Abstract
The recent outbreak of the novel coronavirus SARS-CoV-2, which causes COVID-19, can be diagnosed using RT-qPCR, but inadequate access to reagents and equipment has slowed disease detection and impeded efforts to mitigate viral spread. Alternative approaches based on combinations of isothermal amplification and CRISPR-mediated detection, such as the SHERLOCK (Specific High Sensitivity Enzymatic Reporter UnLOCKing) technique, offer reduced dependence on RT-qPCR equipment, but previously reported methods required multiple fluid handling steps, complicating their deployment outside clinical labs. Here we developed a simple test chemistry called STOP (SHERLOCK Testing in One Pot) for detecting SARS-CoV-2 in one hour that is suitable for point-of-care use. This simplified test, STOPCovid, provides sensitivity comparable to RT-qPCR-based SARS-CoV-2 tests and has a limit of detection of 100 copies of viral genome input in saliva or nasopharyngeal swabs per reaction. Using lateral flow readout, the test returns result in 70 minutes, and using fluorescence readout, the test returns result in 40 minutes. Moreover, we validated STOPCovid using nasopharyngeal swabs from COVID-19 patients and were able to correctly diagnose 12 positive and 5 negative patients out of 3 replicates. We envision that implementation of STOPCovid will significantly aid “test-trace-isolate” efforts, especially in low-resource settings, which will be critical for long-term public health safety and effective reopening of the society.
Introduction
Rapid point-of-care (POC) tests capable of operating in any low-resource setting, including at home, are needed to adequately combat the COVID-19 pandemic and reopen society. POC tests for SARS-CoV-2, the novel coronavirus causing COVID-19 disease, that have been authorized by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), including the Abbott ID NOW and Cepheid GeneXpert, require specialized and expensive instrumentation, high level technical expertise, are expensive, and prohibit widespread use. Therefore scalable, affordable, and easy-to-use POC tests remain an urgent need for the fight again COVID-19.
Previously, we developed a sensitive and specific nucleic detection technology called SHERLOCK (Specific High Sensitivity Enzymatic Reporter UnLOCKing) (Gootenberg et al., 2017, 2018), which achieves detection of DNA or RNA virus signatures through two consecutive reactions: (1) amplification of the viral RNA using an isothermal amplification reaction, and (2) detection of the resulting amplicon using CRISPR-mediated collateral reporter unlocking. During the early period of the COVID-19 outbreak, we developed a SHERLOCK-based test for SARS-CoV-2 (SHERLOCK-Covid). Additional CRISPR-based tests have also been recently developed (Broughton et al., 2020; Ding et al., 2020; Guo et al., 2020; Lucia et al., 2020), but similar to the SHERLOCK-Covid test, all involve two separate reaction steps, liquid handling, and opening of tubes. These steps not only add complexity but also significantly increase the likelihood of sample cross-contamination, prohibiting their use outside well-controlled laboratory environments.
Other isothermal pre-amplification methods, such as Loop-mediated Isothermal Amplification (LAMP), are also being developed as POC tests (Zhang et al., 2020), but these rely on amplification that can be nonspecific. Unlike isothermal amplification-only tests, SHERLOCK provides two rounds of sequence-specific detection, first through primer-specific isothermal amplification, and then via guide RNA-mediated, sequence-specific detection of the viral sequence.
To make SHERLOCK ready for use in POC contexts, we developed a simple testing chemistry called STOP (SHERLOCK Testing in One Pot), which does not require sample extraction and can be performed at a single temperature with one fluid handling step and a simple visual readout similar to a pregnancy test (Figure 1A). Here we report a STOP test for COVID-19 called STOPCovid.
The STOPCovid test works in the following three steps, without requiring separate viral RNA extraction and only simple laboratory equipment (Figure 1B).
Results
In order to turn the classically two-step SHERLOCK into a single-step reaction by integrating the isothermal amplification step with the CRISPR-mediated detection step, we sought to establish a common reaction chemistry capable of supporting both steps. Due to the supply chain constraints for the commercially-available recombinase polymerase amplification (RPA) reagents and difficulties in producing a rapid one-pot RPA test for sensitive RNA detection, we chose loop-mediated isothermal amplification (LAMP) reaction for amplifying the viral RNA.
The requisite enzymes for LAMP are more readily available from a number of commercial suppliers and the LAMP buffers are defined and amenable to systematic optimization with Cas enzymes.
