Access to Episodic Primary Care: A Cross-sectional Comparison of Walk-in Clinics and Urgent Primary Care Centers in British Columbia

Study Design and Setting

This is a cross-sectional study of outpatient clinics providing episodic primary care in British Columbia (BC), Canada. BC has a single payer health care insurance program, and there are no direct to patient charges for primary care services delivered at walk-in clinics or UPCC’s.²⁵ Physician payment is largely by fee for service, and there are only a few clinics where physicians are paid via a capitated model,⁶ that includes penalties if their patients go to walk-in clinics.²⁶

Data Collection and Sources

We used publicly available lists of clinic information including the BC Ministry of Health’s Walk-in Clinic List (Walk-in Clinic List) version: April 2021, ²⁷ and the Urgent and Primary Care Clinic (UPCC) List, version: November 2021.²⁸ The Walk-in Clinic List is maintained by staff at the Ministry of Health, reviewed for completeness by a data steward at the BC Data Catalogue.²⁹ The listing includes: name of clinic, associated website, phone number, street address, as well as, additional data. The UPCC list²⁸ is regularly updated on HealthLink BC which is the public-facing source of non-emergency health information and advice maintained by the BC Ministry of Health. This site provides a list of the names of UPCCs, organized by health authority, and a link to a clinic-specific website.²⁸

The two lists were reviewed for duplication. If the Walk-in Clinic List or the UPCC listing did not include a website address, the clinic and street address were searched via Google. For any clinics with no self-managed website found in a google search, information would be extracted from one of the public, aggregate walk-in clinic websites, searched in order: Medimap³⁰, SkiptheWaitingRoom³¹, Pathways³², and Cortico³³.

A structured data collection form was used to review each clinic website for the variables of interest. Data were collected from walk-in clinic websites between May and June 2021 and from UPCC websites in both June and November 2021, by author MM. UPCC data was collected twice as 13 new UPCCs opened between the start and end of the study period.

Population data by health authority was retrieved from the BC government population estimates and projections website.³⁴ Oversight of access to and quality of health care services in BC is delivered by 5 different geographically defined health authorities (there is also a First Nations Health Authority [FNHA] which is responsible for managing health programs and services for First Nations people in the entire province).³⁵ The number of clinic service hours at walk-in clinic’s and UPCCs per 100,000 people are reported at this level because health system monitoring and funding is directed to health authorities.³⁶

Variables of Interest

Data Analysis

We used a Chi-square test to compare categorical variables, stratified by health authority and clinic type (walk-in clinics vs. UPCCs), and calculated descriptive statistics using the IBM Statistical Package for the Social Sciences software (V27.0; IBM). We accessed publicly available information and per article 2.2 of the Tri-Council Policy Statement 2 (2018) did not require review by an ethics board.³⁸

Clinic service hours

There are 13,094 hours of episodic primary care available in a typical week in British Columbia (Table 1). Fourteen (5.8%) walk-in clinics provide patient services before 08:00, none of the UPCCs do. Sixteen (6.6%) walk-in clinics offer services after 17:00, compared to 22 (88%) of UPCCs, and 153 (63%) walk-in clinics are open on weekends, compared to 24 (96%) UPCCs. Walk-in clinics offered the majority (8,968.6/ 78.4%) of their service hours between 08:00 and 17:00, Monday to Friday. UPCCs offered the majority (889.3/ 53.7%) of their service hours after 17:00. Only 145 (59.7%) walk-in clinics, and none of the UPCCs listed the names and/or number of doctors who worked there (median 5 [Interquartile range (IQR) = 3.7]) (Table 1).

After hours availability, association with other primary care services, booking methods and appointment types

Table 2 compares primary care access characteristics between walk-in clinics and UPCCs and shows that there are significant differences between the types of clinics, including being associated with longitudinal practice, appointment booking and virtual appointment options. Most walk-in clinics in BC (92.6%) are operated as a part of, or adjacent to, a longitudinal family practice and the majority of hours of service (78.4%) are provided during weekday business hours (08:00-17:00). Further, they offer phone (99.6%) and online booking (46.9%) and virtual appointments (73.3%) at significantly higher rates than UPCCs (44%, 0% and 20% respectively).

