Engagement in leisure activities and depression in older adults in the United States: Longitudinal evidence from the Health and Retirement Study

Introduction

In the United States (US), there is currently unprecedented growth in the number of older adults. By 2060, adults aged 65 and above are projected to form 23% of the American population (Vespa et al., 2020). Among this aging population, depression is one of the most common mental health problems, with point prevalence estimates ranging from 11% to 15% (Steffens et al., 2009; Zivin et al., 2010). Despite this, depression is commonly undiagnosed in older adults and is often undertreated (Rodda et al., 2011). As well as causing functional impairments in daily life, depression is associated with increased risks of cardiovascular disease, dementia, diabetes, stroke, and both specific and all-cause mortality (Cuijpers and Smit, 2002; Knol et al., 2006; Leonard, 2017; Pan et al., 2011; Van der Kooy et al., 2007). Additionally, identifying ways to reduce or prevent depression is particularly important in older age, when close social ties may be lost, people are more likely living alone, many have low income, and progressive age-related health problems may limit people’s activities (World Health Organization, 2015).

Leading a socially engaged life is thought to be important for successful ageing, which includes maintaining close relationships as well as being involved in activities that are meaningful and provide purpose, such as leisure activities (Rowe and Kahn, 1997). Leisure activities are voluntary non-work activities that are engaged in for enjoyment (Hills and Argyle, 1998), ranging from hobbies to participating in the arts to taking part in sports or exercise groups. There is extensive evidence that participating in leisure activities can support both the prevention and management of depression in older adults (Adams et al., 2011; Dupuis and Smale, 1995; Fancourt et al., 2020a; Fancourt and Tymoszuk, 2019; Glass et al., 2006; Hong et al., 2009; Katz and Yelin, 2001; Lampinen et al., 2006; Nimrod et al., 2012). This may be because leisure activities involve a range of active ingredients that are health promoting, including providing opportunities for creative expression, aesthetic pleasure, cognitive stimulation, sensory activation, evocation of emotion, and social interaction (Dunphy et al., 2019; Fancourt and Finn, 2019). These ingredients then activate a range of mechanisms of action that may reduce depression, including psychological processes (e.g. improving self-esteem and mood), biological processes (e.g. reducing levels of stress hormones and inflammation), social processes (e.g. reducing loneliness and improving communication), and behavioral processes (e.g. enhancing agency and motivation to engage in other health behaviors; Fancourt et al., 2021).

Cultural, arts, and creative activities represent one domain of leisure activity that may be particularly beneficial for reducing depression in older adults (Adams et al., 2011; Dupuis and Alzheimer, 2008). These cultural activities are commonly split into those that are receptive, involving art that has been created and is now experienced by an audience, and those that are participatory, requiring the creation of and participation in the arts (Fancourt et al., 2021; Fancourt and Finn, 2019; Tymoszuk et al., 2021). Although there is strong evidence from large observational studies that receptive cultural engagement (such as going to the theatre and museums) is associated with lower rates of depression in older adults (Elsden and Roe, 2020; Fancourt and Steptoe, 2019; Fancourt and Tymoszuk, 2019; Ryu and Heo, 2018), these activities may not be accessible to all. For older adults living in the community, receptive cultural engagement may be subject to more socioeconomic barriers than other leisure activities (Bone et al., 2021), and inequalities in access may increase with age (Fluharty et al., 2021). More than one in three older adults in the US have reported some difficulty attending cultural venues (Rajan and Rajan, 2017), which may be a result of cultural equity and relevance (Bone et al., 2021).

In contrast, a wide range of participatory creative and arts-based leisure activities can be done in the home, many of which are inexpensive or free. Despite these activities being more accessible than receptive cultural activities, there is less evidence on the associations between them and depression in older adults. Previous research has typically grouped a range of participatory creative activities into total engagement (Glass et al., 2006; Katz and Yelin, 2001; Lampinen et al., 2006), an approach that has been criticized for combining conceptually distinct pursuits (Kerby and Ragan, 2002; Ritchey et al., 2001; Ryu and Heo, 2018). Identifying activities that are, and are not, associated with depression will allow us to understand the characteristics of activities providing the most benefits. For example, we know that the social element of activities is usually important and protective (Adams et al., 2011; Dadswell et al., 2017; Dupuis and Alzheimer, 2008; Ryu and Heo, 2018), but we do not know whether creative or artistic activities provide additional benefits over and above social engagement. When examining more specific forms of leisure, one longitudinal study found that actively engaging in creative activities, but not cultural attendance, was associated with better mental health in a large sample of adults aged 16 to 101 years (Wang et al., 2020). Engagement in hobbies and crafts is also associated with reductions in subsequent depression in older adults (Dupuis and Smale, 1995; Fancourt et al., 2020a). However, these studies included predominantly White British samples, making generalizability across different nationalities and races/ethnicities difficult. Furthermore, only one indicator of engagement was used, meaning different activities could not be compared.

