Developing a culturally tailored brain healthy diet intervention for older midwestern African Americans: A Qualitative and Quantitative Study

Online Surveys

All participants provided written consent before participating in the study. Prior to focus group discussions 39 participants completed a 30 minute online demographic survey (15-item), eating habits survey (15-item), and needs assessment survey (26-item). The surveys included questions about demographics, health care, eating patterns, cultural food needs, and community nutrition education needs. The survey was administered through a REDCap online link that was emailed individually to each participant 7 days prior to their scheduled focus group discussion.

Focus Groups

Five focus group discussions, each consisting of 5-7 people (39 total), were conducted between May 2021 – July 2021 and each focus group took place virtually using the Zoom platform. Each focus group lasted 60 minutes. Focus groups followed a semi-structured guide in which open-ended, clear, and concise questions were used to stimulate discussion. Additionally, probe questions were used to obtain more detailed information from focus group participants. All focus group discussions were audio recorded and transcribed verbatim. The focus groups were led by a trained AA facilitator. She was selected to facilitate due to her education, prior experience moderating focus group discussions in the AA community, and cultural relation and understanding of the participants. Participants received a $50 gift card in appreciation for their time.

Member Check Focus Group

Upon completion of the data analysis (see below), we conducted member checking, or participant validation to ensure participants perspectives were appropriately represented and not curtailed by the researchers knowledge and personal agenda.²⁹ The member check focus group was comprised of a subset of participants (n=5), was led by the AA facilitator, and took place 3 months after the final focus group discussion via Zoom platform. The member check focus group in this study was conducted to ensure that emerging themes were congruent with the community’s interpretation, resulting in a final thematic consensus. The single member check focus group lasted 30 minutes and gave participants an opportunity to check for accuracy of the data, which is consistent with best practices for exploring credibility and enhancing rigor of qualitative data^29,30

Quantitative data

Demographics of participants and online surveys were analyzed using descriptive statistics.

Qualitative data

Transcribed data was placed into Dedoose, a qualitative analysis software program,³¹ which supported coding, filing, and organizing themes and subthemes. Data was analyzed using a 6-step thematic analysis process including familiarization, coding, generating themes, reviewing themes, defining, and naming themes, and write up.³²

Eating habits

Most participants indicated that they currently either do not follow a dietary eating practice (48.7%) or follow a low sodium eating diet (25.6%). For food preparation most participants reported regularly baking (82.1%), grilling (46.2%), or air frying (43.6%) their food. A full description of reported eating habits can be found in Table 2.

Health conditions knowledge interest

Many participants indicated that they were “very interested” or “interested” in receiving more health education related to AD (89.7%) and blood pressure (76.9%) (Table 3).

Barriers to eating healthy

Regarding perceived barriers to eating healthy many participants indicated that taste (30.8%) a being one of the primary reasons followed by cost (20.5%). A full description of perceived barriers to eating healthy can be found in Table 4.

Nutrition education and delivery preferences

For a dietary intervention participants reported that they were either very interested or interested in receiving education related to water intake (94.9%), meal planning and prepping (87.2%), nutritional content (87.1%), and eating healthy on a budget (84.6%). Most people indicated that they preferred to support from a nutritionist or health coach virtually (94.9%) or by phone (94.9%).

Additionally, most people reported that they would prefer to receive a dietary intervention virtually (94.9%) or at a church (94.9%). See Table 5 for nutrition education and delivery preferences.

Family history

Many participants expressed that they first learned about dementia from having a family history of dementia (i.e. grandparents, parents, in-laws, older siblings). “I first learned about it with my father. My father was diagnosed with it and I just say if you’ve ever been diagnosed with dementia, might as well say you have Alzheimer’s. So that’s how I first learned about it that was about 16 or 17 years ago.” Some participants also mentioned that they first learned about dementia through media outlets (i.e. articles, AARP) and through church in which older congregant members at their church had dementia.

Perceived cause of dementia

Participants across all focus group groups perceived dementia to be prevalent among older people in general not necessarily more prevalent among Black Americans compared to other racial/ethnic groups. However, several participants believed that dementia is serious in the Black community due to the lack of awareness the community has about what dementia is and the perception that it is a normal part of aging (i.e. senility). Participants voiced that they believed contributing factors to lack of awareness stemmed from lack of education and lack of access to available resources. “I’m feeling like it is a serious problem for Black people…. we don’t have the access or the resources or sometimes the will to go and find out what is going on with us or with a relative. On the other hand, I would hesitate to say definitively that there’s this more serious for Black people ’cause I have not seen statistics on that.”

Role of diet in dementia

Regarding the role of diet in dementia most participants believed that following a healthy diet was important for keeping the brain healthy. “I think that a healthy diet is important for every part of your body, especially the brain, because if we give the brain the correct nutrients, I just believe that we will, you know, function better and function longer if we eat the right things.” Specifically, participants perceived that regularly following a healthy diet, especially early in life can provided essential nutrients to keep the brain functioning healthy as we age. However, some participants voiced that they believed that healthy eating is not commonly practiced until one gets older, when people start thinking more about longevity of life.

