ABSTRACT
Background Elderly persons have been more prone to depression, anxiety and stress during COVID-19 pandemic. They need more care and support towards mental health during these difficult times.
Methodology This was a cross-sectional and quantitative study conducted in the state of Madhya Pradesh, during the month of March 2021 to August 2021. Participants were recruited from a population aged more than 60 years, those who were able to read and write Hindi/English or having at least one family member; reporting to a tertiary care teaching hospital during the second wave of COVID-19 in India. Those who were confirmed COVID-19 cases & undergoing treatment, with diagnosed mental health disorders and who didn’t give consent were excluded. A semi-structured questionnaire along with DASS-21 scale was completed by participants online.
Results Out of 690 subjects, 7.25% had mild and moderate depression, 0.58% had severe and extremely severe depression. Mild and moderate anxiety symptoms were reported by 9.56%, 2.46% reported severe and extremely severe anxiety. Mild and moderate stress was reported by 4.78%, while 0.42% were severely and extremely stressed. A positive statistical association was found between alcohol addiction and depression (p=0.028). The elderly subjects had a nap the day time were significantly less depressed during COVID-19 pandemic (p=0.033). It was found that older the subjects, more were they anxious during the pandemic (p=0.042). An association was found between alcohol addiction and stress (p=0.043).
Conclusions Depressive symptoms in participants were positively correlated with alcohol addiction. Females reported higher level of stress. There is a felt need to formulate psychological interventions for elderly to improve their mental health and psychological resilience. We need to tackle and fight the stigma, fear and anxiety related to the COVID-19, which is greater than disease itself.
What is already known Psychological problems like anxiety, depressive symptoms, fearfulness, a state of uncertainty and stress are common in all age groups; furthermore older adults are more prone to develop mental health issues in wake of stressful situations.
What this study adds to About one fourth of elderly developed anxiety, depression and stress during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Effect on practice and policy There is a need for proactive identification through screening of elderly for mental health issues following unprecedented stress like COVID-19 pandemic.
INTRODUCTION
On 31st December 2019, a novel viral pneumonia originating from Wuhan, China was reported to the World Health Organization.[1] Changes to daily life have been swift and unprecedented, as cases of the virus surged, the death toll escalated, and draconian measures to contain the spread of the disease increased across regions of the globe. Although there has been substantial attention towards measures to identify people with the corona virus infection, identifying the mental health care needs of people impacted by this pandemic had been relatively neglected.[2] For instance, in a recent, large survey of people highly susceptible to the corona virus infection, the prevalence rate of traumatic stress was at an alarming rate (73.4%), depression (50.7%), generalized anxiety (44.7%), and insomnia (36.1%).[3] Although these findings are disturbing, but they are not isolated, as research on the psychological impact of previous global disease outbreaks has demonstrated clear links between pandemic-related anxiety and elevated symptoms of stress, anxiety, contamination concerns, health anxiety, post-traumatic stress, and suicidality.[4,5]
In fact, the finding that those with a positive COVID-19 status reported significantly elevated levels of corona virus anxiety score as compare to non-infected and the importance of assessing and treating the psychological needs of those infected with the virus.[6] If some expert opinions are considered, then that would mean that up to 70% of the world’s population could potentially need both medical and psychological care following COVID-19 infections.[7]
During the initial phase of COVID-19 outbreak in China, more than half of the respondents rated their psychological impact as moderate-to-severe, and about one-third reported moderate-to-severe anxiety. Specific, updated and accurate health related information and certain precautionary measures such as covering mouth when coughing and sneezing, washing hands with soap immediately after coughing, sneezing, rubbing the nose, or after touching contaminated objects, and wearing a mask and social distancing were associated with a lower psychological impact of the outbreak and lower levels of stress, anxiety, and depression.[8]
The governments also provided mental health services through different channels including hotline, online consultation, online courses and outpatient consultation, but more attention should be paid to depression and anxiety.[9] There have been increased worries and apprehensions among the elderly regarding acquiring the COVID-19 infection. Elderly persons have higher perceived needs to deal with their mental health difficulties. The older adults were confronted with challenges like non-availability of attendants to help them with tasks of daily living, difficulty in accessing medical help, and perceived apprehension of existing morbidities. The older adults do not have an easy access to the mental health professionals. They are vulnerable to feelings of loneliness and helplessness. They fear that even if they survive the pandemic, social order would change. Some fear worsening of morbidity and deterioration in quality of life. In the general community, overall wellbeing, activity levels, and sleep were reported to be affected along with associated changes in cognitive functioning.[10]
Stress during an infectious disease outbreak can include fear and worry about, health of loved ones that manifests as changes in sleep or eating patterns, difficulty in sleeping or concentrating worsening of chronic health problems, worsening of mental health conditions, and increased use of alcohol, tobacco, or other drugs. Elderly are more prone to depression, anxiety and stress.
