Abstract
Context Dance therapy is well suited to clinical settings in which people have difficulty with classical language-based therapeutic devices. Psychological trauma has significant mental, physiological, and somatic consequences, and dance therapy incorporates the adjusted components for its management.
Objectives To identify (i) the potential therapeutic effects of dance therapy in adults with psychological trauma, and (ii) the barriers and facilitators associated with the impact of dance therapy in adults suffering from psychological trauma.
Method Five relevant keyword combinations were used on seven databases. The inclusion criteria are: adults with psychological trauma, dance therapy, and articles published between 2000 and 2022. The exclusion criteria are: children, adolescents, and publications that are not scientific articles. A bias analysis has been conducted on 20 articles using the tools of the NIH and JBI.
Results Thirteen articles have been included, and a thematic analysis has been conducted on the extracted data. The results indicates that dance therapy helps people suffering from psychological traumas to reconnect with their body, express their emotions, improve the management of the psychopathological symptoms, and sometimes even reducing them. The dance group encourages self-expression and establishment of new relationship with others. The feeling of security and the flow state of participants facilitate the emergence of these beneficial effects. These depend on the skill sets of the therapists and the regularity, constancy, and stability of the sessions.
Conclusion Dance therapy is effective in the treatment of psychological trauma, especially for women and people facing migration.
INTRODUCTION
Since the 1940s, dancing activities has been considered a therapeutic tool in Western societies.1 Dance therapy interventions hare mainly deployed in health (psychiatric hospitals), social (rehabilitation centers, drop-in centers), and educational (schools) settings.2 These interventions are carried out by professionals usually working in artistic and/or therapeutic fields.2 Dance therapy encompasses Dance/Movement Therapy (DMT), defined as “the psychotherapeutic use of movement to promote the emotional, social, cognitive, and physical integration of the individual”.3 Dance therapy mobilizes the individual’s cognitive sphere (learning ability, attention, memory, rhythmic motor coordination, and visual-spatial ability), as well as their creative and emotional sphere (movement improvisation through music, imagination, emotion, and social interaction).4 To date, numerous meta-analyses and randomized clinical trials have evaluated the use of dance therapy and demonstrated its positive impact on physical and mental health.5,6 Studies have shown that dance therapy is an effective way to improve mental and physical health, especially for individuals without psychopathological disorders (children, adults, and the elderly),7 with psychopathological disorders (adults hospitalized in psychiatry),7 and with neurocognitive disorders (neuropsychological deficits, physical and psychological disabilities).7
The positive therapeutic effects of dance therapy on the physical and mental health of a varied population make it a relevant psychotherapeutic treatment tool. Because of its emphasis on the body, dance therapy is particularly well-suited to specific clinical settings in which individuals have difficulty using conventional language-based psychotherapeutic approaches.8,9 Consequently, health and social service institutions are increasingly looking to dance therapy as a means of addressing their patients’ needs. The institutions that implement dance therapy protocols and the research institutions that evaluate them consider that this therapy can have a positive impact on individuals with psychological trauma.10,11 Psychological trauma is defined as a significant psychological shock, caused by one or more critical events, that has the potential to alter an individual’s psychic and physiological functioning.12,13 Defined thus, psychological trauma includes post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)14 and complex post-traumatic stress disorder (CPTSD).15 With an estimated prevalence of 3.9% in the general population and 5.6% among people who have been exposed to traumatic events in their lives,16 PTSD affects women twice as much as men.16 Psychological trauma particularly affects people facing migration, with the presence of PTSD estimated at between 2.2% and 9.3% in this population.17 The typical symptoms of PTSD14 (intrusion, avoidance, disturbances in cognition and mood, changes in arousal and reactivity) are very disabling, especially when mechanisms of traumatic revivification and dissociation phenomena are present.14 Psychological trauma has significant mental,14,18 physiological and somatic (cardiovascular system, immune status, metabolic systems and inflammatory responses) consequences19–22. Because of these multiple consequences, psychotrauma can be a barrier to therapeutic and medical work23 since it hinders communication between the caregiver and the patient24 and contributes to the patient’s disengagement from their care process.23 Consequently, medical care depends on trauma management.
