Virological characteristics of SARS-CoV-2 vaccine breakthrough infections in health care workers

Introduction

Once COVID-19 vaccines became available, health care workers (HCWs) were among the first groups to be vaccinated and reach high vaccine coverage. Registered vaccines have been highly effective in preventing clinically significant coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19), caused by severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2)¹, and have shown to reduce the incidence of infections^2,3. However, mild breakthrough infections in a small percentage of vaccine recipients have been described^4-9 which is not surprising as none of the registered vaccines will provide sterile immunity against infection^10-13. In a setting of mass vaccination, the BNT162b2 vaccine was highly effective (92%) at preventing infection from 7 days after the second dose¹⁴, but a recent study from Israel described vaccine breakthrough infections in 39 health care workers vaccinated with the BNT162b2 mRNA vaccine. The alpha variant was identified as the main causative strain and a majority of cases presented low Ct-values (<30), indicating probable infectivity⁴. For the single dose Ad26.COV2.S adenoviral vector vaccine, a phase IV study reported a 76.1% effectiveness to prevent infection from 14 days after vaccination¹⁵. The effectiveness against infection with the delta (B.1.617.2) variant was 88% for the BNT162B2 vaccine and 67% for the ChAdOx1 vaccine, moderately lower than against infection with the alpha (B.1.1.7) variant¹⁶.

Up to present, little is known about the virological kinetics of SARS-CoV-2 breakthrough infections, and the role of the vaccinated host in the transmission cycle. Better understanding of the dynamics of breakthrough infections is essential to define infection prevention and (public) health policies during the next phase of the pandemic. In this study, we report the virological findings of 161 vaccine breakthrough infections occurring from April to July 2021 in the Netherlands. The infections occurred in HCWs working in two tertiary care hospitals, who were immunized with various mRNA and viral vector vaccines. Infections were caused predominantly by the SARS-CoV-2 delta variant and virus culture was performed as a proxy for infectivity.

Results

A total of 161 fully vaccinated HCWs diagnosed with COVID-19 by PCR were included in this study. In accordance with case definitions defined by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, infections were classified as breakthrough infections if the date of the first positive SARS-CoV-2 RT-PCR was more than 14 days after completion of all recommended vaccine doses¹⁷. Cases with symptom onset <14 days after the last vaccine dose and cases with a previous positive test <45 days prior were not considered breakthrough infections. In parallel with a surge in cases in the general Dutch population¹⁸, an increased incidence of breakthrough infections in HCWs was observed in July 2021. In 126 samples a SARS-CoV-2 lineage could be identified, 90.5% of these showed presence of the delta variant. The mean age of the HCWs with a breakthrough infection was 25.5 years and 91% were less than 50 years old (Table 1). All infections were mild and did not require hospital admission. The individuals were vaccinated between January and May 2021 with either an mRNA vaccine or a viral vector vaccine. Table 1 shows the distribution of vaccines among all HCWs and among the HCWs with breakthrough infections. Although the data may imply an overrepresentation of Ad26.COV2.S and BNT162b2 vaccine recipients among the cases, this study was not designed to compare vaccine effectivity. The indication to receive a certain vaccine was not random and data on risk factors for exposure were not recorded, therefore potential confounders could not be adjusted for.

Table 1 shows the distribution of Ct-values of the breakthrough infections, as a proxy for the nasopharyngeal viral load. Ct-values were significantly lower in symptomatic breakthrough infections (μ = 23.2) than in asymptomatic breakthrough infections (μ = 26.7), corresponding to higher viral loads (p = 0.022, t-test). In symptomatic vaccinated HCWs, the Ct-values decreased significantly throughout the first days from symptom onset and were lowest on the third day of illness (Figure 1A). There were no statistically significant differences in Ct-values between HCWs immunized with the 4 different vaccines. Furthermore, the time since the administration of the last vaccine dose showed no clear relationship with Ct-values (R² = 0.02, p = 0.13, linear regression).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1. SARS-CoV-2 culture positivity and Ct-values in nasopharyngeal samples of health care workers with SARS-CoV-2 breakthrough infections.

