ABSTRACT
SARS-CoV-2 was declared a global pandemic by the World Health Organization (WHO) and was met with lockdown policies to curb the spread of the disease. This meant that 890 million students in 114 countries would be affected by the closure of their educational institutes, affecting their mental health. Mental health disorders are suggested to have a well-correlated link to suicide, which is the third most leading cause of death worldwide amongst children aged 15-19 years. According to WHO, “health is a state of complete physical, mental and social wellbeing and not merely the absence of disease.” Hence the isolation brought about by SARS-CoV-2 is postulated to cause anxiety, fear, and depression amongst the pediatric population, due to the loss of socialization and separation from friends. In this systematic review and meta-analysis, we highlight the major mental health issues in children aged 2-18 years, along with their causes, effects, and potential solutions to tackle these problems.
INTRODUCTION
The novel coronavirus (n-CoV) stemmed as a local epidemic in the Wuhan City of China and presented as viral pneumonia of unknown aetiology. Once the nasopharyngeal samples were utilized to do a reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) testing, it became evident, that this was a mutated version of the notorious Coronavirus family 1. What started as a Wuhan endemic disease, soon spread to other parts of the world and was declared as ‘pandemic’ by the World Health Organization on 12th March 2020 2. To date, 16th June 2020, this virus infected more than 9 million people with >470,000 deaths (mortality rate: 5.19%).
In an attempt to reduce the spread of viral disease, lockdown policies were enforced all around the globe. This measure included the closure of the school and other educational institutes. According to an estimate from United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO), 890 million students in 114 countries would be impacted due to these policies, which makes up for 86% of the world’s student population 3. Even though the closure of institutes in an attempt to curb a health crisis is not a new policy, however, the global exponential increase in the viral spread and disruptions of travel in terms of preventing students from reuniting with their family in such times 4, can and has caused significant psychological distress 5.
In this review, we highlight the major themes of mental health which have impacted the children during SARS-CoV-2. These children range from ages 2-18, and hence includes mostly school children and early collegiate students. We also discuss the challenges to the mental health of children who are already suffering from a particular disease process such as Cystic Fibrosis and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder.
METHODS
This systematic review addresses the impact SARS-CoV-2 had on the pediatric population during SARS-CoV-2. This pediatric population would include individuals who are either tested positive for the viral infection or not and include individuals who were either healthy before this viral infection or were already going through a specific disease process. The PICO Question for this particular review is:
Population
Pediatric population (age range: 2-18 years)
Intervention
SARS-CoV-2
Control
No disease process, healthy individuals, and individuals who were suffering from any disease other than SARS-CoV-2
Outcomes
Mental health outcomes such as Stress, Anxiety, Anger and Depression
Study Design
Case-control, cross-sectional, cohort studies and case series (cases reported >4), letters, perspectives and correspondences
Time Frame
The disease duration: 2019-2020
Search Strategy
An exhaustive literature review was conducted on four major databases, PubMed, CINAHL, Science Direct and Wiley Online Library; and a pre-print server, medRxiv to capture grey literature. The following search string was used: ((“COVID” OR “SARS” OR “n-CoV” OR “Novel Coronavirus”) AND (“Mental Health” OR “Depression” OR “Anxiety” OR “Stress” OR “Anger”) AND (“Child” OR “Paediatric” OR “Pediatric” OR “Adolescent”)). Concerning medRxiv, the search strategy was changed to multiple short searches using the keywords identified in the above search string. The following filters were used to narrow down the search: published in the years: 2019-2020, articles published in English Language and human subjects. A further filter used in Science Direct search included the article type to narrow down the search to only research articles and case reports.
Selection Strategy
All the articles were downloaded in a new Endnote library, and two independent authors screened the non-duplicate articles on the base of title and abstract according to the following selection criteria. Any discrepancies in selection were resolved by a third independent author.
Selection Criteria
Inclusion Criteria
Addressing mental health issues pertaining to depression, anxiety, and stress
Articles addressing mental health issues during SARS-CoV-2
Articles addressing mental health in either healthy individuals or hospitalized patients.
Articles published in the English Language
Case-control studies, cross-sectional studies, cohort papers and case series (cases reported >4)
Letter to the editors and correspondences were included to increase the depth of review
Exclusion Criteria
Articles addressing the parent’s conception of a child’s mental health
Review articles, case reports (cases reported<4), and clinical trial protocols
Initially, the authors decided to exclude letter to the editors, perspectives and correspondences, however, since most articles on this topic were based on such formats, and exclusion of these articles would decrease the content of the manuscript; the authors have decided to include them. The shortlisted articles were then downloaded for full-text review according to the inclusion criteria mentioned above, and any discrepancies in selection were resolved by a third independent author.
Data Extraction & Analysis
The shortlisted articles were then extracted on a structured excel worksheet. Separate qualitative and quantitative analysis spreadsheets were developed to aid in the review process. Quantitative analysis was carried out using Cochrane’s Review Manager-aiding in meta-analysis and develop of the forest-plot diagram.
Risk Bias Assessment
To carry out a risk bias assessment, Newcastle Ottawa Scoring (NOS) System was used for case-control study and modified NOS scale used for Cross-Sectional Study. Articles which did report bias were excluded from the library. NOS measures the risk bias and quality of the research on bases of three variables: selection, comparability and exposure. A score of 7 or more is expected to be a good score. Any study which reported a score of less than 7 was excluded from the final library.
