Month-to-month all-cause mortality forecasting: A method to rapidly detect changes in seasonal patterns

Background Short-term forecasts of all-cause mortality are used retrospectively to estimate the baseline mortality and to obtain excess death after mortality shocks, such as heatwaves and pandemics, have occurred. In this study we propose a flexible method to forecast all-cause mortality in real-time and to rapidly identify short-term changes in all-cause mortality seasonal patterns within an epidemiological year.

Methods We use all-cause monthly death counts and ratios of death counts between adjacent months as inputs. The ratio between one month (earlier month) and the consecutive month (later month) is called later/earlier ratio. We forecast the deaths one-month-ahead based on their proportion to the previous month, defined by the average later/earlier ratio over the preceding years. We provide forecasting intervals by way of a bootstrapping procedure.

Results The method is applied to monthly mortality data for Denmark, France, Spain, and Sweden from 2012 through 2022. Over the epidemiological years before COVID-19, the method captures the variations in winter and summer mortality peaks. The results reflect the synchrony of COVID-19 waves and the corresponding mortality burdens in the four analyzed countries. The forecasts show a higher level of accuracy compared to traditional models for short-term forecasting, i.e., 5-year-average method and Serfling model.

Conclusion The method proposed is attractive for health researchers and governmental offices to aid public health responses, because it uses minimal input data, i.e., monthly all-cause mortality data, which are timely available and comparable across countries.

Keymessages

• What is already known on this topic: There is a lack of methods to forecast all-cause mortality in the short-term in a timely or near real-time manner.

• What this study adds: The method that we propose forecasts all-cause mortality one month ahead assuming a seasonal mortality structure and adjusting it to the level of mortality of the epidemic year. These aspects make the method suitable for forecasting in a timely manner also during mortality shocks, such as the current COVID-19 pandemic.

• How this study might affect research, practice or policy: The forecasts obtained with the proposed method detects changes in all-cause mortality patterns in a timely manner and can be used to aid public health responses.