Chronic fatigue associated with post-COVID syndrome versus transient fatigue caused by high intensity exercise: are they comparable in terms of vascular effects?

Introduction

Severe acute respiratory coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) is responsible for the COVID-19 pandemic, which has resulted in a global healthcare crisis. The health consequences of COVID-19 infection are broad, and not restricted to the respiratory tract. It is now generally accepted that COVID-19 infection causes serious injuries to blood vessels by damaging the vascular endothelium.^1-3 Numerous studies have reported that patients recovering from SARS-CoV-2 infection complain of persistent symptoms, including fatigue, brain fog, diffuse myalgia, and weakness, which may lead to chronic fatigue known as post-COVID or long-COVID.^4,5 Female sex is a risk factor associated with post-COVID syndrome, with sex hormones possibly playing an important role in that risk.^6,7

The list of post-COVID symptoms is long, but fatigue is the most common, occurring in more than 70% of post-COVID patients. There is limited mechanistic knowledge explaining the pathophysiology of chronic fatigue associated with post-COVID. It can be hypothesized that post-COVID syndrome is primarily connected with permanent vascular dysfunction caused by initial vascular injuries occurring during the acute phase of COVID-19 infection. Therefore, it seems rational to compare the vascular effects of chronic fatigue associated with post-COVID with the vascular effects of transient fatigue caused by high intensity exercise. High-intensity exercise is known to impose transient stress on the vascular endothelium, as measured by flow-mediated dilatation (FMD).^8,9 This effect is particularly pronounced in individuals who are not highly physically fit. It is assumed that high-intensity exercise is accompanied by a corresponding increase in reactive oxygen species (ROS), which has the potential to decrease nitric oxide (NO) bioavailability. This effect is often called the “exercise paradox”. In this sense, exercise can be considered as a stressor inducing anti-stress responses, which can be positive for physical fitness.

To test our hypothesis that the chronic fatigue associated with post-COVID is associated with permanent vascular dysfunction caused by initial vascular injuries, we decided to compare the vascular effects associated with post-COVID with those generated by high-intensity exercise. For this purpose, we applied the Flow Mediated Skin Fluorescence (FMSF) technique. The FMSF technique can be used for non-invasive assessment of vascular circulation and metabolic regulation.^10-16 A direct comparison of the vascular effects underlying post-COVID fatigue with exercise-induced fatigue using the FMSF technique could enable the identification of diagnostic parameters for clinical assessment of post-COVID syndrome and monitoring the rehabilitation process.

Materials and Methods

Brief Description of the FMSF Technique and the Measurement Protocol

Measurements were performed using AngioExpert, a device constructed by Angionica Ltd. The AngioExpert device uses the Flow Mediated Skin Fluorescence (FMSF) technique, which measures changes in the intensity of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) fluorescence from the skin on the forearm as a response to blocking and releasing blood flow. The skin is the largest organ of the human body, and is characterized by a specific metabolism. The epidermal layer of skin is not directly vascularized, and oxygen and nutrients are transported from the dermis by diffusion. Therefore, epidermal cell metabolism can be considered a unique and sensitive marker of early dysfunction in vascular circulation and metabolic regulation.

Details concerning the technical aspects and methodology of FMSF technique have been provided elsewhere.^10-12 The measurement protocol in the present study was the same as applied previously.¹⁵ For analysis of the results obtained in the present study, two new parameters were introduced: Reactive Hyperemia Response (RHR) and Normoxia Oscillatory Index (NOI). These parameters are defined in Fig. 1b.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1.

A – Exemplary FMSF trace recorded for a sportsman before high intensity exercise (male, age range 36-40 y.). B – Definition of the RHR and NOI parameters. C,D – Changes in the fluorescence signal relative to the normalized baseline before high-intensity exercise (left) and the corresponding Power Spectra Density (PSD) of the fluorescence signal in the intervals of endothelial (<0.021 Hz), neurogenic (0.021–0.052 Hz), and myogenic (0.052–0.15 Hz) activity (right); E,F – Changes in fluorescence relative to the normalized baseline after high-intensity exercise (left) and the corresponding Power Spectra Density (PSD) of the fluorescence signal in the frequency same activity intervals as for C,D (right).

The RHR parameter characterizes endothelial function related predominantly to the production of nitric oxide (NO) in the vasculature due to reactive hyperemia. RHR is a unique parameter, based on a combination of both the ischemic and hyperemic parts of the measured FMSF trace, as shown in Fig. 1a. The NOI parameter characterizes the microcirculatory oscillations detected at the baseline and represents the contribution of endothelial (<0.021 Hz) and neurogenic (0.021–0.052 Hz) oscillations relative to all oscillations detected at low frequency interval (<0.15 Hz). This parameter is particularly sensitive to high-intensity exercise. Figure 1c–d shows the changes of the fluorescence signal in the normalized baseline before high-intensity exercise, and the corresponding Power Spectra Density in the low frequency interval (<0.15 Hz). Figure 1e–f shows similar changes observed after exercise. The NOI parameter was normalized after 1–3 hours of rest and returns to the values observed before exercise. This observation is in accordance with other studies.^8,9

We observed that both the RHR and NOI parameters should be used jointly for effective diagnostics of post-COVID fatigue and exercise-related fatigue. Based on our experience of using the FMSF technique, the NOI parameter seems more universal as it is age-independent. It is sensitive not only to fatigue caused by intense physical activity, but also to fatigue caused by emotional stress.

