Summary
Aims of the study We know little about the level of physical activity, respiratory physiotherapy practices, and nutritional status of people with primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD), although these are important aspects of patients with chronic respiratory disease. We assessed physical activity, respiratory physiotherapy practices, and nutritional status among people with PCD in Switzerland, investigated how these vary by age, and identified factors associated with regular physical activity.
Methods We sent a postal questionnaire survey to people with PCD enrolled in the Swiss PCD registry (CH-PCD), based on the standardised FOLLOW-PCD patient questionnaire. We collected information about physical activity, physiotherapy, respiratory symptoms, and nutritional status. We calculated the metabolic equivalent (MET) to better reflect the intensity of the reported physical activities. To assess nutritional status, we extracted information from CH-PCD and calculated participants’ body mass index (BMI).
Results Of the 86 questionnaires we sent, 74 (86% response rate) were returned from 24 children and 50 adults. The median age at survey completion was 23 years [IQR (interquartile range) 15–51], and 51% were female. Among all 74 participants, 48 (65%) performed sports regularly. Children were vigorously active (median MET 9.1; IQR 7.9–9.6) and adults were moderately active (median MET 5.5; IQR 4.3-6.9). 59 participants (80%) reported performing some type of respiratory physiotherapy. However, only 30% of adults saw a professional physiotherapist compared with 75% of children. Half of the participants had normal BMI; one child (4%) and two adults (4%) were underweight. People who were regularly physically active reported seeing a physiotherapist more often.
Conclusions Our study is the first to provide patient-reported data about physical activity, respiratory physiotherapy, and nutrition among people with PCD. Our results highlight that professional respiratory physiotherapy, exercise recommendations, and nutritional advice are often not implemented in the care of people with PCD in Switzerland. Multidisciplinary care in specialised centres by teams including physiotherapists and nutrition consultants could improve the quality of life of people with PCD.
Introduction
Due to increased respiratory workload, chronic respiratory diseases affect exercise capacity and nutritional status. These diseases are often complicated by recurrent infections that contribute further to increased metabolic demand [1-4]. Promoting a good level of physical activity and monitoring nutritional status are crucial for maintaining respiratory health; thus, they are important parts of managing chronic lung diseases. In the chronic lung disease primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD), genetic mutations cause structural and functional changes of motile cilia, which reduce mucociliary clearance [5]. Chronic respiratory symptoms and recurrent infections of the upper and lower airways are common in PCD [6]. Therefore, among people with PCD physical activity is recommended for improving airway clearance, in addition to specific respiratory physiotherapy practices [7-9]. We know from other chronic lung diseases, such as cystic fibrosis (CF), that physical activity is associated with improved sputum expectoration. Particularly beneficial are higher intensity activities followed by respiratory physiotherapy [10,11].
Yet, we know little about patients with PCD and their levels of physical activity, respiratory physiotherapy practices, and nutritional status. So far, the few studies involving physical exercise among people with PCD focused on muscle strength measurements and aerobic cardiorespiratory performance [12-15]. No studies examined the level of physical activity of people with PCD in their everyday lives. Regarding nutritional status, no studies assessed appetite and nutritional advice given to people with PCD. A large study from the international PCD (iPCD) cohort reported that children younger than 9 years had lower body mass index (BMI) z-scores than healthy peers [16]. A single centre study of 43 children in the United Kingdom studied nutrition using impedance spectroscopy [17]. Both studies suggested patients with PCD should receive nutritional advice to improve growth and delay lung disease progression [17,18]. In Switzerland where there is no centralised care for people with PCD, we have no information about supportive care. Our study describes physical activity, respiratory physiotherapy practices, and nutritional status among people with PCD in Switzerland, investigates how these vary by age and identifies factors associated with regular physical activity.
Methods
Study design and population
Our national cross-sectional questionnaire survey was nested in the Swiss PCD registry (CH-PCD). CH-PCD is a patient registry (www.clinicaltrials.gov; identifier NCT03606200) enrolling people with confirmed or clinical diagnoses of PCD in Switzerland [19]. Patients with a clinical PCD diagnosis, have a strong clinical suspicion e.g. situs anomalies, persistent cough, persistent rhinitis, chronic or recurrent upper or lower respiratory infections and history of neonatal respiratory symptoms as term infants but have not completed the diagnostic algorithm and have negative or ambiguous results for the tests performed so far [19-21].