RESULTS & DISCUSSION
After a thorough screening process, a total of thirteen studies were shortlisted, which included one pre-print article from MedRxiv. PRISMA guidelines were followed to ensure standardization. A step by step record of included and excluded studies were recorded in a PRISMA flow diagram, displayed in Figure 1.
Risk bias assessment of all shortlisted studies was carried out using a NOS score or a modified NOS score as shown in Table 1. All four studies eligible for analysis had a score of ≥ 7 and hence were included in the study.
Table 2 shows the detailed characteristics of the studies included for review. As explained in the methods, to expand the pool of knowledge, the authors had to include qualitative accounts such as editorials and viewpoints. Only two studies involved children who were already involved in a disease process, i.e. Senkalfa et al. who evaluated the mental health status of patients suffering from cystic fibrosis and Zhang J et al. who explored SARS-CoV-2 mental health impact on patients with ADHD.
The authors then discussed the major mental health themes identified in these papers. Among the major mental health issues identified were stress, anxiety, depression, boredom and the fear of getting infected. Table 4 discusses all of these major themes in detail and provides a brief explanation for all of these findings. The table also briefs on possible solutions identified in the paper regarding the problems highlighted in the paper.
Three papers were identified to be included in the quantitative analysis; Senkalfa et al., Zheng Y et al., and Zhang J et al. A detailed highlight of data extracted from these studies can be visualized in Table 5. We address the major mental health determinants in the study population and pin them against the control population using means and standard deviations for the ease of comparison.
A statistical analysis of whether SARS-CoV-2 has impacted mental health has been carried out on two papers eligible for a meta-analysis. The papers authored by Senkalfa et al. and Zheng et al. analyzed the development of anxiety between the study and control population. Cochrane’s Review Manager was utilized to carry out the meta-analysis and make a forest plot, as shown in Figure 2. The analysis revealed an overall z-score of 0.85 (p=0.39) with Heterogeneity: Tau2 = 3.27; Chi2 =48.44, df= 1 (p<0.00001); I2 = 98%. It is evident that there exists significant heterogeneity in the studies and that there was a non-significant weak correlation between anxiety in the case and control group.
A global pandemic such as SARS-CoV-2 can bring with it, a huge toll on an individual’s psychology. Past research and recent data 19 have shown that individuals can exhibit fear and anxiety-prone distress responses which can either stem from a fear of getting infected themselves, or of their loved ones, and the socio-economic consequences this crisis can bring with it- such as loss of jobs. The loss of jobs can directly impact the growth and development of the child, directly impacting their mental health. Low and Middle-Income Countries (LMIC) such as Pakistan have a large majority of the population who are either daily wagers or depend on their weekly incomes to feed their families. With predicted three million people losing jobs (one million in industrial; two million in the services sector) and poverty headcount to soar from 24.3% to 33.5% 20- many families are expected to be pushed towards starvation, rendering children more vulnerable to an already prevailing malnutrition and mental health deterioration.
It is of vital importance to make sure that the time children spend at home during the lockdowns does not negatively impact their mental health. Among things which should be taken into consideration, the excessive use of the internet cannot be ignored. Deslandes and colleague 21 pointed out how excessive use of the internet during home isolation can render an individual prone to self-harm. This observation comes amidst fear of the ‘unseen virus’ and the easily available paranoia of infections and death tolls in their communities. Hence, organizations such as WHO and UNICEF 22, 23 suggest that the information on the pandemic must be controlled by the parents, without hiding facts, however ensuring that it is communicated in a medium that can be easily understood by children of different age groups. This will enable them to validate their emotions and express their feelings, about the ongoing circumstances.
CONCLUSION
An analysis of available literature illustrates a clear correlation between increasing anxiety amongst children during the SARS-CoV-2 pandemic. Our systematic review encompasses school- going and early collegiate students who have shown to suffer from a deteriorating mental status due to the fear of being infected, a feeling of boredom, and lack of productivity, which adds on to the stress level hindering their focused approach to learning. A quick summary of our review is made in Table 5.
Data Availability
All the data included in the paper has been added in the manuscript and in freely available.
DISCLOSURES
Ethics approval and consent to participate
All procedures performed on patient laboratory samples in this study were in accordance with the ethical standards of the Institute Ethics Committee and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards.
Consent for publication
Not Applicable
Availability of data and materials
The corresponding authors would be highly obliged to share the relevant data and materials of this work on the request of the journal’s editor.
Competing Interests
All authors report no competing interests
Funding
All the authors affirm that no funding was obtained for the conduction of this study
Author Contributions
Mir Ibrahim Sajid and Javeria Tariq were involved in manuscript writing and analysis, Ayesha Akbar Waheed and Dur-e Najaf were involved in the screening of the papers using title, abstract and later full text, Samira Shabbir Balouch and Sajid Abaidullah supervised the project and proof-read before submission.
Acknowledgements
None
Footnotes
Email Addresses (in order): ibisajid{at}gmail.com, javeria.tariq{at}scholar.aku.edu, ayeshaakbar.786{at}gmail.com, najaf.dure{at}yahoo.com, samirasajid69{at}gmail.com, sajidabaidullahemw{at}hotmail.com