Abstract
Nephrotic syndrome (NS) is associated with an acquired hypercoagulopathy and strong predilection for life-threatening thrombotic complications. Current anticoagulant prophylaxis guidelines are based upon controversial hypoalbuminemia thresholds. Anticoagulant prophylaxis is thus inconsistently implemented due to a lack of high-grade safety and efficacy data. Development of evidence-based clinical parameters that define thrombosis risk may thus refine safe and effective anticoagulant use. Endogenous thrombin potential (ETP) is a recognized measure of hypercoagulopathy and established predictor of both incident and recurrent thrombosis. This study utilized biorepository samples from a prospective longitudinal cohort study to demonstrate that ETP is proportional to NS disease activity, resulting in multivariable models that are significantly correlated with ETP. The relationship with disease activity was confirmed in a separate cohort. These models revealed that ETP is related to disease activity in a manner dependent on remission status and that proteinuria and hypercholesterolemia exert the strongest influence on ETP. In contrast to prior epidemiology studies, which did not include hypercoagulopathy measures, we found that hypoalbuminemia was less predictive of ETP. These findings are consistent with our previously reported animal model observations and are expected to inform the design of clinical trials that will generate high-grade evidence to guide more effective and safer anticoagulant use and thus reduce life-threatening thrombotic events in patients with NS.
Introduction
Nephrotic syndrome (NS), a leading cause of end stage kidney disease (ESKD), is characterized by massive proteinuria, hypoalbuminemia, edema, and hyperlipidemia.1-3 As recently reviewed by our group and others, venous thromboembolism (VTE) is a frequent life-threatening complication of NS.4-7 Up to 27% of adults and 3% of children with NS develop VTE during their disease course, with the majority of VTE occurring within 90 days of diagnosis.5, 8 The frequency of VTE in adult NS is thus higher than both the well-known cancer-VTE predilection (≤5.7%) or the medical hospitalization VTE-rate (∼20%), but less than the ∼40% VTE-incidence amongst surgical admissions.9 Therefore, although NS is a rare disease, accounting for only a small proportion of total VTE cases, it nonetheless carries a profound VTE risk. Arterial thrombosis is less common than VTE in adult NS and is rarely reported in childhood NS.10-12 NS-associated VTE risk is secondary, at least in part, to the well-known acquired hypercoagulopathy that develops during NS (NS-hypercoagulopathy).4-6
While VTE complications may be preventable with prophylactic anticoagulation, this intervention remains controversial in NS due to a lack of well-defined indications and randomized controlled trial data demonstrating safety and efficacy.8, 13-16 For example, current KDIGO guidelines cite low-grade evidence, based upon Markov modeling of a virtual NS cohort, to suggest prophylactic anticoagulation when serum albumin is <2.5 g/dL.15 Recent epidemiologic studies have revealed that both proteinuria and hypoalbuminemia are associated with the likelihood of VTE, with higher proteinuria and lower serum albumin correlating with VTE risk, strongly suggesting that NS disease activity may be proportional to the severity of hypercoagulopathy.10, 11, 17-20 Thus, rigorous determination of the relationship between hypercoagulopathy and NS activity biomarkers offers the opportunity to identify clinically meaningful thresholds which may be implemented in clinical trials designed to generate high-grade evidence regarding the safe and effective use of prophylactic anticoagulation for NS patients.
Recently, thromboelastography, which determines the viscoelastic properties of clotting whole blood, was demonstrated to increase proportionally to NS activity.21 Similarly, ex vivo plasma thrombin generation has been used to show that thrombin generation is elevated in NS patients.22 Meanwhile, our group recently reported that both proteinuria and hypoalbuminemia are proportional to hypercoagulopathy, as assessed by in vivo thrombosis, viscoelasticity, and thrombin generation in rat NS models.23 Both thromboelastography and thrombin generation are ‘global hemostasis’ assays.24 The latter measures thrombin production over time, including the period after fibrin clot formation (which is the end point of conventional clinical coagulation assays) and is more amenable to use in centralized laboratories because frozen plasma can be used instead of whole blood.24 Thrombin is the key effector enzyme of the hemostatic system and, because of its negative and positive feedback loops, the amount of thrombin produced by the hemostatic system is a product of both upstream and downstream coagulation cascade status.25, 26 Several parameters are derived from the assay, including endogenous thrombin potential (ETP), which represents the area under the thrombin activity-time curve. Importantly and critical for this study, ETP is a biomarker of hypercoagulopathy that has demonstrated predictive value for both incident and recurrent VTE-risk in non-NS patient populations.27-36 The aim of the present study was thus to determine the relationship between ETP and NS activity biomarkers in human NS.
