1. Abstract
Background The novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) infection has affected the population with various medical issues including the underlying neurological comorbidities such as Parkinson disease. COVID – 19 is found to bind with the host angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 (ACE2) receptors for viral entry. ACE2 receptors are normally expressed in various body surfaces as well as in the neurons and glial cells where they act as an entry port to SARS-CoV-2 infection to invade the central nervous system (CNS). ACE2 are also highly expressed in dopamine neurons which might worsen the outcome in terms of motor symptoms in PD with the treatment course. It may lead to an indirect response via immune-mediated cytokine storms and propagate through CNS leading to damage. Parkinson’s disease has also been noticed due to certain post-viral infections apart from COVID-19 such as, HSV, Influenza virus A, Measles virus, Cytomegalovirus and Mumps (Olsen et al, 2018). We aim to provide a thorough review on neurological outcomes and impact of COVID-19 in Parkinson disease.
Methods A systematic review was conducted to analyze the impact of COVID-19 in patients with Parkinson disease (> 21 yo). Systematic literature search was done using PubMed, Science Direct, Google Scholar and Cochrane databases. PRISMA guidelines were followed summarized in Fig. 3 for study acquisition.
Results Of the Parkinson’s patients that were tested positive for SARS-CoV-2, worsening of motor symptoms were reported along with other COVID-19 symptoms (Fig. 4 and 5). These symptoms include bradykinesia, tremors, gait disturbances, delirium and dementia and severe spasms of arms and legs. Encephalopathy was also one of the main symptoms presented in two of the studies. Increased mortality rates were identified for those who were hospitalized due to COVID-19 and PD when compared to other patients.
Conclusion Parkinson’s disease may experience substantial worsening of motor and non -motor symptoms during COVID 19. Due to the novelty of the virus, studies were reported from recent years and further extensive studies are needed to explore more about the disease severity and neurological outcomes when compared to other non-PD patients. Authors identify this as a limitation for this paper. Additional studies are needed to understand the role of ACE2 in increasing vulnerability to viruses and role of ACE inhibitors as treatment modality.
2. INTRODUCTION
During the time of December in 2019 a new virus outbreak occurred in Wuhan City, China. It was causing pneumonia-like symptoms and belongs to a Novel member of the coronaviridae family named SARS-CoV-2 (severe acute respiratory coronavirus 2 syndrome) [1]. This virus emerged as a global pandemic and threat to life of humans due to its accelerated exponential spreading capability. As of 30 April 2021, there have been 14,99,10,744 confirmed cases of COVID-19, including 31,55,168 deaths reported globally[2].Coronavirus are enveloped positive single stranded RNA viruses and their 3’ terminal contains structural proteins. The Spike (S) protein in this virus allow them to fuse between host cell membrane and virus and also between infected and surrounding uninfected cells [3]. There is a surge in the levels of cytokines (TNF □ α, IL □ 6, IL □ 8, and IL □ 10) leading to suppression of T-cell response. Not many studies were focused on the ACE2 role in increasing vulnerability of viruses and role of ACE inhibitors in treatment of these PD patients. Moreover, COVID-19 was found to invade the host cells or escape detection due to spike proteins [4].
COVID-19 has posed challenges in the healthcare system in terms of its unpredictable and novel manifestations on pulmonary, neurology, cardiovascular, gastrointestinal and hematological systems. Published data showed evidence of the presence of SARS-CoV-2 in CSF, in addition to respiratory, fecal and blood samples. In about 36.4% of cases, neurological findings have been identified ranging over dizziness, headache, hyposmia, hypogeusia, dysphagia, muscle pain, seizures, loss of consciousness, etc[5]. Novel Coronavirus has imposed additional concerns with social factors such as, the surge in isolation, limited social activities which authors hypothesize might accentuate neuro-psychological problems like depression and impairment of cognition. With the availability of limited studies, the authors have tried to provide a comprehensive and analytical review to understand the effect of COVID-19 on Parkinson’s disease. Through this paper, we aim to study the impact of novel coronavirus on Parkinson disease by performing a systematic literature review
3. METHODOLOGY
A systematic literature search was performed from December 2019 to July 2020, using the keywords such as, “COVID19”, “SARS-CoV-2”, “Parkinson’s disease”, “Pandemic” and “Mortality”. We did an extensive search on databases namely PubMed central, Google Scholar, Cochrane, Science Direct and EMBASE for open access studies.
Inclusion criteria: (For studies and the target population)
COVID-19 patients with Parkinson’s disease
Patients diagnosed with Parkinson’s disease before COVID-19 infection
Age group > 21 years old
Both genders
Available articles in English language only
Exclusion Criteria
Non-COVID-19 PD patients
Articles on Pregnant women
Articles on pediatric population
Randomized control trials, crossover studies design.
Study selection
We included studies with COVID-19 positive patients with a history of Parkinson’s disease, studies published in English and with open access. A total of 250 articles were generated from our initial search. Authors scanned the abstract independently which led to inclusion of 154 articles. After the initial full articles screening process, 125 articles did not meet the inclusion criteria and were removed. Finally, 16 articles were added and analyzed in detail by all the authors. Relevant demographic and clinical information were extracted from the selected studies such as age, gender, clinical manifestation, comorbid conditions, diagnostic tests, treatment and outcome. This was then added into the MS-EXCEL spreadsheet for analyses and cumulative result interpretation. (PRISMA guidelines Figure 2).
