High risk of infection caused Posttraumatic Stress symptoms in individuals with poor sleep quality: A study on influence of Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in China

Introduction

On Dec 31, 2019, the World Health Organization (WHO) China Office was informed of cases of an unknown etiology detected in Wuhan City, Hubei province of China (WHO, 2020a). On Jan 7, 2020, a novel coronavirus, which had not been documented before was identified by the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) from the throat swab sample of a patient, and was confirmed as the cause of the Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) by WHO (2020a). On Jan 30, 2020 the outbreak of COVID-19 has been determined by the WHO as a Public Health Emergency of International Concern (PHEIC) (WHO, 2020b). Thus far (up to Feb 4, 2020), more than 20,000 firmed cases have been confirmed in China, and more than 20 countries reported confirmed cases (WHO, 2020c).

According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-5th edition (DSM-5) (APA, 2013), Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is characterized by four symptom groups: (a) involuntary memories of the trauma such as intrusions or nightmares; (b) persistent avoidance of stimuli associated with the traumatic event; (c) negative alterations in cognitions and mood that are associated with the trauma; and (d) alterations in arousal and reactivity that are associated with the trauma. Also in DSM-5, exposure to traumatic events is the immediate causes of PTSD and an essential condition of diagnosis. Being infected with a life-threatening physical illness is a traumatic event and can lead to posttraumatic stress symptoms. For example, 12%-15% survivors of SARS showed one type of PTSD symptom (PTSS) at one month after discharge (Wu et al, 2005); the morbidity of PTSD in patients with traumatic injury reached 9.6% at months (Bryant et al., 2017). In addition, not only being attacked by traumatic illness could cause PTSD symptoms, being contacts and carers of a deadly virus could also lead to symptoms like alternations in mood and arousal (Tine et al., 2016). Living in the endemic area, every Chinese is a carer and a (possible) contact of COVID-19. Although having experienced the outbreak of Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS), a severe infectious disease which had caused hundreds of death in China in 2003 (WHO, 2003), the traumatic course of the infection and the characteristic of human transmission of novel coronavirus (Li et al., 2020) were beyond expectation, causing fear, helplessness and PTSS among Chinese people. Hence in the present study, we focused on the acute PTSS in Chinese under the background of massive COVID-19 outbreak.

Previous studies have proved that massive outbreaks of epidemics like SARS and Ebola virus disease (EVD) could cause sleep problems in relevant individuals. For example, Yu et al. (2005) reported that midlife women felt “sleep was restless” during SARS and this problem was closely associated with their overall negative emotions. Another study showed that chronic post-SARS symptoms were characterized by sleep-related problems (Moldofsky and Patcai, 2011). Survivors of EVD also reported various sleep quality problems (Keita et al., 2017). More importantly, Sleep and PTSS are closely related, and sleep disturbances are core features of PTSD. According to the model raised by Richard et al. (2020), sleep disturbances (short sleep duration, frequent arousals, and et al.) could lead to maladaptive sleep-related compensatory behaviors and cause hyperarousal and anxiety-related disorders like PTSD. Sleep disruption also promoted anxious emotions by disrupt emotion regulation and adaptive memory functions. Thus, it was reasonable to hypothesize that wide-spread transmission of COVID-19 could causes sleep problems in Chinese and result in PTSS.

In early December 2019, the first pneumonia case was identified in Wuhan, the capital city of Hubei province (Huang et al., 2020). With the spreading of the epidemic, Wuhan became the worst influenced area, where the mortality and incidence rate of COVID-19 were above the national level according to the National Health Commission of China (2020). Moreover, not only Wuhan residents were more likely to be infected, 72.3% nonresidents of Wuhan had contact with individuals lived in Wuhan (Guan et al., 2020). Wuhan expose history had become an important diagnosis standard and a source of fear. As a result, we collected data of Wuhan exposure to measure the risk of infection. We hypothesized that Wuhan residents and individuals who had been to Wuhan or contacted with Wuhan residents, would show more sleep problems and PTSS for they were faced with high possibility of infection of COVID-19. We also explored the relationship among the infection risk, sleep and PTSS to identify the role of sleep problems in the development of PTSD. We hope the current study could reflect the influence of COVID-19 on psychological well-being in Chinses and shed light on post-epidemic psychological intervention.

Methods

The methods and reporting procedures were in accordance with the STROBE (STrengthening the Reporting of OBservational studies in Epidemiology) checklist.

