Endometriosis And Chronic Pelvic Pain Have Similar Impact On Women, But Time To Diagnosis Is Decreasing: An Australian Survey

Introduction

Chronic pain in women and girls has been identified as a top five health concern by Australian women ¹ and is identified by a government report as an Australian National Women’s Health Priority ². There are a variety of causes for chronic pelvic pain (CPP) including endometriosis, adenomyosis, chronic infection, vulvodynia irritable bowel syndrome or bladder pain syndrome. Endometriosis is the most common cause of CPP ³, accounting for 24-40% of all CPP diagnoses ^4,5 and has a prevalence rate of around 11% in Australia ⁶. Some people have no demonstrated pathology despite detailed surgical investigation or imaging, leading to a diagnosis of Chronic Pelvic Pain Syndrome (CPPS).

It has been repeatedly demonstrated internationally that endometriosis has a long diagnostic delay ⁷, impacts people’s health and wellbeing ⁸, including social activities ⁹, mental and emotional health ^10,11, work/finances ^9,12, and sexual relationships ¹³; and those with endometriosis report physical quality of life similar to that of cancer patients ⁹. While most research has focused on endometriosis, it is possible that people with non-endometriosis related CPP experience similar issues but possibly with less severe impact ¹⁴, however there is a paucity of research in this area.

The aim of this survey was to determine in an Australian population, with endometriosis or non-endometriosis related CPP, the process of diagnosis, the prevalence of different CPP symptoms, and to explore the management and impact on people’s social, sexual/romantic, work, and academic lives.

Methods

Results

409 valid responses were received. 340 of these people had endometriosis (83%) and 69 (17%) had CPP without a current diagnosis of endometriosis. Table 1 outlines the demographic characteristics of survey participants. The mean age of respondents identifying as being affected by endometriosis was 30.6 (±7) and CPP was 33.7 (±16.3) years. The majority of respondents earned between AUD$510-$1500 per week, with a little more than half of people across both groups held either university or post-secondary qualifications. In people with endometriosis, 33.7% reported stage IV disease at their most recent laparoscopy.

Discussion

Data from this study demonstrates that people with CPP, irrespective of diagnosis, commonly report moderate to severe pelvic pain symptoms, consistent with recent research on endometriosis ²¹. People with endometriosis frequently report symptom onset (most commonly dysmenorrhea and pelvic pain) in their late teens and overall report an eight year diagnostic delay from symptom onset. Nearly three years of this delay is due to the person not presenting to their medical care provider and the remaining 5 years between initial presentation to a doctor and a surgical diagnosis of endometriosis. This is similar to the delay reported in other studies ^9,22 and may, at least be in part, be due to a normalization of the severe dysmenorrhea that is frequently reported in young people with pelvic pain ^23-25. It may also represent commonly held beliefs that even moderate or greater severity menstrual or pelvic pain is a normal part of ‘becoming a woman’ or ‘something you need to put up with’ as documented in qualitative studies ^22,26,27. However, our findings indicate that this delay in presentation to a medical professional is reducing over time, with those reporting their symptoms that have started more recently showing a shorter time delay in seeking medical attention. This may be due to an increased awareness of the symptoms of endometriosis and encouragement to seek medical assistance for these through the efforts of advocacy organizations and the recent increased media coverage of endometriosis including events such as Endometriosis Awareness Month. A variety of educational programs, both in person and online, designed to improve awareness of menstruation and endometriosis have also been developed for Australia and elsewhere ^28-32. Most of these resources have been implemented in 2019 and beyond, therefore, given the timing of our survey, it is too soon to see whether these programs may contribute to any further reduction in diagnostic delay.

Similarly, the clinician seeing the person with CPP for the first time may normalize those symptoms ²² or provide other diagnoses such as irritable bowel syndrome or sexually transmitted infections ^27,33, which can lead to frustration for the patient and further delay in appropriate management that targets their symptoms. Since the introduction of the ESHRE guideline on endometriosis in 2005, there appears to be a significant reduction in both the number of doctors seen before diagnosis and the time between seeking medical help and a diagnosis of endometriosis. It is unclear at this time if an earlier diagnosis of endometriosis will improve pain and fertility outcomes. However, earlier identification of abnormal menstrual symptoms in early education programs ²⁸ may allow for an earlier intervention that could change the course of disease and, at least, improve the quality of life of those affected if appropriately managed. This goal is identified in the Australian National Action Plan for Endometriosis ³⁴ and needs further investigation in future research studies.

