024a).

• The impact of symptoms, experiences and perceptions of the menstrual cycle on recreational PA behaviours in the general population (Srinivasa Gopalan et al. 2024b).

Six organisational reports were identified from the grey literature, and these focused on:

• The health barriers to sport in two groups in the UK: school-aged girls and women experiencing menopausal and perimenopausal symptoms (House of Commons 2024).

• Girls’ experiences of menstruation in the UK and explored the impact of menstruation on sport and exercise (Plan International UK 2018).

• Female participation in sport and PA in Scotland and discussed barriers faced by adolescent girls and women of all ages including menstruation (The Scottish Parliament: Health, Social Care and Sport Committee 2023).

• Supporting women aged 41-60 in the UK to be active during midlife and perimenopause/menopause, while exploring barriers to PA participation (Women in Sport 2021).

• Tackling adolescent girls’ disengagement from sport and exercise in the UK while also considering the barrier of periods (Women in Sport 2022).

• School-aged girls’ participation in sport and PAs in the UK, while it examined barriers to PA at school and physical education (PE) in relation to the menstrual cycle. Girls’ ideas were also investigated regarding what schools could do to help them in PE during their menstruation (Youth Sport Trust 2023).

Five primary studies were identified:

• A UK qualitative study that explored adolescent girls’ views on how menstruation influences their PA (Harvey et al. 2020).

• A cross-sectional study that investigated the relationship between menstruation and leisure time PA in female university students in South Korea (Kim et al. 2022).

• A mixed-methods study that aimed to quantify events of the menstrual cycle and self-reported PA avoidance in women in the UK; and to understand women’s lived experiences of PA throughout the menstrual cycle (Kolic et al. 2021).

• A mixed-methods study that assessed the impact of the menstrual cycle on football performance and exercise ability, and identified barriers in relation to menstruation in amateur female footballers in the UK (Pinel et al. 2022).

• A mixed-methods study that examined the effect of menstruation and PMS on habitual participation in adventurous activities (mountaineering, wild camping, running, wild swimming, climbing, etc.) in the UK (Prince & Annison 2023).

3.1.2. Interventions to increase physical activity participation in relation to the menstrual cycle

Two primary studies were identified:

• A quasi-experimental study that examined the effects of social-media-based support on PMS and PA among female university students in South Korea (Nam & Cha 2020).

• A qualitative study that reported the results of a participatory project consisting of two workshops where adolescent participants in Sweden designed menstrual technologies (Sondergaard et al. 2021).

One organisational report was identified, which focused on:

• The impact of the “Big Sister: By girls for Girls” project which aimed to empower and support adolescent girls in the UK to enjoy sport, exercise and PA during puberty. A part of the project was “Hey Girls” which provided free sanitary products for girls in areas of deprivation (Women in Sport 2023).

3.1.3. Wider barriers to physical activity participation of women, girls, and people who menstruate

One overview of reviews was identified, and it focused on:

• Summarising the barriers and facilitators of PA participation in adolescent girls from existing systematic reviews and identifying key areas for fostering gender-responsive action and policy implications (Duffey et al. 2021).

Six systematic reviews were identified, and these focused on:

• Synthesising evidence from qualitative studies relating to adolescent girls’ perceptions of PA participation (Corr et al. 2018).

• Synthesising current literature on barriers to exercise in postpartum women (Edie et al. 2021).

• Investigating pregnant women’s attitudes and perceived barriers and enablers to PA, including the perspectives of women diagnosed with gestational diabetes mellitus (Harrison et al. 2018).

• Examining factors that influence adolescent girls’ participation in sports and categorising these factors into constructs of the planned behaviour theory (Hopkins et al. 2022).

• Synthesising self-identified barriers and facilitators to young adult women’s participation in PA and offering suggestions for future studies in this population (Peng et al. 2023).

• Investigating influencing factors and adaptation approaches of PA interventions among midlife immigrant women (Zou et al. 2021).

3.1.4. Interventions (unrelated to managing the menstrual cycle) to support physical activity participation of women, girls, and people who menstruate

Eight systematic reviews were identified, and these focused on:

• Assessing the impact of PA interventions on adolescent girls and young adults participation in team sport and identifying potential strategies for increasing participation (Allison et al. 2017).

