Abstract
Introduction - Worldwide, nursing home residents have experienced disproportionately high COVID-19 mortality due to the intersection of congregate living, multimorbidity, and advanced age. Among 12 OECD countries, Canada has had the highest proportion of COVID-19 deaths in nursing home residents (78%), raising concerns about a skewed pandemic response that averted much transmission and mortality in community-dwelling residents, but did not adequately protect those in nursing homes. To investigate this, we measured temporal variations in hospitalizations among community and nursing home-dwelling decedents with COVID-19 during the first and second waves of the pandemic.
Methods - We conducted a population-based cohort study of residents of Ontario, Canada with COVID-19 who died between March 11, 2020 (first COVID-19 death in Ontario) and October 28, 2020. We examined hospitalization prior to death as a function of 4 factors: community (defined as all non-nursing home residents) vs. nursing home residence, age in years (<70, 70-79, 80-89, ≥90), gender, and month of death (1st wave: March-April [peak], May, June-July 2020 [nadir], 2nd wave: August-October 2020).
Results - A total of 3,114 people with confirmed COVID-19 died in Ontario from March to October, 2020 (Table 1), of whom 1,354 (43.5%) were hospitalized prior to death (median: 9 days before death, interquartile range: 4-19). Among nursing home decedents (N=2000), 22.4% were admitted to hospital prior to death, but this varied substantially from a low of 15.5% in March-April (peak of wave 1) to a high of 41.2% in June-July (nadir of wave 1). Among community-dwelling decedents (N=1,114), admission to acute care was higher (81.4%) and remained relatively stable throughout the first and second waves. Similar temporal trends for nursing home versus community decedents were apparent in age-stratified analyses (Figure 1). Women who died were less likely to have been hospitalized compared to men in both community (80% women vs 84% men) and nursing home (21% women vs 24% men) settings.
Discussion - Only a minority of Ontario nursing home residents who died of COVID-19 were hospitalized prior to death, and that there were substantial temporal variations, with hospitalizations reaching their lowest point when overall COVID-19 incidence peaked in mid-April, 2020. While many nursing home residents had pre-pandemic advance directives precluding hospitalization, the low admission rate observed in March-April 2020 (15.5%) was inconsistent with both higher admission rates in subsequent months (>30%), and comparatively stable rates among community-dwelling adults. Our findings substantiate reports suggesting that hospitalizations for nursing home residents with COVID-19 were low during the peak of the pandemic’s first wave in Canada, which may have contributed to the particularly high concentration of COVID-19 mortality in Ontario’s nursing homes.
Introduction
Worldwide, nursing home residents have experienced disproportionately high COVID-19 mortality due to the intersection of congregate living, multimorbidity, and advanced age.1 Among 12 OECD countries, Canada has had the highest proportion of COVID-19 deaths in nursing home residents (78%), raising concerns about a skewed pandemic response that averted much transmission and mortality in community-dwelling residents, but did not adequately protect those in nursing homes.2 In Canada’s most populous province of Ontario there was no official policy denying hospitalizations for nursing home residents with COVID-19, yet media reports and a provincial commission suggest that resident transfers to hospital were strongly discouraged at the onset of the pandemic.3,4 To investigate this, we measured temporal variations in hospitalizations among community and nursing home-dwelling decedents with COVID-19 during the first and second waves of the pandemic.
Methods
We conducted a population-based cohort study of residents of Ontario, Canada with COVID-19 who died between March 11, 2020 (first COVID-19 death in Ontario) and October 28, 2020. Data were extracted on the last day of the study period from the provincial reportable disease surveillance system, which records all reported COVID-19 cases, and their outcomes. All Ontario residents receive medically necessary services under a publicly funded provincial health insurance program, and nursing home residents receive additional personal and nursing care. We examined hospitalization prior to death as a function of 4 factors: community (defined as all non-nursing home residents) vs. nursing home residence, age in years (<70, 70-79, 80-89, ≥ 90), gender, and month of death (1st wave: March-April [peak], May, June-July 2020 [nadir], 2nd wave: August-October 2020). The study received a waiver of consent from the research ethics board of Public Health Ontario.
Results
A total of 3,114 people with confirmed COVID-19 died in Ontario from March to October, 2020 (Table), of whom 1,354 (43.5%) were hospitalized prior to death (median: 9 days before death, interquartile range: 4-19). Among nursing home decedents (N=2000), 22.4% were admitted to hospital prior to death, but this varied substantially from a low of 15.5% in March-April (peak of wave 1) to a high of 41.2% in June-July (nadir of wave 1). Among community-dwelling decedents (N=1,114), admission to acute care was higher (81.4%) and remained relatively stable throughout the first and second waves. Similar temporal trends for nursing home versus community decedents were apparent in age-stratified analyses (Figure). Women who died were less likely to have been hospitalized compared to men in both community (80% women vs 84% men) and nursing home (21% women vs 24% men) settings.
Admissions to hospital prior to death among community and nursing home residents who died with COVID-19, March to October 2020 (N=3,114).
Discussion
Only a minority of Ontario nursing home residents who died of COVID-19 were hospitalized prior to death, and that there were substantial temporal variations, with hospitalizations reaching their lowest point when overall COVID-19 incidence peaked in mid-April, 2020. While many nursing home residents had pre-pandemic advance directives precluding hospitalization, the low admission rate observed in March-April 2020 (15.5%) was inconsistent with both higher admission rates in subsequent months (>30%), and comparatively stable rates among community-dwelling adults. This raises concerns for other jursidictions, including the United States, which has seen substantial inter-state variations in the proportion of COVID-19 deaths occurring in nursing homes, ranging from 18% in Nevada to 79% in New Hampshire.5
This analysis has limitations. Hospitalizations recorded in the surveillance system may undercount hospitalizations compared to administrative records (sensitivity=0.87, specificity=0.98).6 We also lacked information on advance directives which may have impacted the decision to hospitalize.
Our findings substantiate reports suggesting that hospitalizations for nursing home residents with COVID-19 were low during the peak of the pandemic’s first wave in Canada, which may have contributed to the particuarly high concentration of COVID-19 mortality in Ontario’s nursing homes.
Data Availability
The specific dataset used for this analysis is not publically available. Ontario's Ministry of Health does make a modified version of this data publicly available (https://covid-19.ontario.ca/data). Questions regarding access to data should be directed to the ministry of health through the above website.
