Sleep in Frontline Healthcare Workers on Social Media During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Background

Since March 2020, the severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2, SARS-CoV2 (COVID-19) pandemic has impacted all of our lives on a global scale, especially healthcare workers on the frontlines. During the pandemic, healthcare workers (HCW) have used social to share a variety of concerns relating to their experiences on the frontlines, such as lack of personal protective equipment (PPE), mental anguish, burnout,¹ and toll caring for such patients. One such concern also includes sleep loss and other sleep disturbances.² While these sleep issues certainly can be attributed to long hours, they may also be due to other reasons. Social media posts suggest that healthcare workers are suffering from bad dreams, insomnia, and also “doomscrolling” - or using mobile devices at night to review social media.^3,4 Given the increased professional and personal responsibilities for healthcare workers during the pandemic, it’s possible that sleep loss or disturbances could also be compounded by additional worries during the pandemic. Moreover, there is mounting evidence demonstrating inadequate physician sleep is associated with burnout and medical errors.^5,6

Several studies in other countries describe the sleep of HCW during the COVID-19 pandemic. Most notable are two meta-analyses on sleep in HCW during the initial months of the COVID-19 pandemic, with studies mostly focusing on the experience of HCW in China. Pappa et al. ⁷ reviewed 5 cross-sectional studies conducted among Chinese HCW prior to April 17, 2020 and reported a prevalence of insomnia (38.9%) among them. Salari et al.⁸ reviewed 7 cross-sectional studies from Asia and the Middle East conducted among nurses and physicians prior to June 24, 2020 and reported a prevalence of sleep disturbances of 34.8% and 41.6% in nurses and physicians, respectively. Additionally, several other studies reported on sleep loss in HCW from countries such as Oman,⁹ Bahrain,¹⁰ and Spain.¹¹

To date, there have been few studies of the sleep experience among frontline HCW in the United States (U.S.). These studies did not utilize validated measures of sleep and were limited to a single institution.^3,12 In the U.S., to our knowledge, no study has yet to evaluate sleep using standardized measures in clinically active frontline HCW during the COVID-19 pandemic. Despite anecdotal observations of sleep loss described via social media platforms, no study yet has explicitly explored the sleep of frontline HCW in the COVID-19 pandemic utilizing social media, an increasingly important and influential voice during the pandemic. This study aims to describe the sleep disturbances of U.S. frontline HCW on social media during the COVID-19 pandemic using validated instruments. The study also aims to examine the association between various demographic and career characteristics of HCW with reported sleep disturbances and the association between sleep disturbances and burnout.

Methods

From August 31 to September 15, 2020, we recruited frontline HCW from across the world to complete a web-based R.E.S.T. (Recommending Essential Sleep Time) Survey. The restricted, self-selection survey was distributed through Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram social media accounts made specifically for the study. A river sampling method was used to recruit subjects anonymously.¹³ This online sampling technique redirected interested subjects to the survey link via digital promotion (e.g., banners, advertisements, flyers, offers).¹³ A unique “bit.ly” link was created for the social media accounts to enable tracking of views and clicks. Participation in the study was voluntary, and participants could opt-out at any time while responding to survey questions. Subjects included physicians, physician assistants, nurse practitioners, nurses, pharmacists, physical/occupational/respiratory therapists, healthcare trainees, and allied HCW (e.g., medical technologist, therapist, certified nursing assistant). The University of Chicago Institutional Review Board reviewed and approved the protocol.

Results

Our social media posts were seen by 87,061 unique individuals and resulted in 976 clicks on our survey link. Our final sample had 963 surveys that were submitted. The most common ways people discovered the survey were through Twitter (39.4%), private Facebook group (21.1%), and a colleague (10.9%).

Participants were mostly female (73.4%), White (92.8%), aged 30-49 (71.9%), and physicians (64.4%). (Table 1)

Poor sleep quality, defined as a PSQI score > 5, was identified in 88.9% (n = 753) of all healthcare workers (Table 2). Rates of moderate and/or severe insomnia were 28.5% and 4.5%, respectively (Table 2). Average sleep duration was 6.1 +/- 1.2 hours (Table 2). Many (60%) reported sleep disruptions due to device usage or due to bad dreams at least once per week (45%). Those with a sleep disorder were more likely to report burnout, 52.1% vs 63.2% [x2 (4, N= 963) = 116.4, p < 0.001)]. In unadjusted analyses Black race (31.0% vs 59.4%), Hispanic ethnicity (27.9% vs 59.6%), being single (44.6% vs 27.1%), and being a non-physician (50.7% vs. 23.2%) were significantly associated with risk of moderate-to-severe insomnia.

In multivariable logistic regressions, non-physician (OR 2.4; CI: 1.7, 3.4), caring for COVID-19 patients (OR 1.8; CI 1.2, 2.8), Hispanic ethnicity (OR 2.2; CI: 1.4, 3.5), and being female (OR 1.6; CI 1.1, 2.4) were associated with increased odds of insomnia (Table 3). Having a sleeping disorder also increased odds of insomnia compared to those without one (OR 4.3; CI 2.7,6.9). (Table 3).