• Evaluating the effectiveness, acceptability, and active behavioural change techniques of mobile PA technologies among midlife women undergoing menopause (AlSwayied et al. 2022).

• Examining the effectiveness of interventions to increase PA among pre-adolescent girls aged 5–11 years (Biddle et al. 2014).

• Describing the available evidence from PA interventions that targeted young and adolescent girls and determining their effectiveness and key characteristics of success (Camacho-Minano et al. 2011).

• Investigating the relationship between social support and PA in adolescent girls aged 10-19 years, and exploring how different types and providers of social support might influence this relationship (Laird et al. 2016).

• Examining interventions targeting the intersection of body image and movement experiences among girls and women (Matheson et al. 2023).

• Examining the effectiveness of interventions for increasing levels of PA and core physical skills in adolescent girls aged 11-18 years (NICE 2008).

• Investigated the implementation and outcomes of telehealth exercise interventions in the postpartum population (Turner et al. 2023).

3.1.5. The effects of physical activity on dysmenorrhea

Three systematic reviews were identified, and these focused on:

• Investigating the effectiveness and safety of exercise for primary dysmenorrhoea (Armour et al. 2019a).

• Analysing the evidence for participant led self-care and lifestyle techniques in primary dysmenorrhea (Armour et al. 2019b).

• Evaluating the effectiveness of PA for the treatment of primary dysmenorrhea (Matthewman et al. 2018).

3.1.6. The effects of exercise on premenstrual syndrome

Two systematic reviews were identified, and these focused on:

• Examining the evidence for the effectiveness of exercise as a treatment for PMS (Pearce et al. 2020).

• Investigating the effect of exercise on premenstrual symptoms (Saglam & Orsal 2020).

3.1.7. The menstrual cycle and exercise performance

One overview of reviews was identified, and it focused on:

• Examining and critically evaluating the influence of menstrual cycle phase on acute performance and chronic adaptations to resistance exercise training (Colenso-Semple et al. 2023).

One scoping review were identified, and it focused on:

• Providing a summary of the biological mechanisms underlying the menstrual cycle’s impact on various performance determining anatomical and physiological parameters, and to identify various proposed concepts and theories that may explain performance changes following hormonal fluctuations (Bernstein & Behringer 2023).

Four systematic reviews were identified, and these focused on:

• Determining the effects of the menstrual cycle on exercise performance and provide evidence-based, practical recommendations to eumenorrheic women (McNulty et al. 2020).

• Establishing a consensus across studies to enable evidence-based recommendations for training individualisation depending on menstrual cycle phases (Meignié et al. 2021).

• Examining the effects of the different menstrual cycle phases on isometric, isokinetic, and dynamic maximum strength in female athletes (Niering et al. 2024).

• The impact of the menstrual cycle phase on perceived exertion during aerobic exercise in eumenorrheic women (Prado et al. 2023).

3.2.1. Barriers to exercising in relation to the menstrual cycle

• A systematic review revealed that cyclically menstruating athletes (amateur to elite level) and their coaches experienced barriers to sport participation, such as menstruation taboo, lack of knowledge and awareness, and lack of communication among stakeholders. Facilitators included female coaches, positive experiences of communicating about the menstrual cycle, and trust (Srinivasa Gopalan et al. 2024a).

• A systematic review which focused on the general population found that adult women and adolescent girls experience barriers to recreational PA participation, such as sociocultural taboo against menstruation, lack of knowledge and resources related to the menstrual cycle. An individualised approach to recreational PA promotion is needed to account for variability in menstrual symptoms and experiences (Srinivasa Gopalan et al. 2024b).

• A House of Commons (2024) report suggested that barriers to school-aged girls’ sport and exercise participation were partly driven by hormonal differences. The barriers included: difference between girls’ and boys’ puberty experiences; lack of timely school education on managing the menstrual cycle; insufficient training for teachers on how to educate on the menstrual cycle; PE teachers’ inadequate understanding on girls’ experiences of puberty. One highlighted recommendation to increase participation in PE was that schools should allow a wide choice of kit for girls to improve comfort. Identified barriers for women’s (aged 41-60) participation included perimenopausal and menopausal symptoms.

• An organisational report, which focused on girl’s experience of menstruation in the UK, identified the universal issues of stigma, taboo, access to menstrual products, and pain management. The main barrier to sport and exercise participation was concern over leaking (Plan International UK 2018).

