Abstract
Vaccines against SARS-CoV-2 were authorized at the end of 2020 and are effective in preventing deaths; however, many persons remain unvaccinated. Using weekly publicly available CDC data of COVID-19-associated death rates by age and vaccination status from 26 US jurisdictions, we estimated the number of excess deaths that might have been averted by vaccination among unvaccinated persons ≥ 18 years old from May 30 to December 4, 2021. We subtracted the death rate in the vaccinated from rates in the unvaccinated to estimate the death rate each week that could be attributable to non-vaccination and multiplied this rate difference by the number of people in the unvaccinated group for each age group and each week, to estimate the excess mortality among the unvaccinated. Then, we extrapolated the number of deaths due to non-vaccination in the 26 jurisdictions to the whole US population using 2020 census estimates. In the 26 participating jurisdictions there were an estimated 83,400 excess deaths among the unvaccinated from May 30 to December 4, 2021. The largest number of excess deaths occurred in those 65–79 years old (n=28,900; 34.7% of total), followed by those 50-64 years old (n=25,900; 31.1%). Extrapolated to the US population we estimated approximately 135,000 excess deaths during the study period in persons ≥18 years old. Our estimates are an underestimate of all excess deaths that have occurred since vaccine became available because our analysis period was limited to May 30 to December 4, 2021, and many excess deaths occurred before and after this period. In summary, we used retrospective data to estimate the substantial number of COVID-19-associated deaths among the unvaccinated illustrating the importance of vaccination to prevent further unnecessary mortality during this pandemic.
TEXT
Vaccines against SARS-CoV-2 were authorized at the end of 2020 and are effective in preventing deaths; however, many persons remain unvaccinated. Using weekly publicly available US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) data of COVID-19-associated death rates by age and vaccination status from 26 US jurisdictions (Appendix I), we estimated the number of excess deaths that might have been averted by vaccination among unvaccinated persons ≥ 18 years old from May 30 to December 4, 2021. May 30 was chosen because vaccine was readily available to the public by then. We subtracted the death rate in the vaccinated from rates in the unvaccinated to estimate the death rate each week that could be attributable to non-vaccination, obtained from [1] (Appendix II). We multiplied this rate difference by the number of people in the unvaccinated group for each age group and each week, to estimate the excess mortality among the unvaccinated. This accounted for the changing attack rate, and changing proportion vaccinated, during this time period. Then, we extrapolated the number of deaths due to non-vaccination in the 26 jurisdictions to the whole US population using 2020 census estimates, after excluding those partially vaccinated [2] (Appendix III).
The 26 US jurisdictions had similar age structure to the overall US population and a similar cumulative incidence of COVID-19 per 100 persons. However, the 26 jurisdictions had a higher proportion unvaccinated compared to that in the US overall, when considering only the fully vaccinated and unvaccinated (Table 1).
Comparing the 26 participating jurisdictions with the overall US population
In the 26 participating jurisdictions there were an estimated 83,400 excess deaths among the unvaccinated from May 30 to December 4, 2021. The largest number of excess deaths occurred in those 65–79 years old (n=28,900; 34.7% of total), followed by those 50-64 years old (n=25,900; 31.1%) (Appendix IV). We extrapolated the estimate to the US population after excluding those partially vaccinated based on national data on vaccination rates [3], and estimated approximately 135,000 excess deaths during the study period in persons ≥18 years old. In our sensitivity analyses, the excess deaths varied by the assumed size of the unvaccinated population in the non-26 jurisdictions, which dropped to 119,000 were the population that was unvaccinated 30% lower, and increased to 150,000 were it 30% higher, in the rest of the country (Appendix V), and also varied by proportion partially vaccinated (Appendix VI).
We used data that represented over half of the total US population and the 26 US jurisdictions have age structure and incidence similar to the nation overall. In addition, rates of underlying conditions and prevention behaviors may vary between vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals and confer differing risks for acquisition of SARS-CoV-2 infection and mortality. Although we cannot be certain that all the excess deaths in unvaccinated could have been prevented with vaccination, subtracting rates of death among vaccinated from deaths in unvaccinated should partially account for deaths that would have occurred even if persons were vaccinated. Handling of partial vaccination is a challenge because the proportion partially vaccinated is not reported for the 26 jurisdictions and because of possible reporting lags and misclassification [3]. This was further evaluated by conducting a sensitivity analysis in Appendix VI. Our estimates are an underestimate of all excess deaths that have occurred since vaccine became available because our analysis period was limited to May 30 – December 4, 2021 and many excess deaths occurred before and after this period. In addition, we only estimated direct effects of vaccination, however the number of excess deaths could have been higher if indirect effects were included since vaccines likely reduce transmission to others. In summary, we used retrospective data to provide an estimate of the substantial number of COVID-19-associated deaths among the unvaccinated illustrating the importance of vaccination to prevent further unnecessary mortality during this pandemic.
Data Availability
All data used in this publication is publicly available from the US CDC. https://covid.cdc.gov/covid-data-tracker/#rates-by-vaccine-status
Supplementary Materials
Acknowledgement
We acknowledge the CDC for curating and sharing the data for this analysis, with special thanks to Akilah Ali, Avnika Amin, Amelia Johnson, and Heather Scobie, for coordinating with individual states, establishing standardized methods, and collating the data.
