Effects of a Ketogenic and Low Fat Diet on the Human Metabolome, Microbiome and Food-ome in Adults at Risk for Alzheimer’s Disease

BACKGROUND

Despite decades of research, the pathophysiologic events that result in cognitive impairment are not fully understood, delaying the development of effective therapeutic options for neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer’s disease (AD) (1, 2). However, it is now appreciated that a variety of systemic changes occur throughout the course of AD, including metabolic dysregulation (3, 4), mitochondrial dysfunction (5, 6), inflammation (7), and body compositional changes (8, 9).

AD-related metabolic dysregulation has been interrogated by comparing AD metabolomic profiles to those of unaffected individuals. However, identifying metabolites universally associated with AD or cognitive decline is not straightforward. Both the Alzheimer’s Disease Neuroimaging Initiative’s (ADNI) studies (10, 11) and mouse models (12) have demonstrated that metabolic signatures for AD are sex and APOE genotype-dependent. Though study of the UK Biobank cohort showed that AD incidence was correlated with metabolites including the ketone body β-hydroxybutyrate, acetone, and valine, these metabolites were also associated with age and APOE genotype, complicating interpretation (13). Triglycerides (particularly polyunsaturated serum triglycerides) are also broadly associated with mild cognitive impairment (MCI) and AD onset (14, 15). In terms of symptom-specific associations, both short- and medium/long-chain acylcarnitines were associated with episodic memory scores and AD severity in the ADNI cohort (16), while C3 (propionylcarnitine) was associated with decreased amyloid-β accumulation and higher memory scores (17). These observations have provided new directions for AD therapeutics.

Separately, research into the gut-microbiota brain axis has spearheaded investigation into an altered gut microbiome in AD (18). It is hypothesized that gut microbiome disruptions may lead to local gastrointestinal inflammation or disturbance of the intestinal mucosal barrier, resulting in dysregulation of the signaling pathways between the gut and brain (19). Another hypothesis for the gut microbiome in AD comes from the connection between cholesterol, bile acids, and the gut microbiota. Cholesterol metabolism is consistently reported to be dysregulated in AD and AD-related diseases (20-22). Cholesterol accumulation in the brain contributes to hepatic encephalopathy, a chronic liver disease that leads to neuron loss and increased risk for AD, through bile acid mediated effects on the farnesoid X receptor (23). This observation is significant because bile acids, the main source of cholesterol elimination in the brain, are transformed by the gut microbiota (24). One preliminary study into this link showed that bile acids in serum were associated with “A/T/N” AD biomarkers, while another demonstrated that AD-related cognitive impairment is tied to higher levels of bacterially-modified secondary bile acids and lower levels of primary bile acids (25, 26). Similarly, another group reported that among the metabolites and metabolic pathways most differential between MCI and cognitively normal (CN) groups included the deoxycholate/cholate (DCA/CA) ratio and primary bile acid synthesis (27).

A significant factor uniting the gut microbiome, inflammation, and neurocognitive status with metabolic disorders is their relationship with diet (28-31). The ketogenic diet (KD) is a candidate therapeutic for AD because of its ability to improve mitochondrial function and cerebral bioenergetics, enhance autophagy, and reduce oxidative stress (30, 31). It also reduces neuronal hyperexcitability and leads to improved amyloid and tau regulation, substantiating its potential use for cognitive impairment (32).

We previously performed a pilot trial of a low carbohydrate modified Mediterranean ketogenic diet (MMKD) in patients at-risk for AD. We found that the MMKD increased levels of Aβ42 and decreased levels of tau in the cerebral spinal fluid (CSF) as well as improved peripheral lipid and glucose metabolism (i.e. reduction of Hb1Ac, insulin, triglyceride levels) in patients with mild cognitive impairment (MCI) (32). Patients on the MMKD also showed increased cerebral ketone body uptake and cerebral perfusion, important metrics of brain function (32). Microbially, the MMKD was associated with increased relative abundances of the Enterobacteriaceae, Akkermansia, Slackia, Christensenellaceae, and Erysipelotrichaceae taxa and decreases in the relative abundances of Bifidobacterium and Lachnobacterium (33). Metabolically, the MMKD was associated with increased propionate and butyrate and decreased lactate and acetate in stool (33). Interrogation into the mycobiome, or fungal microbiome, demonstrated that MMKD increased the relative abundance of Agaricus and Mrakia and decreased the relative abundance of Saccharomyces and Claviceps in patients with MCI (34).

