ASSESSMENT OF RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN CLINICAL MANIFESTATION OF CHIARI MALFORMATION TYPE I AND CEREBELLAR TONSILS HERNIATION MEASUREMENT WITHIN THE FORAMEN MAGNUM

BACKGROUND

The description of CMI was initially based on pathological and anatomical anomaly related to the cerebellar tonsils (1). Based on anatomical definition; CMI is characterized by hindbrain deformity and elongation of the cerebellar tonsils resulting into their descent into the foramen magnum. The classic definition of CMI is radiological and is defined as herniation of the cerebellar tonsils below the foramen magnum of > 3 mm in children and> 5 mm in adults(2). There are questions about the most accurate radiological criteria to diagnose CMI which remain unanswered. Is CMI a sagittal disease? should we only rely on the cut off descent of cerebellar tonsils of 5mm below foramen magnum in sagittal plane in diagnosis of CMI ? can the descent of cerebellar tonsils in coronal plane reflect the severity of CMI? Can the volume of cerebellar tonsils herniation reflect better the severity of CMI ? Can T/F volume ratio (Cerebellar tonsil volume/Foramen magnum volume) reflect better the severity CMI patients.

METHODS

This study was conducted in 3 teaching hospitals: King Faisal Hospital(KFH)-,University Teaching Hospital of Kigali (CHUK) and Rwanda Military Hospital(RMH). All of these hospitals are major tertiary referral hospitals having neurosurgeons treating CMI. Cerebellar tonsils measurements were taken from CIM Patients who underwent cranial cervical 1.5T MRI at King Faisal Hospital 1.5T during the study period. We conducted a prospective observational cross sectional analytical study. Patients with clinical and radiological confirmation of CMI were enrolled based on most common clinical findings in patients with CMI; clinical inclusion criteria was at least patients presenting with occipital headache or neck pain, dizziness, limb paraesthesia and increased deep tendon reflex 3+ on physical exam. Cerebellar tonsils herniation at the level of foramen magnum measured in sagittal, coronal and axial planes reflecting respectively the length, height and width of the herniated cerebellar tonsils using cranio-cervical MRI was measured.

Cerebellar tonsils were considered to be ellipsoid structures and its volume was calculated based on the following formula: volume =lenght∗height∗widht∗0.52(Adopted from radiological calculation of prostate volume and prostate ellipsoid formula)(17)(18). The most inlet of the foramen magnum which is the inner diameter of opisthion-basion plane was used as reference point for the above mentioned measurements. Foramen magnum was considered to be sphere shaped; the volume of foramen magnum at the largest point was calculated using the following sphere formula: V=4/3 π r3

DATA MANAGEMENT AND STATISTICAL ANALYSIS

To assess the relationship between clinical manifestation of CMI and cerebellar tonsils, we computed various non-parametric statistical tests and hypothesis testing to analyze correlation and variation of cerebellar tonsils measurement in sagittal,coronal and axial planes, cerebellar tonsils volume, and the T/F volume ratio (cerebellar tonsils volume/foramen magnum volume) we run spearman rank correlation to analyze correlation between headache severity and both sagittal and coronal measurements (right and left), correlation between total cerebellar tonsils volume and foramen magnum, correlation between cerebellar tonsils volume and headache severity, myelopathy severity and tonsils volume, and T/F volume ratio and myelopathy. The hypothesis tests using Wilcoxon rank sum tests were also constructed to assess the significance of variation between right and left cerebellar tonsils measurements (coronal and sagittal measurements)in diagnosis of CMI, cerebellar volume (left and right), and sagittal and coronal measurements. we computed descriptive analysis to determine demographic characteristics of the study participants, occurrence of signs and symptoms among patients with CMI. Before running every test, we assessed the skewness of the data by variable and made a log-transformation whenever suitable likely, we found none. When we found that the data were skewed, we went on running and look for a suitable non-parametric tests. We did all the calculations in python 3 using scipy. stats, Wilcoxon, pearsonr, seaborn, and matplotlib.pyplot packages and pandas library

RESULTS

Our study included ninth six (96) patients based on calculated sample size and statistical power of the study. the study results are presented on basis of the study objectives and statistical findings. CMHI was most common in female patients. Fifty-nine patients in ninety-six patients(59/96) representing 61.4% was female while the male patients with CMI was thirty-seven in ninth six patient(37/96) representing 38.5% of the study population. The majority of patients with CMI in our study was in fourth and fifth decade with age ranges : less than 20 years of age, between 20-30 years of age, between 40-50 years of age and Above 50 years representing 7.3%, 12.5%, 39.6%, 32.3% and 8.3 % respectively. The table1 below summarizes the results on demographic information of our study population.