To determine the optimal combination of LAMP primers and guides, we designed 29 sets of LAMP primers targeting different regions of the SARS-CoV-2 genome and identified the best primer set for amplifying gene N, which encodes the nucleoprotein (Figure 2A). As LAMP operates at a higher temperature than RPA (55-65 °C compared to 37-42 °C), a one-pot reaction demands a Cas enzyme with collateral activity that is thermostable. Alicyclobacillus acidoterrestris Cas12b (AacCas12b), which has been shown to be thermostable at 55C (Shmakov et al., 2015), has been incorporated into a one-pot detection assay with LAMP (Li et al., 2019), but because it is unstable at the high temperature required for LAMP, we did not find adequate sensitivity and performance. Of the various Cas proteins we explored, Cas12b from Alicyclobacillus acidiphilus (AapCas12b) (Teng et al., 2018) maintained sufficient activity in the same temperature range as LAMP (Figure 2B).
However, because the AapCas12b locus did not contain a CRISPR array, the published single guide RNA (sgRNA) for AapCas12b (Teng et al., 2018) used a direct repeat (DR) sequence from Alicyclobacillus macrosporangiidus Cas12b, which could impede activity. To remedy this, we searched for alternative orthologs with similar protein sequences to AapCas12b and found that AacCas12b shared a 95% sequence homology (Shmakov et al., 2015). Additionally, the AacCas12b tracrRNA and predicted AapCas12b tracrRNA are 97% identical. Given the high degree of similarity between AapCas12b and AacCas12b protein and tracrRNA, we surmised that the sgRNA for AacCas12b should closely match the cognate AapCas12b DR-tracrRNA hybrid. Indeed, reactions combining AapCas12b enzyme with AacCas12b scaffold sgRNA produced more robust and specific nuclease activity compared to the previously published AapCas12b sgRNA (Figure 2C).
For the best LAMP amplicon, we systematically evaluated 18 sgRNAs to identify the optimal combination of primers and guide sequence (Figure 2D). Using this combination in a one-pot reaction, we found that AapCas12b generated faster and higher collateral activity than AacCas12b protein (Figure 3A). We further optimized one-pot reaction components by screening 94 additives to improve thermal stability of the one pot reaction (Figure 3B), finding that addition of taurine significantly improved reaction kinetics (Figure 3C).
We profiled the optimized reaction with a lateral flow readout and an RNA extraction-free input using SARS-CoV-2 genome standards spiked into pooled healthy saliva or nasopharyngeal (NP) swabs to determine the limit of detection (LOD), ideal incubation temperature, readout time, and robustness. We found that the LOD of the reaction was 100 copies of SARS-CoV-2 (Figure 4A,B) for readout using one strip. This LOD was reliable and reproducible over 30 replicates (Figure 4A,B). The ideal incubation parameters were 60°C for at least 50 minutes for lateral flow (Figure 4C,D), and the reaction components could be formulated as a mastermix and maintained functionality after 6 freeze-thaw cycles (Figure 4E). The assay exhibited no cross-reactivity with the SARS-CoV or MERS-CoV genomes (Figure 4F) and could be performed using either a standard heat block or via a water bath maintained by a commercially-available low-cost (under $40USD) sous-vide cooker (Figure 4G,H).
We evaluated STOPCovid detection using viral transport media from NP swabs obtained from 12 SARS-CoV-2 RNA positive and 5 negative patients (Figure 5A-C). Our assay reliably detected SARS-CoV-2 in patient samples: 3 out of 3 replicates for 11/12 patient samples, and at least 2 out of 3 replicates for 12/12 patient samples. STOPCovid also reliably returned negative results for all 5 negative patient samples (0 out of 3 replicates for each sample).
To further simplify the assay workflow, we tested if lysis with QuickExtract at room temperature (22 °C) or at one-pot incubation temperature (60 °C) for 10 mins would be sufficient for detection. As QuickExtract contains Proteinase K that inhibits SHERLOCK without heat inactivation at 95 °C, we added Proteinase K Inhibitor to the SHERLOCK and RT-qPCR reactions. In both cases, we could identify 11/12 positive patient samples (Figure 5D,E). Comparison of RT-qPCR Ct values between the lysis methods suggested that both lysis methods are viable alternatives for streamlining the assay workflow, though with a slight decrease (0.2/0.4 Ct at 60°C and 0.4/0.7 Ct for 22°C for CDC N1/N2 probe sets) in sensitivity (Figure 5F).