Household decision making

Many participants indicated that they lived alone therefore household decision making about food was made individually. “I live with myself, so me.” Among those who indicated that they were married many indicated that the wife did a majority of the decision-making regarding food. Lastly, the key factor that played a role within the decision making for food was cost.

Food purchasing practices

Participants voiced that food purchasing practices were largely influenced by cost and that they shopped based of deals from grocery-ads and deals in their supermarkets. Some participants indicated that due to the COVID-19 pandemic their food purchasing practices have shifted to primarily grocery shopping online, with the exception of going in-person to a grocery store to purchase produce. “Since the pandemic, I have had like uh most of my shopping online and I go and pick it up, and I have a few smaller stores that I go to purchase things that um things like vegetables, things that I usually go in person to pick those out, not at a smaller store.” Also, participants indicated that food purchasing practices including shopping for a variety of food within a week due to the preference of not wanting to eat the same foods/meals several times throughout the week.

Food preparation practices

Most participants voiced that they liked to use a variety of food preparation practices including baking, air frying, and grilling. It is important to note that many participants stated that frying foods was rarely practiced within their households. “I sauté. I’m using the oven, as the weather continues to change, and now that I can make a good fire, I might use the grill more. But frying is just not something I do not do at all.”

Access

Many participants voiced access to healthy foods as being a significant barrier to eating healthy in the Black community. Specifically, many participants indicated that there are food deserts in many of the predominantly Black neighborhoods coupled with poor public transportation which makes it difficult to access healthy foods. “In many of the communities they don’t have access to fresh fruits and vegetables…Places like when I’m walking is a food desert, you know they don’t have uh fresh produce in the stores in the neighborhoods, so if they don’t have it there, they can’t get it.” Additionally, many participants stated that stores that are available in these neighborhoods do not offer fresh produce results in community members purchasing foods that are readily available, which often aren’t healthy options.

Cost

A majority of the participants across all focus groups voiced that cost of healthy food was a significant barrier to eating healthy in the Black community (i.e. fruits and vegetables) and believed that people would eat healthier if they could afford it. “Cost. I think that, I think that if you eat healthier, it’s going to cost you more, instead of being an investment in your life, so some of the plant based foods are more expensive, and some of the plant based cheese are more expensive.” Additionally, some participants believed cost was more of a barrier for people living in households with more than one generation. Overall cost of foods inhibits the Black community’s from being capable of fully investing in their health due to lack of affordability.

Taste

Some participants perceived taste as a barrier to consuming healthy food noting that healthy food often taste bland. Also, it was perceived that people in the Black community are more accustomed to foods that have higher sodium for seasoning which makes it less appetizing when consuming healthy foods of lower sodium. “Sometimes people are used to the salt, and they don’t want to eat bland food.”

Food Spoilage

Participants indicated that they perceived healthy foods, particularly produce to spoil quicky which hindered their ability to follow a healthy diet. “I like vegetables, so it’s not a problem. The only problem is just keeping the vegetables on hand, you know without them spoiling and I have to throw them out.” Specifically, people perceived fresh produce to have a short shelf life meaning that they would need to make multiple trips to the grocery store throughout the week, which can be burdensome.

Cooking Education

Across all focus group participants highlighted the importance of providing cooking education to support buy-in from the community. “I just think, more education. If you go out in the community and maybe even do demonstrations where you can show people that, how the food tastes, how easy it is to prepare.” Many participants believed that education centers around cooking demonstrations as a means to explore new foods. Cooking demonstrations coupled with sample tasting allows for the community to get a better sense of healthy foods that they may like/don’t like so that they can incorporate more healthy foods in their diet moving forward.

Accessibility Guidance

Many participants indicated that although providing education (i.e. recipes, cooking demonstrations) is helpful in providing support to a more healthy dietary lifestyle in the Black community it is imperative to show where and how people can obtain healthy foods (i.e. highlighting specific grocery stores, farmers markets). “It also has to be available, we can educate, we can show, we can even provide taste, but we have to make it available and show them where they can obtain or acquire these healthy foods, these recipes, these meals.”

Recruitment

Several people stated the recruitment into a brain healthy diet intervention needs to be comprehensive, meaning that it should include diverse outlets to reach a wide range of diverse older adults (across the city) within the Black community. Specifically, recruitment through media outlets such as the newspapers, radio, and tv ads would be best in reaching older Black adults. “It needs to be put out comprehensively. Television, radio, magazines, newspapers, social media, churches, groups go into nursing homes and things of that nature that’s you know, a comprehensive approach because you can’t just utilize one level of approach. Because that’s only going to affect only a segment of that community.” Many participants across focus groups also voiced the importance of establishing partnerships local churches and community centers who could support recruitment efforts by distributing recruitment materials via newsletter and email. Notably, social media outlets (i.e. Facebook and Twitter) were not favorably viewed by many of the participants as a way to recruit older adults due to irregular use of the platforms.

