ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND Voluntary asphyxia induced by apnea in competitive breath hold (BH) divers affords a unique opportunity to examine integrated mechanisms underlying the preservation of cerebral bioenergetic function. This study examined to what extent physiological extremes of oxygen (O2) demand and carbon dioxide (CO2) production impact redox homeostasis and corresponding red blood cell (RBC)-mediated cerebral vasodilation.
METHODS Ten ultra-elite apneists (6 men, 4 women) aged 33 ± 9 (mean ± SD) years old performed two maximal dry apneas preceded by, [1] normoxic normoventilation resulting in severe hypoxemic hypercapnia apnea (HHA) and [2] hyperoxic hyperventilation designed to prevent hypoxemia resulting in isolated hypercapnic apnea (IHA). Transcerebral exchange kinetics of ascorbate radicals (A·-, electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy), lipid hydroperoxides (LOOH, spectrophotometry) and nitric oxide metabolites (NO, tri-iodide reductive chemiluminescence) were calculated as the product of global cerebral blood flow (gCBF, duplex ultrasound) and radial arterial (a) to internal jugular venous (v) concentration gradients determined at eupnea and after apnea.
RESULTS Apnea duration increased from 306 ± 62 s during HHA to 959 ± 201 s during IHA (P = <0.001), resulting in individual nadirs of 29 mmHg and 40 % for PaO2 and SaO2 respectively in HHA and PaCO2 peak of 68 mmHg in IHA. Apnea resulted in a more pronounced elevation in the net cerebral output (v>a) of A·- and LOOH in HHA (P = <0.05 vs. IHA). This coincided with a lower apnea-induced increase in gCBF (P = <0.001 vs. IHA) and related suppression in plasma nitrite () uptake (a>v) (P = < 0.05 vs. IHA), implying reduced consumption and delivery of NO consistent with elevated cerebral oxidative-nitrosative stress (OXNOS). While apnea-induced gradients consistently reflected plasma consumption (a>v) and RBC iron nitrosylhemoglobin formation (v>a), we failed to observe equidirectional gradients consistent with S-nitrosohemoglobin consumption and plasma S-nitrosothiol delivery.
CONCLUSIONS These findings highlight a key catalytic role for hypoxemia in cerebral OXNOS with reduction the more likely mechanism underlying endocrine NO vasoregulation with the capacity to transduce physiological O2-CO2 gradients into graded vasodilation.
INTRODUCTION
The neurovascular complex (NVC) is a recent concept that highlights the functional interaction between the multi-hetero-cellular structure comprizing the neurovascular unit (NVU) and the systemic vasculature1. Precisely how the NVC integrates, coordinates and processes molecular signals that collectively maintain cerebral blood flow (CBF) and structural integrity of the blood–brain barrier (BBB) remains to be fully understood, although emergent evidence suggests a key role for redox-regulation2.
In support, a neuroprotective hormetic role has emerged for the physiological formation of free radicals and associated reactive oxygen/nitrogen species (ROS/RNS) that enable the sensing and subsequent clearance/delivery of the respiratory gases carbon dioxide (CO2) and oxygen (O2) to which the human brain has evolved exquisite sensitivity. In contrast, when excessive and sustained, free radical formation can result in structural destabilization and vascular impairment of the NVU subsequent to oxidative inactivation of vascular nitric oxide (NO), collectively termed oxidative-nitrosative stress (OXNOS)3, 4.
However, to what extent O2 and CO2 tensions independently modulate NVC function including the potentially differential impact on the redox-regulation of nitrite () and S- nitrosohemoglobin (SNO-Hb) bioactivity, the principal competing mechanisms underlying endocrine NO vasoregulation5, remains to be established. Prolonged apnea performed by ultra-elite breath-hold (BH) divers, given its ability to evoke profound hypoxemic-hypercapnia and compensatory adaptations that preserve bioenergetic homeostasis, affords a unique opportunity to address these knowledge gaps.
