ASSESSING SYSTEM PERFORMANCE OF MATERNAL AND CHILD HEALTH CARE DURING COVID-19 PANDEMIC IN COMMUNITY HEALTH CENTER- COMORO DILI TIMOR-LESTE

Timor Context

Timor Leste (TL) reported good improvement in the indicators of Maternal and Child Health during the two decades of Independence. Despite this, the rates are still considered high compared to other Asian countries with maternal mortality rate of 218 per 100,000 live births and under-five mortality of 41 deaths per 1,000 live births (TDHS, 2016). The MCH services has been become one of the priorities services and delivered through 3 tiers of health systems consists of hospitals, community health centers, health posts and through primary health care strategies such as SISCa, SnF, and Villages Midwives. In 2020, in responds to COVID-19, Ministry of Health issued a policy to guide the continued implementation of essentials health services, including MCH care. Several activities in MCH services must be carried out, were including the first and third trimester pregnancy checks, normal deliveries for non-COVID-19 cases, routine postpartum and family planning services, first postpartum visits, neonatal services, and immunization. (Politica, 2020).

TL reported it first COVID-19 cases in March, 2020 and by October 27 2021, it registered 19.785 cases with 121 deaths. [19] TL health system was still young and not ready to deal with COVID-19 Pandemic. [20] Despite of its huge challenges, the MOH structures and health facilities continue to deliver essential health services during COVID-19 Pandemic. However, the strict lockdown and mandatory stay home measures have negatively impacted essential services delivery. [21] Two nationals’ studies focusing on services delivery component of MCH during COVID-19 pandemic reveal contradictory results of the disruption of MCH services. [22] [23]

So far there is no study commissioning to assess health system readiness for delivering MCH services in Timor-Leste. We conducted this study to thoroughly assessed system performances for delivering MCH services during COVID-19 Pandemic in a Community Health Centers, Comoro Dili, Timor-Leste

Study Setting

This study is conducting in the one of main community health centers in Dili Municipality, Timor-Leste. Timor-Leste is small countries divided into 12 Municipalities, and 1 especial region of Oecusse with Population of 1.321 million. [24] The Comoro CHC is one of the main health centers with in-patients care with 12 beds, an emergency room, maternity clinic, laboratory and out-patients care. It located in Comoro CHC has served a population of 159,773 people with an area of 33.12 km². The working area of the Comoro health center is located in the Posto Administrativo Dom Alexio area, Dili Municipality, Timor-Leste, which has 7 villages.

The Government health facilities in the area consist of one community health center (Comoro CHC) and eight health posts. There are 102 employees working at the Comoro Community Health Center and 45 employees working at the Health Post. Some of these employees have the status of civil servants and there are also contract employees who are responsible for organizing and implementing health programs on a routine basis and in emergency situations. About 14 priorities programs, including MCH care were implemented regularly in this health center, see - table-1.

Respondent Characteristics

We have successfully interviewed 94 participants compose of midwives, Nurses, Medical Doctors, Pharmacist and Medical Scientists working in supporting MCH services in CHC Comoro during COVID-19 Pandemic. Information from Table-2 below, reveal that about 70% of respondents were temporary contract and voluntary staffs; with 56,4 % has less than 5 years working experiences, and 90.4 % with them ages between 24-36 years old. Most respondents (77.7%) was female and was tasked to deliver routine MCH services in Comoro CHC. However, during the COVID-19 Pandemic around 24.5% of them did not delivery MCH services.

While, looking at the data on types of professions, it shows that the respondents composed of 12.8% midwives, 13.8% doctors, 30.9% nurses, and 42.6% Allied health professionals were tasked to deliver MCH services during the COVID-19 pandemic. However, about 33% of those health professionals working did not carry out MCH services during the pandemic. The most interruption was observed in Allied health for professionals (12.8%) and followed by midwives at 10.6%.