In view of the dimensions (cognitive, creative, and sensory) mobilized by dance therapy and the repercussions (mental, physiological, and somatic) of psychological trauma, dance therapy appears to be a clinical and therapeutic tool of choice in the management of this type of trauma. In particular, the mobilization of the body seems to be important in the psychotherapeutic resolution of psychological trauma25 and is specifically put to use by dance therapy. Despite this, scientific research is yet to isolate the effects of dance therapy on specific pathologies and populations, and to better understand its beneficial effects on psychological trauma.
The primary objective of this article is to identify the potential therapeutic effects of dance therapy in adults with psychological trauma. Its two secondary objectives are to identify the barriers and facilitators associated with the impact of dance therapy in adults suffering from psychological trauma. The aim is to guide future studies on the effectiveness of dance therapy in the management of psychological trauma, refine the quality of clinical referrals, and provide theoretical support for clinical dance therapy practices.
METHOD
Settings
This qualitative systematic review, registered in PROSPERO under the reference CRD42022306326, is based on the research project VaDDanC, funded by the LOBA association. It concerns the therapeutic impact of dance therapy on adults suffering from psychological trauma.
Articles were selected (Figure 1) via a list of French and English keywords: “dance”, “danse”, “therapy”, “trauma”, “intervention”, “group”, “violence”. The authors created five combinations and entered them into 7 databases: Cochrane, Embase, PubMed, Web of Science, PsycINFO, PsycArticles, ScienceDirect. In addition, a filter was systematically applied: publication years from 2000 to 2022.
Flow diagram of selection process
The inclusion criteria were: adults, carrying psychotrauma, dance therapy; and the exclusion criteria were: children, adolescents, off-topic, book chapters, books, published thesis and dissertations, conference abstracts, guides, expert opinion.
Two researchers analyzed bias using two assessment tools: the NIH and the JBI. When the article design permitted, both tools were used, and the results were cross-tabulated. However, for the case studies only the JBI was used as the NIH does not provide a suitable scale.
Finally, the data extracted from the selected articles (see Table 1 & Table 2) are: authors, date, title, country, objectives, hypotheses, type of article, population, study parameters, type of analysis, main results, associated results, and the authors’ main interpretations. The biases of the eligible articles are listed in a second table (see Table 3). A thematic analysis26 was conducted on the extracted data. All sub-themes were identified, isolated and their recurrence noted. The 14 sub-themes were grouped into 6 themes.
Study selection
The database search screened 1114 articles. After removing off-topic articles (n=812) and duplicates (n=185), 117 articles were filtered by two researchers using the Rayyan QCRI software. The inclusion and exclusion criteria were applied to article abstracts, titles, and keywords, and 97 articles were excluded.
The two researchers assessed the remaining 20 articles for bias. They excluded 7 articles: 2 were off-topic,27,28 3 had the wrong format29–31 and 2 were of poor quality because they contained too much methodological bias32,33 (the description of the intervention was too vague, the variables were not clearly established, the data collection and analysis did not correspond to the protocol presented, the sample was not described). They included 13 articles (Figure 1).
Data analysis
A meta-analysis based on a statistical combination of two or more studies on the same variable34 could not be performed since the data extraction did not isolate enough quantitative date per studied variables.
The results are presented according to the SWiM protocol35 and discussed. A list of recommendations for those involved in research and the clinical field is then formulated to shed light on the future theoretical, psychotherapeutic, and psychopathological directions that the practice of dance therapy may take.
RESULTS
The selection process included 13 studies, conducted in Europe (Germany - 3, Netherlands - 2, Austria - 2, United Kingdom - 2), the United States of America (5 studies) and China (1 study). The selection contains two meta-syntheses, one not including the selected articles, the other including two articles from our selection process. It contains 3 quantitative studies (1 monocentric and 2 multicentric) and 8 qualitative studies (6 monocentric and 2 multicentric), including 3 case studies. The sample sizes ranged from 1 to 864. Apart from one study that did not report the gender of its population, the samples were predominantly female (6 articles with exclusively female populations and 7 articles with predominantly female populations). The diagnosis of psychotrauma (PTSD and psychological trauma) is systematic. It is associated with migration (4 studies), violence in daily life (4 studies) and war survival (2 studies). Data were collected through semi-structured interviews (5 studies), questionnaires (4 studies) and observations (5 studies). A thematic analysis26 of the data from these articles isolated 6 major themes: Body and Space, Individual Psychological Factors, Relationship, Group, General Health, Psychological Processes (see Table 4).