Although thought-provoking, previous analyses relied on amplicon sequencing (of the 16S ribosomal RNA gene and internal transcribed spacer regions). In the present study, we sought to further characterize the complex relationship between diet, cognitive status, and the human microbiome and metabolome using shotgun metagenomic sequencing and untargeted metabolomics on the same samples. Furthermore, we employed a novel reference data-driven tool to empirically and retrospectively read out dietary metabolites from our samples (35). By updating our methods and integrating multiple data types, we identified key modulations to the gut microbiome and metabolome related to diet alone, cognitive status alone, or both.

METHODS

RESULTS

Twenty-three adults were enrolled in the study and twenty completed the full intervention. Participant characteristics by AD risk group may be found in Table 1.

Dimensionality Reduction of Microbiome, Food-omics, and Metabolome datasets

To visualize relationships between samples, we performed dimensionality reduction with Robust Aitchison Principal Component Analysis (RPCA) on each -omic dataset (39; Figure 1A). We found that the metabolomics data separates most strongly by individual subject, though separation by Cognition Group and Dietary Sequence are also statistically significant (F=29.684, p=4.33e-6; F=23.562, p=3.25e-5; F=20.987, p=6.58e-5) while metagenomics and food-omics data separate most strongly by Cognition Group, though not significantly (F=3.896, p=0.196; F=4.114, p=0.213). However, RPCA did not account for the longitudinal nature of the dataset. Controlling for repeated measures with compositional tensor factorization (CTF) revealed consistent dietary-related patterns in PCA space regardless of diet order (40; Figure 1B). Results from all ANOVAs performed on CTF Aitchison beta-diversity distances from baseline are available in Table S1.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1. Microbiome (left column), food-omics (middle column), and metabolome (right column), separate by subject and by diet across time.

Robust Aitchison Principal Component Analysis (RPCA) PC1 (x-axis) and PC2 (y-axis) colored by subject identification with marker shape by diet across study, clusters by subject. Compositional tensor factorization, method accounting from repeated measures across time (x-axis) PC1 (y-axis) colored by diet types, follows crossover study design in each data modality.

Relative Abundance Analyses

We identified microbial, food, and metabolite features that were associated with cognition and diet using a Negative Binomial Linear Mixed Effect model. We identified features that were associated with diet but not cognitive status, cognitive status but not diet, and both diet and cognitive status.

Microbial Features Associated with Cognitive Status and Dietary Intervention

The top ten microbial features associated with normal cognition or mild cognitive impairment are displayed in Figure 2A. Notably, Ruminococcus sp. CAG:330 is associated with MCI while Bacteroides fragilis and Dialister invisus are associated with CN independently of diet or timepoint (Figure 2D; p=0.016, p=0.028 respectively). The top ten microbial features associated with the ketogenic diet or a low-fat diet are displayed in Figure 3A. We observed higher abundances of Akkermansia muciniphila in the ketogenic diet, and higher abundances of Veillonella sp. ACP1 in low-fat diets (Figure 3D). To identify OGUs that were highly associated with both cognitive status and diet, we plotted the log ratios for CN to MCI against the log ratios for MMKD over AHAD and examined features that fell in each corner of the plot (Figure 4A). We found that the ratio of Alistipes sp. CAG:514 to Bifidobacterium adolescentis was significantly different between MCI and CN individuals only after consuming the low-fat AHAD (Figure 4B; t=3.78, p=0.00082).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 2. Microbial strains (left), foods (middle), and metabolites (right) related to cognition, but not necessarily diet type.

