Associations Between Air Pollution and relative Leukocyte Telomere Length Among Northern Swedish Adults: Insights from the Betula Study

1. Introduction

Ambient (outdoor) air pollution is a major global health concern (1). The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that ambient air pollution causes 3.5 million premature deaths annually and that 99% of the world’s population are currently being exposed to levels above the current air quality guidelines outlined by WHO in 2021 (2). Even at relatively low concentrations, adverse health effects of air pollution thus persist, highlighting its ongoing harm to human health (3).

Extensive evidence from large-scale studies and meta-analyses has demonstrated associations between exposure to ambient particulate air pollution, and the development of dementia (4). With an ageing population, dementia is now the leading cause of death in some European countries, for example the UK and Belgium. Alzheimer’s disease (AD) stands as the primary cause of dementia and is characterized by various pathological features, including the buildup of amyloid-β plaques and neurofibrillary tau tangles, which result from complex interactions among genetic and lifestyle factors (4). Given the absence of a definitive therapy for AD and other dementia disorders, it is imperative to identify biomarkers that can help predict an individual’s susceptibility to the disease. Notably, air pollution, as a modifiable environmental risk factor, presents an opportunity to address the risk of dementia (4, 5). It is thus furthermore imperative to understand the role of air pollution on such potential biomarkers.

With the ultimate goal of preventing and better treatments for AD and other dementia disorders, a deeper understanding of the molecular-level impact of air pollution and its effects on cellular biomarkers is crucial. Telomeres, the non-coding ends of chromosomes, play a pivotal role in maintaining genomic stability and integrity by safeguarding the coding genome (6). These protective caps prevent chromosome erosion and fusion, but successively shorten during DNA replication and cell division. Comprised of repeated DNA sequences and specialized proteins, telomeres form a complex structure crucial for cellular health and longevity (7). Accumulating evidence has linked shorter relative leukocyte telomere length (rLTL) with aging, AD (8), age-related diseases and mortality (9). Research indicates that telomeres undergo progressive shortening with age, but various environmental and lifestyle factors can expedite this process. The harmful effects of air pollutants are rooted in inflammation, characterized by oxidative stress and systemic inflammation, raising concerns about their potential impact on cellular integrity and aging as well as overall health. Unravelling the effects of air pollution on telomere length can thus provide insights into the underlying mechanisms through which environmental factors influence human health and disease progression.

According to a systematic review of 12,058 subjects from 2018, exposure to air pollution (long-term, short-term or occupational exposure) may shorten telomere length (10). In a systematic review from 2019, only four studies were deemed high enough quality for a meta-analysis however, and the meta-estimate was inconclusive (11).

Health effects of air pollution in general, and inflammatory effects specifically, can be expected to differ depending on the composition of air pollution, both in terms of dominating sources of local air pollutants and the proportion of pollution coming from near sources or from long distance transport. It has for example been suggested that air pollution from sources nearby is more harmful for health than regional-level air pollution (12). To date, no previous study on air pollution and telomere length has distinguished between different sources of air pollution, or between local or regional air pollution. Studies in areas with low levels of air pollution and high-resolution air pollution models are furthermore lacking.

This study aims to address this gap by exploring the association between air pollution and rLTL in a low-level air pollution area while distinghuishing between different sources of local air pollution, and between local and total air pollution (where the latter include air pollution from long-range transport).

2. Material and Methods

3. Results

In the Betula study sample, 519 individuals had their rLTL measured during T2. Furthermore, residualization of rLTL against age and gender varibles resulting in a refined dataset consisting of 473 participants for initial analysis. Detailed characteristics of these participants can be found in Table 1.

The age of the participants ranged from 40 to 85 years (mean: 61.7 years, standard deviation (SD): 14.7). Among this group, 53.1% were female, 47.4% were smokers, and 27% had completed a university degree. The annual mean concentrations (SD) of total PM2.5 and BC were 9.83 (0.64) μg/m³ and 0.562 (0.143) μg/m³, respectively for 1990 (used as marker for long-term exposure in the study). During the follow-up period up to 2016, 15.9% developed dementia up to 2022, and the proportion of females in the dementia group was higher (53%) than the proportion of males (47%). The mean rLTL value exhibited variation depending upon whether participants would later be diagnosed with dementia or not. Shorter mean rLTL values (−0.0072) were observed among study participants who later were diagnosed with dementia than those who were not (0.00135), however, the difference was not statistically significant (p-value= 0.61) The linear associations between air pollution and residualized leukocyte telomere length (rLTL), are presented in Table 2.

