Mental health, gender, and care-seeking behavior during the COVID-19 pandemic in Sweden: An exploratory study

Introduction

Gender has consistently presented as an important determinant of both physical and mental health (1–3). There are gender differences in risk factors, prevalence, symptomatology, and prognosis of mental health (2,3). The extent of healthcare utilization is another important factor, which can impact on individual ‘s mental health trajectory. While many studies have found that women typically seek care for both physical and mental health concerns more often than men (4–7), much of this evidence comes from cross-sectional studies, with results varying depending on the setting and outcomes being assessed (8–11).

The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic has been far-reaching, with consequences on mental health and care-seeking behavior. During the early stages of the pandemic (i.e., February-September 2020), several cross-sectional studies from various settings showed that many adults avoided seeking medical care, either urgent or routine, as well as care for pre-existing or newly-onset psychological symptoms (12–16). Data from the United States suggests that delaying care multiple times during the pandemic led to more adverse outcomes than delaying care once or not at all (17). Sweden has a decentralized, publicly funded healthcare system with universal coverage for all residents (18,19) and existing e-Health mental health solutions (20,21). Nevertheless, insufficient access to care has been reported among socioeconomically disadvantaged groups, which has only been exacerbated by the pandemic (22,23). Sweden had very different COVID-19 prevention strategy in the first wave of the pandemic from other Nordic and European countries, with a range of recommendations for social distancing rather than strict lockdown measures (24). Regardless, there is evidence that Swedish residents still suffered from negative physical and mental health outcomes during the pandemic (20,25,26).

Data on the COVID-19 pandemic and the impact it has had on care-seeking behavior tends to come from cross-sectional studies (12–16). There is currently a shortage of studies with longitudinal data and studies focusing on potential gender difference. Therefore, we aimed to first describe how care-seeking behavior differed between men and women over three time points during the pandemic in Sweden. Secondly, we aimed to describe the relationships between mental health, gender, care-seeking, and delayed care at all three time points. Finally, we aimed to investigate the association between care-seeking and mental health, by gender.

Methods

Results

Table 1 summarizes sociodemographic characteristics and mental and physical health of the participants at baseline. Majority of the participants (81.47%) were female. The mean age was 48.76 years (SD = 15.73). Most participants (72.44%) reported being in a relationship. Approximately half of the participants (50.69%) reported a BMI in the normal range, whilst 51.84% had never smoked. Over half of the participants did not engage in habitual drinking. The majority of participants reported no previous mental health diagnosis (66.44%). However, a high frequency of mental health symptoms was reported by participants, with higher percentages observed among women (12.59% vs 10.03% for moderate depressive symptoms, 6.21% vs 4.76% for moderately severe depressive symptoms, 3.10% vs 2.72% for severe depressive symptoms, 9.58% vs 7.23% for moderate anxiety symptoms, 6.04% vs 4.05% for severe anxiety symptoms, and 32.40% vs 19.05% for severe COVID-19-related distress). The majority of participants reported no somatic disease at baseline (66.25%). At baseline, 5.18% of participants reported that they had been diagnosed with COVID-19, which accumulated to 42.99% at 12-month follow-up.

A higher percentage of women, compared to men, avoided seeking care due to COVID-19, both for mental (3.99% vs 3.41% at baseline, 1.40% vs.0.70% at 6-month follow-up, 1.26% vs 1.06% at 12-month follow-up) and somatic health (14.31% vs 10.51% at baseline, 5.53% vs 2.72% at 6-month follow-up, and 4.47% vs 3.09% at 12-month follow-up) (Table2). Women also reported more delayed care (16.45% vs 12.69% at baseline, 5.50% vs 3.64% at 6-month follow-up, 8.27% vs 6.07% at 12-month follow-up). However, at the two follow-up time points, men more frequently had missing responses. A small proportion of participants reported worries about delayed care, with under 1% of participants reporting that they were ‘very much ‘ worried.

Mixed Graphical Models (MGM)

The networks shown in Figure 1 illustrate that anxiety and depression were highly positively correlated at all three time points. At both baseline and 6-month follow-up, female gender was positively associated with COVID-19-related distress and previous mental health diagnosis. At 12-month follow-up, female gender was additionally associated with anxiety and avoidance of care-seeking for mental health. Avoidance of care-seeking for mental and somatic health due to worry of COVID-19 was strongly positively correlated at all time points. A negative correlation between delayed care and avoidance of care-seeking for somatic health was also found at all three time points.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1: Mixed graphical models (MGMs)

Note: ‘Avoid MH care ‘ stands for having previously avoided care-seeking for mental health due to reasons related to the COVID-19 pandemic, ‘Avoid SH care ‘ stands for the same but with somatic health, ‘Comorbidity ‘ stands for somatic comorbidities, ‘COVID-19 ‘ stands for cumulative COVID-19 diagnosis, ‘Distress ‘ stands for COVID-19-related distress and ‘MH diagnosis ‘ stands for previous mental health diagnosis.

