Underlying Pressures that Black Mothers and Their Children Face: A Qualitative Assessment on the Effects of Racism/Discrimination and the COVID 19 Pandemic

INTRODUCTION

Witnessing the Black Lives Matter protests and the unproportionable deaths of African Americans due to the COVID-19 pandemic drove the inspiration for this study. Poverty, racism, discrimination, inadequate access to healthcare, and personal, everyday stressors such as parenting lead to poor health outcomes, especially in African American families in the south. In the southern United States, influences of environmental stressors, such as poverty, racism, lack of medical care access, and personal stressors such as parenting or mental health, decrease the health outcomes in families [1-5]. In 2020, the COVID pandemic hit and disproportionately affected black families, killing more black Americans than their respective population proportional [9]. Along with the COVID pandemic, racism, and discrimination took center stage leaving Black/African Americans in the center of the storm. Black families all over the country expressed their anger, fear, and sadness with the current state of racism in America. The pandemic and current racism in America place a huge burden of stress on black families and their loved ones, adding to the already heavy load of stressors families face in underserved Alabama. Currently, there is limited data on how these accumulated stressors affect the Black mother and child relationship. This study aims to investigate the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic and racism on black mothers and their young children using in-depth interviews.

METHODS

We used a semi-structured in-depth interview approach to gather data from seven Black/African American families from pediatric clinics in Alexander City.

One-on-one interviews were conducted in an intimate setting with the mothers and children, separately. The in-depth interviews addressed three different stressors, racism/discrimination, covid-19 pandemic, and parenting. Each of these stressors was assessed using the Health Belief Model as a framework with the following constructs: knowledge, school/work, action, emotions, and seriousness/susceptibility. Each of the questions were open-ended and trained staff were asked to allow time for a response. Interviewers were encouraged to ask, “tell me more” when there were opportunities to do so. Although we asked questions about covid-19 and the vaccine, interviewers avoided using jargon language. Interviewers were trained to be active listeners and treat their participants with respect. In the event a participant became upset, the interviewers were trained to allow time for the participant to take a moment to collect themselves or discontinue the interview. While the mothers were being interviewed, the children were in the room either interviewing with another staff member or playing/coloring waiting their turn to be interviewed.

Second-year nursing and medical students were trained in delivering the semi-structured in-depth interviews for mom and child. The semi-structured approach was beneficial when working with small children as it was difficult to maintain their attention during the interview. Interviews lasted approximately 1.5 hours per family. Data was recorded and transcribed by trained medical students. After transcription, the team met to discuss each of the transcript files where inaudible data was discussed to determine the accuracy of the file.

RESULTS

DISCUSSION

Historically, American systems have excluded Black women from support and resources conferred on white women, an inequity exemplified by the welfare system (10). The participants agreed they were susceptible to covid, but the perceived severity of the virus varied based on individual experiences of knowing someone personally who was sick. Regardless, all participants were adherent to the mask mandate but wary of the vaccination. This can be attributed to a possible lack of knowledge of how the vaccine was made, the timing of the vaccine, and exposure to public opinions of fear and distrust in the vaccination in general. One recent study found that out of 963 Alabamians, 44.5% were unlikely or highly unlikely to get vaccinated. Furthermore, healthcare providers were the most trusted regardless of vaccination status, however those who were unlikely to be vaccinated trusted social media and their local news more (11). Covid-19 has placed undue stress on families to adjust their daily routines. Some children were forced to transition to a virtual classroom that allowed them to continue their studies but isolated them from their friends and denied them the opportunity to enjoy their favorite activities at school like recess. Some mothers were worried about how they would financially support their families due to layoffs from the pandemic. According to a recent executive labor summary in Alabama, the pandemic disproportionately affected women and persons of color more (12). Through the seven families interviewed we are already seeing a clear effect that Covid has on financial and emotional stability.

Mothers were motivated to protect their children from racism and social concerns. Many wanted them to enjoy being children and not have to worry about some of the harsh realities. It was, however, clear, that many would eventually have the discussion in the future. Even if not prompted directly by the parents, many were not hesitant to introduce concepts of racial injustice to their children through the exposure of recent events, including national protests against police brutality. Fortunately, many children interviewed denied experiencing outward signs of racism at school but had a plan for if they did, which usually involved telling an adult.

Apart from data pending, there are a few limitations to the results that possibly inhibited us from grasping a full picture of how stress from covid/racism affects coping behavior. The small sample size of seven moms and their children limits the variety of life events experienced. Some children were subjected to virtual classrooms while others still maintained in-person lessons at school. Within the responses from participants, we noticed a difference in the amount of schoolwork, exposure to play, and exposure to friendships based on the type of learning environment children were subjected to. One could imagine that the children who were exposed to a virtual classroom didn’t have the same coping mechanisms available as those attending in person.

In addition, bias could have been introduced within data collection due to different interviewers asking questions. Not all questions could have been asked the same way for each family. Not all families could have felt open to discussing these sensitive topics with each interviewer based on comfortability. These factors would most certainly affect the quality of answers given at the time.

There is a possibility that leading bias was introduced into the study as well due to redirecting children in each interview. The time required to complete each survey superseded the attention span of some participants. It led some interviewers to rephrase open-ended questions like, “how is your school work” to closed-ended questions like “you do well in school, right”?

The interplay between the pandemic and racism experienced by the families will have to be further analyzed upon completion of the quantitative arm of this study to see how it affects coping behaviors. Some moms admitted to crying, their children lashing out to get what they want, and moms picking up habits like smoking when faced with chronic stress in general. The qualitative arm examined in this study allows us to peek into some of the perceptions families hold but doesn’t give us a complete picture.

CONCLUSIONS

As hypothesized, mothers followed CDC precautions and taught their children to prevent contracting Covid. In addition to mothers teaching their children how to be safe, school, and social media played a role in influencing mask behavior and social distancing as well. Many children were not convinced they were susceptible to covid but agreed it would be bad if they were sick with this virus. In addition, children were bothered by the limited playtime with friends at school and sometimes inconvenienced by the mask mandate when it was hot outside.

Many of the moms had been affected by racism in their lives but had not had a discussion with their children on how it presents and what to do if they themselves experienced it. Some children had an idea of what racism was and how they would respond to someone bullying them but had not admitted to experiencing it in their daily lives at school. To truly complete the picture of how covid and racism affect both mother and child, the stress they endure, and subsequent coping mechanisms we will need to finish the quantitative arm of this study.