Results
Demographics and Clinical Characteristics
The Nephrotic Syndrome Study Network (NEPTUNE) cohort consisted of plasma samples from 150 unique subjects randomly selected to represent the available proteinuria spectrum within the NEPTUNE biorepository as of October 2014. Three (2%) samples had undetectable thrombin generation indicating that the plasma had clotted during the pre-analytic phase; the remaining 147 samples were thus advanced for further analysis (Table 1). Patients with minimal change disease (MCD) or membranous nephropathy (MN) were significantly younger or older (median age 17 vs. 55 years, respectively) than those with focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS; median age 39 years; p<0.05). Patients with MCD (53%) or FSGS (32%) were more likely to be on immunosuppressive therapy (vs. 21% of MN patients; p<0.05). Urinary protein-to-creatinine ratio (UP:C) was significantly higher (median 3.5 g/g creatinine) in the MN patients (vs. 0.3 g/g and 1.9 g/g for MCD and FSGS, respectively; p<0.05). Because serum albumin (the conventional clinical laboratory method) is not uniformly determined on simultaneously collected serum specimens in a NEPTUNE central laboratory, we performed albumin measurements on the plasma aliquots as a surrogate method. Plasma albumin was similar in the MCD and FSGS groups (median 3.3 and 3.4 g/dl, respectively) and significantly higher than the MN group (2.5 g/dl; p<0.05). FSGS patients had the lowest estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR; 60 ml/min/1.73m2 vs. 81 and 97 for MN and MCD, respectively; p<0.05). The distributions of UP:C, plasma albumin, total cholesterol, and eGFR across all 147 patients are shown in Figure 1. Thrombin generation assays are susceptible to confounding by preanalytical variables, such as sample collection technique and processing, shipping, and freeze/thaw cycles, all of which are unknowns when using biorepository samples.37 Thus, to enable validation of ETP signals observed in the NEPTUNE cohort, we also collected urine and plasma from a second, locally-derived group of NS patients, for whom we were able to carefully control these preanalytical variables. This “Columbus cohort” consisted of 23 newly-diagnosed NS patients, the characteristics of which are shown in Table S1.
Univariate Relationships with Endogenous Thrombin Potential
To address the hypothesis that ETP is proportional to disease activity, we performed univariate analyses comparing ETP to markers of NS disease activity (e.g. UP:C, plasma albumin, lipids), various NS therapeutics, and known risk factors for cardiovascular disease (e.g. tobacco use, alcohol use, age) available in the NEPTUNE database. As shown in Table 2, ETP was significantly correlated with plasma albumin (Spearman’s rho (ρ) rank correlation coefficient ρ=‾0.31; p<0.001; Figure 2A) and urinary protein-to-creatinine ratio (UP:C; ρ=0.35; p<0.001; Figure 3A). ETP was also significantly correlated with total cholesterol (ρ=0.42; p<0.001; Figure 2B) and other components of the lipid profile (Table 2). ETP was also correlated with eGFR (ρ=0.17; p=0.04; Figure 2C). Age was negatively correlated with ETP (ρ=‾0.19; p=0.02; Figure 2D). However, this relationship was primarily driven by higher ETP in children vs. adults (≥18 years; 5,705.90±160.79 nM*min; p=0.002) and ETP was not correlated with age within either age group sub-cohort. Treatment with steroids and renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system (RAAS) blockade were both correlated with ETP, but with opposing effects (Table 2). Whereas steroid therapy was positively correlated with ETP, RAAS-blockade was associated with decreased ETP. Alcohol use was negatively correlated with ETP, whereas tobacco use did not influence ETP in this study. Germane to our hypothesis, similar univariate relationships with UP:C and plasma albumin were identified in the Columbus cohort (Table S2). Unfortunately, there was insufficient power to assess hyperlipidemia and eGFR in the Columbus cohort because data for these unexpected relationships were not included in the protocol. There was no identifiable influence of NS histology on ETP in either cohort (p=0.26). Antithrombin activity did not correlate with ETP in either cohort (ρ=‾0.06; p=0.47 and ‾0.23; p=0.28 for NEPTUNE and Columbus, respectively; Figure S1). In addition to ETP, several other parameters are derived from thrombin generation assays (i.e. lag-time, velocity index, peak thrombin, time to peak). In contrast to ETP, these other parameters were insignificantly or only weakly correlated with NS activity markers (data not shown).