The Association Between Health System Components and Disruption MCH Services during COVID-19 Pandemic

The Bivariate Analysis (Crosstabulation) of the association between health systems disruption and COVID-19 Pandemic was presented well in table-3. Each health system component was cross-tabulate using Bivariate Analysis to assess the association of its disruption caused by COVID-19 Pandemic.

• 4.2.1 The Association between Services Delivery component and Disruption of MCH Services during COVID-19 Pandemic

  Table 3 shows that 68.6% of respondents stated that health services delivery of MCH care was disrupted during COVID-19 Pandemic.

• 4.2.2 The Association between Human Resource component and Disruption of MCH Services during COVID-19 Pandemic

  Table 3 shows that (73,1%) of respondents stated that on unavailability of some health professionals to provide MCH care during COVID-19 Pandemic.

• 4.2.3 The Association between ICT component and Disruption of MCH Services during COVID-19 Pandemic

  Table 3 shows that 66,7% of respondents stated that ICT component for MCH care was not utilized to disseminate information and consultation on MCH Care during COVID-19 Pandemic.

• 4.2.4 The Association between the availability of essential medicines and equipment component and Disruption of MCH Services during COVID-19 Pandemic

  Table 3 shows that 58.3 % of respondents stated that the unavailability of some essential medicines, equipment, PPE for MCH care during COVID-19 Pandemic.

• 4.2.5 The Association between the availability of financing component and Disruption of MCH Services during COVID-19 Pandemic

  Table 3 shows that 67.7 % of respondents stated that the less availability of finance for support MCH Care during COVID-19 Pandemic.

• 4.2.6 The Association between the stewardship component and Disruption of MCH Services during COVID-19 Pandemic

  Table 3 shows only 36.7 % of respondents stated that the stewardship provided to MHC services was interrupted was interrupted during COVID-19 Pandemic.

Provision Of MCH Services

High percentage (68.6%) of respondents said they did not carry out regular health services for mothers and children during the COVID-19 Pandemic. This finding in line with the cohort data on the reduction of ANC1, ANC4, Facility Delivery, and postnatal care (PNC) in 2020 during COVID-19 Pandemic compared to 2019 in Comoro-CHC. [26] The situation was worsening during 2021 due to community transmission of Delta and Omicron variant in the country caused many deaths and hospitalization. [21]This finding of maternal and child health services disruption was similar with research findings from many developing countries in Asia and Africa region. [3] [10] [11] [12] [13]. A rapid review carried out on PNC services availability and utilization during the COVID-19 era in sub-Saharan Africa revealed that there were significant declines in the availability and utilization services during and after the COVID-19 lockdown. [14].

The interruption of services delivery in Timor-Leste may be caused by many reasons including lockdown restriction and mandatory stay home order implemented in the country from April 2020 to November 2021. [20] [21] Interviews with healthcare providers and clients from study in Ethiopia highlighted several barriers to service utilization during COVID-19, including fear of disease transmission, economic hardship, and transport service disruptions and restrictions. [11] Kapoor and collaegues.2022, in their study found a causal link between restrictions and health service utilization and call for policy makers in low- and middle-income countries to carefully consider the trade-offs of strict lockdowns during future COVID-19 waves or future pandemics. [27] Study from Tanzania suggest that a part erratic political response, it was rather fear of the pandemic itself and diversion of resources to control COVID-19, that may have contributed most to lower the utilization of mother and child services. [28]

The Availability of Health Care Workers

During the pandemic, health care workers (HCWs) have been in the frontline of health system response. This requires them to acquire knowledge and protection through personnel protective equipment (PPE) and Immunization in order to delivery health services. We found high percentage (73.1%) of frontline health workers interviewed in this study said they did not carry out work as a health profession regularly. One of the reason among others is because they were infected with COVID-19, especially during the second and third wave caused by Delta and Omicron variant. [21] During the periods of COVID-19 pandemic many health care professionals were trained and relocated to COVID-19 treatment centers to provide care to COVID-19 patients and increase their chance to get infected. [20] [21] In Timor-Leste, HCWs were at the high risks of getting infected compare to the general population. Evidence from seroprevalence study among HCWs indicating a significant sub-clinical infection among HCWs early in the local outbreak. [29].