(A) Ct-values by day from symptom onset (B) Ct-values of HCWs with vaccine breakthrough infections (primarily Delta) compared to Ct-values of HCWs with primary infections (primarily D614G) (C) Probability of culture positivity by nasopharyngeal viral load (Probit Analysis), comparing HCWs with vaccine breakthrough infections (primarily Delta) to HCWs with primary infections (primarily D614G)

Subsequently, RT-PCR positive swabs were tested for the presence of infectious virus using cell culture. As a reference, we used the (first positive) samples from mild primary infections that occurred in the same cohort of HCWs prior to the onset of vaccination, these infections were primarily caused by SARS-CoV-2 D614G. The mean Ct-value upon diagnosis was similar between these two groups: 24.6 (15.3 - 33.9) for vaccinated HCWs and 24.2 (14.53 - 33.8) for unvaccinated HCWs (p = 0.53, t-test) (Figure 1B). The SARS-CoV-2 culture of nasopharyngeal swabs was positive in 68.6% of vaccinated HCWs versus 84.9% of unvaccinated HCWs with primary infections (p = 0.005, t-test). As the probability of culture positivity depends on viral load¹⁹, this was corrected for using a probit regression model with both viral load and vaccination status as predictors. Figure 1C shows the probability of a positive culture for a given viral load in vaccinated and unvaccinated HCWs. A positive vaccination status significantly decreased the probability of culture positivity (p = 0.002, Wald test).

Discussion

In this study we assessed the virological kinetics of mild COVID-19 breakthrough infections upon immunization with several vaccines. Our data support that the SARS-CoV-2 infectious virus shedding is lower in vaccinated individuals with breakthrough infections (caused by primarily the delta variant) than in unvaccinated individuals with primary infections (caused by SARS-CoV-2 D614G). Nevertheless, virus culture was positive in 68.6% of breakthrough infections and Ct-values decreased throughout the first three days of illness. Despite the reduced viral viability, the infectivity of individuals with breakthrough infections should not be neglected.

It remains a challenge to assess infectivity of an individual based on clinical sampling. Although RT-PCR is a highly sensitive method to diagnose SARS-CoV-2 infection, it detects RNA produced in infected cells rather than whole (infectious) virions and is therefore not an optimal indicator of infectivity ¹⁹. Ct-values are sometimes used to differentiate between phases of infection, but the definition of a cut-off value is complicated, due to the large variety of assays and clinical samples. Considering these limitations of RT-PCR, demonstrating viral viability through replication in cell culture is currently considered the best proxy to demonstrate infectious virus in a clinical specimen^20,21. We and others previously showed that the viability of SARS-CoV-2 depends on several factors among which the severity of disease, timing of sampling, the type of specimen and presence of antibodies^19,22. To our knowledge this is the first study to report on virus cultures in COVID-19 vaccine breakthrough infections. Although reduced immune responses may likely account for breakthrough infections, further studies are needed to investigate whether these are still able to reduce infectious virus shedding.

Obviously, the use of virus culture has its limitations as well: it is a laborious method only performed in specialized BSL-3 laboratories and therefore not widely applicable. In addition, lack of standardization of methods (e.g. the cell line used) still hampers interchangeability of results between laboratories. Nevertheless, an experimental animal study on SARS-CoV-2 transmission recently confirmed a strong correlation between transmission and virus culture ²³.

To study the effect of vaccination on infectivity, it would be preferable to compare infections occurring in vaccinated and unvaccinated individuals during the same time period, to minimize the impact of different SARS-CoV-2 variants. Due to the high vaccine coverage in HCW, we diagnosed very few infections in unvaccinated HCWs. For this reason, we used infections prior to the onset of vaccination as a reference. Although the predominant SARS-CoV-2 variant differed between groups, the groups were similar with respect to demographic characteristics, severity of disease, testing algorithms and Ct-values upon diagnosis. The study participants comprise a population immunized with several vaccines, which reflects the current situation in many countries. This study was not designed to detect differences in vaccine effectiveness, as HCWs who received different vaccines also differed with respect to demographic characteristics. The frequency of breakthrough infections in the different groups was likely influenced by variables that were not controlled for.

Phase IV studies have confirmed that vaccination is highly effective at preventing COVID-19-related morbidity and mortality^2,14,15 although vaccine effectiveness will never reach 100%. Our study supports the excellent effectiveness of vaccination in preventing severe SARS CoV-2 related disease, but also demonstrates that vaccinated individuals can still acquire infection and carry infectious virus. Although symptomatic vaccinated individuals should be tested to further reduce the chance of virus transmission to individuals at risk for severe disease, further studies are needed to assess whether the decreased infectious virus shedding in breakthrough infections also lowers the chance of virus transmission.

Methods