Materials and Methods
Design of LAMP and SHERLOCK reactions
We designed LAMP amplification primers and SHERLOCK AapCas12b guide RNAs to target the N gene of SARS-CoV-2. The N gene is known to be present at higher copy numbers than other segments of the SARS-CoV-2 genome, which helps to increase the detection sensitivity (Kim et al., 2020). Below are the LAMP primer sequences and SHERLOCK AapCas12b guide RNAs:
LAMP PrimersF3: 5′– GCTGCTGAGGCTTCTAAG –3′
B3: 5′– GCGTCAATATGCTTATTCAGC –3′
FIP: 5′– GCGGCCAATGTTTGTAATCAGTAGACGTGGTCCAGAACAA –3′
BIP: 5′– TCAGCGTTCTTCGGAATGTCGCTGTGTAGGTCAACCACG –3′
Loop Forward: 5′– CCTTGTCTGATTAGTTCCTGGT –3′
Loop Reverse: 5′– TGGCATGGAAGTCACACC –3′
AapCas12b Guide RNA targeting SARS-CoV-2 Ngene
5′–UCUAGAGGACAGAAUUUUUCAACGGGUGUGCCAAUGGCCACUUUCCAGGUGG CAAAGCCCGUUGAGCUUCUCAAAUCUGAGAAGUGGCACCGAAGAACGCUGAAGCGCUG -3' (The spacer targeting N gene is underlined.)
AapCas12b Protein Sequence
MAVKSMKVKLRLDNMPEIRAGLWKLHTEVNAGVRYYTEWLSLLRQENLYRRSPNGDGEQ ECYKTAEECKAELLERLRARQVENGHCGPAGSDDELLQLARQLYELLVPQAIGAKGDAQ QIARKFLSPLADKDAVGGLGIAKAGNKPRWVRMREAGEPGWEEEKAKAEARKSTDRTAD VLRALADFGLKPLMRVYTDSDMSSVQWKPLRKGQAVRTWDRDMFQQAIERMMSWESWNQ RVGEAYAKLVEQKSRFEQKNFVGQEHLVQLVNQLQQDMKEASHGLESKEQTAHYLTGRA LRGSDKVFEKWEKLDPDAPFDLYDTEIKNVQRRNTRRFGSHDLFAKLAEPKYQALWRED ASFLTRYAVYNSIVRKLNHAKMFATFTLPDATAHPIWTRFDKLGGNLHQYTFLFNEFGE GRHAIRFQKLLTVEDGVAKEVDDVTVPISMSAQLDDLLPRDPHELVALYFQDYGAEQHL AGEFGGAKIQYRRDQLNHLHARRGARDVYLNLSVRVQSQSEARGERRPPYAAVFRLVGD NHRAFVHFDKLSDYLAEHPDDGKLGSEGLLSGLRVMSVDLGLRTSASISVFRVARKDEL KPNSEGRVPFCFPIEGNENLVAVHERSQLLKLPGETESKDLRAIREERQRTLRQLRTQL AYLRLLVRCGSEDVGRRERSWAKLIEQPMDANQMTPDWREAFEDELQKLKSLYGICGDR EWTEAVYESVRRVWRHMGKQVRDWRKDVRSGERPKIRGYQKDVVGGNSIEQIEYLERQY KFLKSWSFFGKVSGQVIRAEKGSRFAITLREHIDHAKEDRLKKLADRIIMEALGYVYAL DDERGKGKWVAKYPPCQLILLEELSEYQFNNDRPPSENNQLMQWSHRGVFQELLNQAQV HDLLVGTMYAAFSSRFDARTGAPGIRCRRVPARCAREQNPEPFPWWLNKFVAEHKLDGC PLRADDLIPTGEGEFFVSPFSAEEGDFHQIHADLNAAQNLQRRLWSDFDISQIRLRCDW GEVDGEPVLIPRTTGKRTADSYGNKVFYTKTGVTYYERERGKKRRKVFAQEELSEEEAE LLVEADEAREKSVVLMRDPSGIINRGDWTRQKEFWSMVNQRIEGYLVKQIRSRVRLQES ACENTGDI*
Specimen and nucleic acid extraction
Two types of patient samples have been tested for compatibility with STOPCovid. All samples should be collected and processed according to the appropriate biosafety procedure.
RNA extracted from patient samples: Please reference the 2020 CDC COVID-19 test protocol for details on specimen collection and subsequent nucleic acidextraction. The input for this protocol can be the same extracted nucleic acid as used in RT-qPCR assays. If starting with extracted RNA, begin with Step (2).