• The Scottish Parliament: Health, Social Care and Sport Committee (2023) reported that there was a persistent gender gap in the rates of participation in sport and PA. Barriers faced by adolescent girls included a lack understanding of the impact that menstruation can have on their participation in PA. Further barriers included access and appropriateness of toilet/changing facilities and sports kit. The Scottish Government’s Women’s Health Plan encourages education about menstrual health as part of the Scottish curriculum, although evaluation of this plan has not been undertaken. Additionally, new statutory guidance on school uniforms could address issues with sport kit. Barriers faced by women of all ages included period pain, leakage, and lack of adequate toilet facilities in sports environments.

• An organisational report from Women in Sport (2021) found that approximately one third of women aged 41-60 did not meet PA guidelines. Based on a survey, while 30% of women reported lower activity levels since menopause, 71% of women wanted to be more active. Ninety percent of respondents would be more open to the idea if PA was prescribed by a GP or healthcare professional. Reported barriers included limited perception of what PA could entail, fear of standing out and judgement. Suggested interventions included creating support networks, expanding their frame of reference on PA, and engaging health professionals and employers to help encourage women to take up PA in midlife.

• An organisational report of a large survey including over 4,000 adolescent boys and girls identified a gender gap regarding disengagement from sport and exercise, with 43% of girls saying that they used to be sporty but no longer are compared to 24% of boys (Women in Sport 2022). Barriers faced by girls included self-belief, capability, body image and periods. Around 7 in 10 avoided being active when on their period, with barriers including pain (73%), fear of leakage (62%), tiredness (52%) and self-consciousness (45%).

• An organisational report from Youth Sport Trust (2023) highlighted that 38% of secondary school aged girls reported their periods as a barrier to participating in PA in school, and 21% reported it out of school. Overall, periods were the most reported barrier. Only 51% of girls reported that they were comfortable to take part in PE whilst on their period. Almost half of the girls surveyed (48%) reported that they were not at all comfortable with discussing their period with their teacher, with 8% reporting that they were comfortable to do so. Girls’ main concerns about participating in PE or school sport whilst on their period were: pain and discomfort (68%), leaking (60%), and low mood (57%). When asked about how school could help them take part in PE whilst on their period, 40% requested teachers to have more empathy and understanding. Over half of the responding girls (56%) wanted more options in PE kit.

• A qualitative study conducted by Harvey et al. (2020) identified barriers to adolescent girls’ PA participation during menstruation, such as feeling unprepared due to insufficient information about menstruation received too late (following menarche); fear of leaking; feeling exposed and uncomfortable; clothing; disliking tampons; and menstrual symptoms. Facilitators included social influences, shared responsibility with peers in sports, and being active helped relieve premenstrual symptoms. Participants reported diverse strategies to overcome barriers including wearing dark clothing, carrying spare underwear, choosing lower intensity activities, among others.

• A cross-sectional survey of female university students in South Korea found that those with regular menstruation patterns had higher health consciousness, greater level of PA and intention to participate in leisure time PA than those with irregular periods (Kim et al. 2022).

• A mixed methods study of women’s experiences revealed that those who avoided PA when menstruating reported heavier periods, higher levels of fatigue and pain compared to non-avoiders (Kolic et al. 2021). Reasons for PA avoidance or modification included menstrual symptoms, personal thoughts, and concerns about other people’s views on menstruation.

• A mixed methods study, which focused on amateur female footballers, revealed that 73% of participants felt that menstruation presented one or more barriers to football participation. Confidence and aerobic capacity were identified to be the most negatively impacted during pre-menstrual and menstrual stages (Pinel et al. 2022).

• A mixed methods study of women attending adventurous activities (mountaineering, wild camping, running, wild swimming, climbing, etc.) found that 89% of participants felt that their activity participation was affected by menstruation/PMS. Barriers to participation in adventurous activities included challenges posed by hygiene and waste disposal during menstruation (Prince & Annison 2023).

3.2.2. Interventions to increase exercise participation in relation to the menstrual cycle

• A quasi-experimental study found that female university students in South Korea who used social media-based support significantly increased their amount of PA and their premenstrual symptoms decreased compared to the control group (Nam & Cha 2020).