Our reporting conforms with the Strengthening the Reporting of Observational studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) statement [22]. Detailed information about the study design is published elsewhere [23]. CH-PCD received ethical approval from the Cantonal Ethics Committee of Bern in 2015 (KEK-BE: 060/2015). We obtained written informed consent from participants or parents of participants younger than 14 years.
In February 2020, we sent a postal questionnaire to all people with PCD enrolled in the CH-PCD. After we mailed the questionnaire by post, we distributed the questionnaire at the PCD outpatient clinic in Bern to an additional five people who newly enrolled in CH-PCD (figure 1). After 2–3 weeks, we sent a reminder by post to everyone who had not yet returned questionnaires.
Flowchart of people with PCD living in Switzerland and their parents who were invited and participated in the survey.
Questionnaire
The questionnaire was based on the FOLLOW-PCD questionnaire (version 1.0), a PCD-specific standardised questionnaire, and part of a follow-up form developed by an international PCD expert group [24]. The FOLLOW-PCD questionnaire’s main domains included chronic respiratory symptoms from the past three months and health-related behaviours, such as physical activity during the past 12 months [23]. Our study used all original questions from the FOLLOW-PCD questionnaire and included additional questions about respiratory physiotherapy and nutritional intake. We added a section on respiratory physiotherapy based on the relevant clinical module from the FOLLOW-PCD form [24]. We reviewed the physiotherapy-related questions with respiratory physiotherapists in Switzerland to ensure they would be understandable by participants and relevant to local techniques. Lastly, we added more questions about nutritional advice in Switzerland based on expert suggestions.
We developed new questions in German, then a native French speaker with knowledge about PCD translated them into French. Questionnaires were age-specific for adults (ages ≥18 years), adolescents (ages 14–17 years), and parents of children (ages 0–13 years) with PCD available in German and French [23].
Physical activity
We asked if participants performed sports, what type of sports, and how many hours per week. For school-age children, we asked if they played school or any additional sports. We classified physical activity into five categories: aerobic activity, such as endurance or cardio activity; muscle strengthening; bone strengthening; balance activity; and flexibility activity [25]. If multiple types of physical activity were listed, we reported them all.
Since types of physical activity differ in intensity of cardiorespiratory exertion, we used metabolic equivalents (METs) to better reflect the intensity of reported activities. The MET of the adult compendium is described as the ratio of work metabolic rate to the resting metabolic rate [26]. One MET is defined as the amount of oxygen consumed sitting at rest; it is equivalent to 3.5 ml oxygen/kg body weight/min. We calculated the total MET per week based on participants’ activities. Since there is no standardised reference, we added a MET combination of gymnastics (3.8 MET) and children’s games (5.8 MET) to the total MET per week for children who always performed school sports. For children attending school sports sometimes or usually, we added one-third or two-thirds of the MET combination of gymnastics and children’s games, respectively. We categorised physical activity in three MET intensity categories: light (<3.0 METs), moderate (3.0–5.9 METs), and vigorous (≥6.0 METs) [27].
Nutrition
We assessed participant nutritional status by collecting information about appetite, physician advice for increasing caloric intake during the past 12 months, and calculating participant BMIs. If increasing caloric intake was recommended, we asked about specific recommendations, such as increases of energy-dense food, larger portion size, or meal frequency. Furthermore, we assessed if recommendations had been successful increasing energy and if body weight stabilized or increased. Other questions revolved around intake of oral nutritional supplements.
To calculate BMI, we used height and weight data from the CH-PCD measured in the hospital or private practices closest to the time when participants completed the survey. We calculated BMI by dividing weight in kilograms by height in meters squared (kg/m2). We classified BMI for adults as underweight (<18.5 kg/m2), normal (≥18.5 to <25), overweight (≥25.0 to <30), or obese (≥30.0 to <35) by World Health Organisation (WHO) standards (WHO) [28]. For children and adolescents aged 5–17 years, we calculated sex and age-specific BMI z-scores based on the 2007 WHO references [29]. We defined thinness (<-2 z-scores), normal (−2 to 1 z-scores), overweight (1 to 2 z-scores), and obesity (>2 z-scores).
Respiratory physiotherapy
We collected information on respiratory physiotherapy practices during the past three months, including if participants performed any physiotherapy; whether they had seen a professional physiotherapist; and which respiratory practices they used for upper and lower airway clearance, such as nose blowing, nasal rinsing, specific airway clearance techniques, and use of breathing exercise aids. We asked about the use of inhalation for the upper and lower airways, particularly with isotonic (0.9% sodium chloride) or hypertonic (>0.9% sodium chloride) saline. Lastly, we asked how difficult airway clearance was for them during this period and if they felt any improvement of their respiratory symptoms after respiratory physiotherapy.