MIND Dietary Model

Of the 3 diets (MIND, Mediterranean, and DASH) discussed at each of the focus group sessions the MIND diet model was most favored and seen most feasible to follow due to the variety of food options and because it was viewed as aligning more with lifestyle practices within the black community. “I like the variety; you know most of it, I’ve kind of been doing already. Not much of the olive oil, like I said I stick with kind of canola oil. So, it limits you on the cheese, I see that. I mean I use way more cheese than one serving a week. Everything else is OK.” Moreover, the MIND diet was viewed as less restrictive compared to the Mediterranean diet. However, many participants voiced that some adjustments in the model are needed to increase acceptability within the Black community including increasing the recommended amount of butter and cheese as well as providing plant-based alternatives options in these categories. “Less than, 1…if I’m fixing broccoli, if I’m fixing potatoes, they’re all gonna have some type of butter in it. If I’m fixing corn, it has butter in it. So, I don’t know if this is do-able for me.” Participants also voiced the importance of including information about spices within the model to address the taste barrier many people in the Black community have. “There is a vaster range of herbs and spices out there and we have to learn to use those” Several participants discussed how they felt berries were not necessarily aligned with Black culture so alternative fruits that support brain health that are affordable should be highlighted such as cantaloupe which is high in antioxidants.³³ “I don’t like certain textures, so I don’t like blueberries or berries for that reason. But I could mix them into something for the flavor.” “I think I like it even more if I can eat cantaloupe…berries cost a little bit more than cantaloupe and apples and things like that.” Additionally, more specific information about serving sizes in lay language need to be included so it is easier for people to follow. Many focus group participants believed it was imperative to include information about the importance of water intake in relation to the MIND diet. For the adapted MIND diet model participants voiced the importance of including foods for each of the 10 categories that the Black community would easily recognize (i.e. green leafy vegetables - collard greens, starchy vegetable – sweet potato, whole grains - oatmeal). Lastly, for each of the 10 food categories on the MIND diet many participants indicated that they felt that it was important to include a snippet of health information (i.e. sweet potatoes contain large amounts of fiber which improve the health of the gut and digestion) so people can understand additional benefits food groups have for the entire body, not just benefits for brain health.

Comprehensive Education and Delivery Method

Many focus group participants voiced the importance of a dietary intervention including a faith component (i.e. scriptures, health devotionals) coupled with ongoing education with resources (i.e. cooking classes with samples, simple recipes, preparation videos, pocket cards (MIND diet).

“I know being a person of faith here at, being with my church, there are scriptures that talks about taking back what the enemy has stole from you. So that includes your mind. We often go into material things, but your mind and your health is something that it was stolen because we did not eat correctly because of lack of education and resources. So, if they are available, you know for me, myself, I would use scripture going right along with the MIND diet. So, you prayed this scripture in the natural, what are you going to……. I mean for the spiritual piece, what are you going to do in the natural? So, in the natural pray this scripture, and in the physical eat the food along with it and walk along with it and let’s see what’s going to come. So, let’s just be you know, realistic with that as far as myself, that is the way that I’m going to approach the seniors here at our church about this MIND diet so we’re praying this, let’s put this into action.”

Regarding delivery of education, participants across all focus groups indicated the importance of offering a hybrid model which would provide greater access to receiving education in the Black community. Additionally, for in-person education many participants believed it should be offered in community settings such as community centers and recreational centers.

Retention

To support retention efforts in the brain healthy diet intervention many participants voiced that it would be helpful to provide the community with various incentives (i.e. financial incentives such as grocery store gift cards to off-set the cost of healthy food). Since cognitive changes take time, many participants voiced the importance of highlighting short term benefits that will take place by following a healthy diet. Specifically, several participants emphasized the importance of designing an intervention that highlights the early benefits of following a healthy diet (i.e. weight loss, lower blood pressure, potential financial benefits from getting off medication), which would result in a higher retention rate in a brain healthy diet intervention. “Incentives might work too, if people stay on this and they know they’ve lost some weight, maybe a small token or reward uh you know, or a trip or free meal, I don’t know, something. Incentives always help people.”

Strengths

Our study has several strengths including use of the mixed methods approach, resulting in a more thorough knowledge imperative to inform future intervention development. Also, use of focus groups provided a richer and more informed understanding which can add meaning to quantitative findings.

Limitations

Our study was limited in a single Midwestern geographical location therefore it is difficult to generalize results to a larger population. The study was also limited due to the lack of use of random sampling in which selection bias can occur with use of purposive sampling.