Body and space
Bodily sensations and perceptions
The studies reviewed have shown that dance therapy improves the sensory-motor perceptions of individuals suffering from psychological trauma. Qualitative studies10,36–39 point to improved body awareness and the emergence of a mind-body connection through the sensory experience of movement, rhythm, and relaxation. These results are not confirmed by the experimental quantitative study,40 which measures the evolution of the feeling of self-efficacy related to the body and the perceived level of fitness in participants in a Flamenco session, compared to a control group. The differences between the two groups were not significant (fitness: F=0.37, p=.549, eta2=0.01 and body-related self-efficacy: F=0.71, p=.405, eta2=0.02). The authors identify two major limitations to their study: the small sample size and the fact that there was only one Flamenco dance session. The lack of significance is likely related to these limitations. A case study article41 highlights the mechanisms associated with bodily experience and the mind-body connection. Conducted on a woman diagnosed with borderline personality disorder, it confirms these findings in the presence of a psychiatric diagnosis.
Movement
The studies analyzed demonstrate that dance therapy improves the motor skills of individuals with psychological trauma. The qualitative studies10,38,42 point to an increase in range of motion, an expansion of movement repertoire, and the creation of a mind-body connection through movement. Repetition of the sessions is essential for participants to become aware of these improvements.42 The article discussing a case study43 of a migration-affected woman identifies the experience of the moving and silent body as important in care. However, expression through movement can only occur if the therapists are able to observe and decipher the movement.10,38
Individual psychological factors
Emotions
The studies retrieved from the databases point to the identification, expression, and externalization of emotions in the case of dance therapy practice for individuals suffering from psychological trauma. The qualitative studies37–39,44 show an improvement in emotional state, a better recognition of emotions, a focus on emotions, emotional release, and the development of kinesthetic empathy (to feel in one’s own body the movement of the other). Two case studies43,45 state that the emotions expressed were primarily fear, shame, and guilt. Dance therapy promotes the emergence of psychic processes such as awareness and verbalization of affects, as well as a reduction in suffering. The emotional expression promoted by dance therapy allows for the integration of the trauma43 and the improvement of the emotional experience.39 However, these improvements are observed during the treatment or just after the last session. It is not possible to know whether they persist over time.
Identity and mental health
The selected articles show that dance therapy mobilizes identity factors. Similarly, the mental health of individuals suffering from psychological trauma is improved by dance therapy. The qualitative studies36–39 indicate that dance therapy mobilizes psychological resources, improves reflexivity and creativity, provokes new feelings of being alive and enjoying the here and now, and initiates the process of empowerment. Additionally, the articles describe a rediscovery of self-encouraged individual and social dimensions (femininity, sensuality, and spirituality). These movements contribute to the reconstruction of the self, increase self-confidence and pride in being oneself. The case studies41–43 highlight an emergence of a will to move towards the future,43 an improvement in the ability to think and to be attentive to one’s emotional state.41 These case studies show the construction of a new internal stability.45 One of the case studies45 was conducted with a woman with a psychiatric diagnosis of borderline personality disorder. Although the variables studied are numerous and observed only during the treatment, the results of the studies converge sufficiently to show a positive impact of dance therapy on the mental health of individuals with psychological trauma.