The differential abundances for the top 10 and bottom 10 with mean (bar) and model 95% confidence interval (error bars) associated with cognitive normal (more positive, blue) and mild cognitive impairment (more negative, red) (A, B, C). The log-ratio (y-axis) of the top and bottom bacterial strains (D&E) plotted across time (x-axis) and colored by cognition phenotype. Presented cognition p-values in log-ratio plots are determined from linear mixed effects models with fixed effects of diet, cognition, period, and diet sequences with random effect of subject.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 3. Microbial strains (left), foods (middle), and metabolites (right) related to diet type, but not necessarily cognition.

The differential abundances for the top 10 and bottom 10 with mean (bar) and model 95% confidence interval (error bars) associated with cognitive Ketogenic (more positive, green) and low-fat / american heart association diets (more negative, blue) (A, B, C). The log-ratio (y-axis) of the top and bottom bacterial strains (D), and sum of the top and bottom 10 foods (E) or metabolites (F) plotted across time (x-axis) and colored by diet. Presented diet stage p-values in log-ratio plots are determined from linear mixed effects models with fixed effects of diet, cognition, period, and diet sequences with random effect of subject.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 4. Microbial strains (left), foods (middle), and metabolites (right) related to both cognition and diet.

Scatter plot of log ratios of differential abundances by diet (x-axes) and cognition (y-axes) for microbes, with the ten most differential microbes and metabolites in both axes colored (A). Violin plot of the log-ratio of Alistepes sp. CAG: 514 to Bifidobacterium adolescentis at four different timepoints in the study (B). Scatter plot of log ratios of differential abundances by diet (x-axes) and cognition (y-axes) for microbes, with the ten most differential microbes and metabolites in both axes colored (C). Violin plot of the log-ratio of plant metabolites to Diarylheptanoids at four different timepoints in the study (D). In the scatterplots shown in (A) and (C), each corner corresponds to a different subpopulation: the top right corner represents microbes/metabolites associated with the MMKD and normal cognition, the top left corner contains the microbes/metabolites correlated with the AHAD and normal cognition, the bottom left corner shows microbes/metabolites associated with the AHAD and mild cognitive impairment, and the bottom right corner corresponds to microbes/metabolites correlated with the MMKD and MCI. These analyses allowed us to examine microbial and metabolite changes that were modulated by both diet and cognitive status.

Food Features Associated with Cognitive Status and Dietary Intervention

The top food microbial features associated with normal cognition or MCI are displayed in Figure 2B and the top food microbial features associated with the MMKD or AHAD are displayed in Figure 3B. Interestingly, cognitively normal individuals had higher levels of dietary metabolites that matched to cheddar cheese, goat cheese, and almonds - all foods that one might consume on a ketogenic diet - while individuals with MCI had relatively higher loads of dietary metabolites that matched to turkey and smelt (Figure 2B). As one might expect, those on the MMKD had higher relative abundances of dietary metabolites found in dairy products including cheddar cheese, low-sugar fruits like cherries, and low-sugar vegetables including broccoli (Figure 3B). Those on the AHAD diet had higher relative abundances of dietary metabolites that matched to foods including parsley, oregano, and shrimp (Figure 3B). However, the log ratios of the sum of the top 10 most MMKD-associated to the sum of top 10 AHAD-associated dietary metabolites were not significantly different over the course of the study (Figure 3E-F).