4. RESULTS
Of the 16 articles, 7 (43.8%) were case reports and case series,4 (25%) case-control studies, 2 (12.5%) cross-sectional, 2 (12.5%) cohort and 1(6.25%) retrospective study (Figure 3) [6-21]. All Together describing a total of 1290 Parkinson’s patients with COVID-19. Male gender was predominant in 10 studies [6–15] and female gender was predominant in 6 studies [14] [16–20]. Of the patients whose data was available, Average mean age was 76.9 and average disease duration was 11 years. Almost most of the patients reported to have other comorbidities, most common were hypertension [6][10][12][13][17][18][20][21], diabetes [7][9][13] [15-18], obesity [6], dyslipidemia[18], cardiovascular disease[6][7][11[12][16-18][21], immunocompromised[6][12][21], COPD[6][10][11][15], asthma[15], chronic renal and liver diseases[15][16][21].
Of the Parkinson’s patients that were tested and positive for infection with SARS-CoV-2, worsening of motor symptoms [6–8] [11–13] [15,16][18][20] including bradykinesia, tremors, gait disturbances, delirium and dementia [10][16] and severe spasms of arms and legs [19] reported, with individual study percentage ranging from 19% to 100%, along with other COVD-19 symptoms. Encephalopathy was also one of the main symptoms presented in 2 of the studies [17][20]. Mortality rates for those who were hospitalized ranged from 5.7% to 100% [6-13][15-19][21].
Studies and selected subjects characteristics:
5. Discussion
A wide variety of neurological consequences have been reported by a large number with COVID-19 positive [22-32]. Neurological syptoms including those associated with core dysfunction (fatigue, headache, confusion, stroke [33], dizziness, syncope[34], seizure, anorexia, and insomnia) [35-38], central-peripheral mixture (Guillain Barre syndrome)[39], enteric, or peripheral nervous systems dysfunction (anosmia, ageusia, myoclonus[40], neuropathic pain, and myalgia)[41].
The increase in the hospital admission and mortality rates in the PD and other chronic neurological diseases during Covied 19 pandemic needs to be addressed to understand the exact effects. Most neurological diseases including Parkinson’s are highly dependent on prescribed medications to control their symptoms, with social isolation and some of the clinical practices forced to shut down, which led to irregular visits might be one of the reasons for worsening of the symptoms [42].
In this Systematic Review, We included studies with COVID-19 positive patients with a history of Parkinson’s disease. The most common manifestation related to COVID 19 in PD is Motor dysfunction. Most of the study shows a common domain that is motor neuron deficit, in the range of moderate to severe. Some of the patients show delirium, dementia, encephalopathy among other covied-19 complications. This can be related to the ACE2 mechanism of the brain. When SARS-CoV-2 enters the cell, it increases the activity of T cells, causing vasodilation, thrombosis, and hypoxemia, which then leads to stroke and seizures. Exact mechanism is still unclear. Some theory shows the effect is due to the virus attacking the ACE 2 receptors of the brain. Another theory shows the presence of new receptors in the corona virus including sialic acid residues [43]. How SARS-COV2 affects the brain is still questionable.
The median age is 76.9 with male predominance and average disease duration is 11 years. Almost most of the patients reported to have other comorbidities, most common were hypertension, diabetes, obesity, dyslipidemia, cardiovascular disease, immunocompromised, COPD, asthma, chronic renal and chronic liver diseases.
The major limitation for this systematic review is the presence of confounder factors as the majority of the Parkinson’s diseases patients are elderly with other comorbidities. Also the duration of the diseases and the severity of the symptoms may influence the clinical outcome of covid-19 infection. Important information including patients medication compliance which might affect the coveted 19 infection outcome were lacking as well.
6. Conclusion
Covid-19 has become the most prevalent infectious disease that extensively affects multiple body systems. The Central Nervous System is substantially susceptible to this infection,which can lead to deteriorating neurological findings, particularly in patients with PD. Some of these findings are motor dysfunction, delirium, dementia, severe spasms of arms and legs and encephalopathy. These signs observed in Covid-19 positive patients with a history of PD are mostly elderly male with longer duration of illness and other comorbid conditions. It is still unclear how Sars-CoV2 affects the nervous system in such patients, which is why future research is encouraged to provide more concrete information to diminish neurological outcomes, hospital stay and mortality on PD patients.
FUNDING
NIL
ETHICAL APPROVAL
NOT NEEDED IN SYSTEMIC REVIEW
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
AUTHORS DON’T HAVE ANY CONFLICT OF INTEREST
Footnotes
Email: viki29jai{at}yahoo.com
Email: danah.alquraish{at}gmail.com
Email: nagpals{at}stjosham.on.ca
Email: dattatreyamukherjee4u{at}outlook.com
Email: prakitisshrestha{at}gmail.com
Email: diana.sanchez.v{at}upch.pe
Email: doc.prathima{at}gmail.com
Email: arushree999{at}gmail.com
Email: salonisavani1234{at}gmail.com
Email: elma.halilaj1{at}hotmail.com
Email: ruxmohan{at}yahoo.com
Authors Contributions:
1- Research Project: A. Conception, B. Organization, C. Execution.
2- Statistical Analysis: A. Design, B. Execution, C. Review, and Critique.
3- Manuscript: A. Writing of the first draft, B. Review of Critique.
VJ: 1A, 1B, 1C, 2A, 3A, 3B
DA, PS, DM: 2A, 2B, 2C, 3A
SN, PG, AB, DS, EH: 3A, 3B
Two Authors name have spelling mistake, I have corrected that.
References
Subject Area
Reviews and Context
0
Comment
0
TRIP Peer Reviews
0
Community Reviews
0
Automated Services
1
Blogs/Media
Author Videos