Relationship between Endogenous Thrombin Potential and Proteinuria is Dependent on Remission Status
The UP:C scatterplot suggested a non-linear relationship between ETP and Log-UP:C (Figure 3A). Thus, the data were further analyzed after division into two groups: complete remission (CR; defined a priori for NEPTUNE as ≤0.3 g/g creatinine) and active disease (>0.3 g/g creatinine).38 This analysis revealed that the correlation was indirect and non-significant for patients in CR (R2=0.1; p=0.06), whereas there was a significant direct correlation among those with active disease (R2=0.23; p<0.001), suggesting an important interaction between ETP and remission status. When a quadratic regression formula was applied to the raw data the ETP nadir corresponded to UP:C 0.28 g/g creatinine (Figure 3C), mathematically confirming an interaction at a UP:C value that closely approximates the pre-defined CR threshold. Finally, when the subjects were grouped by remission status (CR vs. partial remission (PR) vs. no remission), those not in complete or partial remission had significantly higher ETP than either the CR or PR group (p<0.001; Figure 3D). Importantly, the observation that ETP was significantly and positively correlated with UP:C during active disease was also confirmed in the Columbus Cohort of newly-diagnosed NS patients (ρ=0.51; p=0.01).
Disease Activity Biomarkers are Independently Predictive of Endogenous Thrombin Potential
Backward selection multivariable linear regression was used to construct an overall model of the relationship between ETP and NS disease activity (Table 3). All three NS activity biomarkers (UP:C, plasma albumin, and total cholesterol) were independently predictive of ETP, along with dichotomous age (children vs. adults). However, the other variables identified by univariate analysis were no longer predictive when incorporated into the multivariable model. The final model was significantly predictive of ETP (R2=0.38). The effect size of each variable included in the final model was estimated with the eta-squared (η2) function, wherein the sum of all η2 is equal to the overall correlation coefficient (R2).39 This analysis revealed that proteinuria had the largest influence on ETP (η2Log-UP:C+η2Log-UP:C2=η2 proteinuria=0.20), followed by total cholesterol (η2total cholesterol =0.09), age (η2age =0.07), and plasma albumin (η2plasma albumin=0.02). Separate models revealed that overall NS activity was significantly predictive of ETP in both adults (R2=0.27) and children (R2=0.57). When the models were reconstructed using the UP:C-defined remission interaction function rather than quadratic UP:C, they were similarly predictive with only minor changes in the correlation coefficients (Overall model: R2=0.40, Adults only: R2=0.29, Children only: R2=0.57; Table S3). In all models, UP:C had the greatest effect on ETP, followed by total cholesterol, with plasma albumin having the least influence.
Discussion
In this study of comprehensively phenotyped patients we found that hypercoagulopathy, as determined by ETP, is proportional to NS disease activity and confirmed this finding in a separate cohort.40 Importantly, NS-hypercoagulopathy improved commensurately with complete or partial remission. We also found that the acquired hyperlipidemia of NS has a previously unreported influence on NS-hypercoagulopathy. These data suggest that both proteinuria and hyperlipidemia exert greater influence on NS-hypercoagulopathy than albumin, which is presently the only clinically utilized biomarker.15, 16 In contrast to studies linking VTE-risk to both acquired antithrombin (AT) deficiency and NS histologic classification, we found no association between these variables and NS-hypercoagulopathy.4-7 Our multivariable models demonstrated that NS disease activity biomarkers were independently predictive of ETP and that the composite models were more predictive than the individual variables. These findings are expected to inform the design of studies needed to move toward evidence-based anticoagulant prophylaxis recommendations for patients with NS.