Global studies have documented on the morbidity and mortality the frontline health care workers during COVID-19 Pandemic. Various reasons were identified contributing to the cause of Morbidity and Mortality of HCS were including lack of PPE, Not received Immunization, lack of supporting facilities and infrastructure, excessive working hours, and mental health problems [30] [31] [32] [33], [34], [35] [36], [37], [38] [39] There were also other reasons that caused interruption of HCWs from health facilities during COVID-19 Pandemics. They are including factors such as less motivated than usual to work, ration the use of PPE, scared of being infected, concerned for family members get infected, and anxiety. [33] [35] Therefore, It is important for the future pandemic to equip these frontline health workers with knowledge, equipment, proper infrastructure, incentive and moral support to keep them working and serving patients both COVID-19 and non Covid-19.

The availability of MCH Medical products and equipment

During the pandemic, the most attention and resources were diverting towards preventing, diagnostic and treating COVID-19. Despite, MOH call for ensuring the delivery of essentials services through-out the country, but many other these services were disrupted. [20] About 58.3% HCWs interviewed in this study answer that there were stock-out of essential medicines and health products for the MCH service program at this Community Health Center during the COVID-19 pandemic. The COVID-19 pandemic reduces the capacity of SAMES to procure health products due to country lockdown and supplier issues. Despite alternative mechanism was sought to UN procurement system to purchase COVID-19 health products and essential medicine, [20] it’s can only provide short-term solution for chronic and ongoing problems. The stock-out of essential medicines and health products has always been issues for Timor-Leste for decades. [40] [20] Various factors including change management, prescriptions problems, and no pharmaceuticals industries in the country were contributing to ongoing stock-out of essential medicines and health products in Timor-Leste.

The issues of stocks-out of health products and equipment were also documented from other developing countries. In India and Nepal also the pandemic has decreased availability of certain medications necessary for pregnant women, and decreased access to contraceptives for others. [41] In Ethiopia, study from hospital settings reveal that the availability of key essential medicines for maternal and child health in the study area was low. The overall stock-out situation of MCH products has worsened during COVID-19 compared to pre-COVID-19 pandemic. [42]

Therefore, to ensure that stock outs of medicines and health products do not occur in the future, it is necessary to provide capacity development regarding supply chain management training to staff holding pharmaceutical units. Delivery of drugs and other products between consumers should be through rationalized prescriptions by medical personnel, so that recommended interventions can be used judiciously. [25]

Information, Communication, and Technology Used for MCH Services

Despite, there was huge investment and utilization of ICT for COVID-19 during the pandemic in Timor-Leste. [20] [43] About 66.7% of HCWs interviewed in study said there was not available information, communication and utilization of technology for MCH care during COVID-19 Pandemic. This is true because during the pandemic most of the information, communication, and technology was directing towards on prevention of COVID-19 and to provide the right information on adverse effects of AstraZeneca that were emerged during the early deployment of the Vaccine in Timor-Leste. [43] Before COVID-19 pandemic, communication and information a [20] activities on MCH were regularly implemented are in all health facilities and through-out communities via SISCa, SNF and Villages Midwives. The use of digital health applications has increasingly become an important and strengthened during COVID-19 Pandemic. Despite huge challenges of mobile cellular networks, slow internet, and lack of digital infrastructure. Before the pandemic, there was one digital health intervention in operation – Liga Inan, which connects pregnant mothers and their health providers through mobile phones. [44] The Liga-Inan program was one of the reliable digital tools that continue provide pregnancy related information to all pregnant mother and child during the COVID-19 pandemic in Timor-Leste.