Appendix I
Appendix II
The bar plot shows the total number of individuals 18 and older in the 26 jurisdictions by vaccination status (partially vaccinated individuals were excluded) (A). The line graph shows the mortality rate (per 100,000) for COVID-19-associated deaths in the two groups. The number of excess deaths was estimated by multiplying the red bars in (A) by the difference between the red and the blue lines in (B) (i.e., excess mortality rate among the unvaccinated population), by age and week.
Appendix III Data sources and analysis
Data on COVID-19-associated deaths by vaccination status
Data on vaccination status and COVID-19-associated deaths were from the US CDC, aggregated across participating US jurisdictions (CDC, 2022a). Included jurisdictions had to regularly link their case surveillance and immunization data with CDC. Twenty-six of the jurisdictions reported deaths among vaccinated and unvaccinated persons and were included in the analysis.
Vaccination status
Individuals were considered as fully vaccinated if they completed a primary series of a COVID-19 vaccine authorized by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) at least 14 days before the date of record (Scobie et al 2021). The number of unvaccinated was estimated by subtracting the numbers of fully and partially vaccinated (which were determined by vaccine administration data) from the US 2019 population estimate (Johnson et al 2021). However, the partially vaccinated individuals, who had at least one dose of the approved vaccine but did not complete the series at least 14 days before the time of record, were excluded from the data set (CDC, 2022a). Correspondingly, we excluded the partially vaccinated when extrapolating the number of excess deaths from the 26 jurisdictions to the US total.
Ascertainment of COVID-19-associated deaths
A COVID-19-associated death was defined as a person who had a positive documented SARS-CoV-2 diagnosis and died. The data set recorded deaths among vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals based on the week of a positive specimen collection, which was usually up to 30 days ahead of the date of death (CDC, 2022a). Methods of outcome ascertainment varied across jurisdictions: it was common to use vital records, while some jurisdictions used a combination of vital records and provider reporting and/or case investigations (Scobie et al, 2021).
Mortality rate difference
For each week in the study period, we estimated the mortality rate difference, by subtracting the rate of deaths among unvaccinated individuals with that among vaccinated individuals, for each age group in the 26 jurisdictions. This measure will account for both the changing attack rate over the course and the proportion vaccinated that increased over time.
We then multiplied the mortality rate difference to the total number of unvaccinated individuals in the 26 jurisdictions by age group and week, to estimate the number of excess deaths.
Thirdly, we extrapolated the excess deaths to the whole US population, with the partially vaccinated excluded from the numerator (see formula below). The percentage partially vaccinated was obtained from another CDC data set on vaccination demographics in the US. We subtracted the percentage fully vaccinated from the percentage vaccinated with at least 1 dose(s) by week, for each age group: the 18-24, 25-39, 40-49, 50-64, 65-74, and the 75+ years old (CDC, 2022b), to obtain the percentage partially vaccinated.
We multiplied the total US resident population of each year-age with the factor (1 - %partially vaccinated), for each age group (US Census Bureau, 2022), and then extrapolated the excess mortality as follows:
Lastly, we summed the weekly number of excess deaths by age and by week to obtain the total number of excess deaths among the unvaccinated population from May 30 to December 4, 2021.
Appendix IV Estimated weekly excess COVID-19-associated deaths among unvaccinated populations 18 years old and above, May 30 – December 4, 2021
Estimated weekly excess COVID-19-associated deaths among unvaccinated populations 18 years and older in 26 US jurisdictions (A) and in the US (B), May 30 – December 4, 2021
Appendix V Estimated total number of excess deaths under varying assumptions about the proportion of the population unvaccinated in the non-26 US jurisdictions, May 30 – December 4, 2021
The excess mortality for the whole US population is given by
By allowing the number of unvaccinated in the non-26 jurisdictions to change by a percentage m%, we have
The resulting estimates are:
Estimated weekly number of excess deaths among the unvaccinated population in the US using different assumptions about the proportion unvaccinated in the non-26 US jurisdictions, May 30 – December 4, 2021. The numbers of fully vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals and their mortality rates were derived from the data set for 26 participating US jurisdictions, and therefore the total number of excess deaths in those 26 jurisdictions was unvaried in this sensitivity analysis.
Estimated total number of excess deaths among the population 18 and above in the US, May 30 – December 4, 2021, under different assumptions about the proportion unvaccinated in the non-26 US jurisdictions, after excluding those partially vaccinated.
Appendix VI Estimated total number of excess deaths under varying assumptions about the proportion partially vaccinated in the United States, May 30 – December 4, 2021
In this sensitivity analysis, we extrapolated the excess deaths among the unvaccinated by considering different percentage changes in the proportion partially vaccinated in the whole US population. We allow it to change by p% for each scenario, as in:
As seen from the plot below, the estimated excess deaths decreased if there were a higher percentage of partially vaccinated in the population, and vice versa.
Estimated excess deaths under varying assumptions about the proportion partially vaccinated among individuals 18 years and older in the US, May 30 – December 4, 2021
Estimated total number of excess deaths among those 18 years old and above in the US, May 30 - December 4, 2021, by varying the proportion partially vaccinated in the population
Footnotes
Updated formatting of text and figures