Extending prior work focused exclusively on BBB integrity6, this study combined volumetric assessment of CBF with concurrent sampling of arterio-jugular venous concentration differences (a-vD) to calculate cerebral exchange kinetics of intravascular OXNOS biomarkers in world-class apneists over the course of two maximal, static apneas performed in ambient air. The first was performed following (standard) prior normoxic normoventilation resulting in severe hypoxemia-hypercapnia apnea (HHA) whereas the second followed prior hyperoxic hyperventilation, designed to prevent hypoxemia resulting in isolated hypercapnic apnea (IHA). By manipulating arterial O2 independent of CO2 tension, we sought to address the following hypotheses (Figure 1A). First, that cerebral output [venous (v) > arterial (a)] of free radicals and suppression of NO metabolite consumption and CBF would be more pronounced in the normoxic (HHA) compared to hyperoxic (IHA) apnea, implicating hypoxemia as the dominant OXNOS catalyst. Second that the apnea-induced elevation in CBF would be proportional to a net loss (a > v) of and SNO-Hb taken to reflect metabolite consumption and delivery of NO.
METHODS
Ethics
Experimental procedures were approved by the University of Split, Ethics Committee (#H14-00922). All procedures were carried out in accordance with the most (7th) recent amendment of the Declaration of Helsinki of the World Medical Association7 (with the exception that it was not registered in a publicly accessible database prior to recruitment) with verbal and written informed consent obtained from all participants.
Participants
Ten physically active, elite apneists (6 men, 4 women) aged 33 (mean) ± 9 (SD) years old with a body mass index of 23 ± 2 kg/m2 and forced vital capacity of 6.40 ± 1.48 L volunteered from the Croatian National Apnea Team. At the time of these experiments, six had placed within the world’s top 10 within the last 5 years. One female set a new official world record in dynamic apnea while another male set the world record for apnea following prior hyperoxic hyperventilation (24 min 33 s). A medical examination confirmed that all participants were free of cardiovascular, pulmonary and cerebrovascular disease and were not taking any nutritional supplements including over-the-counter antioxidant or anti-inflammatory medications. They were advised to refrain from physical activity, caffeine and alcohol for 24 h prior to formal experimentation and maintain their normal dietary behavior. Participants attended the laboratory following a 12 h overnight fast.
Design
Parts of this study including blood gas and select aspects of cerebral hemodynamic function (Supplementary material Tables 1-2) have previously been published as part of separate investigations focused on the link between hypercapnia and cerebral oxidative metabolism8 and hyper-perfusion-mediated structural destabilization of the NVU6. Thus, although the present study adopted an identical experimental design, it constitutes an entirely separate investigation complemented by de novo experimental measures and a priori hypotheses focused exclusively on altered redox homeostasis. Participants were required to perform two maximal apneas preceded by, [1] normoxic normoventilation resulting in severe hypoxemic hypercapnia apnea (HHA) and [2] hyperoxic hyperventilation designed to prevent hypoxemia resulting in isolated hypercapnic apnea (IHA). The order of trials was non-randomized given the long-lasting carryover effects of hyperoxia and fatigue associated with a more prolonged apnea8. Data were collected at baseline and timed to coincide with the point of apnea termination (Figure 1B).
Procedures
All apneas were completed on a single day with the Croatian national apnea coach present to motivate divers and ensure maximal efforts. Each apnea was preceded by 30 min of supine rest followed by two standardized preparatory (practice) apneas designed to maximize the experimental apneas (see below). The first preparatory apnea was performed at functional residual capacity (FRC) until seven involuntary breathing movements (IBMs) were attained. Two minutes later, the second preparatory apnea was performed at total lung capacity (TLC) lasting for ten IBMs. Participants then rested quietly for 6 min prior to two ‘maximal’ apneas that were each performed at TLC:
Trial 1: Prior normoxic normoventilation-hypoxemic hypercapnia apnea (HHA)
Participants performed a maximal apnea in room air (normoxia).
Trial 2: Prior hyperoxic hyperventilation-isolated hypercapnic apnea (IHA)
Participants performed a maximal apnea preceded by 15 min of hyperventilation of 100% O2 while receiving auditory feedback from the coach to achieve an end tidal PCO2 (PETCO2) of ∼20 mmHg.