We have previously demonstrated that ETP is proportional to disease activity in NS animal models.23 The present data show that these pre-clinical observations are translatable to human NS, suggesting that these animal models may be utilized for robust pre-clinical investigations of NS-hypercoagulopathy. Recently, viscoelasticity assays have been used to characterize human NS-hypercoagulopathy.21, 41 Viscoelasticity was proportional to hypoalbuminemia, but not proteinuria, in MN patients whereas MCD patients were similar to healthy controls.21 However, in a subsequent MN study, the same laboratory reported viscoelastic changes proportional to proteinuria, serum albumin, triglycerides, platelet count, fibrinogen, and AT.41 While whole blood viscoelasticity assays thus offer a promising method for clinical NS-hypercoagulopathy research, they are difficult to apply to multicenter study settings because they require fresh whole blood samples, making interlaboratory standardization problematic.42, 43 Others have shown that ETP is elevated in human NS but the studies were underpowered to demonstrate a significant relationship with disease activity.22 Here we found that ETP was significantly related to NS activity and is thus a robust NS-hypercoagulopathy marker amenable to centralized laboratory testing using frozen and shipped samples. While this may simplify the analysis of hypercoagulopathy in multicenter NS studies, thrombin generation may not detect important contributions from cellular elements (e.g. platelets) that may be captured using whole blood viscoelasticity methods. Nonetheless, our animal model data suggest that the thrombin generation and viscoelastic methods may be interchangeable.23
Epidemiologic studies have shown that VTE-risk during NS is dependent upon both serum albumin and proteinuria, with albumin being the most widely studied.10, 11, 17-20 Thus, current guidelines suggest the use of serum albumin as a clinically relevant VTE-risk biomarker.15 As expected, ETP was dependent upon both proteinuria and albumin levels in our univariate analyses. Interestingly, total cholesterol was also independently predictive of ETP. Although hyperlipidemia is a well-described diagnostic feature of NS, it is generally not followed as a biomarker of NS disease activity.3, 38 However, hyperlipidemia may contribute to atherothrombotic complications of NS and has been associated with VTE-risk in post-menopausal women.1, 44, 45 Surprisingly, in this study, total cholesterol was more strongly associated with ETP status than was albumin. In MN patients, triglycerides (but not cholesterol) are associated with viscoelastic hypercoagulopathy which was ameliorated in patients taking statins.41 Similarly, statin use has been shown to both reduce VTE-risk in patients with NS and to reduce ETP in VTE patients without NS.46, 47 Moreover, cholesterol is known to enhance thrombin generation, an effect that is correctable with statin therapy.48 Very low-density lipoprotein (VLDL) has been shown to have the greatest effect on thrombin generation, followed by chylomicrons, and low-density lipoprotein (LDL).49, 50 However, oxidized LDL has a similar effect on thrombin generation as VLDL.49 Because all lipid components may be elevated in NS and were associated with ETP in this study, further study will be required to reveal which lipid components contribute most to thrombin generation during NS.1, 44
It has long been suggested that NS-hypercoagulopathy is due to urinary losses of AT resulting in intravascular AT depletion.4-7 Thus, it was not unexpected that 28% of the NEPTUNE samples had an AT activity <70%, a level which may be considered clinically relevant.51 We thus postulated that AT activity would be strongly correlated with ETP. To our surprise, however, we found no relationship between AT and ETP. This suggests that other, yet unknown, mechanisms drive ETP elevation during NS. As reviewed by our group and others, several other mechanisms (including hyperlipidemia) have been proposed,4, 6 but limited biorepository sample volume availability precluded further mechanistic exploration within the context of this study.