Notably, small but imprecise tendencies for rLTL to increase with air pollution exposure were observed, especially for the BC elements. For example, higher concentrations of BC were associated with longer rLTL: a 1 μg/m³ increase in total BC was associated with a unit increase of 0.04 (95% CI:-0.046, 0.114) in rLTL in Model 3 (Table 2). The corresponding estimates for PM2.5_exhaust, PM2.5_woodburning, BC_traffic and BC_woodburning were: 0.02 (95% CI: −0.023, 0.072), 0.001 (95% CI: −0.033, 0.044), 0.05 (95% CI: −0.019, 0.042), and 0.11 (95% CI: −0.221, 0.445), respectively. The estimates from the subgroup analysis based on dementia status are reported in Table 3.

Associations between air pollution exposure and rLTL appeared to be present mainly in study participants who later developed dementia, but all p-values are larger than 0.10, so the results are not conclusive. The interaction terms for effect modification by dementia status were furthermore not statistically significant.

4. Discussion

In this study, associations between air pollution and telomere length were not evident. There were however some tendencies for telomere length to increase with exposure to ambient particles, among study participants who were later diagnosed with dementia. Overall, the results diverge from our initial hypothesis however, which anticipated air pollution to be associated with a decreased telomere length. The statistical precision of the estimates were low. Consequently, these findings should be interpreted cautiously and corroborated in other studies. If we speculate however, the results raises questions about susceptibility to air pollution and about the state of the inflammatory response in people who develop dementia. The idea that susceptibility to air pollution may differ between different groups in the population is not new; we have for example previously observed that associations between particulate air pollution and dementia were mainly present among study participants carrying the APOE ɛ4 allele and for those with low performance on odor identification ability in the same cohort (21).

Previous research on air pollution and telomere length have yielded somewhat conflicting findings although long-term exposure (10, 11). In a study using cross-sectional data on 471,808 UK Biobank individuals, telomere length decreased with increases in long-term concentrations of air pollution (22). Another large study conducted on UK Biobank participants found no significant association between long-term exposure to several pollutants and telomere length however (23). Discrepancies may thus occur in the same cohort, the main difference between the two studies seem to be the air pollution modelling. In alignment with our findings, a study involving school children in East London demonstrated an increase in telomere length with rising long-term concentrations of air pollution (24). Interestingly, genetic ancestry seemed to influence the associations in that study, with stronger associations being observed in black children. In the present study, associations seemed stronger in people who later developed dementia, which is also linked to genotype. In a study from Shanghai, China, on patients with diabetes mellitus, no associations between short-term levels of air pollution and telomere length was observed (25). In a heterogenous cohort of critically ill patients it was observed that long-term exposure to air pollution was s positively associated with telomere length (26). The authors speculate that an interaction of air pollutant exposure and acute inflammation may activate telomerase in these patients (26).

The mixed findings in previous studies underscore the complexity of the relationship between air pollution and telomere length, suggesting that multiple factors may contribute to the observed results. The levels and composition of air pollution may evidently partly explain some of the discrepancies in findings. The role of short-term versus long-term exposure to air pollution is potentially influencing the results as well. In the present study, we used annual mean concentrations of air pollution as a marker for long-term exposure to air pollution. We did not have access to short-term measurements. It has been proposed that the acute, toxic effects of inflammation following short-term air pollution exposure, such as one’s average daily exposure, may lead to telomere lengthening by the activation of the enzyme telomerase (27). In the present study we find it unlikely that short-term exposure would influence the results however, since we have previously seen that the correlation between short-term levels and long-term exposure is very low in the Betula study (28).

