Abstract
Background Human schistosomiasis caused by Schistosoma intercalatum is poorly understood compared to other species of public health importance, such as S. haematobium, S. mansoni, and S. japonicum. The restricted distribution of S. intercalatum in Africa, its perceived low virulence, and poor understanding of its pathological consequences are possible reasons for this neglect. However, schistosomiasis as a public health problem cannot be eradicated without adequate knowledge of existing species of schistosomes and the biological interactions between them, their hosts, and the environment. Current information on S. intercalatum is often confused with the previous S. intercalatum (Lower Guinea strain) which has now been described as S. guineensis n. sp. The S. intercalatum (Zaire strain) with known foci only in Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) is now recognized as the ‘true’ S. intercalatum species. Investigators not conversant with the present status of both species still get confused in understanding the literature hence this review. It is essential to discuss available knowledge on S. intercalatum and highlight gaps that are critical for deepening our understanding of the parasite in the DRC.
Methods Thus, we systematically review existing available literature on S. intercalatum obtained from PubMed Central, Web of Science, Embase, and Scopus databases according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. Relevant publications were screened and publications reporting S. intercalatum from other than the DRC were excluded. Eligible studies on the epidemiology and biology of S. intercalatum were reviewed.
Results Based on 38 publications that met our inclusion criteria, we confirm that S. intercalatum is the most neglected among Schistosoma species responsible for human schistosomiasis. We discuss our synthesis of the available information in the context of the distribution, biology, pathology, and genetics of S. intercalatum. Also highlighted are outstanding questions on S. intercalatum population genomics, hybridization with other Schistosoma species, snail vector host, zoonotic epidemiology, and pathology.
Conclusion The review calls for a rekindling of research interest in the parasite and the need to answer fundamental questions that can deepen our understanding of the parasite epidemiology, disease ecology, and environmental interactions to help in control strategies and elimination.
Introduction
Three parasitic worm species in the genus Schistosoma (S. mansoni, S. japonicum, and S. haematobium) are the widely recognized and studied causative agents of human schistosomiasis. Schistosoma japonicum and S. mansoni are responsible for intestinal schistosomiasis, while S. haematobium is responsible for urogenital schistosomiasis. Other species include S. guineensis, S. intercalatum, and S. mekongi, which have a lower global prevalence because of their localized distribution and, thus, are the least studied [1,2].
The adult stages of the parasites lodge in the host’s blood vessels within the intestinal or urogenital systems, where the mature female produces thousands of eggs, which are deposited in various tissues and organs, most notably the liver, bladder, small and large intestine, cervix, and vagina. Most disease pathology arises from inflammatory reactions and immune responses due to trapped eggs in the various organs. It can result in complications such as hepatosplenomegaly, periportal fibrosis, bladder cancer, and female genital schistosomiasis [1, 2].
Although under-studied because of its localized distribution, and first identified in the Upper Congo by Chesterman, S. intercalatum is also of medical importance as responsible for rectal schistosomiasis. [3]. In 1934, Fisher [4] described the parasite as a new species of schistosome, and the features of the eggs essentially led to the name ’intercalatum’ to underscore the intermediate profile when compared to eggs by S. haematobium and the bovine schistosome S. bovis [4]. Before the year 2003, two unique populations of S. intercalatum were recognized and marked by specific geographic locations, snail hosts, prepatent period in snail, egg morphometrics, isoenzyme patterns, Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA (RAPD), and Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism (RFLP) [5 - 10]. Pages [11] supported by DNA sequencing data, grouped the S. intercalatum populations from the Lower Guinea forest region of Cameroon as a unique species described as S. guineensis n. sp. Other countries in the Lower Guinea forest region with reported foci for S. guineensis include Gabon, Equatorial Guinea, Nigeria, Benin Republic, and Sao Tome and Principe. Presently, S. intercalatum is known to have foci only in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC) [12, 13].
Although the distinct taxonomic status of S. intercalatum and S. guineensis was established in 2003, the large literature on S. intercalatum prior to 2003 has yet to be systematically reviewed and sorted according to species. Investigators not conversant with the present status of both species still get confused in understanding the literature. In this review, we focus only on literature pertaining to S. intercalatum species with known loci in the DRC. We discuss our synthesis of the available information in the context of the distribution, biology, pathology, and genetics of S. intercalatum.