Respiratory symptoms
The questionnaire asked about several upper and lower respiratory symptoms and their frequency during the past three months. We defined symptoms as frequent if they were reported daily or often. Reported frequency of all symptoms ranged from daily, often, sometimes, and rarely to never [23].
Possible factors associated with regular physical activity
We categorised physical activity into regular (once a week or more) and irregular (less than once a week). We considered the following factors as possibly associated with regular physical activity: experiencing respiratory symptoms, such as chronic nasal symptoms, cough, shortness of breath, and sputum production, that might influence physical activity performance; performing any physiotherapy; and seeing professional physiotherapists.
Statistical analysis
We described characteristics of the population, physical activity, respiratory physiotherapy practices, and nutritional status in the total population and separately among children (<18 years) and adults with PCD. For continuous variables, we used median and interquartile range (IQR); for categorical variables, we used numbers and proportions. We used Wilcoxon rank-sum and Pearson’s Chi square to study differences between children and adults and factors possibly associated with regular physical activity. We calculated Wilson 95% confidence intervals (CI) for proportions. We performed all analyses with Stata version 16 (StataCorp LLC, Texas, USA).
Results
We invited 86 people; 74 (86%) participants returned the questionnaire (figure 1). The median age at survey completion was 23 years (IQR 15–51) and 38 (51%) were female. Among participants, 24 were children or adolescents (referred as children from now onwards) of whom 17 attended school. Of the 50 adults, 42% were employed full-time (80–100%), while 18% were retired or on disability pension (table 1). In the past 12 months, most children and adults (64%) missed fewer than one week of school or work due to PCD-related symptoms; few adults (10%) missed more than 2 weeks. About half of participants (46%) lived in areas with little or no traffic. Age and sex did not differ between questionnaire respondents and non-respondents (data upon request). Missing responses to individual survey questions were less than 5%.
Characteristics of people with PCD in Switzerland participating in the survey, overall and by age group (N=74)
Physical activity
Among all 74 participants, 48 (65%) performed sports regularly (table 2). All 17 schoolchildren attended school sports; 14 of them (82%) participated always. The seven children not yet in school, were all physically active. Categories of sports did not differ by age. The most common type of physical activity were aerobic activities, e.g. children played soccer or hockey (25%), whereas adults preferred jogging or walking (56%). We found children were vigorously active (median MET 9.1; IQR 7.9–9.6) and adults were moderately active (median MET 5.5; IQR 4.3–6.9). Adults spent more time (median 7 hours/week; IQR 3.5–12) performing light sports when compared with children who spent most of their time (median 4 hours/week; IQR 3–7) performing vigorous sports. We present the most reported physical activities in supplemental table S1.
Physical activity of people with PCD in Switzerland, overall and by age group (N=74)
Respiratory physiotherapy
Overall, most participants (59; 80%) reported they performed some type of respiratory physiotherapy; of them, 18 children (75%) and 28 adults (56%) daily. Only 15 adults (30%) saw a professional physiotherapist in comparison to 18 children (75%) (p=0.008). Regarding upper airway physiotherapy, 69% of the participants blew their noses; most daily (table 3). Over half of participants (61%) performed nasal rinsing; eight children (33%) and 13 adults (26%) daily. Only 21 participants (28%) performed inhalations for the upper airways; eight children (33%) and five adults (10%) daily. Among all participants, 11 (17%) used saline for upper airway inhalation, nine of them hypertonic (>0.9%) saline. We found no differences in upper airway physiotherapy practices between children and adults apart from nose blowing and nasal rinsing, which were more common in children.
Upper airway physiotherapy practices of people with PCD in Switzerland, overall and by age group (N=74)
Regarding lower airway physiotherapy, 49 participants (67%) applied some airway clearance technique, such as autogenic drainage; 21 participants (28%) daily (table 4). The most common aid used for airway clearance was a flutter (19%) or positive expiratory pressure combined with flutter (7%). Overall, 65% performed inhalations for lower airways; 63% of children and 42% of adults daily, mainly with hypertonic saline. 19 participants (26%) reported difficulty clearing their lower airways; 13 children (54%) and 18 adults (36%) reported their lower respiratory symptoms improved after physiotherapy. Lower airway physiotherapy practices did not differ between children and adults.