Blood sampling
Catheterization
Participants were placed slightly head down on a hospital bed, and two catheters were inserted retrograde using the Seldinger technique under local anesthesia (1 % lidocaine) via ultrasound guidance. A 20-guage arterial catheter (Arrow, Markham, ON, Canada) was placed in the right radial artery (a) and attached to an in-line waste-less sampling setup (Edwards Lifesciences VAMP, CA, USA) connected to a pressure transducer that was placed at the height of the right atrium (TruWave transducer). A central venous catheter (Edwards PediaSat Oximetry Catheter, CA, USA) was placed in the right internal jugular vein (v) and advanced towards the jugular bulb located at the mastoid process, approximately at the C1-C2 interspace (Figure 1). Facial vein contamination was ruled out by ensuring that all jugular venous oxyhemoglobin saturation (SO2) values were < 75% at rest. Participants rested for at least 30 min following catheter placement prior to the collection of baseline samples.
Collection and storage
Blood samples were drawn without stasis simultaneously from the RA and JV directly into Vacutainers (Becton, Dickinson and Company, Oxford, UK) before centrifugation at 600g (4°C) for 10 min. With the exception of blood for determination of blood gas variables, plasma and red blood cell (RBC) samples were decanted into cryogenic vials (Nalgene Labware, Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc, Waltham, MA) and immediately snap-frozen in liquid nitrogen (N2) before transport under nitrogen gas (Cryopak, Taylor-Wharton, Theodore, AL) from Croatia to the United Kingdom. Samples were left to defrost at 37°C in the dark for 5 minutes prior to batch analysis.
Measurements
Blood gases
Whole blood was collected into heparinized syringes, maintained anerobically at room temperature and immediately analyzed for hemoglobin (Hb), hematocrit (Hct), partial pressures of oxygen, carbon dioxide (PO2/PCO2), SO2, pH and glucose (Glu) using a commercially available cassette-based analyzer (ABL-90 FLEX, Radiometer, Copenhagen, Denmark). Hydrogen ion (H+) concentration was calculated as [H+] = 10-pH. The intra- and inter-assay CVs for all metabolites were both <5%9.
Antioxidants
Plasma was stabilized and deproteinated using 10% metaphosphoric acid (Sigma Chemical, Dorset, UK). Ascorbic acid was assayed by fluorimetry based on the condensation of dehydroascorbic acid with 1,2-phenylenediamine10. Concentrations of the lipid soluble antioxidants (LSA) encompassing α/γ-tocopherol, α/β-carotene, retinol and lycopene were determined using high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC)11, 12. The intra- and inter-assay CVs for both metabolites were both <5%9.
Free radicals
Ascorbate free radical (A·-): We employed electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectrosopic detection of A·- as a direct measure of global systemic free radical formation9. Plasma (1 mL) was injected directly into a high-sensitivity multiple-bore sample cell (AquaX, Bruker Daltonics Inc., Billerica, MA, USA) housed within a TM110 cavity of an EPR spectrometer operating at X-band frequency (9.87 GHz). Samples were recorded by cumulative signal averaging of 10 scans using the following instrument parameters: resolution, 1024 points: microwave power, 20 mW; modulation amplitude, 0.65 G; receiver gain, 2 × 106; time constant, 40.96 ms; sweep rate, 0.14 G/s; sweep width, 6 G; centre field, 3486 G. All spectra were filtered identically (moving average, 15 conversion points) using WINEPR software (Version 2.11, Bruker, Karlsruhe, Germany) and the double integral of each doublet quantified using Origin 8 software (OriginLab Corps, MA, USA). The intra- and inter-assay CVs were both <5%9.
Lipid hydroperoxides (LOOH): LOOH were determined spectrophotometrically via the ferric oxidation of xylenol orange (FOX) version II method, with modification9. Intra- and inter-assay CVs were <2 % and <4 % respectively9.
