Coronavirus-related online web search desire amidst the rising novel coronavirus incidence in Ethiopia: Google Trends-based infodemiology

Background

Globally, the emerging of the COVID-19 pandemic is still at its rise affecting more people. The family of coronaviruses is already known for its spread of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) in China and Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS) in Saudi Arabia in 2003 and 2012, respectively [1]. Bats are believed to be the nidus for virus transmission, remaining as an intermediary zoonosis [2,3]. As compared to its peers, COVID-19 is a highly infectious disease, and worldwide nearly six million confirmed COVID-19 cases were recorded, as of late May 2020 [4].

Until May 22, 2020, COVID-19 infections were reported from 54 countries in Africa with cumulative confirmed cases of nearly a hundred thousand, and above three thousand deaths [5]. The first confirmed COVID-19 case in this continent was from Egypt and then Algeria [6,7]. In Ethiopia, the first COVID-19 case was detected and reported on March 13, 2020. Thereafter, incidences of COVID-19 cases in the country are increasing day to day and as of late May 2020 report, there were a total of 831 confirmed COVID-19 cases and 7 confirmed deaths [8].

During a disease outbreak, social communication and behaviors are believed to be just as important to public health as tests and diagnosis [9]. As a result, with the emerging spread of COVID-19, individual activity in almost all social media reaches its peak. Various studies on the mode of using social media for assessing knowledge, health promotion messaging and crisis communication has been carried out [10–12]. Additionally, the advancement in surveillance systems has enabled the scientific community to assess a large amount of real-time data globally which helps stakeholders to identify primary issues of concerns and address them. Sources for these real-time data include Google searches, Facebook, twitter posts, Wikipedia access, and Google plus [1,13].

The science which deals with the determinants and distribution of information in an electronic medium, in particular the internet sources, or in a population to inform public health and public policy is called infodemiology [14,15]. Google Trends is the most widely used website for infodemiologic studies of public health concern. It has advantages for analyzing, monitoring, forecasting, and nowcasting health topics related to infectious disease outbreaks and others [16,17]. There are about 526 million internet users in Africa and 4.2 million in Ethiopia [18]. According to the 2020 report, Africa’s internet penetration was estimated to be 39.3%, in Ethiopia, the estimated penetration was 17.8 % [19].

On online search metrics, like Google Trends, changes in the trends of information and communication on the internet can indicate changes in public health which can have a negative or positive impact. Especially during an outbreak, there will be a circulation of misinformation in the communities. Fake news, misleading, and misinformation circulating online in the community are referred to as infodemic monikers. Thus, checking the trends of information related to public health concerns is highly crucial, particularly during disease outbreak [13]. So far infodemiologic studies are limited in Africa, as well as in Ethiopia. As a result, this study explored users’ concern towards coronavirus-related online web searches and examined the extent of infodemic monikers adopted for identifying the virus in the country in the early stage of COVID-19 spread in Ethiopia.

Methods

Data analysis

To determine the average trend of the various Google queries at the national and regional level, we used the APC index, which is the RSV mean value over the considered period. Each keyword APC has been presented with a 95% confidence interval. To do this, we calculated the standard error of the mean (SEM) as σ/√N, with σ standard deviation; then, we built the interval [APC-2×SEM, APC+2×SEM]. Furthermore, for all the regions whose data were accessible, we looked for any linear correlation between the number of COVID-19 cases per region and the various health-related searches. The Pearson coefficient expressing the above correlation was indicated with the letter “R” and reported with its p-value. We chose R=0 as H₀null hypothesis (R ≠ 0 as H₁ resp.) and α = .05 as a threshold value.

Results

Covid-19 identification search

The top names adopted by the Google users to identify the virus in Ethiopia were “corona,” “virus,” “coronavirus,” “corona virus”, “China coronavirus,” and “COVID-19” (Fig 1).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1: Shows the trends of the main names adopted by Google users to identify the virus in Ethiopia over the study period.

The overall trends starting from the first COVID-19 case report in Ethiopia showed the greatest relative search value for the keyword “corona” followed by “coronavirus,” with APC of 60 (95% CI, 55 – 66) and 55 (95% CI, 50 - 60), respectively. On April 06, the search for the keyword “corona” achieved the highest RSV (100), while the highest RSV (92) for the keyword “coronavirus” was on April 05, 2020. Starting from April 18 the searching trend was changed, and the term “coronavirus” became the predominantly searched term followed by the term “corona”. Of the keywords searched by the users to identify the virus, nearly all of them are infodemic monikers in type (overall relative search percentage of 99%) (Table 1).

Health-related search

The top five searches related to health in Ethiopia after the first COVID-19 case report were grouped under COVID-19 related “Updates,” “Mortality,” “Symptoms,” “Cures” and “Prevention”. On average, the keyword “updates”-related search was the highest of all searched term (a total APC of 72, 95% CI, 66 – 79) followed by “mortality” related (a total APC of 14, 95% CI, 12 – 16) and “symptoms” related (a total APC of 11, 95% CI, 9 – 12) queries (see Additional file 2). On April 02, 2020, the “updates” related searches in Ethiopia reached the highest (total RSV, 125). The “mortality” related searches reached a maximum peak (total RSV, 38) on April 10, 2020, whereas “Cures” related searches reached the highest peak (total RSV, 36) on April 22, 2020 (Table 2).