Results

General results of sleep quality and PTSS

Figure 1 showed trends of PCL-5 scores and sleep quality during the 5-day survey. Both PCL-5 scores and sleep quality scores showed raising tendency from Jan 30, 2020 to Feb 2, 2020 and decreased in Feb 3, 2020. One-way ANOVA showed that there was a significant difference of PCL-5 scores on different dates, F=4.38, p<0.05. LSD test showed significant increases was illustrated from Jan 31 to Feb 2 (ps<0.05); however, the PCL-5 score in Feb 3, 2020 were significantly lower than that in Feb 2, 2020 (p<0.05).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1. Changes of PCL-5 scores and participants with sleep quality problems in the 5-day survey

Chi-square test showed significant differences of sleep quality in the 5-days period, χ²=12.33, p<0.05 for subjective sleep quality, χ² =34.32, p<0.05 for sleep fragment and χ²=20.03, p<0.05 for sleep duration. However, latency onset of sleep did not illustrate significant change during the period.

Discussion

According to National Health Commission of China (NHC), until Feb 4, 2020, prevalence rate and fatality rate of COVID-19 in Wuhan were much high above the national level (NHC, 2020), making exposure to Wuhan a risk factor of infection and a cause of mental health problem. The current study aimed to investigate the influence of potential danger of infection on sleep and PTSS. We also explored regulating effects of sleep quality on the relationship between Wuhan exposure history during outbreak of COVID-19 and PTSS. To this end, we conducted ANOVAs and Chi-square tests with the above variables.

Results indicated that data of PTSS growth rapidly in the first 4 days in our study, and decreased in the last day. Interestingly, scores of sleep quality showed the same tendency. This might indicate the close relationship between sleep and PTSD. Moreover, up to the end of our survey, the firmed cases and susceptive cases were still frantically increased, showing no sign of decline (WHO, 2020e). We assumed that results of the present study suggested that emergence of psychological “inflection point” which meant a turning from deterioration of mental health to growth of resilience showed on Feb 3, 2020. It was a date before the number of confirmed cases of COVID-19 showed any sign of downward trends in China. We supposed that the change in psychological response might be a result of Chinese government’s efforts in disease management, psychoeducation and prevention education.

Results illustrated that Wuhan exposure history affected PTSS. For those having Wuhan-expose experiences, PTSS were more obvious. This result was in line with previous findings that subjective perception of dangerousness during SARS related with severity of PTSD symptoms (Mak et al., 2010). Results also highlighted the influence of trauma expose on latency onset of sleep, which was different in subjects with and without Wuhan exposure history. Difficulty in falling asleep might be a result of increased presleep cognitions. According to Fast (2003), traumatic experiences caused reactions of fear, increased arousal and re-experience, and these reactions affected presleep cognitions and leaded to chances of sleep onset latency. Increased sleep onset latency then influenced mood, cognition and physiological responses.

We confirmed that subjective sleep quality, delayed sleep onset, sleep fragment and sleep duration all regulated the effect of Wuhan exposure history on PTSS. Wuhan-expose history influenced only those with relatively poor sleep quality, but if individuals showed few or none sleep problems, Wuhan-expose was not a risk factor of PTSS. These results indicated that traumatic events provide bases for PTSD but one’s ability to keep sleep quality was a protective factor of onset and development of PTSD. This was line with Germain et al.’s (2016) model of sleep and PTSD which indicated that sleep related more closely with PTSS than trauma events. These results were also consist with previous studies which showed alters of REM sleep after uncontrolled stress accounted for the long term physiological and behavioral impairments in an animal model (Vanderheyden et al., 2015). The mechanisms regulating the interactions of traumatic stress and sleep were poorly understood, and we extended previous findings by showing regulation effect of sleep quality on the relationship between trauma expose and PTSD in human samples. To prevent mental illness and protect mental health in the peak rush of COVID-19 and other infectious fatal diseases, health authorities should be mindful of the influence of infectious risks on psychological reactions, propagate the importance of keeping good sleep quality like enough sleep time, keeping early hours etc.

Limitations of the current study included the use of a health example and the fact that we used online survey in data collection. Only a few subjects were confirmed or suspected COVID-19 patients in our study. And the mean levels of sleep quality and PTSS were in the moderate range. For those being infected with COVID-19, sleep and metal health problems might be far more severe. Considering the risk of infection, we used online survey to investigate relationship among Wuhan exposure history, sleep and PTSS. However, it was hard to guarantee authenticity with this method and the validity was limited. We suggested that future studies could exam PTSD and related factors among COVID-19 survivors with face-to-face investigation or interview.

Conclusion

The present study suggested that sleep quality level decreased and posttraumatic stress symptoms increased with time and change of this tendency was shown on 3^rd Feb, 2020. Individuals with and without Wuhan-expose history showed different levels of PTSS and sleep onset latency under the influence of COVID-19. Wuhan-expose history influenced PTSS severity in individuals with poor sleep quality, but not those with high-quality sleep.