Nitric oxide (NO) metabolites
Ozone-based chemiluminescence (Sievers NOA 280i, Analytix Ltd, Durham, UK) was used to detect NO liberated from plasma and RBC samples via chemical reagent cleavage facilitating detection of plasma and red blood cell (RBC) , S-nitrosothiols (RSNO), S-nitrosohemoglobin (SNO-Hb) and iron nitrosylhemoglobin (HbNO) according to established methods13–15. Total NO bioactivity was calculated as the cumulative concentration of plasma and RBC metabolites. Signal output was plotted against time using Origin 8 software (OriginLab Corps, Massachusetts, USA) and smoothed using a 150-point averaging algorithm. The Peak Analysis package was used to calculate the area under the curve and subsequently converted to a concentration using standard curves of sodium . Intra- and inter-assay CVs for all metabolites were both <10%13.
Cardiopulmonary function
All cardiopulmonary measurements were averaged over 15 s immediately prior to blood sampling. A lead II electrocardiogram (Dual BioAmp; ADInstruments, Oxford, UK) was used to measure heart rate (HR). Intra-arterial ABP was recorded directly via a pressure transducer placed at the level of the heart for determination of mean arterial pressure (MAP). Internal jugular venous pressure (IJVP) was measured with the transducer connected to the jugular catheter. End-tidal partial pressures of oxygen and carbon dioxide (PETO2/CO2) were measured via capnography (ML 206, ADInstruments Ltd, Oxford, UK). Finger photoplethysmography (Finometer PRO, Finapres Medical Systems, Amsterdam, The Netherlands) was used to measure beat-by-beat stroke volume (SV) and cardiac output () using the Modelflow algorithm16 that incorporates participant sex, age, stature and mass (BeatScope 1.0 software; TNO; TPD Biomedical Instrumentation, Amsterdam, The Netherlands).
Cerebrovascular function
Intracranial: Blood velocity in the middle cerebral artery (MCAv, insonated through the left temporal window and posterior cerebral artery (PCAv, insonated at the P1 segment through the right temporal window) were measured using standardized procedures with a 2 MHz pulsed transcranial Doppler ultrasound (TCD; Spencer Technologies, Seattle, WA, USA). Bilateral TCD probes were secured using a specialized commercial headband (Mark600, Spencer Technologies, Seattle, WA, USA) using standardized search techniques.
Extracranial: Continuous diameter, velocity and blood flow recordings in the right internal carotid and left vertebral arteries were obtained using a 10 MHz, multifrequency, linear array vascular ultrasound (Terason 3200, Teratech, Burlington, MA). Arterial diameter was measured via B-mode imaging, whereas peak blood velocity was simultaneously measured with pulse-wave mode. The ICA was insonated ≥1.5 cm from the carotid bifurcation, with no evidence of turbulent or retrograde flow present during recording. The VA was insonated at the C4–C5 or C5–C6 vertebral segment and standardized within participants for the HHA and IHA trials. The steering angle was fixed to 60° and the sample volume was placed in the center of the vessel and adjusted to cover the entire vascular lumen. All images were recorded as video files at 30 Hz and stored for offline analysis using customized edge detection software designed to mitigate observer bias17. Simultaneous measures of arterial diameter and velocity over >12 consecutive cardiac cycles were used to calculate flow. Between-day CVs for and are 5 % and 11 %, respectively18.
Data integration
All cardiopulmonary measurements were sampled at 1 kHz and integrated into PowerLab® and LabChart® software (ADInstruments, Bella Vista, NSW, Australia) for online monitoring and saved for offline analysis.
Calculations
Cerebral bioenergetics
Perfusion: Volumetric blood flow was calculated offline as:
or were averaged for a 1 min eupnea baseline and during the last 30 s of apnea.
During the latter half of each apnea, IBMs and corresponding contraction of the sternocleidomastoid prevented reliable blood velocity traces. To circumvent this, QICA and QVA were estimated (e) from changes in MCAv (for ) and PCAv (for ) respectively, as previously described19, 20:
Assuming symmetrical blood flow of contralateral ICA and VA arteries, global cerebral blood flow (gCBF) was calculated as:
Cerebral perfusion pressure (CPP) was calculated as MAP-IJVP with the latter serving as a surrogate for ICP21.
