Exposure to bovine livestock and latent tuberculosis infection in children: investigating the zoonotic tuberculosis potential in a large urban and peri-urban area of Cameroon

Introduction

Mycobacterium bovis (M. bovis) is the most common zoonotic, and second most common aetiologic cause of tuberculosis in humans after Mycobacterium tuberculosis (M. tuberculosis) [1,2]. Its natural resistance to pyrazinamide, a key component of TB standard treatment, and diagnostics difficulties, contribute to poorer treatment outcomes in patients and challenges to TB control programmes [3]. Cattle is the main animal reservoir, though M. bovis can also be found in a range of other mammals [4-6]. In sub-Saharan Africa, including Cameroon, strong evidence suggest that the burden of bovine tuberculosis (bTB) is on the rise, partly due to the intensification of cattle livestock farming to meet the increasing demands to higher rates of urbanisation. A 2016 study which sampled over 2300 bovine carcasses in abattoirs across the four main areas of livestock farming in Cameroon found a high prevalence of M. bovis ranging from about 3% in the North West region to over 21% in the Northern Region, as well as a non-negligible prevalence of non-tuberculous mycobacteria [7]. The study also reported a wide genetic diversity, and evidence of recent and expanding M. bovis transmission in intensive dairy farming areas in the North-West region [8].

Rapid urbanisation and increased demand for fresh dairy products has been driving a rapid expansion of the local dairy farming industry in many sub-Saharan African countries, contributing to the increased potential risk of zoonotic TB in the general population, beyond the occupational risk often limited to livestock workers. The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates the highest morbidity and mortality due to zoonotic TB, occurs in its African region, which is likely severely underestimated due to diagnostic limitations [1]. Unfortunately, in Cameroon, like most sub-Saharan African countries, zoonotic TB remains largely neglected [9], with control limited to regulatory inspection of animal carcases at the point of slaughter, mandated carcass destruction and recommended milk pasteurisation, often poorly enforced.

Despite high bovine TB prevalence, very little data exist on the impact on human population health, and its contribution to TB burden in Cameroon which limits advocacy efforts as well adequate planning and tailored control efforts [10]. Routine TB diagnosis platforms (microscopy, culture and Gene-Xpert) are mostly focused on pulmonary tuberculosis, and unable to differentiate M. bovis from M. tuberculosis. Besides, the natural history and long latency period between Mycobacterium infection (Latent Tuberculosis infection - LTBI) and the onset of active disease complicates correlating human disease burden from routine surveillance with contemporaneous animal epidemiology. Conversely, LTBI in children is a reliable indicator of recent Mycobacterium transmission [10]. We conducted a pilot study to compare the LTBI risk in children living in areas with high cattle density to that in children sampled from the general population, in and around Yaoundé, the capital and second-largest city of Cameroon. We hypothesized that higher M. bovis transmission and burden would be reflected by higher LTBI risk in children with more exposure to cattle and consumption of fresh cow-milk dairy products.

Methods

2. Data collection

A face-to-face structured questionnaire was administered using the Open Data Kit suite (ODK) on a tablet computer, to collect information on participants’ socio-demographic characteristics including parental education and assets ownership, vaccination history, respiratory health history, exposure to cattle, consumption of fresh cow-milk dairy products, and household history of tuberculosis. Their upper arm was also examined for the BCG vaccine scar, with a brief clinical examination for signs of active tuberculosis.

We also collected from each participant 5ml of peripheral venous blood in a sodium heparin tube to diagnose latent TB infection using the Quantiferon-TB Gold Plus (QTF-plus) Interferon Gamma Released Assay (IGRA) (Qiagen Strasse, Germany). This assay measures the cell-mediated immune response elicited by infection with Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex, including M. bovis, using a mixture of early secretory antigenic peptide-6 (ESAT-6) and culture filtrate protein-10(CFP-10) antigens; this antigen mixture allows the assay to distinguish infected individuals from those uninfected, with and without Bacille Calmette and Guerin( BCG)-vaccination [11]. Stool samples were also collected to screen intestinal helminth parasites, as there has been suggestions that they can interfere with the IGRA response [12].

The blood samples were kept in the field in an ice box (0 to 4°C) and transported to the laboratory on the same day. For each sample, 1ml of blood was immediately transferred into each of four QuantiFERON-TB Gold Plus tubes (Nil tube, TB1 tube, TB2 tube, and Mitogen tube) and incubated for 24 hours at 37°C temperature. The tubes were then centrifuged at 3000G for 15 minutes, the plasma was collected, aliquoted and frozen at -20°C until analysis. At the end of field data collection, the stimulated plasma samples were analysed using quantitative Enzyme Linked Immuno-Assays (ELISA) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. The manufacturer’s software was then used to interpret the raw optical densities data, including the assay validation and quality control, and computation of interferon gamma (IFN-ϒ) concentration in international units per millilitre (IU/ml). A positive IGRA result was defined as valid assay with IFN-ϒ released concentration ≥ 0.35 IU/ml after blood stimulation with mycobacterial antigens.

3. Statistical analysis

The primary outcome, LTBI, was defined as a positive QFT-plus result with no clinical sign of active tuberculosis. The main exposure was categorised into three TB groups: exposure to a known TB case through household membership, frequent exposure to livestock, with children from the general community being the comparison baseline. We also performed exploratory analyses for the association between various participant characteristics and LTBI.