Geographic variation in availability of clinic service hours

Figure 1 Describes and compares the total clinic service hours per 100,000 population between walk-in clinics and UPCCs across all 5 geographic health authorities. Interior and Northern Health Authorities cover large areas of less densely populated portions of the province and have lower hours per 100,000, than Fraser, Vancouver Coastal and Vancouver Island Health Authorities, which each contain at least one large metropolitan area. In all regions, the majority of available hours for episodic primary care are provided by walk-in clinics.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1: Variation in Number of Clinic Service Hours Available Per Week, Per 100,000 Population, by Health Authority

Footnotes:

British Columbia is divided into 5 geographic health authorities: Interior, Fraser, Vancouver Coastal (VCH), Vancouver Island (VIHA), and Northern

Population estimates for each health authority were collected from BCStats BC Populations Estimates and Projections³⁴

Most walk-in clinics are associated with a longitudinal family practice

Almost all walk-in clinics in BC (92.6%) are operated at the same site as a longitudinal family practice; it is unclear why this structure has emerged as opposed to expansion of longitudinal care given the community need. It is possible resources used to provide episodic care have decreased resources available to provide longitudinal care.²³ While the original intention of walk-in clinic services may have been to serve as an adjunct to longitudinal care,^24,39 given the family doctor shortage, it is possible that the current use of walk-in clinics is primarily by people unattached to a longitudinal practice.²²

In BC, the provincial licensing body, the College of Physicians and Surgeons dictates that walk-in clinics must fulfill the same Practice Standard⁷ as clinics that provide longitudinal care. Notably, this practice standard references continuity but only as it applies to follow up on episodes of medical care and laboratory tests rather than the establishment of a longitudinal relationship between patient and provider that has been shown to reduce mortality.¹⁵ Across Canada, the practice standards put forward by the provincial and territorial Colleges show variation (See Supplement 1). It is possible that the function and role of walk-in clinics also has variation province to province, and that this clinic type shifts, based on unmet needs of the region it is operating in. Future studies using clinics as a unit of analysis would benefit from transparent reporting of access features to allow for inter-provincial comparison.⁴⁰

UPCCs offer patient services after-hours more often than walk-in clinics

UPCCs are offering patient services after-hours at higher rates than walk-in clinics. This features is more reminiscent of the original description of walk-in clinic services.^1,2 The impact of after-hours episodic primary care has had limited study and the authors are unaware of studies examining the impact on the availability of longitudinal care; the authors note that studies looking at costs and emergency department utilization have mixed results.^13,41,42 Findings from these studies urge careful consideration of local context before creating policies and/or adding resources to increase episodic after-hours access versus longitudinal primary care.^9,11,43

Geographic variation

Access to episodic primary care accessibility shows geographic variation in B.C. The province operates using the health authority (HA) system; where each HA is responsible for identifying and meeting their populations health needs.³⁵ It is possible that primary care attachment, continuity of care, and after-hours service provision differs according to need across each health authority, or there could be insufficient resources available in some areas. The authors are unaware of any published studies to estimate the “appropriate” amount of episodic primary care for a region. A 2000 study found that rural patient populations were more likely to contact their longitudinal primary care providers during after-hours, compared to those situated in urban areas.⁴⁴

Limitations

Limitations of this study include the reliance on publicly available data, sourced directly from walk-in clinic and UPCC websites that may not be updated, nor reflect actual practices. Secondly, this study could only measure access to episodic primary care via clinic’s business hours, methods of booking appointments, adjacency to a pharmacy, and availability of virtual services. There was inconsistent reporting of the number of clinicians at work during opening hours and none provided the volume of patients seen per shift. This means that our data cannot be used to indicate the volume of patients seen on a daily basis which would be a more ideal report of service capacity. Despite these limitations, we have been able to use publicly available data to provide a description of episodic primary care access across BC which may be useful to establish a baseline measure in other regions to inform future research, evaluation or policy development of the capacity and impact of episodic primary care.