Convergent abnormalities of β-amyloid deposition, glucose metabolism, and fMRI activity in the dorsal precuneus in subjective cognitive decline

Participants

Participants were recruited through public advertisements and referrals from general physicians, memory clinics, and informants. All participants signed a written informed consent before the experiment. The recruitment and assessment of participants have been described in the protocol of the Sino Longitudinal Study on Cognitive Decline (SILCODE) previously.¹⁰ The study was registered in ClinicalTrials.gov (Identifier: NCT03370744) and approved by the ethics committee of Xuanwu Hospital of Capital Medical University (Identifier No. [2017]046). The participants were recruited from February 27th to November 15th in 2018, and finally 65 right-handed and Mandarin speaking participants (50 for SCD and 15 for NC) were included. Fig. S1 illustrates the eligibility criteria for the study population.

SCD was defined according to the research criteria for pre-MCI SCD, including 1) self-experienced persistent decline in cognitive capacity compared with a previously normal status and unrelated to an acute event; 2) normal age-, sex-, and education-adjusted performance on standardized cognitive tests and not meet the criteria for MCI or dementia.^1,10 Individuals with normal performance on the standardized neuropsychological tests and without cognitive problems via the SCD-interview¹¹ were included as the NC group.

The exclusion criteria were as follows: 1) a history of stroke; 2) current major psychiatric diagnoses, such as severe depression and anxiety (Hamilton depression scale (HAMD) score > 24 or Hamilton anxiety (HAMA) scale > 29); 3) other diseases that could cause cognitive decline; 4) history of psychosis or congenital mental developmental delay; 5) contraindications for MRI or unable to complete the study protocol.

Neuropsychological assessments

The neuropsychological tests included three cognitive domains: auditory verbal learning test-Huashan version (AVLT-H), animal fluency test (AFT), 30-item Boston naming test (BNT), and shape trail test (STT) parts A and B.^12-15 In addition, all subjects implemented tests for global cognition, daily life ability, and neuropsychiatric assessments, including Montreal cognitive assessment-basic (MoCA-B),¹⁶ functional activities questionnaire (FAQ), HAMA, and HAMD.

Image data acquisition

For each participant, PET and MRI data were simultaneously acquired with an integrated 3.0 Tesla TOF PET/MR scanner (SIGNA PET/MR, GE Healthcare, Milwaukee, WI, USA) at Xuanwu Hospital of Capital Medical University. Participants were instructed to keep their eyes closed, relax but not fall asleep, and move as little as possible during scanning. Foam pads were used to minimize head movements and earplugs were used to reduce machine noise.

Data analysis

AV45-PET and FDG-PET images were analyzed by Statistical Parametric Mapping version 12 (SPM 12; https://www.fil.ion.ucl.ac.uk/spm/software/spm12) and in-house software with MATLAB (https://www.mathworks.com). The preprocessing and calculation of the standardized uptake value ratio (SUVR) of the AV45-PET (voxel-wise and global SUVR) and FDG-PET (voxel-wise SUVR) were listed in the Method-SA.

RS-fMRI datasets were preprocessed using the Data Processing Assistant for Brain Imaging (DPABI_V4.1) and Resting-State fMRI Data Analysis Toolkit (RESTplus_1.22).^17,18 The details were listed in the Method-SA.

Then, three RS-fMRI metrics for local activities were calculated, including ALFF reflecting the amplitude of the fluctuation of each time series of the fMRI signal, ReHo reflecting the local synchronization of the time series of neighboring voxels, and DC reflecting the functional connectivity density of a voxel with all other voxels.^3-5 It should be noted that, DC is actually an FC index, but often taken as a local metric in graph theory analysis.

Seed-based FC analysis was a post-hoc analysis. As shown in the Results section, 6 voxels in the left dorsal precuneus (dPCu), which showed abnormal activities in 7 of the total 8 neuroimaging metrics in SCD subjects, were taken as a region of interest (named dPCu-ROI hereafter). The details for FC analysis were listed in the Method-SA.