The questionnaire data was cleaned and coded, then consistency and range-checks performed to check the data quality and correct data-entry mistakes. The distribution of categorical variables was examined, with some categories merged as required to the small sample size. We performed descriptive analyses using simple cross-tabulations, looking at the distribution of various characteristics in the study participants. Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was used to combine information on assets ownership into a socio-economic score [13]; assets used in the score included ownership of a television, cable TV, computer, smartphone, fridge, gas stove, and the house building material and number of bedrooms. The PCA predicted score was categorised into lower versus higher socio-economic status.

We calculated the crude LBTI prevalence (without adjusting for sampling stratifying variable age, sex, and place of residence), tabulated against participant’s characteristics, and we investigated its association with the TB exposure group and other participants’ characteristics. The magnitude of association was measured using Odds Ratios (ORs) and 95% confidence intervals (95% CI). First, we computed minimally adjusted ORs (and 95% CI) of association between LTBI and variables, controlling for age, sex and place of residence. We then built a fuller multivariable logistic regression model, further adjusting for confounding by other participant characteristics. The model was constructed using a forward stepwise approach, starting with the minimally adjusted model (including TB exposure group, age group, sex and place of residence as a priori confounders), then adding other variables in turn and checking their introduction did not cause data sparsity or collinearity.

We also did a subgroup analysis excluding children with exposure to TB patients in their household, thus restricted to those exposed to livestock and from the general community, to investigate the association between consumption of fresh cow-milk dairy product and raw meat and LTBI.

All statistical tests of association were done using the likelihood ratio test (LRT), and OR and 95% CI were obtained using maximum likelihood estimation. Statistical analyses were conducted using Stata 17.

Results

Discussion

This pilot study contributes some insights in the potential contribution of bovine tuberculosis, a neglected zoonosis, to TB burden in Cameroon, especially in children. Key findings were suggestions that after adjusting for confounding, children with frequent exposure to cattle may have over three-time higher risk of LTBI than those from the general community. Despite our study’s modest power, these results, in a context where Bovine TB( bTB) is endemic and highly prevalent in cattle, are consistent with the hypothesis of spill over to human populations, thus contributing to the TB burden. There is limited data on the true burden of bTB in human populations in Africa, but the results are also aligned with reports from other sub-Saharan African settings where higher TB rates have been observed in pastoral populations or with occupational exposure, 21% compared to the general population[14]. The LTBI prevalence in children exposed to cattle husbandry in this study is however lower than what has been reported in people with occupational risk: Torres and colleagues in Mexico reported 58.5% of individuals with latent TB infection [15]; Catalina and associates reported in a group of 674 agricultural workers exposed to livestock in Columbia 10.7% [16]. The difference likely reflect different populations and exposure, with the later groups mostly made of adults working closely and frequently with cattle, thus more exposed.

Subgroup analyses showed that the consumption of cow’s milk was associated with higher risk of infection in our study population. This is a common practice in pastoralist communities [17,18], and a cheap and readily available source of nutrients for developing children. It suggests that exposure to contaminated cow food products, especially milk, could be an important bTB transmission route in our target population. If confirmed, this finding offers practical targets for risk mitigating public health actions.

An incidental finding in our pilot study is the very high (61%) LTBI prevalence in children exposed to PTB cases in their households. There is limited data measuring LTBI using IGRA in children household contacts. Data from a high TB burden province in South Africa, using the Tuberculin Skin Test (TST) which is less specific, reported lower LTBI prevalence of around 20% in children under 15 years [19]. The higher prevalence in our study could reflect delays in pulmonary TB patients seeking care, or challenges in the implementation of national TB policies regarding the screening and prophylactic treatment of household contacts; this finding should be explored further and may offer additional insights into factors contributing to persisting high TB rates in urban settings despite control efforts.

To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to investigate LTBI among children in Cameroon using IGRA. Participants were recruited during the Covid-19 pandemic when restrictions were in place to minimise social mixing; this presented challenges with response rate and implementation, partly explaining the small sample size. There was however no suggestion that non-response was different between the targeted subgroups, therefore mostly leading to study low statistical power, rather than biased results. The small study size also limited or ability to explore the association with levels of exposure in more details. Using IGRA, especially the QFT-plus assay offered higher specificity in the identification of LTBI patients compared to studies using TST, in a population with high BCG vaccination coverage, and we also checked for intestinal helminths to account for any interference with assays. We were also able to adjust analysis for several confounders, including BCG vaccination and socio-economic level. It is possible that there was residual confounding, given we only used approximate measures such as the BCG scar rather than vaccination records, and assets ownership; but their confounding effect appeared modest, so it is unlikely residual confounding would have biased the results. In summary, while we appreciate the limitations of this pilot study, notably its limited statistical precision, we believe it does provide invaluable data on an understudied and neglected, yet important public health issue.

Conclusion

Overall, by showing higher LTBI risk in children exposed to cattle than the from general population, our study provides indirect evidence in support of the hypothesis that bovine tuberculosis may contribute to the TB burden in Cameroon. This should be explored in a larger study, including a follow-up component to monitor progression to active tuberculosis which could allow the confirmation of M. bovis as the etiologic agent and an estimation of its net contribution to disease burden. We would also advise the Cameroon National TB control programme to further investigate the seemingly high LTBI prevalence in children household contacts of people with pulmonary tuberculosis, as part of its efforts to reduce TB transmission.

Authors’ contributions

PND conceives the study; MAFT and PND designed the study protocol, with input from HCND, JK, JFTK and HDM. MAFT, HOTP, RD and MON performed field data collection under supervision from PND; MAFT, MAN and PND conducted statistical analyses. MAFT and PND prepared the manuscript, with contribution from all co-authors.

Conflicts of interest

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interests