Lower airway physiotherapy practices of people with PCD in Switzerland, overall and by age group (N=74)
Nutrition
Weight and height information from clinical visits near survey completion (within 12 months, usually a few months apart) was available for 53 (72%) participants: 16 children and 37 adults. Median BMI was 22.3 kg/m2 (IQR 20.4–25.0) for adults and median BMI z-score was 1.0 (IQR 1.0– 1.0) for children (table 5). Half of participants had normal BMI; only one child (4%) and two adults (4%) were underweight/thin. There was no difference between children and adults in BMI categories. Overall, seven people reported decreased appetite (9%). Physicians recommended increased caloric intake to three children (13%) and three adults (6%); three people (4%) ate larger meal portions, two increased their meal frequency, and one child received energy-dense food. Five adult participants reported ingesting hypercaloric drinks; four only during periods of increased physical activity or colds. Increased caloric intake and hypercaloric drinks helped four patients stabilise or gain weight. One child and two adults reported these measures increased their energy.
Nutritional information of people with PCD in Switzerland, overall and by age group (N=74)
Factors associated with regular physical activity
We found no difference in frequency of reported nasal symptoms, cough, shortness of breath, and sputum production between participants who were regularly or less physically active (figure 2). Respiratory physiotherapy was not associated with regular physical activity. However, regularly physically active people were less likely to see professional physiotherapists (p=0.008).
Frequency of reported respiratory symptoms and use of respiratory physiotherapy in the past three months in people with PCD in Switzerland who perform regular (at least once a week) physical activity (PA) compared to people who are less physically active.
Discussion
Our study is the first to provide patient-reported data on physical activity, respiratory physiotherapy, and nutrition for people with PCD. Our results suggest people with PCD in Switzerland are health-oriented, physically active, and normal weight; they also perform respiratory physiotherapy.
A strength of our study includes our questionnaire. We based our survey on the PCD-specific standardised FOLLOW-PCD questionnaire [24], allowing for future comparisons with larger multicentre studies. We also developed additional questions based on input from experts, such as physiotherapists. Further, we nested our study in the national PCD registry, which provided objectively measured BMI data. Other strengths include a remarkable response rate of 86% and a low proportion of missing survey data.
Our study has several limitations. Although we invited all people enrolled in CH-PCD, selection bias is possible because PCD in Switzerland is underdiagnosed [19]. The COVID-19 pandemic could have affected physical activity. However, since more than 75% of the questionnaires were returned by March 2020 before lockdown in Switzerland started, we expect any effect to be small. Furthermore, most participants reported outdoor activities, which were not affected by COVID-19 restrictions. As many questions referred to the last 12 months, there is a risk of recall bias. We expect answers reflected mostly health-related behaviours closer to date of survey completion. Since FOLLOW-PCD does not include validated physical activity questions, we calculated MET for reported activities to describe exercise intensity. So far, MET is standardised for adults only; however, to describe and compare the intensity of physical activity for the whole study population, we calculated it for all participants.
Previous studies among people with PCD showed reduced physical fitness in hospital settings. For example, a recent single-centre study of 27 Turkish children with PCD reported reduced muscle strength and endurance [15]. Another single-centre study with 22 Danish children with PCD found reduced cardiopulmonary fitness [14]. Children in our study reported a median moderate to vigorous activity of 6.5 hours/week, which is lower than the average 7.5 hours/week among 10–14 year-old children and 6.5 hours/week among 15–19 year-old adolescents who perform additional sports besides attending school sports in Switzerland [30]. However, it is comparable to the level of recreational sports (median 3.0 hours/week, IQR 1–5) of children who survived cancer in Switzerland [31]. In a multicentre service evaluation of over 300 children with PCD in England, all children were trained and advised to perform regular airway clearance physiotherapy [32]. In our population, most people reported doing respiratory physiotherapy but only 18 children (75%) and 28 adults (56%) on a daily basis. Despite having chronic respiratory symptoms, most people with PCD in Switzerland have normal BMI, which is lower than the national average of three people with overweight, and one person with obesity of every ten adults in Switzerland [33]. Our study included very few children younger than age 9 so it was not possible to see whether this group had a lower BMI z-score as in the large iPCD cohort study [18].