In this study, we used a large nationally representative cohort of older adults in the US (the Health and Retirement Study; Sonnega et al., 2014) to explore associations between engagement in a range of leisure activities and concurrent and subsequent depression. We measured seven activities that are commonly done by older adults: reading books, magazines or newspapers; writing (e.g., letters, stories, or journal entries); baking or cooking something special; making clothes, knitting, or embroidery (sewing); working on a hobby or project; going to a sport, social, or other club; and attending meetings of non-religious organizations (political, community, or other interest groups). Although not traditionally labelled as ‘arts’, we included this diverse range of activities as they could all include artistic or creative engagement, potentially sharing similar properties of creative skill and imagination. These activities combine complex and distinct elements, differing in specificity as well as the extent to which they could involve creativity and whether they are likely to entail social interactions. We therefore aimed to investigate whether these activities were differentially associated with depression, furthering our understanding of the characteristics of leisure activities that are important for preventing or reducing depression in older adults. We hypothesized that more frequent engagement in creative activities would be associated with lower odds of concurrent and subsequent depression.

Methods

Results

In total, 19,134 participants provided data on leisure activities and depression in at least one wave of HRS. After weighting, 55% of participants were women, 85% were White/Caucasian, and 47% were retired. As white people represent less than 80% of the US population (Gibson and Jung, 2002), this is an underrepresentation of other groups. Overall, 20% of the sample met diagnostic criteria for depression. The prevalence of depression differed according to several socioeconomic and health-related factors (Table 1), as did the frequency of engagement in leisure activities (Table S1).

Frequency of engagement differed considerably across activities; 85% of participants read weekly, whereas only 4% attended meetings of non-religious organizations weekly (political, community, or other interest groups; Table 2). After reading (books, magazines, or newspapers), the most common activities were baking or cooking something special, working on a hobby or project, and writing (e.g., letters, stories, or journal entries).

Discussion

We explored the associations between engagement in a diverse range of leisure activities and concurrent and subsequent depression in a large nationally representative cohort of older adults in the US. Attending a sport, social, or other club weekly or monthly was consistently associated with reduced odds of concurrent and subsequent depression. Spending time on a hobby or project weekly was also associated with lower odds of concurrent and subsequent depression, but for monthly hobby or project engagement this association was only present concurrently, not longitudinally. Although baking or cooking something special was not associated with concurrent depression, weekly baking or cooking something special was associated with reduced odds of depression two years later. These associations were independent of a range of confounders and previous depression. However, writing (e.g., letters, stories, or journal entries), reading books magazines or newspapers, making clothes knitting or embroidery (sewing), and attending non-religious organizations (political, community, or other interest groups) were not consistently associated with depression. Additionally, there was no evidence that the association between hobbies or projects, sport social or other clubs, and depression varied according to gender or age group. However, more frequent baking or cooking something special was only associated with lower subsequent depression in those aged 50-59.

Both overall engagement in participatory leisure activities and attending cultural events have previously been shown to be associated with a reduced risk of subsequent depression in older adults (Fancourt and Steptoe, 2019; Fancourt and Tymoszuk, 2019; Glass et al., 2006; Katz and Yelin, 2001; Lampinen et al., 2006). We aimed to build on this evidence by exploring whether specific participatory activities, with diverse characteristics, were differentially related to depression. We were particularly interested in whether the extent to which activities involved creative or artistic elements might alter their influence on depression in older adults. Of the activities we included, those most often referred to as the arts (writing letters stories or journal entries, reading books magazines or newspapers, sewing [making clothes knitting or embroidery]) were not associated with depression. We therefore found no evidence that more artistic or creative activities were associated with depression. This is in contrast to previous evidence that creative activities provide additional benefits for older adults over other leisure activities (Dadswell et al., 2017; Fancourt et al., 2021) and the positive effects of creative arts interventions for older adults experiencing depression (Chen et al., 2021; Curtis et al., 2018; Dunphy et al., 2019; Fancourt et al., 2020a, 2020b; Zhao et al., 2016). However, it has been proposed that the concept of creativity should not be limited to formal arts activities and should instead be extended to being creative in daily life, including in constructing personal knowledge and understanding, problem solving, and performing everyday tasks in an imaginative or artistic manner (Beghetto and Kaufman, 2007; Bellass et al., 2019). Using this definition, one could argue that all leisure activities included in this study required creativity, and the extent to which activities have traditionally been included in definitions of the arts becomes less relevant.