Psychopathological symptoms
The studies reviewed show that dance therapy improves the psychological state of the individuals and reduces specific symptoms of psychiatric pathologies associated with trauma. A non-randomized clinical trial46 involving 25 women participating in a dance therapy program measured changes in mental distress with the General Health Questionnaire (GHQ12). Mental distress decreased before and after participation (t=-1.46, p=0.16, d=-0.4). Five weeks after the end of the intervention, mental distress remained lower than at the beginning (t=-0.54, p=0.59, d=-0.2), although these decreases were not significant. One article presents a case study41 conducted on a woman diagnosed with borderline personality disorder and highlights the positive evolution of anxiety and aggression manifestations. However, we noted that the populations in these two studies did not benefit from diagnostic criteria derived from a standard psychiatric nomenclature. A cross-sectional study,47 with a large sample (N=1003), associated the improvement in the psychological state with the flow state. In this study, 899 people answered that they had one or more psychopathologies: traumatic experience (N=511), anxiety (N=451), depression (N=298), chronic pain (N=255) and drug addiction (N=205). Most of the subjects in this study reported that dance helped them manage their psychopathological disorders (depression 96.3%, anxiety 96.2%, trauma 94.9%, chronic pain 89.4%, and substance abuse, 87.8%). Among these participants, flow state was found to be greater than among those who did not identify any beneficial effect of dance therapy in managing their psychopathological disorders. The correlation between each psychopathological variable and flow state was significant for 276 individuals in the management of depression (t (276) = 5.06, d = 1.94, p < 0.0001), for 434 in the management of anxiety (t (434) = 5. 58, d = 1.52, p < 0.0001), for 482 in managing traumatic experience (t (482) = 5.84, d = 1.30, p < 0.0001), and for 237 in managing chronic pain (t (237) = 4.08, d = 0.91, p < 0.0001). However, this study47 is based on individuals’ knowledge of psychopathological symptoms, and they may be mistaken or unaware of the existence of these symptoms.
Relationship
Relationship with others
The selected articles show that the use of group dance therapy engages more individuals suffering from trauma to develop interpersonal relationships and improves their relational skills. A comparative experimental quantitative study40 of a Flamenco dance session highlights significant improvement at p < .10 in participants’ perception of boundaries (F=3.19, p=.084, eta2=0.10) and personified intersubjectivity (F=3.37, p=.076, eta2=0.10). Although the sample was small (N=33) and the evaluation was carried out in a single session, these results were obtained in a non-randomized clinical trial46 of 25 women. A thematic analysis of the patients’ discourse shows an improvement in the construction of spatial and bodily limits, and in the ability to create links with others. The qualitative studies36–39 support these results and highlight the importance of the quality of group support36 in cultural and social dimensions,37 as they allow the development of relational skills.38,39 These results are observed during the dance sessions and at the end of the treatment, but we do not know if these effects are lasting. A case study45 specifically highlights the importance of the presence of peers during the trauma narrative. Peers accompany the talk with sustained attention and mirroring of the individual’s emotional state. In addition, they comfort the individual verbally and/or non-verbally. This prevents too much internal rigidity and reduces the phenomenon of dissociation. Thus, the story does not evoke the trauma suffered. On the other hand, this repetition can take place during the dance, when the body is mobilized.45 Dance therapy also encourages the expression of the patient’s need for space.43
Self-expression
Some of the research reviewed shows that dance therapy facilitates and enhances self-expression. The qualitative studies37,39 highlight an improvement in verbal expression and an increase in self-expression and freedom of speech in participants during dance therapy sessions. These results are still in evidence after the intervention in one of the two studies.39 A case study41 obtained these results with a patient diagnosed with borderline personality disorder. It highlights the exploratory dimension of dance, which promotes the expression of thoughts, behaviors, and emotions. In each study, the authors emphasize that feelings of confidence and safety are facilitators of self-expression.