The Utilization of Digital Technology for sharing information and medical training such telehealth was increasingly utilizing in many global settings. Enhancing primary healthcare, use of telehealth, extended prescription, and public communication were countermeasures undertaken by China during the rapid rise period. [45] Uptake of telehealth and a shift from in-person care has been a major contributor to maintaining pregnancy care during pandemic restrictions in, New South Wales, Australia. [46]Researcher from Africa call for the use of telemedicine needs to be improved in African countries to allow for the continued provision of health services during pandemics. [47] Globally, Various (IEC) materials have been produced to raise awareness regarding protection of mother and child during COVID-19 through professional associations and made available free only [8] However, due to internet connecting challenges, these free materials were often lacking the lower level health facilities especially in the post-conflict and developing countries. The utilization of various mechanism of Internet of Things (IOT) and digitalization of health that was previously utilized for COVID-19 in Timor-Leste, such as WhatsApp Group (WG), Zoom, Google meet, COVID-19 Dashboard, and online call, [20], shall be further expanding to cover other essential services including MCH, continue post-pandemic and strengthening for future pandemic.

Leadership and Financing MCH Services

Effective leadership and governance ensure the existence of strategic policy frameworks, effective oversight and coalition building, provision of appropriate incentives, and attention to system design, and accountability. [7]The majority (71.1%) of HCWs interviewed for this study respond on the good leadership provided for MCH during COVID-19 Pandemic. As argued by Joshua F and collegues, 2023, the eeffective national-level coordination of the response to the pandemic was important to ensure a cross-sectoral government approach, and because of the imperative of coordinating inputs from multiple development partners operating within Timor-Leste. [43] Early in the pandemic, the new governance structure of the Integrated Centre for Crisis Management (Centro Integrado de Gestao de Crises (CIGC)) was established under the Prime Minister’s office to provide leadership and governance in dealing with the COVID-19. [20]). Leadership in a health system includes setting priorities and the overall vision and direction A good leader will also ensure that policies and regulations are in place for effective and safe service delivery, and that appropriate mechanisms are in place to ensure accountability. Stewardship of the health care sector includes coordination between service delivery agencies, donors and other ministries. [48] Ministry of Health, 2020 issues special instruction for pregnant women or mother infected with COVID-19 to be treated with intensive care and also instruction to treat pregnant women and mother without infection. [49]The Pillar-9 under CIGC -Task Force was responsible to ensure the continuity delivery of essential health care services, including MCH services through-out the country. [20]

A good health financing system raises adequate funds for health, protects people from financial catastrophe, allocates resources, and purchases good and services in ways that improve quality, equity, and efficiency. [7] Funding should be made available for a quick and effective response to emergencies, requiring a supportive flexible public financial management system. Especially for the outpatient care, can also minimize the potential infection in health facilities. [50] This was not the case in Timor Leste during experiencing COVID-19 Pandemic. About 67.7 % of HCWs interviewed in this study stated the unavailability of finance resources to support MCH Care during COVID-19 Pandemic. In contrast, in respond to the pandemic, Parliament of Timor Leste allow the funding from the Petroleum Fund (a national wealth fund used for emergency purposes) in used for an extraordinary transfer to the state budget to fund COVID-19 health services and to maintaining essential health services. [21] Similarly, In Asia and the Pacific, COVID-19 services in most countries have been funded by government budgets and public insurance systems. In China, Indonesia, Malaysia, Mongolia, and Vietnam, for example, government budgets were used for both regular and emergency purposes. [50] Study from Nigeria report on the huge out-of-pocket expenses, and the least responsive of the COVID-19-related commodity procurement to the needs of those most in need of care and support.. [51]

Study Limitation and Strength

Limitation: This results study present here is based only on the interviewed of HCWs from Comoro CHC. Therefore, it does not represent situation of all health facilities in Dili municipalities and the whole country. By the nature of study (cross-sectional study/survey) is prone to selection biases, interview biases and interpretation biases.

Strength: This is the first study that utilizing WHO six building Blocks to assess the system performance of MCH in a primary health care facility in Timor Leste. The study interviewed mostly COVID-19 frontline health care workers that directly working under the system during COVID-19 Pandemic.

Future research utilizing mix-methods combining quantitative interview with document review and field observation against the six-health system block in all community health centers in Dili or other municipalities, will provide better picture on the health system disruption for MCH care in Timor-Leste.