Methodology
Eligibility
Our primary objective was to compile peer-reviewed research publications, review articles, and case reports pertaining only to S. intercalatum species from the DRC. We aimed at synthesizing the information from all available publications from the 1900s till date. Our inclusion and exclusion criteria were based on the geographical source of the S. intercalatum reported in a publication. Literature reporting S. intercalatum originating from the DRC was included, while publications citing S. intercalatum originating from other African countries were considered as S. guineensis and thus excluded from our pool of literature for the review.
Literature search strategy
Three authors, OGA, JPKM, and ELK were responsible for the literature search and selection. Both JPKM and ELK are fluent French speakers and were therefore able to thoroughly appraise publications that were in the French language. A literature search of bibliographic databases Web of Science, EMBASE, SCOPUS, and PubMed Central was conducted between April 2022 and August 2023 for publications reported between the year 1900 to August 2023. To complement the database search, a manual search of publications was conducted by examining references from reviews and opinion articles on S. intercalatum or other Schistosoma species. Two search terms, “Schistosoma intercalatum” and “intercalatum” were used within field tags ‘Article Title,’ Abstract,’ and ‘Key Words’. Analysis of the retrieved literature complied with the reporting elements for systematic reviews guidelines prescribed in the PRISMA 2020 statement for reporting systematic reviews [14].
Results
A total of 2,814 publications were retrieved from bibliographic databases, and after screening, 38 met the eligibility criteria and were used for full-text review (Fig.1).
PRISMA chart of literature selection process on Schistosoma intercalatum
Discussion
Schistosoma intercalatum in the DRC
The history of S. intercalatum in the DRC dates to early 1900 in the regions around the former Belgian Congo (the present-day countries of DRC, the Republic of Congo, and parts of the Central African Republic). Several investigators reported terminal-spined S. haematobium-like eggs exclusively from stool samples in several foci in the Belgian Congo (see review in Fisher, [4]). Gillet and Wolfs [15] have also provided detailed historical accounts of the distribution and biology of three agents of schistosomiasis (S. mansoni, S. haematobium, and S. intercalatum) in the Belgian Congo. The last review of published research on schistosomiasis in the DRC confirmed the occurrence of one or more species of Schistosoma by microscopy (S. mansoni, S. haematobium, and S. intercalatum) in all but one of the provinces in the country [16]. The current prevalence rate of S. intercalatum is unknown. However, old reports based on microscopic analysis indicated it ranges between 1 and 10% [9, 17], except for the study by Gillet and Wolfs [15] and Schwetz [18], which reported above 30%. Although there are no recent reports of the bovine schistosome S. bovis in the DRC, its occurrence has been documented previously [18, 19]. In these studies, which used 781 cattle to determine the possible associations between different bovine trematode species in the Ituri region of the DRC, S. bovis adult worms were recovered from the mesenteric veins.
Biology of S. intercalatum
i. Lifecycle
Schistosoma intercalatum lifecycle, larval and adult stages are similar to other known human Schistosoma species (Fig. 2). Fisher [4] and Wright [5] have provided morphometric and behavioral information on the species from isolates originally derived from a patient in Kinshasa, which were experimentally passaged through infected mice or hamsters.
The life-cycle of S. intercalatum and its hybrid.
The cercariae of S. intercalatum and S. guineensis (formerly S. intercalatum, Lower Guinea strain) have been observed to concentrate near the surface of the water and readily attach to floating debris or the sides of a container in the laboratory, in contrast to S. mansoni cercariae, which typically swim to the surface of the water, rest briefly, and sink partially before swimming back [5, 20].
ii. Snail host
Crucial to the lifecycle of schistosomes are the appropriate intermediate snail hosts, and for S. intercalatum, Fisher [4] reported Physopsis africana (old nomenclature), now Bulinus africanus. However, the known difficulty in accurately morphologically identifying Bulinus species in Africa warrants the use of currently available molecular tools to aid species identification [8, 21 - 23]. Wright et al. [5] were unsuccessful in infecting several Bulinus species (B. africanus, B. globosus, B. ugandae, B. nasutus, B. forskalii, and B. camerunensis) that had been collected from various countries in Africa and bred in the lab with S. intercalatum. Only B. globosus from South Africa, Ghana, Zimbabwe, Sudan, and B. wrighti from Saudi Arabia were successfully infected. However, Wright et al. [5] observed a lengthier prepatent period compared with other species of Schistosoma investigated in the study. Frandsen [6, 24], however, demonstrated successful experimental S. intercalatum infections of B. globosus from Malawi, Togo, Rhodesia (Zimbabwe), and DRC. Interestingly, B. africanus from Kenya and Tanzania were susceptible to S. intercalatum, while the albino strain of B. globosus from Zimbabwe was the most compatible compared to other snail species successfully infected. De Clercq [17] also confirmed B. globosus as natural hosts for S. intercalatum in the DRC. However, Tchuem Tchuenté et al. [9] were unsuccessful in finding naturally infected snails for S. intercalatum in the DRC but reported similar experimental results reported by Wright et al. [5]. The snail infection trials demonstrated incompatibility between S. intercalatum and B. forskalii, B. truncatus/B. tropicus complex, and B. africanus group, except for B. globosus from Zambia and B. wrighti snails. Although Frandsen [6, 24] has done extensive snail host specificity experiments for S. intercalatum, they were by no means exhaustive of the diversity of Bulinus species in Africa [8]. Also, the susceptibility and compatibility of other non-Bulinus species to S. intercalatum are yet unknown.