Metabolites Associated with Cognitive Status and Dietary Intervention

The top metabolite Feature IDs associated with normal cognition or MCI are displayed in Figure 2C, while the top metabolite Feature IDs associated with the MMKD or AHAD are displayed in Figure 3C. We found that the log ratio of the sum of the top 5 metabolites associated with the ketogenic diet to the sum of the top 5 metabolites associated with the low-fat diet was not significantly different throughout the intervention (Figure 3F). Furthermore, none of the top metabolites mapped to an exact reference through FBMN. However, metabolite 10007, which is associated with both the ketogenic diet and cognitive normality, was suspected to be related to curcumol through a nearest neighbor suspect spectral library (41). It is interesting that curcumol is associated with the ketogenic diet and normal cognition since another Curcuma metabolite, curcumin, has been associated with decreased gut motility through increased both gallbladder contraction and luminal bile acid levels (42). For this reason, in tandem with the fact that cognitive impairment in AD is tied to higher levels of bacterially-modified secondary bile acids and lower levels of primary bile acids, we decided to monitor bile acid levels in this population (24). We plotted the log ratios for cognitive normal to mild cognitive impairment against the log ratios for MMKD over AHAD and examined annotated bile acids as well as other molecules related to curcumin (Figure 4C). We found that the log ratio of two plant-derived metabolites to Diarylheptanoids, the class of molecules curcumin is a part of, was much lower in individuals with MCI only after consuming the AHAD (Figure 4D; t=-2.33, p=0.0326).This indicates that curcumin may be selectively enriched in people with cognitive impairment when they eat a low-fat diet.

Multi-omics Analyses

We were particularly interested in monitoring the relative levels of primary and secondary bile acids in individuals with MCI and those with normal cognition due to their associations with AD. Bile salt hydrolase (BSH) promotes the production of secondary bile acids, so we sought to examine the relationship between abundance of BSH-containing microbes and bile acid levels (42, 26). We used MMvec to identify bile acids that are associated with particular microbes and to cluster these relationships by diet (43). We found that Bifidobacterium adolescentis, Akkermansia muciniphila, and Akkermansia muciniphila CAG:154 were associated with 12-ketodeoxycholic acid, taurocholic acid, cholic acid, and hyocholic acid in the MMKD while Alistipes sp. CAG:514 and Clostridium sp. CAG:568 were associated with demethoxycurcumin, deoxycholic acid, cholic acid, and leucine-conjugated chenodeoxycholic acid in the AHAD (Figure 5A). We were also interested in examining the relationship between the metabolite demethoxycurcumin and levels of BSH-containing microbes as well as the ratio of unconjugated to conjugated bile acids, since turmeric increases luminal bile acid levels (42). Interestingly, we found that individuals with MCI had lower relative abundances of BSH-encoding microbes when their metabolome contained curcumin, while no difference was found in cognitively normal individuals (Figure 5B; t=2.9, p=0.0089; t=0.5, p=0.6308). On the other hand, cognitively normal individuals had a higher ratio of unconjugated bile acids to conjugated bile acids when their metabolome contained curcumin, while there was no significant difference in individuals with MCI (Figure 5C; t=-2.3, p=0.0328; t=-0.6, p=0.5681).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 5. Strongest diet and cognition linked differential abundances and co-occurrences linked to bile salt hydrolase (BSH) containing bacterial species, diarylheptanoids, and bile acids (BA).

The MMvec log cooccurrence probabilities (red-blue colors, colorbar) between differentially abundant and annotated metabolites (y-axis) and microbes (x-axis) colored by their association to diet (color bar top of x-axis, color legend) (A). The log-ratio of BSH containing microbes vs. those without BSH (y-axis) across diets and diarylheptanoids consumption (x-axis) (B). The log-ratio of unconjugated to conjugated BAs (y-axis) across diets and diarylheptanoids consumption (x-axis) (C). The annotations are Level II or Level III according to the Metabolomics Standards Initiative (46). Significance was evaluated by a two-sided t-test.

DISCUSSION

The gut microbiome, metabolism, and neurocognition are all significantly influenced by diet. In this work, we have demonstrated the effect of two dietary interventions for mild cognitive impairment on the gut microbiome, dietary metabolites, and general metabolome.

