Willingness and acceptability of anxiety and depression screening among women living with HIV in Ethiopia

Introduction

Depression, a common mental disorder which affects more than 300 million individuals of all age groups in this world wide. This disorder which is more common in women than men, is the primary cause of disability and one of the main contributors of global disease burden (1) including suicide (2,3).

Depression affects about 20% of women during their lifetime, with reproductive health problems being a period of high vulnerability (4). It is also predicted that depression which is estimated to be the second leading cause of disease and disability in the world in 2020, will be twice common in women than men (5–9).

Anxiety and depression is common among people living with HIV infection (5,10–18). High and low-income countries have presented higher rates of depression in people living with HIV when compared with HIV negative individuals. The level of depression mostly appears to be related to the severity of symptoms of HIV infection (19).

In developing countries, depression is also one of the main challenges that should be addressed when dealing with HIV prevention strategies, as the two illnesses are intensely associated and aggravate each other. In recent evidences, depression and depressive symptoms are found to be the key predictors of poor adherence to HIV treatment (20) and negatively impact on clinical outcomes (21).

So far, depression is highly prevalent in Ethiopia, and it is considered as one of the common psychiatric disorders affecting women as its associates are gender-specific (5–10,14,22,23). One of the findings conducted in Ethiopia showed that there is high prevalence of depression on people living with HIV/AIDS and stated that 38.94% of the studied participants were depressed (7). Another systematic review conducted in Ethiopia has presented that the pooled prevalence of depression was higher among People Living with HIV than the general population (24).

Regardless of its prevalence among people living with HIV, depression and anxiety are commonly under diagnosed by health care providers. More than half of those eligible patients, miss the opportunity to be screened for anxiety and depression disorders by doctors (25).

Furthermore, people with chronic illnesses are usually unwilling to seek health professional support and counselling. A mong people who manifest depressive symptoms, less number is reported to seek treatment in their course of disorder (26,27).

Even though the significance of depression screening for the intervention and care of HIV patients in health facilities has been long recognized, yet little is known about the acceptability and predictive factors related with the acceptance of anxiety and depression screening among women attending HIV care services. Therefore, this study will examine the acceptability and the predictive factors associated with screening of anxiety and depression among women Living with HIV. The findings of this study can be a baseline for the introduction of anxiety and depression screening in HIV care services of health facilities in Ethiopia.

Methods and materials

Results

Discussion and conclusion

In this study we examined the acceptance of anxiety and depression screening among women living with HIV who attend the antiretroviral treatment care. The findings of this study has shown that the acceptance rate for screening of anxiety and depression among the study participants was 87.3% and this indicates relatively lower proportion when compared to a study conducted on depression and anxiety among pregnant women in Kilimanjaro, Tanzania in which 96.2% of the respondents accepted the screening. (11) and another similar study on prevalence of depressive symptoms on women in Sabah, Malaysia were 92.2% in which women accepted to undergo screening for the study (29).

Probably, the reason for the variation of the findings might be the difference in the study population, since the later studied on pregnant women who possibly had more frequent visit and follow up in their health facilities. One unanticipated finding shows regardless of the acceptability level of the participants, the awareness of the respondents about the availability of anxiety and depression screening was low (28.1%), when compared to other studies conducted earlier in different settings. The reason could be explained non-existence of proper mental health education sessions in the facility where the patients were expected to receive information.

The results of this study shows that the majority of the participants who accepted the screening were holding college level education. Hereafter, education denote the formal education obtained in academics and not merely the health related knowledge of the women participants. This finding is consistent with other studies which presented that positive association between higher educational level and women’s attitude towards anxiety and depression interventions (30,27). It is common in Ethiopia, that low service utilization is typically associated with the poor literacy among women. In line with this, it is found that HIV patients with no formal education was more likely to develop distress (31). As a result, education and awareness pay a major role in reducing the unmet needs in health service utilization including depression screening.

The respondents who were divorced, and those who were self employed by occupation were more likely to accept the screening. Contrary to expectations, and not common in low income countries where women empowerment is low, this finding may determine the autonomy of women for taking decisions in regard to health seeking when they are economically independent (32). However, among the married women, their claim of partner approval was the main reason of opting out the screening offer. Thus, in marital union, male involvement in decision making for the screening uptake was acknowledged.

Most of the study participants has mentioned health care provider’s as their main source of information to take part the screening. Although, this study did not initially identify the reasons for the high acceptance rate, the health provider’s initiated counselling could be the motive for the high acceptance rate. One of the HCP’s drive could be ascribed to their intention to practice the protocol of Ethiopia’s national guideline for comprehensive HIV prevention, care and treatment which suggests the screen for depression among the HIV patients in regard to. (33). Despite, the HCPs recognize that the screening was prominently required service, however it was not practiced in the studied health set up. This is common in major health facilities where depression is often unnoticed and not practiced (34). This could be attributed to the reality on the ground which is related with the practicality, availability of validated tools, less number of trained professionals, and overall the guiding principle of the hospital implementation plan. Depending on the regional difference, these limited service provision was recognized to increase a large proportion of patients, remain un-detected in the ART.

Moreover, a larger proportion of the participants who accepted the screening had a history of previous screening of depression and anxiety. This similar to other studies which concluded that women who had a previous engagement in screening were more receptive and willing to accept the screening (35–37). Yet, the type of screening tool and their decision process determines their choice to accept the screening. As several studies has published that women understandings and decision manners commonly regulates their response and acceptance of the screening (38–40). Thus, in order to reduce the frequent challenges of integrating mental health with the comprehensive HIV care and minimize the unmet need of HIV women to be screened for depression, recent findings suggest that ART attendees should be invited for depression screening and eligible clients should be linked for further examination and treatment (41).

Conclusion

As the screening of symptomatic depression in HIV patients has recorded an apparent health implication for the adherence of treatment and care, health care providers should consider a routine check-up for the HIV patient’s neurocognitive functioning and wellbeing. This research has shown that women participant living with HIV were willing to undergo the screening for depression and anxiety. Therefore, all concerned bodies like health organizations should enhance efforts that promote mental health interventions in order to address vulnerable community member like people living with comorbid diseases; HIV and depression.

Conflict of interest

There is no conflict of interest among authors in this article.

Ethics approval and consent to participate

All the study procedures were according the ethical standard of the institution’s human ethical procedure. The ethical approval of this study was obtained from the IIUM Research Ethics Committee (IREC) (Reference: IIUM/305/14/11/2/IREC/2018-042. Dated: 04/01/2019). A permission letter was also gained from the Jijiga University board of review. The women participants in this study were provided a written document approved by IREC and informed consent then confirmed by their signatures for the use and dissemination of the study findings.

Consent for publication

Not applicable

Data availability

The qualitative data included in this study is available from the authors upon request.

Funding

This study has not received any funds or grants from any institution or public and private sectors.

Authors contribution

AY and SR: conception and design, data collection, statistical analysis, interpretation of data and drafting the manuscript. RM and ML: critical revision of the manuscript. All authors have contributed and approved this manuscript.