• A qualitative workshop in Sweden focused on designing menstrual technologies which responded to adolescents’ premenstrual symptoms in collaboration with the participants. They found that a toolkit approach to the design of menstrual technologies allowed for pluralist experiences of menstrual cycles (Sondergaard et al. 2021).

• The Big Sister project in 11 deprived areas of the UK aimed to empower and support adolescent girls to enjoy sport, exercise and PA during puberty. Some of the barriers it aimed to tackle were period poverty and stigma. By collaborating with the “Hey Girls” project (an award-winning “buy one, donate one” social enterprise) they provided free sanitary products for girls in areas of deprivation. Different types of products and information about periods were distributed in women’s toilets/changing rooms at leisure centres, schools, and community projects. Evaluation of The Big Sister project showed positive impact on girls’ engagement in sport and PA with 44% of girls doing a lot more exercise, 64% enjoying taking part, 61% feeling motivated to take part and 58% more confident to take part in sport and exercise (Women in Sport 2023).

3.2.3. Wider barriers to physical activity participation of women, girls, and people who menstruate

• An overview of reviews identified multiple factors that affect adolescent girls’ participation in PAs. The most common barriers were lack of support from peers and/or family, and limited time, while family, peer and teacher support and weight loss were identified as facilitators of PA participation. Identified areas for practice and policy implementation included: inclusive approach to addressing gender norms in the curriculum; training for professionals working with adolescents; environmental change to ensure safety and attractiveness of the PA settings; engagement of multiple stakeholders at local, regional, and national level in incorporating a gender-responsive approach toward PA participation (Duffey et al. 2021).

• A systematic review of qualitative studies identified adolescent girls’ barriers to PA participation, such as gender bias in sport, motivation and perceived competence, and competing priorities. Meeting societal expectations, such as peer and adult influences were seen to have both positive and negative aspects regarding PA participation. Community influences were also identified, and rural settings were associated with limited choice of activities. In urban settings while there was a variety of activities, financial constraints often hindered participation (Corr et al. 2018).

• A mixed methods systematic review reported that postpartum women’s barriers to exercise commonly included tiredness/lack of sleep, lack of time due to domestic chores/responsibilities, and insufficient support from family, friends and other mothers, weather, and breast feeding. Additionally, it was advised that physical therapists and other healthcare professionals should be aware of the unique barriers to exercise amongst postpartum women to provide counselling strategies and meaningful education to this population (Edie et al. 2021).

• A systematic review revealed that pregnant women had positive attitudes regarding PA, acknowledging its importance and benefits. Barriers were often intrapersonal and included fatigue, lack of time, and pregnancy related discomfort. Additionally, enablers included maternal and foetal health benefits, social support, and pregnancy specific programs. Person-centred strategies using behaviour change techniques should be used to address barriers and translate pregnant women’s positive attitudes into increased PA participation. There was little information found on barriers and enablers for PA in pregnant women with gestational diabetes (Harrison et al. 2018).

• A systematic review reported factors associated with adolescent girls’ sport participation including personal, peer, family, socioeconomic, and other circumstances. Personal factors, including self-perceptions and desirable personal outcomes related to sport, were most frequently associated with participation (Hopkins et al. 2022).

• A systematic review identified barriers to PA for young adult women that included factors such as time, body image, societal beauty standards, family duty, social support, religious and cultural norms, safety issues, facilities and physical environment (Peng et al. 2023).

• A systematic review identified multiple factors that influenced midlife immigrant women’s PA participation. These included individual, familial and community factors. Individual factors related to health status, limited time, lack of motivation and proficiency in life skills, such as language proficiency, driving, and PA knowledge. Familial factors consisted of family support and seasonality (as in seasonal celebrations), while community factors related to social support and physical environment (Zou et al. 2021).

3.2.4. Interventions (unrelated to managing the menstrual cycle) to support PA participation of women, girls and people who menstruate

• A systematic review found that PA interventions may encourage adolescent girls and young adults (11-25 years) to try new sports. However, there was limited evidence of sustained participation. Recommended strategies included consultation with girls, implementation of peer-leaders and friendship group elements, early intervention, and considerations for setting (Allison et al. 2017).

• A systematic review with a meta-analysis conducted by AlSwayied et al. (2022) showed that there was a small to moderate increase of 61.38 weekly minutes in moderate to vigorous PA in midlife women undergoing menopause following mobile based PA interventions. Positive improvements were also found in menopause-related outcomes, such as weight reduction, anxiety management, sleep quality, and menopause-related quality of life. Participants perceived mobile PA interventions to be acceptable and helpful.