Three hundred and ten open-ended comments regarding factors affecting sleep were categorized into the following four themes: (1) Children and family; (2) Work demands affecting sleep; (3) Personal health conditions; (4) Pandemic-related sleep disturbances. The most frequently reported non-pandemic-related theme was children and family (n = 59), (“COVID plus home stress plus stress over my kids, my job, my marriage.”) (Table 4). Other non-pandemic related sleep disturbances included work demands affecting sleep (n = 48) (“The volume of calls and messages from my patient and caregiver population is through the roof and I’m sleeping 4-5 hours per night.”) and personal health (n = 41), (“Insomnia predating COVID, but worsened with COVID.”) (Table 4). Pandemic-related sleep disturbances (n = 48), (“I never had sleep issues prior to the COVID-19 pandemic; suddenly I had issues with sleep initiation.”) were also noted (Table 5).

Discussion

To our knowledge, this is the first study to evaluate sleep disturbances among U.S. frontline HCW on social media during the COVID-19 pandemic using self-reported validated measures. Our study demonstrates nearly 90% of surveyed HCW report poor sleep, over 30% report moderate-severe insomnia, and over 50% report burnout. A majority also reported sleep disruptions due to device usage or bad dreams at least once per week. Additionally, survey participants reported a mean sleep duration of 6.1 hours, less than the recommended 7 hours of sleep for U.S. adults.²¹ Controlling for those who had a known sleep disorder, those at highest risk of insomnia included those that were non-physicians, non-male, Hispanic, and those HCW that directly cared for COVID19. We also demonstrate that sleep disturbances in HCW during the pandemic not only relate to work demands and personal health, but also are related to children and family, and to the pandemic itself, including worry about the response to the COVID19 pandemic. Given the strong association between sleep and burnout among health professionals, it is not surprising that so many HCW report burnout.⁵

The results of this study are consistent with prior studies demonstrating a high prevalence of insomnia in nursing and physicians caring for COVID-19 patients on the frontlines.⁸ Salari et al.⁸ report in a systematic review and meta-analysis on the increase of insomnia in frontline nurses near 35% and in frontline physicians near 42%, however they did not report on a sub-group analysis of insomnia in women. In the meta-analysis by Pappa et al.,⁷ insomnia prevalence in HCW during the COVID-19 pandemic was near 40%, and the authors did not report specifically the prevalence of insomnia in women frontline HCW. Our data is also in concert with a Trockel et al. ⁵ demonstrating sleep-related impairment as an occupational hazard associated with increased medical-related errors and burnout. In comparing our sample to the general U.S. physicians, we find higher rates of sleep disturbances and insomnia risk than the general population of practicing physicians.^22–24 Our study findings of sleep disruption due to device usage are consistent with findings demonstrating increased nightly screen time in HCW and reports of “doomscrolling.” ^3,4

There are many clinical implications of these findings. Frontline HCW involved in the direct care of COVID-19 patients report decreased sleep time, increased insomnia, nightmares, fears of safety, increased clinical workload, and concerns for their family, reportedly impacting their sleep. Healthcare workers are at high risk for the development of psychological distress and medical errors.^5,25 The professional environment for healthcare workers has drastically changed with the pandemic and brought with it challenges related to increased workload, reduced protective equipment and resources, rapidly evolving protocols, relocation of intensive care settings, fear of viral transmission, and social isolation from supportive networks.^26,27 Given this unfolding environment, findings of sleep disturbances of frontline HCW is not surprising.

The study findings are particularly concerning given the natural course of insomnia and potential for long term psychological impact, as seen in HCW during prior Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) outbreaks.^28–30 In a recently reported longitudinal study on insomnia, nearly half (42%) of patients who had insomnia initially (as measured by the ISI) also had insomnia 5 years later, demonstrating a persistent course.³¹ Likewise, studies on the mental health of HCW active during the 2003 SARS epidemic suggest the psychological consequences may persist months to years after the epidemic ends.³⁰ While noting long term impacts of mental health, it is also important to consider the implication of potential medical errors due to sleep loss by these HCW.⁶ Studies of sleep disorders in HCW during prior infectious outbreaks are in concert with our study findings, and they forecast the potential longitudinal psychological impact on the sleep health of our frontline healthcare colleagues.

Although social media platforms are widely utilized in 2020, a limitation of this study may be that recruitment through social media platforms may not be a representative sample of HCW in the U.S. Because the focus of our survey was on sleep, it is possible that HCW who were more likely to have a sleep disturbance completed the survey. Given the prevalence of sleep disorders in the general U.S. population of 8 to 19%,^32,33 our sample does not appear to over-represent those with sleep disorders. There were not enough non-physician HCW in our sample to characterize the sleep quality for non-physician workers (e.g., physician’s assistant, nurse practitioner, nurse, pharmacist, allied health workers). We also asked subjects to complete the survey questions by reflecting on a time when they experienced the greatest clinical intensity and risk of COVID-19 transmission; this may have led to inconsistencies in our data. All data were self-reported, and we do not have objective measures of sleep duration and quality in this sample. We also do not have longitudinal data on our sample, limiting our ability to draw longitudinal conclusions. Furthermore, when utilizing social media data, it is difficult to capture the accurate outreach and link clicks; e.g., if an individual shares the link but not our original post, we cannot calculate the outreach and metrics. Therefore, the actual metrics may be higher than those we were capable of measuring.

Conclusion

During the COVID-19 pandemic, 90% of HCW surveyed on social media reported poor sleep, with nearly half of respondents reporting moderate-severe insomnia and over half reporting burnout. Immediate interventions to improve HCW sleep and well-being, discourage nocturnal social media usage, and “doomscrolling” are needed to strengthen their ability to continuously meet daily demands of the COVID-19 pandemic. Considering that sleep is a modifiable factor of our physical and mental health, prioritizing it may help mitigate the health risks associated with the pandemic and potential longitudinal impacts on sleep and health.