The leisure activities included in this study also differed in their specificity. Four of the activities were well-defined, included a relatively narrow range of behaviors, and were likely to take place in the home. These were reading (books, magazines, or newspapers), writing (e.g., letters, stories, or journal entries), baking or cooking something special, and sewing (making clothes, knitting, embroidery). In contrast, the other three activities (doing hobbies or projects, sport social or other clubs, and non-religious organizations) were quite broad and could have included a range of behaviors in a variety of settings. Of these activities, three of the four specific items were not associated with depression, whereas most of the more general leisure activities were. These findings are consistent with existing evidence that engagement in broadly defined hobbies is associated with lower odds of depression (Dupuis and Smale, 1995; Fancourt et al., 2020a; Hirosaki et al., 2009). This makes it difficult to study the specific mechanisms underlying the association between participation in leisure activities and depression and suggests that the mechanisms are likely to differ across individuals (Fancourt et al., 2021). Future research could further investigate whether it is the way in which leisure activities are defined that affect associations with depression, the settings in which activities occur, or other factors that are most important.

It is widely accepted that leisure activities that involve social interactions are particularly beneficial for mental health in older age (Adams et al., 2011; Dadswell et al., 2017; Dupuis and Alzheimer, 2008; Ryu and Heo, 2018). In line with this, we found that attending sport, social, or other clubs was most strongly associated with depression. However, attending non-religious organizations (political, community, or other interest groups) was not consistently associated with lower odds of depression. These contrasting relationships demonstrate the importance of investigating leisure activities separately. To understand these differences, we can consider the potential active ingredients of attending sport, social, or other clubs, which may activate causal mechanisms that reduce depression (Fancourt et al., 2021). For example, one active ingredient of clubs is the provision of social resources that can reduce loneliness and can be used in the development of a social identity (Dadswell et al., 2017; Haslam et al., 2009). Social identity theory states that individuals build a sense of who they are based on their group membership (Hogg, 2006), and there is evidence that individuals with stronger social identities have lower rates of depression (Cruwys et al., 2014; Haslam et al., 2009; Postmes et al., 2019). Although one could expect similar active ingredients of non-religious organizations (political, community, or other interest groups), it is possible that these more formal groups might not lead to the formation of strong social identities or positive social interactions, and thus are not associated with depression.

Although attending a sport, social, or other club was most consistently associated with depression, there were still associations between doing hobbies or projects, baking or cooking something special, and depression after accounting for the association between clubs and depression, suggesting that these activities provide additional active ingredients. They are not necessarily social activities, although they could lead to social interactions. By providing cognitive stimulation, hobbies or projects and baking or cooking something special could activate cognitive mechanisms including enhanced cognitive restructuring (identifying problematic cognitions and rationalizing and rebutting these thoughts; Fancourt et al., 2021). This is a key element of treatments for depression, such as cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), and is effective in reducing depressive symptoms (Clark, 2013). As more sedentary leisure activities (writing, reading, sewing) were not associated with depression, another important mechanism could be the physical activity involved in the other leisure activities (Dunphy et al., 2019; Fancourt et al., 2021). Increased physical activity and fitness is protective against depression in older adults (Kandola et al., 2020, 2019; Schuch et al., 2018). There may also be other active ingredients of clubs, hobbies or projects, and baking or cooking something special, leading to further mechanisms that reduce depression, which may interact and operate cyclically (Fancourt et al., 2021). These mechanisms should be explored further in longitudinal population-based studies.

In contrast to previous evidence for gender-dependent associations in working age adults (Cuypers et al., 2012), we found no evidence that engagement in leisure activities differentially affected depression in men and women. Activities may be equally beneficial across genders, even if there are gender differences in engagement. We did not expect to find age differences in the association between baking or cooking something special and depression. It is possible that adults aged 50-59 were more likely to bake or cook for friends or family, and thus more frequent engagement in this activity was an indicator of increased social interactions in this age group, which were then associated with reduced odds of subsequent depression (Kawachi and Berkman, 2001). However, adjusting for social network composition did not attenuate this association.

Conclusions

Our findings indicate that engagement in some leisure activities, which may be more accessible to older adults than receptive cultural engagement, are independently associated with reduced odds of depression. However, we found no evidence that more artistic or creative activities were associated with depression. Despite this, and given the high prevalence of depression in older adults, the fact that is commonly undiagnosed and untreated, the impacts on daily life, and comorbidity with other health problems (Rodda et al., 2011; World Health Organization, 2015), it is promising that engagement in sport social or other clubs, hobbies or projects, and baking or cooking something special could lead to lower rates of depression. These associations may occur through the activation of mechanisms such as increased social identity, cognitive stimulation, and physical activity. Associations persist across genders and age groups, holding promise for many older adults in the US. The potential of these easily accessible activities to reduce depression is particularly important in the wake of COVID-19 with the closure of many arts venues. It is possible that an individual’s own choices of activities, be it sport social or other clubs, hobbies or projects, or baking or cooking something special, are more beneficial for their mental health than creative arts interventions that often only provide the opportunity to engage in a specific activity (Curtis et al., 2018; Dunphy et al., 2019). Policy makers should consider how older adults can be supported to engage in leisure activities that may help to prevent depression as they age. For example, in the United Kingdom, social prescribing systems allow primary care practitioners to connect older adults to community groups, which may improve health (Drinkwater et al., 2019). Similar systems could be tested to establish whether they have the potential to reduce the risk of depression in older adults in the US.