Notably, we showed that the microbiome and food-ome were not significantly associated with cognitive status or diet without explicitly accounting for the longitudinal nature of the data. Upon doing so, we found that the metagenome, food-ome, and metabolome were significantly associated with diet. The metagenome and metabolome were not significantly impacted by dietary order, while the food-ome was. Although there was noise due to factors such as inter-individual variation, dietary sequence, and cognitive status, there were consistent diet-related variations in the microbiome. This pattern corresponds to previous observations that dietary-induced changes to the microbiome can overwhelm inter-individual differences, even when dietary changes are short-term (28).

We also identified the top microbial, metabolic, and food features that were associated with diet independent of cognition and cognition independent of diet. Microbially, we found that Ruminococcus sp. CAG:330 is associated with MCI while Bacteroides fragilis and Dialister invisus are associated with cognitive normality. Furthermore, Akkermansia muciniphila is highly associated with the MMKD, while Veillonella sp. ACP1 is related to the AHAD. The Akkermansia muciniphila observation matches previous reports that its relative abundance increases significantly in mice when they are fed a ketogenic diet (44). This same study demonstrated that microbe Akkermansia muciniphila is essential for the ketogenic diet’s ability to protect against seizures in mice since it limits gut bacterial GABA production (44). Interestingly, we found that Alistipes sp. CAG:514, is enriched in individuals with MCI on the low-fat AHAD (Figure 4B). This finding is significant because microbial strains that are similar to Alistipes sp. CAG:514 are known to produce GABA (45). This led us to re-investigate the relative relationship between Akkermansia muciniphila and Alistipes sp. CAG:514 and levels of the GABA metabolite in our population. We found that the ratio of Alistipes sp. CAG:514 to Akkermansia muciniphila is elevated in individuals with MCI relative to normal individuals only on the low-fat AHAD (Figure S3A). Furthermore, GABA levels are higher in the stool of cognitively-impaired individuals on the AHAD than on the MMKD, but there is no dietary-related difference in cognitively-normal individuals (Figure S3B). This trend was consistent in a separate dataset examining cerebrospinal fluid metabolites of the same individuals (Fig S3B). These observations led us to hypothesize that low-fat AHAD modulates key neurotransmitters, such as promoting GABA production, in individuals with cognitive impairment. This dysregulation may be related to increases in GABA-producing microbes such as Alistipes sp. CAG:514, while dietary interventions such as the MMKD may decrease GABA levels in the opposite direction through its associated increases in GABA-regulating microbes such as Akkermansia muciniphila.

We found that one of the top metabolites associated with both the ketogenic diet and cognitive normality was related to curcumol through a nearest-neighbor suspect library (41). Another compound produced by the same plant, curcumin, was instead elevated in participants with MCI who ate the low-fat AHAD diet (Figure 4F). Consumption of turmeric, which contains curcumin and curcumol, is known to stimulate gallbladder contraction which results in higher luminal bile acid levels (42). Bile acids were also of interest because the cognitive impairment observed in AD is tied to higher levels of bacterially-modified secondary bile acids and lower levels of primary bile acids (24). Therefore, we hypothesized that cognitively normal people may have higher relative levels of primary bile acids when curcumin is found in their metabolome. Indeed, we found that cognitively normal individuals had a significantly higher ratio of unconjugated bile acids to conjugated bile acids when their metabolome contained curcumin, while there was no significant difference in individuals with MCI (i.e. individuals with MCI had relatively higher load of conjugated bile acids, Figure 5C). We hypothesized that the difference in relative levels of unconjugated to conjugated bile acids may be due to the levels of BSH (26). Cognitively normal individuals retained similar levels of BSH-containing microbes regardless of diet or curcumin-presence, while individuals with cognitive impairment had significantly lower levels of BSH-containing microbes when curcumin was present in their diet (Figure 5B). It appears, therefore, that the low-fat AHAD decreases the levels of BSH-containing microbes as well as Akkermansia muciniphila in individuals with MCI, leading to alterations of key metabolites including the neurotransmitter GABA. These individuals also have higher relative levels of unconjugated bile acids to conjugated bile acids than cognitively normal individuals, leading us to hypothesize that they may have decreased gut-transit time. We have outlined the details of our overall model in Figure S4.