While NS, regardless of underlying histopathology, is associated with increased VTE risk, epidemiologic studies suggest that VTE is most prevalent amongst those with MN.4, 13-15, 18, 19, 52 It was thus surprising that ETP did not vary significantly by histopathology and thus does not explain the histopathologic variability in VTE predisposition. With the recent discovery that autoimmunity against phospholipase A2 receptor (PLA2R) or thrombospondin type-1 domain-containing 7A (THSD7A) are major mechanisms underlying MN, it is possible that disrupted PLA2R or THSD7A signaling are driving a prothrombotic vascular response.53-57 Local vascular responses might also explain the peculiar propensity for renal vein thrombosis during MN.4
Previous non-NS studies have demonstrated that ETP increases with age.58, 59 In contrast, we observed higher ETP in children than adults and no correlation with age within either age group. This difference may simply reflect sample size limitations, since we did not set out to study age as an EPT variable, or may be a function of NS pathology such that NS-hypercoagulopathy has a greater influence on ETP than does age. These data are limited by the lack of one or more confirmatory hypercoagulability assays, which were not possible given the biorepository sample volume restraints. Nonetheless, these data are congruent with previous single institution studies using viscoelastic methods.21 They are also congruent with the viscoelastic and ETP patterns we previously described in NS animal models.23 Moreover, we found similar patterns in the Columbus cohort which provides some evidence of internal validity. While this study was not designed or powered to determine ETP or NS activity biomarker thresholds predictive of thrombosis, appropriate power for such a study can now be extrapolated from these data. Future studies should thus be directed toward discerning VTE-risk thresholds that may guide the development of more effective and safer use of anticoagulant prophylaxis for patients with NS.
In summary, NS is a profoundly prothrombotic medical condition due, at least in part, to its acquired hypercoagulopathy. NS-hypercoagulopathy has now been shown to be proportional to disease activity using both viscoelastic and thrombin generation assays. The latter technique offers the opportunity to comprehensively study these associations within multicenter NS cohorts using a centralized laboratory to standardize analyses.24 It is hoped that these studies will lead to the development of evidence-based biomarker thresholds to guide appropriate, safe, and effective use of anticoagulant prophylaxis for patients with NS.
Methods
Study Subjects
NEPTUNE Cohort
The composition of the Nephrotic Syndrome Study Network (NEPTUNE) has been described previously.38, 40, 60 The study is registered at clinicaltrials.gov (NCT01209000) and each subject (or their parent/guardian) provided written, informed consent prior to participation. Participants were enrolled from 24 clinical sites in North America with local IRB approval at each institution. Briefly, adults and children with proteinuria (≥500 mg/d on a 24 h urine sample or UP:C ≥0.5 g/g on spot urine) were eligible for enrolment at the time of a first clinically indicated renal biopsy. Histologic classification of disease subtype (MCD, FSGS, or MN) was confirmed by core pathology review.61-63 Because renal biopsy at presentation is not the standard of care in pediatrics, children (≤18 y) were also eligible for enrolment based upon the above proteinuria criteria alone. Exclusion criteria included life expectancy <6 months, prior solid organ transplantation, and kidney manifestations of systemic disease. For the purposes of the present study, participants with a recorded prescription for anticoagulant or antiplatelet medications were excluded, as were participants with a pre-enrolment history of VTE. Sodium citrate anticoagulated blood was collected from NEPTUNE participants using standard of care phlebotomy techniques at the time of enrolment and at follow-up intervals, processed to plasma within one hour, aliquoted, frozen at ‾80°C, and transferred to the Michigan Biobank. Corresponding phenotypic data for each patient’s sample was collected from the NEPTUNE Data Coordinating Center database (tranSMART). The pre-defined criteria for complete and partial remission utilized for NEPTUNE (UP:C ≤0.3 and UP:C <3.5 plus a ≥50% UP:C reduction, respectively) were applied where indicated.
Columbus Cohort
Because thrombin generation is easily confounded by pre-analytic variables that are not easily controlled using biorepository samples and because thrombin generation samples should ideally be collected into sodium citrate supplemented with corn trypsin inhibitor, a locally derived comparison cohort was recruited.37, 64 These patients were subject to the same eligibility criteria as the NEPTUNE participants, including exclusion for pre-enrolment VTE history, anticoagulant, or antiplatelet medications. This portion of the study was approved by the Nationwide Children’s Hospital Institutional Review Board (IRB12-00290) in reciprocity with The Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center IRB (neither institution is a NEPTUNE site). Written informed consent was obtained from each participant or parent/guardian. Blood was collected only at the time of enrolment, processed to plasma within one hour, and locally maintained at ‾80°C until analyzed. A simultaneous random urine sample was collected without preservatives, aliquoted, and frozen at ‾80°C for UP:C analysis.
Phenotypic Data
UP:C assays were performed in a NEPTUNE central laboratory, and these values were extracted along with other phenotypic data. For the Columbus cohort, NS subtype was extracted from institutional pathology reports and UP:C was determined using spectrophotometric methods by Nationwide Children’s clinical laboratory.