Metabolism: Arterial and jugular venous oxygen content (caO2 and cvO2 respectively) were calculated as: where 1.34 is the O2 binding capacity of Hb and 0.003 is the solubility of O2 dissolved in blood.
Global cerebral O2 and glucose delivery (gCDO2/gCDGlucose) were calculated as:
The cerebral metabolic rate of oxygen (CMRO2) and glucose (CMRGlucose) were calculated as:
Transcerebral exchange kinetics
gCBF was converted into global cerebral plasma (gCPF) and red blood cell (gCRBCF) flow: for corresponding calculation of net transcerebral exchange kinetics of plasma/serum/RBC-borne metabolites according to the Fick principle: Exchange (µmol or nmol/min) = gCBF or gCPF or gCRBCF × (a – vD).
By convention, a positive value (a>v) refers to net uptake (loss or consumption) whereas a negative value (v>a) indicates net output (gain or formation) across the cerebrovascular bed.
Data analysis
Data were analyzed using the Statistics Package for Social Scientists (IBM SPSS Statistics Version 29.0). Distribution normality was confirmed using Shapiro-Wilk W tests (P > 0.05). Data were analyzed using a combination of two (State: Eupnea vs. Apnea × Site: Arterial vs. Venous) and three (Trial: HHA vs. IHA × State: Eupnea vs. Apnea × Site: Arterial vs. Venous) factor repeated measures analyzes of variance. Post-hoc Bonferroni-corrected paired samples t-tests were employed to locate differences following an interaction. Relationships between selected variables were analyzed using Pearson Product Moment Correlations. Significance was established at P < 0.05 for all two-tailed tests and data presented as mean ± SD.
RESULTS
Apnea
Apnea duration increased from 306 ± 62 s (range: 217-409 s) during HHA to 959 ± 201 s (range: 579-1262 s) during IHA (P = <0.001).
Blood gas variables
As expected, apnea induced severe systemic and local hypoxemia (↓PO2, ↓SO2, ↓cO2), hypercapnia (↑PCO) and acidosis in NX (Supplemental Table 1). In one participant, nadirs of 29 mmHg and 40 % were recorded for PaO2 and SaO2 respectively, corresponding to a (peak) PaCO2 of 53 mmHg in HHA. Participants were hypocapnic at eupnea in IHA and remained hyperoxemic and comparatively less hypertensive and more hypercapnic/acidotic throughout apnea (Supplemental Table 1). The highest individual value recorded for PaCO2 during IHA was 68 mmHg corresponding to a pH of 7.227. Baseline levels of Hb and Hct at eupnea were elevated in IHA (Supplemental Table 1).
Cardiopulmonary function
Apnea decreased SV and in HHA whereas increases were observed in IHA (Table 1). Apnea was associated with a general increase in MAP, IJVP and CPP that were more pronounced in HHA (Supplemental Table 1).
Cerebral bioenergetics
Compared to the eupnic control states (normoxic normocapnia), a greater increase in gCBF was observed in IHA (+206 ± 52 %) compared to HHA (+83 ± 22 %, P = <0.001) due to consistently lower and values at baseline subsequent to (hyperoxic) hyperventilation-induced hypocapnia (Supplemental Table 3). Corresponding increases in local (VA/ICA) and global cerebral substrate delivery (O2 and glucose) were also more pronounced during apnea in IHA (Supplemental Table 3). Apnea generally decreased CMRO2 whereas CMRGlu remained preserved with no differences between trials (Supplemental Table 3).
Oxidative stress
Apnea increased the a-vD and corresponding net cerebral uptake of ascorbate, α-tocopherol and total LSA that were more pronounced in HHA (Table 1, Figure 2 A-C). This was accompanied by a reduction in the a-vD and reciprocal elevation in the net cerebral output of A·- and LOOH that were also more marked in HHA for A·- (Table 1, Figure 2 D-E).