Discussion

In this study, we reported differences in mental health as well as care-seeking behavior between men and women over three time points during the COVID-19 pandemic in Sweden. We observed higher levels of depression, anxiety, and COVID-19-related distress as well as avoidance of care-seeking among women than men, as well as stronger associations of avoidance of care-seeking for mental or physical health with depression, anxiety, and COVID-19-related distress among men than women.

One of the important findings of this study is that women were more likely to report avoidance in seeking health care services for mental and somatic health problems. Prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, research suggested that men were more likely to avoid seeking care, while conflicting results have been found during the pandemic (4–7). In line with our findings, some studies found that women avoided seeking care more often (12,41) although other studies suggested that men utilized care less (13,20,42), during the pandemic. Nonetheless, a recent review indicates a general decrease in healthcare utilization for non-COVID-19 conditions almost universally, across genders, income levels, and countries, most likely due to a combination of factors, such as lockdown measures and fears of contracting the virus (43).

Network analysis indicated that female gender was positively associated with COVID-19-related distress and previous mental health diagnosis at baseline and 6-month follow-up, likely attributed to discussed gender difference in the prevalence of mental illness as well as diagnostics (2). Furthermore, female gender was positively associated with anxiety and avoidance of care-seeking for mental health due to worry of COVID-19 at 12-month follow-up. Regardless, anxiety was strongly positively correlated to depression at all time points, providing further evidence for the comorbidity of anxiety and depression and a high prevalence of these disorders among women (2,44,45).

Previous mental health diagnosis was shown as a predictor of depression, anxiety, and COVID-19-related distress, before and after stratification by gender. In the gender-stratified analyses, the association of previous mental health diagnosis with burden of mental health symptoms was stronger among men, compared to women. Similar pattern was noted for avoidance of care-seeking for mental health, avoidance of care-seeking for somatic health, as well as experiencing delayed care. This suggests that the impact of avoiding care-seeking and delayed care due to COVID-19 is greater among men than women, a finding that complements research on delayed and missed care leading to worse health outcomes (17,46,47). Finally, evidence has emerged suggesting a bi-directional relationship between poor mental health and a higher risk of COVID-19 (16,48), corroborating findings of the present study showing that previous COVID-19 diagnosis was associated with a higher risk of mental-ill health.

The strengths of this study lie in the 3-time point cross-sectional design that complements the existing evidence base on mental health during the pandemic in Sweden, which mainly consists of classical cross-sectional studies (25,49) and analysis of baseline data from longitudinal studies (20,26). Nevertheless, the data collection period for this study spanned over nearly two years and allows for comparison for changes over time. Limitations of our study must also be noted. Firstly, selection bias could have arisen from the voluntary nature of participation, meaning that the sample is unlikely to be representative of the general Swedish population. Furthermore, the low proportion of male participants (18.53%) limits our ability to draw robust conclusions regarding gender difference. The gender variable used in the study is also limited by the recognition of only two genders in the Swedish personal identification number. Additionally, the results of this study may have limited applicability to pandemic settings in other countries, as the Swedish mitigating approaches have often been interpreted as different, with more relaxed recommendations rather than strict policies (24,50). Furthermore, it was not possible to identify delays in mental health care specifically, as the question for type of delayed care did not have a specific option for mental healthcare. Finally, levels of actual care-seeking in this study could not be assessed, as data was only available on avoided or delayed care. Therefore, this represents an important area for future research.

Conclusion

This study explored gender difference in mental health, care-seeking, as well as the association between care-seeking and mental health during the COVID-19 pandemic in Sweden. A discrepancy was observed between the genders in the prevalence of mental health symptoms as well as avoidance of care-seeking due to COVID-19. In the network analysis, at both baseline and 6-month follow-up, being a woman was positively associated with COVID-19-related distress and previous mental health diagnosis. At 12-month follow-up, female gender was additionally positively associated with anxiety and avoidance of mental health care-seeking. Regardless, a previous mental health diagnosis, avoidance of care-seeking, and experiencing delayed care were more strongly associated with negative mental health outcomes among men than women.

Disclosures

The authors declare no conflict of interest. Omtanke2020 received ethical approval (no. 2020–01785) from the Swedish Ethical Review Authority on 3 June 2020.