Results and Discussion

Our study indicates that post-COVID syndrome is associated with a statistically significant increase in systolic blood pressure (Supplementary, Fig. 1). A rise in blood pressure associated with COVID-19 infection has been noticed previously.¹⁷ Figure 2 (segments A and B) presents a comparison of the NOI parameter in the post-COVID group and the control group. A similar comparison with regard to sex differences is shown in Supplementary (Fig. 2). It is clear that post-COVID syndrome reverses the distribution of the NOI parameter, indicating that this parameter is very sensitive to the vascular problem monitored.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 2.

A,B – Comparison and distribution of the NOI parameter in the control group (n = 32, 19 m, 13 f, mean age 37.8 (30–50 y.)) and post-COVID group (n = 45, 19 m, 26 f, mean age 41.5 (30–50 y.)). C,D – Comparison and distribution of the NOI parameter in the group of amateur runners (n = 26, 26 m, mean age 27.7, (21–40 y.)) before and after high-intensity exercise. Differences between the parameters of the compared groups were considered statistically significant when p < 0.05. The p-values were calculated from the results of the Mann-Whitney test for comparison A and the Wilcoxon signed ranks test for comparison C.

The effects of high-intensity exercise on the NOI parameter are very similar, as shown in Fig. 2 (segments C and D). It appears that the fatigue associated with post-COVID syndrome and exercise-related fatigue exert very similar vascular effects, which can be observed as lower intensities representing endothelial and neurogenic microcirculatory oscillations at the baseline. An obvious difference is that the exercise-related effect is fully reversible after 1–3 hours of rest.

The vascular effects of post-COVID- and exercise-related fatigue measured by the RHR parameter are also quite similar, as shown in Fig. 3 (segments A and B vs. C and D) and Supplementary (Fig. 3). It should be stressed that both the NOI parameter and the RHR parameter represent distinctive properties of the vascular system. The NOI parameter characterizes microcirculation based on the measurement of microcirculatory oscillations at the baseline. In contrast, the RHR parameter characterizes the vessels based on NO bioavailability, predominantly in large and medium size arteries, due to reactive hyperemia.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 3.

A,B – Comparison and distribution of the RHR parameter in the control group (n = 32, 19 m, 13 f, mean age 37.8 (30–50 y.)) and post-COVID group (n = 45, 19 m, 26 f, mean age 41.5 (30–50 y.)). C,D – Comparison and distribution of the RHR parameter in the group of amateur runners (n = 26, 26 m, mean age 27.7, (21–40 y.)) before and after high intensity exercise. Differences between the parameters of the compared groups were considered statistically significant when p < 0.05. The p-values were calculated from the results of a two-sample t-test for comparison A and the paired sample t-test for comparison C.

The vital conclusion is that both the macro- and microcirculation are affected by vascular stress related to both post-COVID syndrome and high-intensity exercise. Perhaps, the long list of symptoms associated post-COVID syndrome summarized in Table 1 and reported in many other studies can be linked to endothelial dysfunction present in the blood vessels of both the macro- and microcirculation.

The present study also recognizes female sex as a risk factor associated with post-COVID syndrome.^6,7 As shown in the Supplementary Materials (Table 1), careful comparison of the RHR and NOI parameters collected for females and males seems to corroborate a difference in risk based on sex. For example, the RHR parameter is higher for females than males in the control group, but there is no such difference in the post-COVID group. Additionally, the NOI parameter seems unrelated to sex in the control group, but in the post-COVID group this parameter is lower compared to males. The apparent higher risk of females to post-COVID syndrome may indicate viral-induced sex hormone dysfunction, which can result in early menopause, as observed for other viral diseases.⁶

In previous communications, we have suggested that the Hypoxia Sensitivity (HS) parameter can be used to predict severity of the acute phase of COVID-19 infection. However, the present study indicates that this parameter has only minor utility for the diagnostics of post-COVID syndrome, as shown in Table 2.^18,19 The explanation may be that hypoxemia plays an important role only in the acute phase of infection.

The results of this study show the utility of two key parameters (NOI and RHR) for clinical assessment and monitoring the rehabilitation process of post-COVID patients. They can also be used to identify potential treatments to improve exercise tolerance and fatigue in patients after COVID-19, as is being demonstrated by one of the co-authors.²⁰

Conclusion

The following conclusions can be drawn from this study:

• The FMSF technique appears to be uniquely suitable for the analysis of basal microcirculatory oscillations and reactive hyperemia induced by transient ischemia.

• Chronic fatigue associated with post-COVID syndrome is comparable with transient fatigue caused by high-intensity exercise, in terms of vascular effects.

• The NOI and RHR parameters measured by the FMSF technique can be used for non-invasive clinical assessment of post-COVID syndrome, as well as for monitoring the rehabilitation process.

Funding

This work was supported by the European Union from the resources of the European Regional Development Fund under the Smart Growth Operational Program, Grant No. POIR. 01.01.01-00-0540/15-00.