Plasma Samples
Aliquots (200 μL) of plasma isolated from blood collected into 0.105 M buffered sodium citrate tubes (0.32% final concentration citrate) were obtained from the NEPTUNE biorepository. For the Columbus cohort, blood was collected into final concentration 0.32% sodium citrate / 1.45 μM corn trypsin inhibitor (Haematologic Technologies Inc., Essex Junction, VT, USA) and platelet poor plasma (PPP) was prepared as previously described, aliquoted, and frozen at ‾80°C until further analysis.23, 37
Thrombin Generation Assays
Thrombin generation assays (TGA) were performed using the Technothrombin TGA kit (Technoclone, Vienna, Austria) and TGA RC Low reagent using a Spectramax M2 fluorescent plate reader (Molecular Devices, Sunnyvale, California). The hemostatic activators in RC Low reagent consist of ≤5 pM recombinant tissue factor lipidated in ≤3.2 μM phospholipid micelles (final concentration <0.6 mM phospholipid).65, 66 Relative fluorescence units (RFU) were converted to thrombin generation curves using Technoclone Evaluation Software which also calculates endogenous thrombin potential (ETP). A previous study demonstrated that meaningful thrombin generation data could be derived from human plasma at dilutions up to 1:4 and TGA parameters do not change significantly with dilutions up to 1:1.35, 67 Thus, due to limited biorepository specimen volumes, TGA dilution studies were performed on NEPTUNE samples randomly selected to represent the full spectrum of proteinuria to determine the minimal necessary sample volume (Figure S2). These experiments demonstrated no differences in TGA parameters over the full range of dilutions studied (neat, 3:1, 2:1, and 1:1 plasma-to-buffer ratios). Therefore, to conserve available aliquot volumes, the 2:1 dilution was used for all analyses reported in this study. All TGA were performed in duplicate and reported as the mean ETP.
Albumin and Antithrombin Assays
Plasma albumin was quantified using a bromocresol purple commercial assay kit according to the manufacturer’s instructions (BioAssay Systems, Hayward, CA).68 It should be noted that plasma albumin differs from serum albumin by sodium citrate dilution in a variable manner that is dependent on the patient’s hematocrit (not recorded) at the time of collection (9:1 whole blood to anticoagulant ratio). Antithrombin activity was determined as previously described, modified to use human pooled normal plasma for the standard curve.23, 69
Statistical Analyses
Descriptive analyses were conducted on all participants using frequencies and percentages for categorical variables and medians and interquartile ranges for continuous variables. Descriptive statistics were also stratified by cohort within NEPTUNE. Correlations between ETP and NS variables were displayed using scatter plots and quantified with Spearman’s correlation coefficients (ρ). ETP was modeled using linear regression. The following covariates were tested as unadjusted predictors of ETP: age, sex, race, ethnicity, disease cohort, duration of disease, log-UP:C (transformed due to right-skewedness), plasma albumin, eGFR, antithrombin activity, total cholesterol, HDL, LDL, triglycerides, treatment with lipid modifying agents, steroids, any immunosuppressive, or RAAS blockade (each treatment category as separate categories coded as “treated vs. untreated”), alcohol use, and tobacco use. Any variable that was significant with unadjusted p<0.05 on univariate analysis entered a multivariable backwards selection process. There was little missing data and analyses were performed on a complete case basis. There was complete data capture for ETP, UP:C, plasma albumin, and eGFR. Three participants were missing centrally measured cholesterol values. Variables were removed from the model in descending order of p-value until all remaining variables were significant with p<0.05. All analyses were performed using SAS v9.4 (Cary, NC).
Data Availability
Data are available via tranSMART data base according to the NEPTUNE ancillary study policy (see: https://www.rarediseasesnetwork.org/cms/neptune/Healthcare-Professionals/Ancillary).
Disclosure Statement
The authors declare no competing interests.
Author contributions
SVP, BHR, WES, MK, and BAK enrolled patients and collected samples. APW and KJW performed the laboratory assays. APW, JPT, and BAK performed the data analyses and statistics. MTN, WES, MK, and BAK conceived the study. MK and BAK provided financial support. APW, JPT, and BAK wrote the paper. All authors refined the final draft.