Statistical analyses

SPSS (version 24.0, IBM) was used for comparisons of demographic and neuropsychological data. DPABI_V4.1 was used for statistical analysis of the local activities and FC between SCD and NC. In addition, the Aβ positivity effect was also tested.¹⁹ The details were listed in the Method-SA.

Behavioral measures

No significant difference was found in the age, sex, or education level between the SCD group and NC group (all P > 0.05) (Table 1). The HAMA and HAMD were significantly higher in the SCD group than in the NC group.

Alteration of local activity

The SCD group showed: 1) increased Aβ deposition in the left dPCu, left cuneus, left superior parietal cortex, and right medial superior frontal cortex (Figure 1. P < 0.05, FDR corrected); 2) increased glucose metabolism in the left dPCu, left middle occipital cortex, and bilateral paracentral lobule (Figure 1. P < 0.05, FDR corrected). The left dPCu was the only region showing overlapped abnormality for Aβ deposition and glucose metabolism.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1.

Group differences between subjective cognitive decline (SCD) and normal control (NC) groups with controlling for age, sex, and years of education, on Aβ deposition and glucose metabolism (top row), RS-fMRI metrics (middle row), and the overlapping area of the PET and fMRI metrics (bottom row). Overlapping area at the left dPCu means that 7 of 8 metrics showed group difference, i.e., AV45-SUVR, FDG-SUVR, AV45-ALFF, FDG-ALFF, AV45-ReHo, FDG-ReHo, AV45-DC, and FDG-DC. Red and yellow colors indicate increased metrics in SCD vs. NC, and blue color indicates the opposite. SUVR: standardized uptake value ratio. FDR: false discovery rate. ALFF: amplitude of low frequency fluctuation. ReHo: regional homogeneity. DC: degree centrality. L and R: left and right in the brain. T: the T value of two-sample t-test on the PET and fMRI metrics maps.

The difference of RS-fMRI metrics (ALFF, ReHo, and DC) did not survive FDR correction. With an uncorrected P < 0.05, the SCD group showed decreased ALFF, ReHo, and DC in the left dPCu (Figure 1) for both the AV45-fMRI and FDG-fMRI.

Seed-based functional connectivity

One sample t-tests showed that the connectivity patterns of the left dPCu were very similar for AV45-fMRI and FDG-fMRI datasets (P < 0.05, FDR corrected, Figure 2). Significantly negative functional connectivity with the left dPCu was mainly in the DMN regions, including the bilateral medial prefrontal cortex, posterior cingulate cortex, and its adjacent ventral PCu, etc. Significantly positive functional connectivity was located in the bilateral inferior frontal cortex, middle frontal cortex, lingual gyrus, etc. No significant difference in RSFC was found between the SCD group and NC group (P < 0.05, FDR corrected).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 2.

Patterns of seed-based resting-state functional connectivity (RSFC) of the left dorsal precuneus (dPCu) of all the subjects in the AV45-fMRI dataset (A) and FDG-fMRI dataset (B) (P < 0.05, FDR corrected). The yellow-red color indicates positive connections and the blue color indicates negative connections with the left dPCu. MPFC: medial prefrontal cortex. PCC: posterior cingulate cortex. vPCu: ventral PCu. IPS: intraparietal sulcus. L and R: left and right in the brain. T: the T value of one-sample t-test on the RSFC maps.

Correlation between imaging metrics and behavioral measures in the SCD group

We observed significant correlation between any pair of two fMRI metrics (ALFF, ReHo, and DC; P < 0.001) within the dPCu-ROI. No significant correlation was found between other pairs of imaging metrics (Table S2).

As for the correlation between behavioral scales and imaging metrics, although a few correlation showed a P value between 0.05 – 0.01, none survided multiple comarision correction (Table S3).