How snail hosts genetic diversity impacts S. intercalatum presents an intriguing line of research, and in the scenario of hybridization between S. intercalatum and other Schistosoma species, it would be essential to determine if hybrid S. intercalatum recruits new snail hosts. Questions on the genetic basis of Bulinus-S. intercalatum interaction is unanswered. On the possibility of control strategies targeting snail hosts, there is a need to identify genes that convey natural resistance to S. intercalatum in Bulinus species, which may facilitate ways of disrupting the parasite’s life cycle and reducing transmission to humans.
iii. Reservoir hosts
Unlike the two main agents of intestinal schistosomiasis (S. mansoni and S. japonicum) with a broad spectrum of reservoir hosts, no known natural reservoir hosts for S. intercalatum in the DRC have been identified. Monkeys, Congo clawless otters (Aonyx congica), sheep, and goats examined for S. intercalatum by Fisher [4] were uninfected. However, Fisher [4] successfully infected a male sheep with cercariae of S. intercalatum. Schwetz [18] was also able to infect both sheep and goats with S. intercalatum using the same route of infection as by Fisher [4], although no one else has ever tried this route to confirm these findings.
The role of animal reservoir hosts in S. intercalatum transmission remains unexplored. Fisher [4] and Schwetz [18] examined a few mammalian species without recording any natural host for S. intercalatum. Several species of rodents across Africa are known to serve as natural reservoir hosts of several species of Schistosoma and hybrid S. haematobium x S. bovis [25, 26]. The rodent species frequenting water bodies in schistosomiasis endemic communities in the DRC will be interesting for investigation. There is now a wide range of molecular approaches for detecting pathogens that do not require invasive sampling. Also, environmental DNA techniques provide an opportunity for detecting nucleic acid traces in various environmental samples [27 - 29].
Pathology of S. intercalatum
There is generally a dearth of information on the clinical aspects of S. intercalatum due to limited studies on the parasite. There is a need for an adequate understanding of the pathological impacts of the parasite to inform necessary control and elimination strategies. Fisher [4] and Schwetz [18] have highlighted several S. intercalatum clinical signs similar to other intestinal human schistosomiasis caused by S. mansoni, S. guineensis, and S. japonicum. Wolfe [30] provided a case report of an American family returning to the USA from Kisangani, Eastern DRC who were infected with S. intercalatum after parasitological examination of stool. The common symptoms that have been reported include abdominal pain, blood in stool, dysentery, and a few cases of palpable, enlarged livers. None of the reported cases showed any marked degree of anemia.
Molecular epidemiology of S. intercalatum
Before the separation of the Lower Guinea strain of S. intercalatum (now S. guineensis) from the DRC S. intercalatum species, genotyping studies of both species were performed using isoenzyme patterns, Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA (RAPD) and Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism (RFLP) [7 - 9]. DNA-sequence data based on three mitochondrial genes, (cytochrome oxidase subunit 1 (cox1), NADH dehydrogenase subunit 6 (nad6) and small ribosomal RNA (rrnS)) was pivotal evidence for the eventual distinctions between the two species and the subsequent description of S. guineensis [10 - 12]. Presently the available DNA sequence data on S. intercalatum archived on the NCBI nucleotide database is problematic because some of the sequences labeled as S. intercalatum are that of S. guineensis [11 - 13] (Table 1). Unfortunately, most nucleotide sequences deposited at the NCBI are rarely revised or corrected after their initial submission. Apart from sequence alignments consistent with the phylogram reported in [11, [12], and [13], users can quickly ascertain the NCBI sequence data on S. intercalatum by checking the country of origin of the isolate (S. intercalatum will expectedly be from DRC). Webster et al. [13] have also provided information for the correct taxonomic names for sequences on the NCBI nucleotide database labeled as S. intercalatum (now S. guineensis) and those from DRC representing S. intercalatum.