Nitrosative stress
Figure 3 highlights the dynamic interplay and re-apportionment of NO metabolites across the cerebral circulation observable within the constraints of a single a-v transit. The total NO metabolite pool was generally lower in HHA and during apnea due to a combined reduction in plasma and RBC whereas elevations were observed in SNO-Hb and HbNO (Table 2, Figure 3). Corresponding differences translated into net cerebral uptake of plasma , RSNO and RBC (Figure 4 A-B, D) that were opposed by net cerebral output of SNO-Hb and HbNO (Figure 4 E-F). Plasma uptake and SNO-Hb/HbNO output were more pronounced during apnea, with plasma uptake generally lower in HHA (Figure 4 A, E-F). The apnea-induced elevation in A·- output was associated with a reduction in plasma uptake in HHA (r = 0.702, P = 0.024) but not IHA (r = 0.509, P = 0.133).
DISCUSSION
Local sampling of blood across the cerebral circulation during maximal apnea in world-class BH divers has provided important insight into the mechanisms underlying the redox-regulation of cerebral bioenergetic function during the most severe extremes of O2 demand/CO2 production recorded to date in unanesthetized and otherwise healthy humans22. Direct measures of intravascular OXNOS and inclusion of the IHA trial designed to prevent hypoxemia and better distinguish between competing vasoactive stimuli, highlights three novel findings. First, the combined elevation in the net cerebral output of A·- and LOOH during apnea, collectively taken to reflect increased free radical-mediated lipid peroxidation, was more pronounced in HHA, highlighting a key contribution for hypoxemia. Second, this coincided with a lower apnea-induced elevation in gCBF and related suppression in plasma uptake, implying reduced consumption and delivery of NO consistent with increased OXNOS. Finally, that apnea-induced uptake and HbNO output prevailed in the face of increased SNO-Hb output and (general) RSNO uptake, tentatively suggests reduction as the more likely mechanism underlying endocrine NO vasoregulation with the capacity to transduce physiological O2-CO2 gradients into graded vasodilation. Collectively, these findings highlight the dynamic interplay that takes place between free radicals and NO metabolites during a single arteriovenous transit across the cerebral circulation and corresponding implications for cerebral bioenergetic function that may have clinical translational relevance.
Hypoxemia is a key stimulus for cerebral OXNOS
We recently documented molecular evidence for structural destabilization of the NVU that was selectively more pronounced during apnea in HHA compared to IHA despite comparatively suppressed, albeit concerted vasodilation6. While this was originally attributed purely to the ‘mechanical’ stress imposed by more severe systemic and intracranial hypertension caused by hypoxemia, the present findings suggest a potentially additive role for ‘chemical’ stress, taking the form of elevated OXNOS, to which the human brain is especially vulnerable.
To do this, we employed EPR spectroscopic detection of the distinctive A·- ‘doublet’ as a direct biomarker of global free radical formation with LOOH serving as a distal reactant of lipid peroxidation9. That net cerebral uptake (a>v) of ascorbate, α-tocopherol and (total) LSA was observed during apnea in both trials, and more pronounced in HHA, was taken to reflect enhanced sacrificial consumption (uptake by brain parenchyma and/or blood-borne reactions during circulatory transit) to constrain chain initiation-propagation reactions. However, this failed to prevent the overall shift in redox imbalance favouring increased free radical-mediated lipid peroxidation confirmed by proportional increases in the net cerebral output of A·- and LOOH (v>a) that were selectively elevated in HHA. The greater elevation in A·- output in HHA exceeded that predicted by prior modelling due to more ascorbate available for oxidation23 (given increased consumption), highlighting authentic (i.e. de novo) free radical formation. Our measured A·- gradients in HHA (v = 37 % > a) also exceeded those previously recorded during HHA in a separate group of elite apneists24 (v = 4 % > a) and were even more pronounced than those documented during vigorous cycling exercise9 (v = 12 % > a) - helping place its magnitude into clearer physiological context.