The public desire towards health-related Google search over the specified period indicated an initial rise in the health-related search desire, but a decline in this interest was noticed over time. (Fig 2).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 2: Shows trends of the health-related Google searches by the users over the specified period.

Distribution of health-related cumulative Google searches across regions and cities

Distribution of health-related cumulative searches indicated the highest maximum peak search in the Oromia region (cumulative total RSVs, 536) followed by the Tigray (cumulative total RSVs, 512) and Southern Nations, Nationalities, and Peoples Region (cumulative total RSVs, 492) on searching health-related information (Fig 3).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 3: Shows the cumulative Google searches made to health-related searches over the specified period.

The frequently searched keyword was “local updates”; with the highest relative search percentage seen from Afar (93%), and the least from Addis Ababa (48%) (Table 3).

The peak total RSV for the search term “local updates” related issue for Afar and Oromia region (total RSV, 100 each) was the highest, whereas for the“world update” related issue the highest total RSV was observed from Oromia (total RSV, 100) followed by Tigray region (total RSV, 98). The “cures” related issues RSV was highest for the Tigray region (total RSV, 100) and lowest for the Afar (total RSV, 0). Both the “symptoms,” and “prevention” related issue queries achieved the highest total RSV for Addis Ababa (total RSV, 100 each), while “mortality” related issue search was the highest in the Oromia region (total RSV,100) followed by Southern Nations, Nationalities, and Peoples Region (total RSV, 75) and Tigray region (total RSV,74). In the correlation test between the Google health searches and COVID-19 cases per region, all p-values confirmed the null hypothesis i.e. no significant linear correlation was detected (Table 4).

The distribution of COVID-19 cases across the regions/city versus the total Google Tends health-related searches is depicted in the scatter plot below (Fig 4).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 4:

Scatter plot showing the distribution of COVID-19 cases across the regions/city versus the total Google Tends of health-related searches interest over the specified period.

Discussion

In this explorative infodemiology study, we tried to investigate the trend of online search behaviors towards coronavirus in the early stage of COVID-19 spread in Ethiopia using Google Trends. We have also attempted to determine the extent of infodemic monikers used for identifying the virus in the country. On average the term “corona” was the predominantly adopted name in the community for identifying the virus, and the keyword “updates” related search was the highest of all health searches on Google throughout the study period. In almost all searches to identify the virus from Google, the users adopted infodemic monikers. Distribution of health-related cumulative searches indicated the highest maximum peak search in the Oromia region as compared to the others. No significant correlation was noted between the Google health searches and the number of COVID-19 cases per region.

The social contagion of infodemic monikers (erroneous, misleading, and misinformation) during the COVID-19 outbreak has affected global efforts to fight the epidemic. This has resulted in the high demand for timely and trustworthy information about COVID-19 during the outbreak [29]. In our study, 99% of the keywords used in Google search to identify the virus were infodemic. These terms are either they will not specifically identify the COVID-19 (these are keywords: “corona”, “Coronavirus”, “Virus” and “corona virus”) or they are stigmatic ascribing the virus to a specific ethnic group (China coronavirus). They are prone to transmit inappropriate information in the community. Provided that most of the horns of African countries, including Ethiopia are predicted to have a severely alarming epidemic prognosis, the circulation of these misleading and misinformation will probably impose a significant impact in the process of containing COVID-19 in this region [30].

Looking at the trends of the virus name adopted for search in Google, on April 06, 2020, the keyword “corona” has achieved the highest peak search. This happened one day after the first COVID-19 related death report in Ethiopia [31,32]. On this day, the global reports of confirmed COVID-19 cases were above 1 million [4]. On the other hand, April 02, 2020, marked the highest “updates” related Google searches in Ethiopia. This was the day that marked above one million confirmed COVID-19 cases, worldwide [8]. Navigation of health-related cumulative Google search distribution across regions/city in Ethiopia indicated the highest maximum peak search in the Oromia region followed by the Tigray region on searching health-related information. In Ethiopia, the first COVID-19 case was reported in the Adama city, Oromia region`s capital. This has led to the early complete ban of public transportation systems in the region [33]. The Tigray region was also the first to declare a 15-day region-wide state of emergency, like banning all travel and public activities including, closure of all cafes, restaurants, and banning of landlords from evicting tenants or increasing rent. Additionally, any travelers entering the region were also required to report to the nearest health offices [34,35]. These scenarios might have alerted the public in both regions to highly desire online information towards COVID-19 related health issues.

Conclusions and recommendations

This study indicated an initial increase in the interest of COVID-19 related Google search, but this interest was declined after some time. Tremendous circulation of infodemic monikers related to identifying the virus was also noticed in the country. Furthermore, numbers of COVID-19 cases across the regions/city was not found to have a significant association with the highest peak health-related searches. Based on the findings, the authors of this study recommend the government and other stakeholders to work immensely to keep the public alert on coronavirus-related issues. Additionally, the official names of the virus, like “COVID-19”, “SARS-CoV-2” have to be promoted in the public to decrease the circulation of misleading and misinformation amid the outbreak.

Declarations

Supplementary files

Additional file 1: keywords having the same concept and categorized together to identify the virus name related queries

Additional file 2: keywords having nearly the same concept and categorized together to identify the health-related users’ queries

Additional file 3: Dataset .csv file: Coronavirus-related online web search desire amidst the rising novel coronavirus incidence in Ethiopia: google trends-based infodemiology