Table 1. Correct names for nucleotide sequences labeled as Schistosoma intercalatum on NCBI
Outstanding questions on S. intercalatum
Although schistosomiasis is considered a neglected tropical disease, S. intercalatum appears to be the most neglected among the species that cause human schistosomiasis. It is probably due to the difficulty in accessing new specimens from DRC after decades of protracted conflicts and insecurity in the country. The genetic basis for the restricted distribution of S. intercalatum is still unknown. However, the availability of modern DNA sequencing technologies, including Next Generation Sequencing (NGS), provides an opportunity for robust genomic investigations on S. intercalatum. Some outstanding questions still in need of answers include:
Genetic diversity and population genetics / genomics: Compared to other Schistosoma species of medical importance, there is no information on the genetic diversity or population genetics of S. intercalatum. Given the large landmass area of the DRC with its diverse ecological zones and abundant wildlife, it would be interesting to unravel the evolutionary dynamics of the parasite over time.
Hybridization: Interspecific hybridization has been demonstrated to occur in the laboratory within the S. haematobium species complex, which is comprised of eight sister species including S. intercalatum, S. guineensis, S. bovis, S. mattheei, S. margrebowei, S. leiperi, S. curassoni, and S. kisumuensis) [37, 38]. Increasingly, hybrids are being recovered from field sites, but the true extent to which this is occurring in nature remains enigmatic. This is largely because no systematic genotyping strategy exists, and only limited gene markers or genome-scale datasets have been derived from Schistosoma samples collected from natural infections. To date, interspecific hybrids within the S. haematobium group species have been described especially between S. haematobium x S. bovis (reviewed in [39]), S. haematobium x S. guineensis [38], S. haematobium x S. mattheei [39] and S. bovis x S. curassoni [40]. DNA sequence data has thus far not identified any field isolates that exist as S. intercalatum hybrids with other Schistosoma species, although, based on isoenzyme analysis, Tchuem Tchuenté et al. [9] reported that natural hybridization is occurring between S. haematobium and S. intercalatum in the DRC. The reference genome for S. intercalatum, sequenced as part of a consortia project [41] is freely available on the NCBI Short Read Archives (see [40] for details) and appears to be devoid of mixed ancestry. However, previous S. intercalatum hybridization experiments with S. guineensis or S. mansoni have established that S. intercalatum is mating competent under laboratory conditions with its sister species, S. guineensis [42 - 44]. Through a suite of genome analysis tools, it is now possible to analyse the direction of introgression within inter species hybrids, to identify introgressed genes, and to establish whether the hybrids could alter virulence phenotypes [37, 45].
Epidemiology and pathology: Tchuem Tchuenté [9], to our knowledge, is the last peer-reviewed publication on the epidemiology of S. intercalatum from the DRC. There is a need for a nationwide epidemiological survey to determine the current prevalence of S. intercalatum or its hybrid in the DRC and neighbouring countries and detailed documentation of clinical signs of the disease. Importantly, molecular studies of samples from such nationwide surveys will provide information to understand if S. intercalatum has been entirely replaced by S. haematobium as was reported for S. guineensis replacement by S. haematobium in [46 - 48].
Conclusion
Arguably, the 1990s intense security challenges in the DRC affected the study of S. intercalatum. Now that the security in the DRC has improved, there is a need for renewed interest in studying S. intercalatum. While lessons learned from current research in Africa on the two major African human schistosome species, S. mansoni and S. haematobium, can be applied in other endemic regions, there is no such scenario for S. intercalatum. It is of epidemiological importance to know the degree to which S. intercalatum is cross-hybridizing vs. inbreeding and whether this is impacting the incidence and severity of rectal schistosomiasis in the country. In light of the World Health Organization’s roadmap for the elimination of human schistosomiasis, an understanding of the molecular epidemiology of all causative agents and the complex interactions between them, their various host species, and the disease ecology are all vital.
Declarations
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Not Applicable
Consent for publication
Not Applicable
Availability of data and materials
All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article.
Competing Interest
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Funding
This research received no external funding.
Author Contributions
OGA, ELK and JPKM did the literature searches; OGA and JPKM wrote the manuscript. JPKM and MJM updated the text; ELK and DMN reviewed the manuscript; and OGA and JPKM organized and edited the final manuscript.
Data Availability
All data produced in the present work are contained in the manuscript
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Elisha Enabulele for generating the outstanding figure, and Michael Grigg for critical reading of the manuscript.
References