Pain and the associated symptom of fatigue is commonly seen in people with endometriosis ^21,35 and are significant contributors to both the work and education-related absenteeism and presenteeism seen in our respondents ²⁷. Fatigue is a common symptom in people with endometriosis and other types of pelvic pain with 39-43% of respondents reporting that symptom at the onset and all clinicians should ask about this symptom when taking a history of a person presenting with pelvic pain. The fatigue experienced may be debilitating ³⁶ and there is a strong correlation between pain severity and fatigue ³⁷, almost certainly explaining why chronic fatigue syndrome is much more common in people with endometriosis than the general population ³⁷. Educational absenteeism in our survey led to giving up study for 25-50% of people. This is notable since academic achievement declines with any absenteeism ^38,39. Absenteeism also increases social isolation and decreases engagement with peers. The community ⁴⁰ and the consequential cessation of education may substantially limit long-term opportunities for people with endometriosis and CPP.

Previous international surveys ^8,9 and qualitative research ^22,27 have highlighted the impact of endometriosis on social activities and marital/sexual relationships. We also demonstrated that personal relationships, whether friendships or those of a romantic/sexual nature, were negatively impacted by endometriosis and CPP. Reasons for this may include the fatigue experienced reducing social interactions ^35,37 and increased anxiety of experiencing heavy menstrual bleeding, nausea, gastrointestinal and bladder symptoms ²⁷ in public places when interacting with friends, family or others. Similar to previous work ¹³, romantic and sexual relationships were commonly affected in both cohorts, with pain as a direct contributor, but fatigue, nausea, depression, and other co-morbidities also, often, contributing to relationship strain and potential breakdown ⁴¹.

Compared to those with endometriosis people with CPP had symptom onset later, in their early 20s, but with similar presenting symptoms. Previous work also identified a substantial number of people who report CPP symptoms but have not been given any diagnosis ^42,43. Of course, pelvic pain may later be diagnosed as endometriosis ²¹ but most importantly, our work confirms that both diagnosed and non-diagnosed CPP causes substantive negative impact on work, education, sexual relationships, family and friendships. It is therefore necessary to identify and have a treatment plan for pelvic pain symptoms, regardless of the current or future diagnosis.

There are a number of strengths of this study. Whilst this is the first Australian study for endometriosis and there exist similar estimates from other countries ^8,44,45, there are no previous data on the impact of CPP. The use of the WERF EndoCost tool also allows comparison between datasets generated between different centers. However, there are limitations of this study that must be acknowledged. The overall sample size is small, which may reflect the in-depth nature of the questionnaires, which required up to 45 minutes to complete. Respondents were asked to answer the endometriosis section only if they had a histologically confirmed surgical diagnosis although confirmatory evidence of that was not possible. We recognize that people designated to the CPP cohort may have undiagnosed endometriosis, which is an eventual diagnosis in 33-75% ^36,37 of this group. Importantly, our study demonstrates similar negative impacts across many domains irrespective of diagnosis. We did not collect data on geographical location of respondents, so it is possible that our sample did not represent potential variations in the access to appropriately specialised health care professionals, work, or educational opportunities. Respondents were predominantly Caucasian, and therefore caution must be heeded in extrapolating these findings to other culturally and linguistically diverse groups. Given the timing of the survey in early 2017, there may be a ceiling effect with respect to diagnostic delay for the cohort that presented to their health care professional after 2013. However, the reported diagnostic delay observed between 2005-2012 is unlikely to be affected by any ceiling effect. Finally, our recruitment was almost solely via advisory and support groups on social media, and people recruited via this method are likely to have more severe symptoms than those recruited in other settings such as tertiary care ⁴⁶. So it is possible that our respondents may be biased towards a more severe impact of their symptoms on their lives and may not represent the population of people with endometriosis as a whole.

Conclusion

People with CPP, regardless of a diagnosis of endometriosis, experience significant negative impact across a range of domains including education, work, social, and romantic/sexual relationships, which may have long lasting consequences if not appropriately recognised and managed through access to adequate health care resources. Our findings suggest that there has been a significant decrease in diagnostic delay over time, possibly due to improved guidelines and advocacy. However, the diagnostic delay still exists and still carries a significant burden to those suffering CPP. Widespread, evidence based educational programs, recognising the symptom profile of CPP, for both the public and medical providers, are urgently needed to help reduce this delay and implement and provide access to the most appropriate management plan for these people.

Author contributions

All authors contributed significantly to this work. MA, KL, CS and JA designed the study. MA, KL, JS and MH performed the data collection and statistical analysis. MA and JS drafted the article. JA, CS, CN and KL contributed to critical revisions on the manuscript. All authors reviewed the manuscript and approved the final draft.

Competing interests

MA,JS, CS: As a medical research institute, NICM Health Research Institute receives research grants and donations from foundations, universities, government agencies and industry. Sponsors and donors provide untied and tied funding for work to advance the vision and mission of the Institute. This study was not specifically supported by donor or sponsor funding to NICM. MA is a member of the clinical advisory board for Endometriosis Australia.

JA: Medical Director, Endometriosis Australia (NFP)

KL: None known.

CN: None known.

MH: None known.

Data availability

The datasets generated during and/or analysed during the current study are available from the corresponding author on reasonable request.