Aβ deposition positivity and neuroimaging metrics in the dPCu-ROI

The demographic and neuropsychological data of NC^-, SCD^- and SCD⁺ groups can be found in Table S4. The HAMD score was significantly higher in the SCD⁺ group and the SCD^- group than in the NC^- group.

SCD⁺ group showed significantly higher global AV45-SUVR than both NC^- and SCD^- groups, but no significant difference was found between NC^- and SCD^- (P = 0.43) (Figure 3A). Both SCD^- and SCD⁺ groups had significantly higher AV45-SUVR in left dPCu-ROI than NC-group, while no significant difference was found between SCD^- and SCD⁺ (P = 0.08) (Figure 3B).With regard to the FDG-SUVR and all RS-fMRI metrics, both SCD⁺ and SCD^- showed hypermetabolism and decreased fMRI activity in the dPCu-ROI, except for the comparison of FDG-ReHo between SCD⁺ group and NC^- group (P = 0.11) (Figure 3).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 3.

Comparisons of global AV45-SUVR (A) and the 8 metrics in the left dPCu-ROI among three groups, i.e. AV45-SUVR (B), FDG-SUVR (C), AV45-ALFF (D), AV45-ReHo (E), AV45-DC (F), FDG-ALFF (G), FDG-ReHo (H), and FDG-DC (I). NC^-: Aβ negative NC. SCD^-: Aβ negative SCD. SCD⁺: Aβ positive SCD. * : P < 0.05, ** : P < 0.01, *** : P < 0.001. All box and whisker plots: box range, 25–75%; whisker range, 5–95%.

Independent verification of data analyses

In order to controlling for the potential influence from data anslysis upon our results, we replicated all the analyses by two independent research teams based on the same software and pipeline. The results were substaitially the same (Fig. S2-4 and Table S5-6).

Convergent abnormal local activity in AD/MCI/SCD

In the PCC and its adjacent PCu (sometimes named PCC/PCu) of MCI and AD, meta-analyses have reported increased Aβ deposition and decreased glucose metabolism, decreased RS-fMRI ALFF, and ReHo.^6,8,9 However, the current study found convergent abnormal activities in 7/8 functional metrics in the dPCu. Furthermore, the seed-based RS-fMRI FC showed that the dPCu was negatively connected with the DMN (including PCC and its adjacent ventral PCu). Previous RS-fMRI studies have segmented the precuneus into 6 or 8 sub-regions,^20,21 suggesting precuneus may be functionally heterogeneous. We searched in the Neurosynth (http://neurosynth.org) (coordinates: −6, −68, 62; distance: 4 mm) and found that the dPCu was reported to be involved in more cognitive than memory tasks, e.g., unfocused attention,²² in healthy people. Although many task fMRI studies have been carried out on SCD (Table S7), none has reported abnormal activation in the dPCu. Future studies should investigate the specific cognitive processing of the dPCu, and hence develop more specific cognitive tests for SCD.

Increased Aβ deposition vs. increased glucose metabolism in SCD

Meta-analysis has reported that the increased Aβ deposition was associated with decreased glucose metabolism in the same area of PCC in MCI/AD,⁶ indicating a decreased neuronal activity. However, we found an association of increased Aβ deposition with increased glucose metabolism in the dPCu, indicating an increased activity. No previous PET imaging studies of SCD, MCI and AD reported one positive relationship between cerebral Aβ deposition and glucose metabolism as we found in this study. A few human PET and task fMRI studies^23-25 indirectly support our findingsStudies of animal model of early AD have frequently reported Aβ-dependent increased neuronal activity.^26,27 Our results support the view that Aβ-dependent hyperactivity may occur long before the presence of AD symptoms.²⁶

Decreased value of RS-fMRI local metrics vs. increased glucose metabolism in SCD

As aforementioned, for MCI and AD, both the decreased glucose metabolism and decreased value of RS-fMRI local metrics (ALFF and ReHo) in the PCC were interpreted as decreased neuronal activity. However, we found seemingly discrepant results, i.e., increased glucose metabolism and decreased value of the local RS-fMRI metrics in the dPCu. The following notations might be helpful.