Referring to the figure2 above, summarizing the finding on distribution of signs among CMI patients. Myelopathy followed by sensory loss were the common finding. Upper motor neuron lesion like Hoffman sign, spasticity and clonus was found to be 8% and 18% respectively. The motor weakness as result of CMI was found in 15% of our study population. Scoliosis as result of CMI was found in 5% of our study population. The Syringomyelia was defined as cerebral spinal fluid cavitation within the spinal cord seen as high signal intensity on T2W MRI image sequence and was found in 8% of our study population.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1:

Illustrative drawing showing measurement of cerebellar tonsils in sagittal, coronal, axial plane and transverse diameter of foramen magnum used to calculate tonsil volume, foramen magnum volume and T/F volume ratio

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 2: Distribution of signs among patients Chiari malformation type I

Referring to the figure 3,4 showing headache and myelopathy severity according to NRS and modified Japanese Orthopedics Association (mJOA) respectively; patients with CMI mostly presented with severe headache, moderate headache with 58.3% and 41.7 % respectively according to pain numeric rating scale in our study. The severity of myelopathy is classified into mild, moderate and severe according to mJOA. Most patients with CMI was mild myelopathic with 81.2 % followed by moderate myelopathy with 11.5 % and severe myelopathy in 7.3% of study subjects.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 3: Headache severity according to pain Numeric rating scale(NRS) among CMI patients

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 4: Myelopathy severity according to Modified Japanese Orthopedics Association (mJOA)

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 5: Correlation between myelopathy severity and cerebellar tonsils volume

Referring to the table 2 summarizing tri-dimensional radiological measurements of cerebellar tonsils herniation and foramen magnum; the measurements of herniated cerebellar tonsils within foramen magnum was done in three dimensions; coronal measurement, sagittal measurement, axial measurement and volume of herniated cerebellar tonsils was calculated.

The diameter of FM was measured and the volume of FM calculated using circle formula and transverse diameter of FM diameter respectively.

The left median coronal measurement were11.2 mm with interquatile(IQR) range (9.3 mm-13.1 mm)

The right median coronal measurement were 11.4 mm with interquatile range of (10.3 mm-14.1mm)

The left median sagittal measurement were 7.8 mm with interquatile range of (6.2 mm - 10.4mm)

The right median sagittal measurement were 8.8 mm with interquatile range of (7.2mm-11.3mm) The median transverse diameter of FM were 38.25 mm with interquatile range of (36.2mm-40.63mm)

The median volume of foramen magnum were 29,571.3 mm³ with interquartile range of(24,774.6mm-35,088.1mm)

The median of total cerebellar tonsils volume were 2,427.61mm³ with interquartile range of (1,706.01mm³ - 3,625.2mm³)

The median and interquartile range of T/F volume ratio(Cerebellar tonsils volume/FM volume) were 0.082(0.053 0.177) respectively

Referring to the figure10 above showing the relationship between myelopathy severity and the volume of herniated cerebellar tonsils as well as the relationship between T/F volume ratio and myelopathy severity according to mJOA; there was a correlation between myelopathy severity and the volume of herniated cerebellar tonsils. The more patient has increased volume of herniated cerebellar tonsils, the more the severity of myelopathy on mJOA scale.

Referring to the figure 11 above; there is a crescendo relationship between T/F volume ratio (cerebellar tonsils volume/Foramen magnum volume) and severity of myelopathy. The increase of volume ratio is proportional to the severity of myelopathy on mJOA scale.