Group
Security
The studies reviewed emphasize the safety function of group dance therapy. Three qualitative studies36,39,44 indicate that the development of participants’ sense of safety, when combined with the development of the ritual, symbolic, and metaphorical aspects of dance, contributes to the development of a generalized sense of safety.39 The consolidation of a sense of safety allows individual resources to emerge in participants36 and enables participants to enter into a flow state.39 Finally, the development and consolidation of this feeling are facilitated by the permanence and the framework of the interventions (quality of the premises, geographical location, regularity).39
Culture
The selected works show that it is important to consider cultural aspects in the treatment of people suffering from psychological trauma through dance therapy. Indeed, the qualitative studies36,42 show that cultural, religious and spiritual support36 is important. When these are provided, the subject’s own cultural, family, and environmental resources are diversified.42 A case study45 refines these results, showing the importance for the subject of the cultural aspects of their verbal and non-verbal expression. More specifically, dance therapy mobilizes non-verbal skills, which are particularly useful in a multicultural36 trauma management group.42 It complements psychosocial interventions because it reinforces cultural and family support.36,45
Group characteristics
The extracted studies show that specific modalities of dance sessions influence the management of trauma. A cross-sectional study47 identified the importance of duration (dance practice for more than 5 weeks vs. less than 5 weeks) and frequency (dance practice at least once a week vs. twice a month or less). They were positively correlated with flow state (frequency: t (806) = 3.25, d = 0.23, p = 0.001, duration: t (840) = 3.11, d = 0.22, p = 0.002), life satisfaction (duration: t (932) = 2. 94, d = 0.19, p = 0.003) and mindfulness (frequency: t (850) = 2.72, d = 0.19, p = 0.007, duration: t (932) = 7.86, d = 0.52, p < 0.0001). However, the relationship between the duration and the frequency of dance sessions was not significantly correlated with the intensity of mindfulness (F (1,803) = 0.8, p = 0.4), nor with life satisfaction (F (1,803) = 0.6, p = 0.4), nor with flow state (F (1,803) = 0.02, p = 0.9). The qualitative studies10,39 add the possibility of creating a new healthy relationship with oneself, the group, the therapist, and the movement.10 The quality of these relationships depends on the ability of the therapist to consider cultural dimensions, difficulties in verbal expression and the risk of repetition of the trauma.39 Finally, it is made clear that the quality of the relationships that the subject engages in is conditioned by the therapist’s ability to identify obstacles, to engage with the group and to adapt to the patients.39 Therapists play a critical role in care and must be aware of their own countertransference, their own use of space, and the paradigms contained in their movements.10 In one study,10 the therapist’s own quality is engaged and poorly described.
General Health
Well-being
The articles reviewed reveal that dance therapy improves the overall well-being of individuals suffering from psychological trauma. The quantitative studies40,46,47 measure different variables of well-being. The non-randomized clinical trial46 shows results that are interesting but not significant, at p<0.05. The measurement of self-esteem using the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale (RSES52) shows an increase in self-esteem (t = 1.85, d = 0.3 p = 0.08) after the dance therapy program, which persists 5 weeks after the end of treatment (t = 1.11, d = 0.2, p = 0.28). This study46 also used the three dimensions (overattachment, body-mind obstruction, affect posture inhibition) of the Stagnation Scale.48 It shows an overall decrease in stagnation1 symptoms (t = -0.48, d = -0.1, p = 0.64), maintained at 5 weeks after completion (t = -0.43, d = -0.1, p = -0.67). Overattachment decreases after care (t = -1.63, d = - 0.2, p = 0.12), and then 5 weeks after care ended (t = -1.81, d = -0.3, p = 0.08).
The quantitative experimental study40 identifies the positive and negative dimensions of well-being. The score for the positive dimension of well-being was not significantly higher after dance therapy (F = 0.60, p = .445, eta2 = 0.02). The score for the negative dimension of well-being was significantly lower after dance therapy (F = 4.97, p = 0.33, eta2 = 0.14). In addition, this study40 clearly shows an improvement in perceived health (F = 18.71, p = .000, eta2 = 0.38). The cross-sectional study47 shows that people who have been practicing dance for more than 5 weeks have a higher mindfulness score (t (932) = 7.86, d = 0.52, p < 0.0001). Subjects also had higher levels of life satisfaction (t (932) = 2.94, d = 0.19, p = 0.003) and better flow states (t (840) = 3.11, d = 0.22, p = 0.002). Similarly, in this study47 and with a different subsample, people who dance at least once a week more have higher mindfulness scores (t (850) = 2.72, d = 0.19, p = 0.007) and better flow (t (806) = 3.25, d = 0.23, p = 0.001), but do not have significantly higher life satisfaction. Two other qualitative studies39,44 also found improved physical health and flow states in those who participated in dance sessions.
Physical pain
The work reviewed emphasizes that dance therapy encourages the expression and recognition of physical pain. The cross-sectional study47 highlights the usefulness of dance in the management of chronic pain (89.4% of people with chronic pain). Those who reported being helped by dance in the management of their chronic pain had a better flow state compared to those who reported not being helped (t (237) = 4.08, d = 0.91, p < 0.0001). Similarly, the quantitative experimental study40 measures perceived physical pain before and after a flamenco workshop. After the workshop, and compared to those who did not participate, participants present less physical pain (F = 4.25, p = .048, eta2 = 0.12). A case study43 shows that dance therapy reduces physical pain and the emotional pain related to shame. These studies do not specify whether the effects last beyond the dance therapy intervention, but they are reported through to the end.