Saliva or nasopharyngeal (NP) swabs: Saliva or NP swabs dipped in viral transport media (VTM) or VTM equivalents can be directly used.
Reagents
For Step (1) - lysis of viral sample:
- QuickExtract DNA Extraction Solution (QE09050), Lucigen. Once thawed, aliquot and store at −20 °C to avoid >3 freeze-thaw cycles.
For Step (2) - STOPCovid detection reaction:
- Bst 2.0 WarmStart® DNA Polymerase (M0538L), New England BioLabs
- WarmStart® RTx Reverse Transcriptase (M0380L), New England BioLabs
- 10X Isothermal Amplification Buffer (B0374S), New England BioLabs, supplied with M0538L and M0380L
- 100 mM MgSO4 (B1003S), New England BioLabs, supplied with M0538L and M0380L
- 10 mM Deoxynucleotide (dNTP) Solution Mix (N0447L), New England BioLabs
- Taurine (86329-100G), Millipore Sigma
- AapCas12b protein purified according to Kellner et al.. Nature Protocols 2019. stored as 10 μL aliquots at 2 mg/mL.
- Guide RNA for detecting N gene can be ordered from Synthego
- Reporter DNA for lateral flow read out (Lateral Flow Reporter: /56-FAM/TTTTTTT/3Bio/), can be ordered from IDT
- (Optional) Proteinase K Inhibitor (539470-10MG), Millipore Sigma. Resuspend 10 mg of Proteinase K Inhibitor with 150 μL of DMSO to make the stock solution. Dilute stock solution 1:100 with ddH2O to make working aliquots. Store both stock and working solutions at −20 °C
- (Optional) Reporter DNA for fluorescent readout (Fluorescent Reporter: /5HEX/TTTTTTT/3IABkFQ/), can be ordered from IDT)
- 10X LAMP Primer Mix can be prepared as follows:
A Sherlock mastermix can be prepared as follows:
For Step (3) reading out using lateral flow dipstick:
- HybriDetect Dipstick (MGHD 1). Milenia Biotec GmbH
Positive control sequences
- SARS-CoV-2 RNA control (102019). Twist Bioscience
Equipment
- 95 °C heat block or water bath
- 60 °C heat block or water bath
- Alternative: a sous vide immersion cooker capable of supporting the temperature range of 55 °C to 95 °C can also be used (example).
One-step SHERLOCK Protocol for SARS-CoV-2 Detection
*** IMPORTANT NOTE: To prevent sample contamination from confounding detection results, two different work areas should be used for performing Steps (1)/(2) and (3). Steps (1)/(2) should be performed in a pre-amplification area and is especially sensitive to contamination. Amplified samples should not be opened in the work area for Steps (1)/(2). A separate area for post-amplification reactions should be used for performing Step (3) of the protocol.
Step (1) – Lysis of patients sample. *PERFORMED IN THE PRE-AMPLIFICATION AREA*
Saliva or NP swab samples should be lysed using the QuickExtract lysis buffer.
Mix 10 μL of saliva or NP swab sample with 10 μL of Quick Extract in an eppendorf tube.
Incubate the sample-QuickExtract mixture at 95 °C for 5 minutes (or at room temperature or 60 °C for 10 mins) and proceed to Step (2).
Step (2) – STOPCovid detection. *PERFORMED IN THE PRE-AMPLIFICATION AREA*
For each sample, set up one reaction as follows. In addition, a positive control can be set up using the SARS-CoV-2 control RNA. A negative control with Isothermal Amplification Buffer, MgSO4, dNTPs, Lateral Flow Reporter, and sample could also be set up to control for DNAse contamination that may produce false positive results. We did not observe DNAse contamination in negative control reactions when validating our assay using patient NP swabs.
View this table:Mix thoroughly and incubate each reaction at 60 °C for 1 hour. Transfer the reaction tubes to the post-amplification area before proceeding to Step (3).
Step (3) – Visual readout of detection result via lateral flow strip. *PERFORMED IN THE POST-AMPLIFICATION AREA*
Place a HybriDetect Dipstick into each reaction tube and wait for the reaction to flow through the dipstick. Generally, 2 minutes is enough time to develop a positive band at the limit of detection (longer wait times will not impact the result).
Positive control samples should show the top line and a faint bottom line. Negative control samples should show the bottom line.
For each test sample, check to see the top line appears, indicating positive SARS-CoV-2 detection.