This study was planned to find out the prevalence of depression, anxiety and stress during COVID-19 times and their association with demographic and clinical factors and is aimed to fill these very lacunae in the available research especially in elderly population. It is important to study the mental health impacts in elderly for planning effective intervention strategies for this population.[11]
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Study Design
A quantitative cross sectional study was conducted with duration of 06 months from March 2021 to August 2021 in a tertiary care teaching hospital in the state of Madhya Pradesh, in central India. The study population consisted of elderly persons (≥60 years of age) who were free of any COVID-19 related symptoms at the time of data collection. The subjects reported their mental health experiences of first as well as second wave of COVID-19 in India.
Sample selection
A sample size of 690 subjects was recruited through online survey after the approval of Institutional Human Ethics Committee of All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India (Letter No. IHEC-LOP/2020/EF0221, dated: 24/12/2020). A written consent was taken from the participants after explaining the detail about research work. The sample size for this study was calculated as per a previous study by Gorrochategi et al. using DASS-21 scale, [12] taking prevalence of depression and anxiety in the age group ≥ 60 years as 18.6% and 13.5% respectively and applying the formula for cross-sectional study as 4pq/d2, taking 80% power, relative precision to be 20%, and non-response to be 10%, it was found that minimum sample size required was 482 and 690 respectively. The data collection was done through a semi-structured questionnaire used along with DASS-21 scale through a google form to recruit the participants.
Inclusion criteria
Subjects of age ≥ 60 years of age and residing in the state of Madhya Pradesh; those who were able to read and write Hindi/English or having at least one family member who could read and write Hindi/English so that they could answer the questions of DASS-21 and semi structured questionnaire and they were be free from any COVID-19 related symptoms at the time of data collection were recruited for this study.
Exclusion criteria
Those who were confirmed COVID-19 positive cases, with ongoing treatment at the time of study, people with diagnosed mental health disorders and those who did not give consent were excluded.
RESULTS
Out of 690 subjects on applying DASS-21, 28(4.06%) suffered from mild depression, 22 (3.19%) moderate depression, 2(0.29%) severe depression and 2(0.29%) from extremely severe depression. 21(3.04%) were mildly anxious, 45(6.52%) had moderate anxiety, 6(0.87%) severe anxiety and 11(1.59%) extremely severe anxiety. 19(2.75%) elderly subjects were stressed mildly, 14(2.03%) were moderately stressed, 1(0.14%) severely stressed and 2(0.28%) extremely stressed. (Table-1)
Among the participants, COVID-19 information level was very high (91%). Around 19% participants reported that their work was adversely affected during to COVID-19 pandemic. Fear of infection was testified either ‘occasionally’ or ‘many times’ by 39% participants. However, their self-assessment for physical health and mental health was reported as ‘good’ and ‘very good’ in 86% and 87% respectively. Around 70% elderly conveyed that they were spending more than one hour of time in watching television or social media. (Table-2)
On linear and multiple regression, a positive significant statistical association was found between alcohol addiction and depression (p=0.028). (Table -3)
The elderly subjects who had more day time sleeping hours were significantly less depressed in these times of COVID-19 (p=0.033). (Table -3)
A positive significant association was found for age of participants and levels of anxiety. The older the subjects and more were they anxious during the pandemic (p=0.042). (Table-4)
On multiple regression analysis, a positive statistical association was found between alcohol addiction and stress (p=0.043); females were more stressed as compared to males (p=0.045) and people who were more educated were more stressed during the pandemic (p=0.036). (Table-5)
DISCUSSION
This study involved quantitative cross sectional assessment of elderly on online platform utilizing DASS-21 local language (Hindi) alongside English. The sampling method included a convenience sample of 690 respondents.
We found a point prevalence of 7.25% for mild and moderate depression and 0.58% for severe and extremely severe depression; 9.56% for mild and moderate anxiety and 2.46% for severe and extremely severe anxiety; 4.78% for mild and moderate stress and 0.42% for severe and extremely stress.
The older adults have a higher risk for severe respiratory problems due to COVID-19 including the risk for hospitalization, the requirement of ventilatory support and a high mortality rate contributing to significant stress, anxiety, and other related mental health problems. They are likely to experience more stress and difficulty in accessing essential services due to the restrictions enforced to maintain the social distancing to prevent the spread of COVID-19. Additionally, they are less likely to have social contact using technology and social media which are useful for maintaining social contact despite the need for physical distancing. The resulting isolation is one of the important risk factors for mental health problems like depression and anxiety in older adults.[13] All these factors may explain the higher prevalence of depression, anxiety and stress in around 25% of sample in our study.
It was found that 4.49% elderly were already having some pre-existing mental health issues (Table-2). According to the Centre for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), older adults with COVID-19 are more likely to be hospitalized (31-59%) and die of it (4-11%). They also have higher chances of worsening of pre-existing medical and psychiatric illnesses because of difficulty in ensuring regular medication and routine health care due to COVID-19 related restrictions.[14]
Mental health issues
Alcohol addiction, time spent on internet and television, higher COVID-19 information level, more fear of COVID-19 infection, higher stress due to inadequate supply, financial crisis during lockdown, absurd change in food and bowel pattern during pandemic, sleep disturbance in form of long time taken for deep sleep, difficulty to get back to sleep, early morning sleep awakening, non-refreshing sleep and daytime sleepiness were the factors found to be related with the mental health of elderly population (Table-2).