DISCUSSIONS

The majority of patient with CMI in our study were in fourth and fifth decade with age ranges: less than 20 years of age, between 20-30 years of age, between 40-50 years of age and Above 50 years representing 7.3%, 12.5%, 39.6%, 32.3% and 8.3 % respectively. Our finding are similar to the finding of Aska Arnautovic and colleagues in their review of study on demographics, operative treatment and outcome showed that peak age of presentation in the pediatric studies were 8 years, followed by 9 years, and in the adult series,41 years, followed by 46 years old with female to male ratio 1.3:1(23) James R Houston et al in their study on evidence for sex difference in morphological abnormality in CMI report no sex difference of morphometric abnormalities of CMI malformation.(24)

Patients with CMI mostly presented with severe headache and moderate headache with 58.3% and 41.7 % respectively according to pain numeric rating scale in our study. There was no correlation between headache severity and cerebellar descent measurement in both sagittal and coronal. In contrast there was proportional correlation between headache severity and T/F volume ratio (cerebellar tonsils volume/foramen magnum volume ratio). Our finding are similar to the study by Dan S. Heffez et al who report no correlation between symptoms severity with extent of cerebellar descent in CMI patients (5).

Jonathan Pindrik et al in their study on clinical presentation of CMI and syringomyelia in pediatric population report headache or neck pain in 27%–70%, motor or sensory deficits of the extremities, 6%–17%,Scoliosis 18%–50%,Ataxia or gait impairment, decreased coordination 4%–9%,Spasticity 6% (27)

The syringomyelia is define as cerebral spinal fluid cavitation within the spinal cord seen as high signal intensity on T2W image MRI sequence. Syringomyelia was found in 8% of our study population.

The pathogenesis of syringx associated with CMI has not been clarified. Many theories explaining the presence of syringx in CMI have been postulated in literature, however disorder in CSF pathway around FM is taught to be main cause of syringx (28)

The prevalence of syringx in CMI is variable among adults and pediatric population. The occurrence of a syringx in association with CMI varies between 35 to 75% in pediatric patients while in adults syringx associated with CMI varies between 40 to 60% (26).

Aitken and colleagues identified spinal syringomyelia in 12% of patients with CMI(29). The scoliosis associated with CMI in our study is 5% of the study population.

The exact mechanism of scoliosis in association with CMI is not well known. It is thought to result from chronic compression of cervico-medullary junction by cerebellar tonsils, abnormality in posterior column tracts affect postural reflex resulting in difficulty sustaining appropriate posture their by subsequent scoliosis. However others authors associated the scoliosis with the presence of syringomyelia(30)

Our finding are similar to the result of Mohammad Hassan A.et al who report scoliosis resulting from isolated CMI in 3.0% (30). On the other hand Palma Ciaramitaro et al found scoliosis in 18%–50% of CMI(26)

Siri Sahib S. et al in their study on morphometric and volumetric in pediatric population with CMI found no clinical usefulness of 2D or 3D measurements that can help to differentiate symptomatic pediatric patients with CM-I from those who are asymptomatic CMI in their study hence, recommend an other diagnostic criteria beyond classic measurement of tonsil position useful for detecting best candidates for surgical management in patients with CMI(33). Our study showed a correlation between myelopathy severity and the volume of herniated cerebellar tonsils. There was a proportional increase of volume of herniated cerebellar tonsils and the severity of myelopathy. In addition, our study found a crescendo relationship between T/F volume ratio (cerebellar tonsils volume/foramen magnum volume) and severity of myelopathy. The increase of T/F volume ratio is proportional to the severity of myelopathy.

Currently, there is paucity of data in literature showing the relationship of severity of myelopathy and cerebellar tonsil volume as well as the relationship between T/F volume ratio (cerebellar tonsils volume/foramen magnum volume) and severity of myelopathy as discussed in our study.The T/F volume ratio (cerebellar tonsil volume/Foramen magnum volume) and cerebella tonsil volume can be an additional tool to be used in diagnosis and predict the severity of CMI.

CONCLUSIONS

Many studies have showed no correlation between cerebellar tonsils herniation and clinical severity in patients with CMI and suggests other diagnostic criteria beyond standard measurement of cerebellar tonsil position which can help in determining the best candidates who need surgical management for patients suffering from CMI. Our study is the first in literature to show the correlation between the tonsil volume and T/F volume ratio(cerebellar tonsil volume/foramen magnum volume) and headache severity using pain numeric rating scale(NRS) as well as severity of myelopathy.

Our study shed light on cerebellar tonsil volume and T/F volume ratio as predictors of severity in patients with CMI.

Further study is recommended to find out if cerebellar tonsils volume and T/F volume ratio(cerebellar tonsil volume/foramen magnum volume) can be used as diagnostic tool in patients with CMI.

It is of great importance to calculate both sagittal and coronal measures in assessment of patients with CMI.