Psychological process
Linking affects and representations
The extracted research highlights that dance therapy favors the connection of affects in people with psychological trauma. The case study43 with the 40-year-old affected-migration woman identifies the important role of dance in the expression of her emotions. Physical activity allows for the expression of repressed emotions, which immediately leads to a feeling of liberation and relief. In the case study41 with a woman diagnosed with borderline personality disorder, dance is used to create distance from her emotional distress, which she described as overwhelming. It is noted that there is a failure of the anamnesis elements in this study,43 preventing the results of the treatment to be visualized when it is completed. However, the two case studies41,43 link the subject’s affects to somatic expression. They clearly identify the outlet function of movement43 and establish a correlation between physical psychodynamic movements and psychic movements.41
Mental movement
The case studies included show that the physical movement of dance induces psychic movement in people who have been frozen by trauma. The case study45 of a group practicing dance therapy highlights the use of the sensorimotor to initiate trauma integration work. Identifying and activating the processes at the base of the body’s resources allows the process of emotional and cognitive integration of the trauma to begin. In this study,45 the activation of the sensory-motor pole in the subjects allows the reintegration of the fragmented and negatively invested body image. In addition, the case study43 with the woman facing migration finely shows the process of resilience in the treatment. Dance therapy enabled this patient to gain a sense of strength and to express intense emotions linked to the past trauma. She succeeded in symbolically lightening herself through movement, in space and in form. The reduction of her symptoms was accompanied by the reintegration of her fragmented body image and the strengthening of her psychic resources. Movement can have a symbolic function, allowing the diversity of affects to emerge and subjecting them to interpretation.43 The case study with the group45 also describes a reinstatement of psychic movement through the body.
DISCUSSION
The articles resulting from our selection protocol have shown that the effects of dance therapy include reappropriating the body, expressing emotions, and improving the management of, or even reducing, psychopathological symptoms in people suffering from psychological trauma. Group dance therapy favors self-expression and a new relationship with others. The feeling of safety and the ability of participants to be in a flow state facilitate the emergence of these beneficial effects. They depend on the skill set of the therapists and the regularity, constancy, and stability of the sessions.
Dance therapy improves the sensory-motor perceptions and motor skills of people with psychological trauma. These variables are highlighted by other studies5,49 conducted on the effects of dance therapy, particularly in prevention contexts and with populations of children with disabilities. We hypothesize several reasons for these findings. First, repeated physical activity is strongly correlated with the development and amelioration of the encoding devoted to motor skills.50 Second, dance therapy enhances sensory-motor perceptions as it is a potential reminder of the individual primary experience of movement and sound.51 Third, improved sensory-motor perception enhances body schema,52 which in turn promotes the development of motor skills. If these hypotheses are confirmed, dance therapy would be particularly effective for people suffering from psychological trauma, as it would encourage them to redevelop a deep connection with their bodies, which have been distanced by the dissociation and amnesia linked to psychological trauma.53
Dance therapy improves the psychological state of people with psychological trauma and promotes the identification, expression, and externalization of emotions. This is consistent with the literature on the effectiveness of dance therapy5,49,54 in the general population. We hypothesize several reasons for these results. First, an improvement in participants’ psychological state correlates with a pre-existing interest for dance and physical activity.55 Second, dance is a non-verbal medium that allows the expression of emotions through the body while initiating the process of emotional identification.56 The work of emotions through dance therapy is particularly interesting in the treatment of dissociation (initially caused by psychological trauma) because it is characterized, among other things, by a disruption in the integration of emotions.14 The psycho-affective register would be strengthened, which would improve mentalization, frozen by sideration during the traumatic event, and would reduce feelings of shame and guilt.57 Third, reaching a flow state facilitates the improvement of the psychological state58 because it reduces excessive self-consciousness. This reduction would be positively correlated with the decrease in feelings of shame and guilt related to the psychological trauma,59 which would facilitate verbal expression in people suffering from psychological trauma.