While it is conceivable that hypoxemia, hypercapnia and hyperoxemia independently contributed towards global oxidative stress, it was not experimentally possible to fully differentiate between stimuli, only combinations thereof. Hypoxemia and hyperoxemia independently generate mitochondrial superoxide (O2·-) and NO·, notwithstanding contributions from extra-mitochondrial sources including nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate- and xanthine oxidases, cytochrome P-450 enzymes, lipoxygenases and phagocytes, that can further propagate oxidative stress via secondary formation of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2), peroxynitrite (ONOO-) and Haber-Weiss/Fenton catalyzed hydroxyl radicals (OH·-)25, 26. Furthermore, the addition of (hypercapnic) acidosis, common to both trials yet more severe in HX given the extended BH times, would have been expected to further amplify oxidation since molecular CO2 can react with ONOO- and H2O2 to form redox reactive carbonate radicals and peroxymonocarbonate27. However, that cerebral oxidative stress was considerably more pronounced in HHA suggests a key catalytic role for hypoxemia that far outweighed the additive effects of hyperoxemia and (more severe) hypercapnia, confirming prior observations in healthy humans albeit exposed to poikilocapnic (hypocapnic) hypoxia9, 28.
To what extent this represents a physiologically adaptive (molecular signalling) or pathologically maladaptive (structurally damaging) response remains unclear given the pleiotropic mechanisms underlying redox-regulation of NVU function4. That oxidative stress was elevated in the face of reduced gCMRO2 and gCMRGlucose, attributable in part to hypercapnia8, has also been observed in (more) anoxia–hypoxia-tolerant vertebrates and interpreted to reflect an adaptive O2-conserving strategy to improve neuronal survival29. However, two observations in the present study tentatively suggest that the overall impact was likely maladaptive. First, that apnea in NX was associated with a lower net uptake of plasma implied reduced consumption of NO, potentially tempering vasodilation (see below). This may reflect oxidative inactivation of NO by O ·- and/or secondary lipid-derived alkoxyl-alkyl radicals formed subsequent to the reductive decomposition of (elevated) LOOH to form ONOO, collectively taken as evidence for elevated OXNOS ( ONOO-)30. Second, that our prior research has shown that apnea induces mild disruption of the BBB and increased neuronal-gliovascular reactivity that were consistently more pronounced in HHA6, stands testament to the thermodynamic potential of radicals to cause structural damage to the NVU, which is not unreasonable given its histological vulnerability4, 31.
NO metabolites and vasoregulation
Our findings highlight that the NO metabolite pool is in a perpetual state of dynamic flux even within the time constraints of a single a-v transit and that metabolite re-apportionment between plasma and RBC compartments is not solely related to changes in O2 but also involves CO2 and pH (Figure 3). By measuring corresponding gradients of and SNO-Hb, the principal metabolites capable of transducing NO bioactivity within the cerebral microcirculation32, 33, we sought to determine if differential changes could further inform the mechanism(s) underlying cerebral vasodilation across extremes of PaO2 and PaCO2. Both metabolites likely originated from the combined effects of apnea-induced elevations in shear-mediated conduit vessel endothelial34, neuronal35 NO synthase bioactivation and transpulmonary S-nitrosylation32; however, their respective roles in endocrine NO signalling and cerebral bioenergetic function remain widely contested, albeit unified by allosteric-coupled Hb deoxygenation and acidic disproportionation5.
The reductase hypothesis favors as the major intravascular NO storage molecule with conversion to NO or dinitrogen trioxide (N2O3) catalyzed by deoxyHb-mediated reduction and acidic disproportionation13, 33, 36. In contrast, the SNO-Hb hypothesis contends that NO is stabilized, transported, and delivered by intra-molecular NO group transfers between the heme iron and β-93 cysteine, that upon deoxygenation releases an as of yet unidentified moiety that is exported from the RBC involving transnitrosylation of the anion exchanger AE1, as a low molecular weight RSNO to effect vasodilation32, 37, 38.