Literature suggests that, sleeplessness, feeling anxious, boredom, panic attacks, nightmares, feeling of emptiness, fear of contracting COVID-19, fear of spreading the infection to others, health anxiety, feeling of imprisonment, anxiety related to uncertainty about future, anxiety about death and dying in unnatural circumstances without access to other relatives are some of the psychological issues that can occur in older adults. Some of them may develop depression, anxiety, hypochondriasis, post-traumatic stress disorder, substance abuse/withdrawal in these stressful situations. Those living in old age homes/residential set-ups or living alone are the most vulnerable during this pandemic in terms of mental health.[15]
Findings of our study showed that the COVID-19 pandemic had worsened depressive mood and apathy among the community-dwelling older adults. The results were remarkable especially in elderly aged less than 75 years. Higher physical activity is important in maintaining mental health.[16] Individuals aged more than 75 years might be less affected by COVID-19 because their baseline physical activity was lesser than that of individuals aged less than 75 years. Additionally, this study suggests that elderly aged less than 75 years, who are usually considered to be relatively robust, however they are at high risk for worsened depressive mood and apathy. It was noted that mental abnormalities in this situation may have long lasting effects like post-traumatic stress disorder and has brought forth the risk of the current lack of mental health screening systems.
Additionally, apart from the physical effects of COVID-19, significant psychological effects such as anxiety, depression, and loneliness are shown to affect individuals of all ages including the older adult population; individuals aged 65 years and older.[17] Social isolation and lack of social contacts related to the COVID-19 pandemic potentially worsens anxious and depressive feelings, increasing the risk for adverse health outcomes in the high-risk older adult population.[18] One systematic review focusing on data of last 15 years of prevalence of depression in older adults reported rates of major depression ranging broadly from 0.9% to 9.4%.[19] Specific factors in older adults, including somatic illness, poor health, cognitive or functional impairment, history of depression, lack of close social contacts are identified as main predictors of depressive disorders.[20] In a systematic review of 11 cross-sectional and longitudinal studies conducted during this pandemic, a strong association was identified between psychological effects such as worry, anxiety, and mental anguish with pandemic behaviors such as social distancing and enhanced hygiene measures such as frequent hand washing.[21] The literature identifies feelings of isolation, loneliness, anxiety, and depression are prevalent in the older adult population, which were potentially worsened during a pandemic.[22]
Associated Factors
In our study, it was found that older people who slept during the day were substantially less depressed. (p=0.033) (Table 3). As per literature, napping was found to improve cognitive and emotional health in older persons.[23] A mid-day nap is shown to be advantageous in healthy, young people. A nap in the middle of the day reduces drowsiness while improving executive function, memory consolidation and subsequent learning.[24-26]
Recommendations for intervention
The first step is increasing the awareness about mental health issues among the older adults and their family members via social media (Online programs, website, online forum, group email or messages). Utilizing the services of community health workers or trained social workers for the screening of older adults at old age homes/assisted living facilities for mental health issues. Telemedicine can be used for consultations requiring more detailed psychiatric evaluation and prescription of medication. Provision of mental health services to older adults in China during the COVID-19 pandemic was found to be challenging, with the “digital divide,” quarantines, and “restrictions on movement” having significant impact.[27] Responses to COVID-19 for older adults can borrow general mental health recommendations from historic pandemic influenza preparedness initiatives including a focus on strengthening social networks and community support, communication networks, directive leadership and stress management. One of the few positives in the pandemic literature in older adults is the possibility that older adults may experience more adaptive coping in a crisis than younger adults, as suggested by a study in Hong Kong during the SARS epidemic.[28] This form of resilience may relate to their lived experience of coping with adversity and could potentially be harnessed now.
Lessons learnt from earlier pandemics like SARS have proved that regular telephonic contact, monitoring and contact with family, relevant and updated information, caring for the general medical and psychological needs, and respecting their personal space and dignity are important components of mental health care in the elderly.[29]
Similar to other situations leading to any disaster, most of the older adults are likely to have sub-syndromal mental health issues like anxiety and depressive symptoms related to the threat of COVID-19. This will require brief psychological and psychosocial intervention that can be delivered by any health care personnel, volunteers, with some guidance and training from mental health professionals. Older adults need reassurance that most of the mental health issues experienced in these situations are normal reactions to abnormal stress. Yoga, meditation, healthy diet, mental stimulation through home-based activities with appropriate safety precautions is essential. Brief relaxation exercises and supportive therapy can be done for those having severe psychological distress. It is warranted to establish a system that could promptly screen and support the mental health of older adults and other mentally vulnerable populations.
CONCLUSION
Based on a cross-sectional quantitative study, it was found that a significant proportion of elderly had depression (7-8%) anxiety (9-10%) and stress (5%) making it around 1/4th of the sample of 690 respondents. Alcohol related problems were associated with stress & depression and age of subjects was associated with level of anxiety in linear fashion. Day time nap was found to have a positive effect on the mental health of participants. Based on the findings of this study it may be considered necessary to screen elderly population for mental health issues and provide timely interventions for the same.
Data Availability
All data produced in the present study are available upon reasonable request to the authors
REFERENCES