Another potential explanation for the disparity in results in previous studies is the realm of proinflammatory effects of air pollution and differential distribution of leukocytes in response to inflammation. Telomere measurement is conducted as a weighted average of different leukocytes subtypes and it is important to note that proportion of neutrophils in blood circulation is higher than other leukocytes subtypes and they have longer telomere length than lymphocytes (29, 30). Notably, acute inflammation is characterised by predominant accumulataion of neutrophils rather than lymphocytes, thus, it is plausible to presume that inflammation as a result of air pollution exposure may cause longer telomere length due differential clonal expansion of leukocytes (27). In the present study however, we controlled for lymphocyte proportion in an attempt to control for such differential expasions. Anonther mechanism by which air pollution may increase the telomere length is based on inflammation related oxidtative stress. Although, oxidative stress has been suggested to decrease telomere length but contrarily it may also cause an increase in telomere length by pairing up four guanine residues in the DNA strand (31). This enhances the accessibility of telomerase enzyme which eventually causes an increase in telomere length.

There are several strengths and limitations of the present study that should be acknowledged. One of the key strengths is the estimation of air pollution concentrations using a high-resolution dispersion model. These estimates were further refined by accounting for meteorological conditions, traffic volume (including vehicle types and speed), street width and neighbouring building heights. Additionally, this study is among the first, to our knowledge, to examine the effects of source-specific particles on telomere length. Other strengths are the detailed dementia diagnosis and the long follow-up time within the Betula study(15). There are also several limitations to consider. Firstly, telomere length measurements with qPCR are known to suffer from measurement imprecision, although qPCR is still the preferred method in epidemiological studies due to its cost-effectiveness (32). There is furthermore a risk of bias or lack of precision due to self-reported covariate information. There may also be residual confounding. We adjusted for level of education, which previous research has confirmed to increase with telomere length (33), but residual confounding due to socio-economy or lifestyle factors may have biased the estimates. The generalizability of our study is furthermore limited as it focuses on a specific geographic location with relatively low air pollution levels compared to other regions worldwide. The source-specific estimates should be reasonable generalizable to other similar areas in the world, however. Additionally, our study relies on cross-sectional observational data, which makes it challenging to establish causal inferences. However, follow-up for dementia incidence was conducted longitudinally. Moreover, our previous studies in the Betula study shows high correlation between long-term exposure to air pollution and the annual mean (which was used in the present study). We, furthermore, acknowledge the possibility of selection bias, as some participants with short residual leukocyte telomere length (rLTL), which is, again, associated with aging, age-related diseases and mortality, may have died before study enrolment. This could potentially lead to an underestimation of the effect estimates between air pollution and rLTL. Given that the levels of air pollution was low and the study size was limited compared to for example the studies in the UK biobank (22, 23), the statistical power to detect associations could furthermore be too low to detect associations. The particle levels were well above the WHO guidelines for PM2.5 from 2021 however, and in previous studies in Betula we have been able to detect associations between air source-specific pollutants and dementia (21, 34).

5. Conclusion

In summary, we did not observe any clear assocition between air pollution and leukocyte telomere length. In people who later developed dementia, there were tendencies for air pollution to be associated with an increase in leukocyte telomere length, however. Despite established health risks associated with air pollution, its specific impact on telomere length is a complex and evolving field. Conflicting study results highlight the need for further investigation to unravel the intricacies and discrepancies, shedding light on underlying mechanisms. Future research should focus on exploring the associations between air pollution exposure and telomere length, with attention to susceptible groups and the mechanisms involved.

Author Contributions

Conceptualization (AO), Formal Analysis (WR), Funding Acquisition (AO, SD, SP, PJ, KMK), Resources (AO, SD, SP, RA), Writing (WR, AO, EF, SP, SD), Writing – Review & Editing (all authors).

Disclosure Statement

The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest

Ethics and Consent

The study was approved by the ethics review authority with Dnr: 2022-04608-01 and written informed consent was given by all Betula participants.

Funding Information

This research was supported under the 2019 JPCO-Fund call for Personalised Medicine under the grant number, JPND2019-466-037 (ADAIR). This research has furthermore received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 814978 (TUBE). SP, SD and RA were furthermore supported by a grant a grant from the Swedish Research Council (2018–01729), and SD and AO were supported by grants from the medical faculty, Umeå University.