Most participants were physically active, despite reporting frequent respiratory symptoms. This might indicate that people with PCD are accustomed to their chronic symptoms and exercise despite them. Or they use physical activity as a method for airway clearance to relieve symptoms, explaining why fewer people who exercised regularly saw a professional physiotherapist. People might replace respiratory physiotherapy with physical activity. Exercise is a recommended method of airway clearance for patients with CF. However, it remains unclear whether it can replace physiotherapy or to what extent for patients with CF or PCD [8,34]. Although physical activity aids in airway clearance of larger airways, peripheral airway dysfunction persists with mucus obstruction [35].
Our study is the first to provide patient-reported data on health-related behaviours of people diagnosed with PCD. Our results highlight the importance of implementing exercise recommendations, professional respiratory physiotherapy, and nutritional advice that are currently missing in the routine care of people with PCD in Switzerland. Multidisciplinary care in specialised centres by teams including physiotherapists and nutrition consultants could improve the daily lives of people with PCD in Switzerland.
Data Availability
Data may be shared upon reasonable request.
Author contribution
M Goutaki and CE Kuehni developed the concept and designed the survey. YT Lam, M Goutaki, and L Hüsler organised the survey, then cleaned and standardised the data. YT Lam performed the statistical analyses supervised by M Goutaki and E Pedersen. YT Lam, M Goutaki, and E Pedersen drafted the manuscript. All authors commented and revised the manuscript. YT Lam and M Goutaki take final responsibility for the content.
Statement on funding sources and conflicts of interest
This study is funded by a Swiss National Science Foundation Ambizione fellowship (PZ00P3_185923) and by a Swiss National Science Foundation project grant (320030B_192804). PCD research at the Institute of Social and Preventive Medicine (ISPM) at the University of Bern also receives funding by the Lung League Bern. The authors participate in the BEAT-PCD (Better experimental approaches to treat PCD) clinical research collaboration, supported by the European Respiratory Society, and they are supporting members of the PCD core of ERN-LUNG (European Reference Network on rare respiratory diseases). FN Belle is supported by Swiss Cancer Research (KFS-4722-02-2019). C Clarenbach received advisory fees from Roche, Novartis, Boehringer, GSK, Astra Zeneca, Sanofi, Vifor, OM Pharma, CSL Behring, Grifols, Daiichi Sankyo and Mundipharma within the last 36 months. P Latzin received grants, honorary, for participation in data safety monitoring board or advisory board from Vertex, Vifor, OM Pharma, Polyphor, Santhera, Sanofi Aventis within the last 36 months.
Acknowledgments
We thank all people with PCD and their families in Switzerland for participating in the survey and the CH-PCD. We are also grateful to the Swiss PCD support group that closely collaborates with us. We thank Eugenie Collaud (ISPM, University of Bern) for her contributions to the French translation of the questionnaire and Kristin Marie Bivens (ISPM, University of Bern) for her editorial assistance.
The current Swiss PCD research group includes (in alphabetical order): Juerg Barben (Kantonsspital St. Gallen), Sylvain Blanchon (University Hospital of Lausanne), Jean-Louis Blouin (University Hospitals of Geneva), Marina Bullo (Inselspital Bern), Carmen Casaulta (Inselspital Bern), Cristian Clarenbach (University Hospital of Zurich), Myrofora Goutaki (ISPM, University of Bern), Nicolas Gürtler (University Hospital of Basel, Switzerland), Beat Haenni (Institute of Anatomy Bern), Andreas Hector (University Children’s Hospital Zurich), Michael Hitzler (Children’s Hospital Lucerne), Andreas Jung (University Children’s Hospital Zurich), Lilian Junker (Hospital Thun), Elisabeth Kieninger (Inselspital Bern), Claudia E. Kuehni (ISPM, University of Bern), Yin Ting Lam (ISPM, University of Bern), Philipp Latzin (Inselspital Bern), Romain Lazor (University Hospital of Lausanne), Dagmar Lin (Bern University Hospital), Marco Lurà (Children’s Hospital Lucerne), Loretta Müller (Inselspital Bern), Eva Pedersen (ISPM, University of Bern), Nicolas Regamey (Children’s Hospital Lucerne), Isabelle Rochat (University Hospital of Lausanne), Daniel Schilter (Quartier Bleu Bern), Iris Schmid (Quartier Bleu Bern), Bernhard Schwizer (Quartier Bleu Bern), Andrea Stokes (Inselspital Bern), Daniel Trachsel (University Children’s Hospital Basel), Stefan A. Tschanz (Institute of Anatomy, University of Bern), Johannes Wildhaber (University of Fribourg), and Maura Zanolari (Hospital of Bellinzona).
Footnotes
↵* group members listed in acknowledgments
References
