Inter-population differences of allele frequency and regulome tagging are associated with the heterogeneity of loci identified by cross-ancestry genome-wide association studies

Abstract

To investigate cross-ancestry genetics of complex traits, we conducted a phenome-wide analysis of loci with heterogeneous effects across African, Admixed-American, Central/South Asian, East Asian, European, and Middle Eastern participants of UK Biobank (N=441,331). Testing 843 phenotypes, we identified 82 independent genomic regions mapping variants showing genome-wide significant (GWS) associations (p<5×10⁻⁸) in the trans-ancestry meta-analysis and GWS heterogeneity among the ancestry-specific effects. These included: i) loci with GWS association in one ancestry and concordant but heterogeneous effects among the other ancestries; ii) loci with a GWS association in one ancestry group and an experiment-wide significant discordant effect (p<6.1×10⁻⁴) in at least another ancestry. Since the trans-ancestry GWS associations were mostly driven by the European-ancestry sample size, we investigated the differences of allele frequency (Δ_AF) and linkage-disequilibrium regulome tagging (Δ_LD) between European populations and the other ancestries. Within loci with concordant effects, the degree of heterogeneity was associated with European – Middle Eastern Δ_AF (p=9.04×10⁻⁶) and Δ_LD of European populations with respect to African, Admixed-American, and Central/South Asian groups (p=8.21×10⁻⁴, p=7.17×10⁻⁴, and p=2.16×10⁻³, respectively). Within loci with discordant effects, Δ_AF and Δ_LD of European populations with respect to African and Central/South Asian ancestries was associated with the degree of heterogeneity (Δ_AF: p=7.69×10⁻³ and p=5.31×10⁻³, Δ_LD: p=0.016 and p=2.65×10⁻⁴, respectively). Considering the traits associated with cross-ancestry heterogeneous loci, we observed enrichments for blood biomarkers (p=5.7×10⁻³⁵) and physical appearance (p=1.38×10⁻⁴). This suggests that these specific phenotypic domains may present considerable cross-ancestry heterogeneity due to large allele frequency and LD variation among worldwide populations.