1. Mathematically, the glucose metabolism of FDG-PET reflects the integrated or mean value over a period of time, while the RS-fMRI ALFF reflects the amplitude of fluctuation or standard deviation within a specific frequency band. The simulation result showed that the mean value has no linear correlation with the standard deviation (Fig. S5). It has commonly been suggested that the fMRI signal is more coupled with the local field potential (LFP) than the action potential.²⁸ Mathematically, both the RS-fMRI signal and the LFP are analyzed in a frequency-dependent way, however, their frequency-dependent correlation of the amplitude, a popular metric for both RS-fMRI and LFP, is far from clear.

2. A few PET-fMRI studies have shown that, although both the glucose metabolism²⁹ and RS-fMRI local metrics show similar higher activity in the default mode network (DMN) regions (e.g., PCC) than other brain regions, voxel-wise across-subject correlation did not show robust significant linear correlation (Table S8).^30-32

3. Brain disorders may show opposite association of glucose metabolism with RS-fMRI local metrics, e.g., increased glucose metabolism³³ but decreased ALFF³⁴ in the putamen of patients with Parkinson’s disease (Table S9). The current study also showed opposite association in the dPCu, however, as aforementioned, AD/MCI showed positive association, i.e., decreased glucose metabolism and decreased value of RS-fMRI metrics.^6,8,9

Considering the non-invasiveness, low-cost, and easy-accessing advantages of RS-fMRI technique, it may be a promising technique for precise localizing the AD-related abnormal activity, and hence, could be used to guide precise brain stimulation, e.g., transcranial magnetic stimulation.

SCD showed abnormal local activities regardless of Aβ positivity

Binary classification of Aβ deposition into positive and negative is a popular way for clinical diagnosis for either healthy aging or participants with SCD.³⁵ The current study thus classified all participants into SCD⁺, SCD^-, NC⁺, and NC^- with the criteria of the cortical summary AV45-SUVR value ≥ 1.11.¹⁹ NC⁺ group was not included into the further analysis due to the limited sample size (n = 4). Both the SCD^- and SCD⁺ groups showed increased Aβ deposition and glucose metabolism and decreased value of RS-fMRI metrics in the dPCu as compared with NC^- group. In other words, like the SCD⁺ group, the SCD^- group also showed evidences of elevated Aβ pathology and hypermetabolism, as well as abnormal fMRI activities. Although the Aβ +/- categorization is often used to define preclinical AD, it does not imply that gobally Aβ negative subjects have no pathology in the brain.^35,36 Consistent with our findings, previous literature also found that local regions (including precuneus and posterior cingulate etc.) may be more sensitive to detect early Aβ deposition than global cortical summary regions.^37-39 Furthermore, we also compared the mean values of the eight metrics in the PCC (Fig. S6), the SCD⁺ group showed significantly higher AV45-SUVR than the SCD^- and NC^- group. However, we did not found significant difference in the FDG-SUVR and fMRI metrics of PCC between the NC-group and the two SCD groups. Together, it is likely that the increased Aβ deposition may occur concurrently with hypermetabolism and abnormal fMRI activities in dPCu (early Aβ-affected region) in the early stage of AD.

Limitations

This study has some limitations. First, this is a cross-sectional data, thus further longitudinal studies would be helpful to investigate the changes of Aβ deposition, neuronal dysfunction, and cognitive function as the disease progresses. Second, we did not have tau PET imaging, thus we can not evaluate tau pathology in this study. Third, although multimodal metrics and two fMRI datasets were used to increase the reliability of our results, data from multiple research centers are needed for validation of the findings in this study. Finally, this study did not include cognitive tests related to unfocused attention which might be more specific to elaborate the functional roles of the dPCu.