The direction and magnitude of gradients observed are generally more consistent with those predicted by the reductase (as opposed to the SNO-Hb) hypothesis. In support, systemic (a) plasma fell during apnea and was accompanied by a concomitant increase in net uptake implying consumption from artery to vein (a>v), although we cannot discount consistently elevated formation on the arterial side due to elevated NOS activity. Plasma consumption was especially marked in HX, coinciding with the most pronounced elevation in gCBF and where the total NO metabolite pool was greatest. This was accompanied by NO formation with concomitant output (v>a) of HbNO, albeit suppressed in IHA consistent with the prevailing SO2 since hyperoxemia persisted at end apnea, culminating in an overall net gain in NO metabolites. These findings were taken to reflect a combination of deoxyHb-mediated reduction of in the RBC and acidic disproportionation subsequent to marked hypercapnia-induced acidosis. Local formation of NO, potentially compounded by the observed increase in ascorbate consumption39, binds to vicinal deoxyHb yielding HbNO (Equations 1 and 2) and, to a lesser extent, the intermediate nitrosating species dinitrogen trioxide that can escape the RBC to effect graded vasodilation33:
The gradients observed reproduce those previously documented across the exercising human forearm circulation and that originally informed the reductase hypothesis33, 36. Similar gradients were more recently documented across the cerebral circulation at rest and in response to acute exercise during hypocapnic hypoxia13.
In contrast, that apnea stimulated SNO-Hb output (v>a) and RSNO uptake (a>v) argues against the SNO-Hb hypothesis, since the gradients observed were diametrically opposed to those originally predicted40, yet consistent with the observations of other research laboratories41, 42. We would have expected an allosterically mediated release from a-v during circulatory transit, resulting in a drop in the RBC and corresponding rise in plasma RSNO in the venous circulation, consistent with SNO-Hb consumption (a>v) and RSNO delivery (v>a) during local deoxygenation. Yet, the gradients observed consistently reflected SNO-Hb formation (v>a) and RSNO consumption (a>v), that in the former, was further compounded during apnea and unrelated to the increase in gCBF.
Experimental limitations
Several limitations warrant consideration. First, it was not possible to fully disassociate changes in PaO2 from PaCO2, only combinations thereof, given the inability to ‘match’ end-apnea hypercapnia that was unavoidably more pronounced in HX owing to extended BH times. Second, it was unfortunate that we did not measure plasma 3-nitrotyrosine due to inadequate sample volume: its elevation would have indirectly confirmed increased ONOO- formation subsequent to oxidative inactivation of NO underlying OXNOS, consistent with our prior observations in hypoxia35. Third, the profiling of NO metabolite gradients, while informative, fails to unequivocally identify the specific NO species responsible for conserving bioactivity and the mechanism(s) underpinning vasoregulation, including potential contributions from ATP-mediated activation of P2Y receptors. Finally, despite prospective power calculations informed by our prior research24, we acknowledge the small sample sizes employed may have limited our ability to detect treatment effects, albeit challenging to perform large-scale invasive studies of this nature. Caveats notwithstanding, mapping the dynamic transvascular interplay of OXINOS biomarkers in this applied model of human asphyxia may prove clinically relevant in that it may help define more sensitive biomarkers of cerebrovascular health and inform interventions designed to optimize tissue oxygenation in the critically ill.
Data Availability
The data that support the findings of this study are not openly available due to reasons of sensitivity and are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
SUPPLEMENTAL MATERIAL
SOURCES OF FUNDING
This study was funded by a Royal Society Wolfson Research Fellowship (#WM170007) and Higher Education Funding Council for Wales (Dr Bailey), Canada Research Chair (CRC) and Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (NSERC) Discovery grant (Dr Ainslie), NSERC (Drs Bain and Hoiland), Autonomic Province of Vojvodina, Serbia (#142-451-2541, Dr Barak) and Croatian Science Foundation Grant (#IP-2014-09-1937, Drs Barak, Drvis and Ainslie).
DISCLOSURES
Dr Bailey is Editor-in-Chief of Experimental Physiology, Chair of the Life Sciences Working Group, member of the Human Spaceflight and Exploration Science Advisory Committee to the European Space Agency, member of the Space Exploration Advisory Committee to the UK Space Agency, member of the National Cardiovascular Network for Wales and South East Wales Vascular Network and is affiliated to the companies FloTBI, Inc. and Bexorg, Inc. focused on the technological development of novel biomarkers of brain injury in humans.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors acknowledge the cheerful cooperation of all participants. We are also indebted to Professor IS Young and Dr Jane McEneny for specialist technical input.