Additional Information
The protocol describes the use of lateral flow dipsticks for achieving a visual readout of the test result. For higher-throughput processing and to achieve semi-quantitative measurement of the virus load, the STOPCovid reaction can be performed with fluorescent readout by exchanging the reporter DNA. This modification allows measurement of hundreds of samples on a standard fluorescent plate reader. All of the reaction conditions remain the same except the lateral flow reporter should be replaced with a fluorescence reporter.
For additional information regarding SHERLOCK, a detailed general protocol can be found in the following reference:
SHERLOCK: nucleic acid detection with CRISPR nucleases. Kellner MJ, Koob JG, Gootenberg JS, Abudayyeh OO, and Zhang F. Nature Protocols. 2019 Oct;14(10):2986-3012. doi: 10.1038/s41596-019-0210-2.
Discussion
STOPCovid is capable of rapid, point-of-care diagnosis of viral shedding in persons with COVID-19 disease. Our method achieved a LOD of 100 molecules of synthetic SARS-CoV-2 genomes in saliva or nasopharyngeal swab per reaction. Validation on patient samples showed that our method successfully diagnosed 12 positive and 5 negative COVID-19 patients, with at least 2 of 3 replicates scoring positive in infected persons.
Importantly, this simplified format, which has minimal sample processing steps and does not require complex instrumentation, can be performed by lay users, making it deployable in low-resource clinics, pharmacies, workplaces, and even developed for at-home use. For these types of applications, we anticipate that saliva samples, which have similar viral loads to nasopharyngeal swabs (Wyllie et al., 2020), will also work as input, as we have shown that spiked-in SARS-CoV-2 genomic RNA standards in healthy saliva is detected by STOPCovid.
Future development of a low-cost and modular heater capable of accommodating a disposable single-use test cartridge would further streamline the workflow and simplify the test for use in diverse environments such as at hospitals, nursing facilities, mobile testing stations, offices, and homes where the tests are most needed (Figure 6). The molecular components for STOPCovid are readily available and can be scaled with numerous commercial partners. The disposable test cartridge can be designed to be compatible with scalable manufacturing processes such as injection molding to allow for high throughput manufacturing. The cartridge would reduce both test complexity and risk of amplicon contamination by processing the sample input internally and directing the completed STOPCovid reaction mixture toward the lateral flow strip for readout. A mobile phone application can analyze images captured by the phone camera to readout test results (Figure 6).
STOPCovid represents a promising platform for developing POC COVID-19 diagnostics and has the potential to play an important role in effective test-trace-isolate measures to end the COVID-19 pandemic and reopen society.
Ethical Statement
This study was performed under the MIT IRB IRB-6095, the University of Washington IRB STUDY00010205, and Partners Healthcare IRB #2020P000804.
Declaration of conflicts of interest
F.Z., O.O.A., J.S.G., J.J., and A.L. are inventors on patent applications related to this technology filed by the Broad Institute, with the specific aim of ensuring this technology can be made freely, widely, and rapidly available for research and deployment. O.O.A., J.S.G., and F.Z. are co-founders, scientific advisors, and hold equity interests in Sherlock Biosciences, Inc. F.Z. is also a co-founder of Editas Medicine, Beam Therapeutics, Pairwise Plants, and Arbor Biotechnologies.
Acknowledgements
We thank R. Shan of Quintara for oligo synthesis; K.Holden, A. Kadina, and J.Walker of Synthego for guide RNA synthesis; Abderrahim Farina for assistance with protein purification; and A. Tang for illustration assistance. Support for specimen collection was provided by Mark and Lisa Schwartz and Enid Schwartz. O.O.A, J.S.G., and F.Z. are supported by the Patrick J. McGovern Foundation and DARPA Award D18AC00006. F.Z is also supported by the NIH (1R01-MH110049 and 1DP1-HL141201 grants); Mathers Foundation; the Howard Hughes Medical Institute; Open Philanthropy Project; J. and P. Poitras; and R. Metcalfe.
Footnotes
*** We will post updates and more information at STOPCovid.science. Groups interested in testing this protocol on patient samples can request test kits by filling out an application at STOPCovid.science. We have made a limited number of research use kits available for distribution. The expression plasmid for AapCas12b will be available at Addgene.
*** IMPORTANT NOTE: This protocol should not be used for clinical purposes. Although we have validated the kit on patient samples, this test is not FDA authorized. We welcome researchers working with COVID-19 samples to contact us and we can provide a starter kit for further experimental testing. We hope this protocol will provide some reference points for researchers interested in further advancing this diagnostic platform and also welcome researchers to contact us for assistance or guidance.