• A systematic review with a meta-analysis indicated that PA interventions for pre-adolescent girls had a small statistically significant effect in increasing participation. Subgroup analysis indicated that interventions that were educational or multicomponent, or those aimed at girls only were more effective than others (Biddle et al. 2014).

• A systematic review suggested that the most effective interventions to promote PA among young and adolescent girls were those that were school-based and multicomponent with PE tailored to girls’ unique needs. Additionally, it showed influence of peers more promising than family support (Camacho-Minano et al. 2011).

• A systematic review and meta-analysis of cross-sectional studies suggested that social support is not a strong predictor of PA in adolescent girls. However, support from parents and friends may have a role in changing girls’ PA behaviour (Laird et al. 2016).

• A systematic review and meta-analysis found that interventions that target the intersection of body image and movement for girls and women led to a small statistically significant improvement in body image at post-test. However, long-term effect detected at follow-up was not significant. Additionally, while body image and movement focused interventions had an effect on fitness outcomes, they were found to have no statistically significant effect on movement behaviour (Matheson et al. 2023).

• A systematic review by National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) (2008) identified school and primary care based interventions that promoted PA for adolescent girls. These interventions consisted of mediated (delivered via computer, phone or printed material) counselling and educational elements. Findings indicate that school-based interventions outside of PE targeting PA behaviour only could have a moderate-to-large effect.

• A systematic review found that telehealth interventions in postpartum women could increase moderate to vigorous PA (Turner et al. 2023). While the majority of included studies showed an effect (n=10), some studies had no significant impact. Findings indicate that video consultations might be most effective.

3.2.5. The effects of physical activity on dysmenorrhea

• A systematic review with meta-analysis found low quality evidence that exercise for 45-60 minutes three times or more weekly may provide a significant reduction in menstrual pain intensity, and therefore could be used solely or in conjunction with other modalities such as non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (Armour et al. 2019a).

• A systematic review with meta-analysis suggested that self-care and lifestyle interventions, such as self-directed acupressure, exercise, and heat all reduced menstrual pain symptoms. Exercise had the largest effect and alongside heat was more effective at reducing menstrual pain symptoms than analgesics (Armour et al. 2019b).

• A systematic review found moderate to low certainty evidence that PA could effectively reduce menstrual pain intensity and duration. However, there is a need for high quality trials (Matthewman et al. 2018).

3.2.6. The effects of physical activity on premenstrual syndrome

• A systematic review with meta-analysis suggests that exercise interventions could reduce overall, psychological, physical, and behavioural symptoms of PMS (Pearce et al. 2020). However, due to heterogeneity of included studies and high risk of bias, uncertainty remains.

• A systematic review found that exercise improved premenstrual symptoms in women including physical and psychological symptoms, such as pain, constipation, breast sensitivity, anxiety and anger. (Saglam & Orsal 2020).

3.2.7. The menstrual cycle and exercise performance

• An overview of reviews found largely inconsistent evidence of marked differences in strength, exercise performance, and hypertrophy throughout menstrual cycle phases (Colenso-Semple et al. 2023).

• A scoping review suggested that oestrogen and progesterone is responsible for differences in athletic performance throughout the menstrual cycle (Bernstein & Behringer 2023). However, the evidence base mainly consists of animal and in vitro research, and more high quality human studies using cycle monitoring methodology is needed.

• A systematic review with meta-analysis found that exercise performance had a very small reduction during the early follicular phase of the menstrual cycle, compared to all other phases. (McNulty et al. 2020).

• A systematic review found a variable association between menstrual cycle and elite athletes’ performance-related outcomes, such as endurance or power resistance, ligament stiffness, decision making skills, psychology, or competitiveness. (Meignié et al. 2021).

• A systematic review with meta-analysis suggested that the early follicular phase is unfavourable for all maximal strength performance. Isometric strength peaks and dynamic strength is optimal in the late follicular phase, while isokinetic strength is the highest during ovulation (Niering et al. 2024).

• A systematic review and meta-analysis found that menstrual cycle phases did not impact rating of perceived exertion during exercise (Prado et al. 2023). However, further research is needed on the topic.