Dance therapy stimulates self-expression and interpersonal relationships, enhancing the relational skills of people with psychological trauma. This is consistent with the findings of major studies on dance therapy.5,49,60 We make several assumptions about these findings. First, interpersonal skills are enhanced by the presence of the group, the therapeutic focus of the dance, and non-verbal communication.5 Second, emotional sharing and the quality of receiving expression encourage self-expression and interpersonal relationships. Third, the development of interpersonal skills and relationships depends on the quality of the individual’s initial attachment.61 The development of interpersonal skills is important in the management of psychological trauma because social functioning is impaired, resulting in a characteristic sense of detachment from others and from oneself.14 The quality of the subject’s initial attachment is a facilitator of the development of relational skills in people with psychological trauma.62
The group dimension of dance therapy develops a sense of personal safety and provides cultural support. These have not been well documented in the current literature in relation to dance therapy. We offer several hypotheses to explain these findings. First, music is integral to personal development and cultural belonging and is, therefore, an important cultural support.63 Second, the unity of time, place and space of the group contributes to the development of participants’ sense of security. The group is an effective tool for people with psychological trauma when the focus of care is specifically on the psychological trauma.64,65 A sense of safety is essential to the management of psychological trauma because it allows the intrusive re-emergence of the traumatic image, linked to the traumatic memory, to be contained and processed in the group.57,66 Cultural support and a sense of safety are even more important for people facing migration.67
Finally, this systematic review shows an improvement in physical health and psychological processes, in line with the results of the literature.5,68,69 Physical activity is positively correlated with mental health68 and its effects depend on the context,68 the regularity and the intensity of the activity.70 Compared to physical activity in general, dance is particularly effective in improving physiological body composition, blood biomarkers, and musculoskeletal function.71 We hypothesize that dance is a particularly effective therapeutic mediator in the management of psychological trauma because sensorimotor activation and its novel intrapsychic processing reduces symptoms related to psychological trauma.72
Recommendations
Based on the results of this systematic review, further research should be conducted on the specific effects of dance therapy in the treatment of psychological trauma, with studies that are primarily quantitative but also qualitative. The results highlight the dimensions and variables that specifically need to be explored. To improve clinical management, it is important to emphasize that these results concern mainly women and people facing migration. Moreover, it is relevant to offer this type of therapy more frequently because dance therapy allows the subject with psychological trauma to work on their motor and psychic abilities, emotions, self-expression, sense of security and interpersonal relationships. According to the results, it is important for therapists to pay attention to the stability of their intervention (unity of time, space, and place), to their countertransference and to the patients’ flow state. Finally, it is advisable to practice dance therapy with people with psychological trauma in a group setting65 and to focus the treatment on the psychological trauma.64 These theoretical supports complements those found in the literature.31
Strengths and limitations
The systematic article search was conducted on seven databases, in English and French. Quantitative, qualitative, and case studies were included, allowing for a fine-grained and complex analysis of the results. Bias analysis, performed by two researchers using two tools (NIH and JBI), allowed the exclusion of studies with too much bias. The small number of studies is the main limitation of our study. This led to the inclusion of studies deemed fair in the bias analysis. Finally, the variables studied are too varied to perform a meta-analysis at this time.
CONCLUSION
Dance therapy is effective with psychological trauma management. It especially adapted for women and people facing migration. It allows them to work on motor skills, psychological state, emotions, self-expression and sense of security, and interpersonal relationships. Physical activity mobilizes and improves physical health, which has repercussions on people’s psychological capacities. Its effectiveness is correlated with the quality of the therapist, the stability of the intervention and the patient’s flow state. In the absence of significant results, which have yet to be produced by scientific research, we can nevertheless consider that dance therapy increases well-being (self-esteem, depressive state, chronic pain), induces psychic movement, and favors the connection of affects and representations.
Data Availability
All data produced in the present work are contained in the manuscript
Footnotes
Declaration of Conflicting Interests: The lead researcher, Crystal Tomaszewski, is funded by the LOBA association, which launched a dance-therapy protocol. The other author(s) declare no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article.
Funding: C.T. and H.O-B. are funded by the LOBA association. Other authors received no specific funds.
↵1 Stagnation is a concept in Eastern medicine that resembles depression in Western medicine48
REFERENCES