Addendum
NEPTUNE Enrolling Centers:
Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH: J Sedor*, K Dell*, M Schachere#, J Negrey#
Children’s Hospital, Los Angeles, CA: K Lemley*, E Lim#
Children’s Mercy Hospital, Kansas City, MO: T Srivastava*, A Garrett#
Cohen Children’s Hospital, New Hyde Park, NY: C Sethna*, K Laurent #
Columbia University, New York, NY: G Appel*, M Toledo#
Duke University, Durham, NC: L Barisoni*
Emory University, Atlanta, GA: L Greenbaum*, C Wang**, C Kang#
Harbor-University of California Los Angeles Medical Center: S Adler*, C Nast*‡, J LaPage#
John H. Stroger Jr. Hospital of Cook County, Chicago, IL: A Athavale*, M Itteera
Johns Hopkins Medicine, Baltimore, MD: A Neu*, S Boynton#
Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN: F Fervenza*, M Hogan**, J Lieske*, V Chernitskiy#
Montefiore Medical Center, Bronx, NY: F Kaskel*, N Kumar*, P Flynn#
NIDDK Intramural, Bethesda MD: J Kopp*, J Blake#
New York University Medical Center, New York, NY: H Trachtman*, O Zhdanova**, F Modersitzki#, S Vento#
Stanford University, Stanford, CA: R Lafayette*, K Mehta#
Temple University, Philadelphia, PA: C Gadegbeku*, D Johnstone**, S Quinn-Boyle#
University Health Network Toronto: D Cattran*, M Hladunewich**, H Reich**, P Ling#, M Romano#
University of Miami, Miami, FL: A Fornoni*, C Bidot#
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI: M Kretzler*, D Gipson*, A Williams#, J LaVigne#
University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC: V Derebail*, K Gibson*, A Froment#, S Grubbs#
University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA: L Holzman*, K Meyers**, K Kallem#, J Lalli#
University of Texas Southwestern, Dallas, TX: K Sambandam*, Z Wang#, M Rogers#
University of Washington, Seattle, WA: A Jefferson*, S Hingorani**, K Tuttle** §, M Bray #, M Kelton#, A Cooper# §
Wake Forest University Baptist Health, Winston-Salem, NC: B Freedman*, JJ Lin**
Data Analysis and Coordinating Center: M Kretzler, L Barisoni, C Gadegbeku, B Gillespie, D Gipson, L Holzman, L Mariani, M Sampson, J Troost, J Zee, E Herreshoff, S Li, C Lienczewski, J Liu, T Mainieri, M Wladkowski, A Williams
Digital Pathology Committee: Carmen Avila-Casado (UHN-Toronto), Serena Bagnasco (Johns Hopkins), Joseph Gaut (Washington U), Stephen Hewitt (National Cancer Institute), Jeff Hodgin (University of Michigan), Kevin Lemley (Children’s Hospital LA), Laura Mariani (University of Michigan), Matthew Palmer (U Pennsylvania), Avi Rosenberg (NIDDK), Virginie Royal (Montreal), David Thomas (University of Miami), Jarcy Zee (Arbor Research) Co-Chairs: Laura Barisoni (Duke University) and Cynthia Nast (Cedar Sinai)
*Principal Investigator; **Co-investigator; #Study Coordinator
‡Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, Los Angeles, CA
§Providence Medical Research Center, Spokane, WA
Acknowledgments
We are indebted to the patient volunteers for their participation in the NEPTUNE and Columbus cohorts as well as the investigators and staff at each of the enrollment centers who made this study possible.
Footnotes
↵8 See Addendum for Nephrotic Syndrome Study Network (NEPTUNE) Investigators and Affiliations.
Funding Sources: This project was supported by grants U54DK083912 (MK), U54DK083912-05S1 and U54DK083912-07S1 (MK and BAK), and K08DK103982 (BAK) from the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (NIDDK) and UL1TR002240 from the National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences (NCATS) for the Michigan Institute for Clinical and Health Research. The Nephrotic Syndrome Study Network Consortium (NEPTUNE), U54DK083912, is a part of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) Rare Disease Clinical Research Network (RDCRN), supported through a collaboration between the Office of Rare Diseases Research (ORDR), NCATS, and NIDDK. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health. Additional funding and/or programmatic support for NEPTUNE have been provided by the University of Michigan, the NephCure Foundation, and the Halpin Foundation.