Smartphone addiction and its association with common mental disorders among students attending the university of Dschang, West region, Cameroon

1. Background

Common mental disorders refer to two main diagnostic categories: depressive disorders and anxiety disorders [1]. These disorders are highly prevalent in the general population (reason why they are considered ‘common’), and impact on the mood or feelings of affected persons [1]. Symptoms range from mild to severe in terms of severity and months to years in terms of duration [1]. These disorders lead to huge losses in work participation and productivity, and yet lend themselves to effective and accessible treatment as part of an integrated program of chronic disease management [1]. In 2010, worldwide, an estimated US$2.5–8.5 trillion in lost output was attributed to mental, neurological and substance use disorders, depending on the method of assessment used [2]. This amount is expected to nearly double by 2030 if a concerted response is not mounted [2]. In view of this concern, the promotion of mental health and wellbeing has been explicitly included in the United Nations’ 2015–30 Sustainable Development Goals [3]. A review reported a prevalence of depression of 33% among university students [4] while two other reviews on anxiety reported a global prevalence ranging from 0.9-28.3% [5] and a prevalence of anxiety disorders in adult populations of 3.8-25% [6] respectively. Student mental health is a growing concern [7] and there is evidence that university students tend to have higher rates of depression than the general population [4].

A smartphone is a mobile phone that performs many of the functions of a computer, typically having a touch screen interface, internet access, and an operating system capable of running downloaded applications [8]. It had been projected that by 2020 the population of smartphone owners would reach 6.1 billion, which is about 70% of the world’s population [9]. Many new users are expected to emerge from developing countries through greater device affordability, growing economies, and young, growing populations [9]. Several studies have examined the relation between smartphone use and common mental disorders [10,11,12,13,14]. Without statistically adjusting for other relevant variables, depression severity was consistently related to problematic smartphone use [15]. The extent of the problem of depression and anxiety among students in low-and middle-income countries (LMICs) is largely unknown [16]. In a recent systematic review with meta-analysis, Sohn and colleagues examined the association between problematic smartphone use and mental health outcomes amongst children and young adults. Although this was a global review which included evidence for the seven-year period 2011-2017 and had no language restriction in its literature search strategy, only studies from Europe, America and Asia were retained. This strongly indicates the huge gap in evidence on the association between smartphone addiction and common mental illnesses in sub-Saharan Africa [17]. This study therefore sought to estimate the prevalence of smartphone addiction in university students who use smartphones; to estimate the prevalence of common mental in the students and to determine the association between smartphone addiction and these mental disorders.

2. Methods

3. Results

3.4. Smartphone use

Participants reported spending on average 7.2 hours per day on their smartphones (with females spending more time (8hours) than males (6.5hours) and spent an average amount of $1.5 per week on communication credit or data bundles for their phones. Smartphones were mostly used for social media activities (39.3%) and short message services (35.8%). Figure 1 shows the main activities performed when using smartphones.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1: Main activities performed on smartphones by students

In our sample, 53.67% [340/634, 95% C.I: 49.74%-57.48%] of participants attested that using smartphone affects their academic performance and among these participants, 64.41% [219/634, C.I: 59.19%-69.31%] declared that it affects their performance positively. The prevalence of smartphone addiction was 20.98% [C.I:17.99%-24.32%].

4. Discussion

The objectives of this cross-sectional study were to determine the prevalence of smartphone addiction and common mental disorders and the association between smartphone addiction and these mental disorders among students attending a state university in Cameroon. This study is one of the largest of its kind in sub-Saharan Africa and is an important contribution to the crucial lack of data on mental illnesses and the association between smartphone use and these mental illnesses in sub-Saharan Africa. We found that smartphone addiction, depression and anxiety were prevalent especially among females and bachelor’s degree students. Smartphones were mainly used for social media activities and SMS. There was strong evidence of an association between smartphone addiction and common mental disorders even after controlling for multiple a priori confounders. Apart from the large sample size, other strengths of the study are the use of multistage random sampling to enroll study participants and logistic regression modeling to assess if there is an association between smartphone addiction and common mental illnesses. The above sampling method and the use of logistic regression are key strategies to reduce sampling bias and confounding bias respectively and they both increase the internal validity of the results.

Previous studies have demonstrated that smartphone addiction among students tends to be high [22,23] with some authors reporting addiction percentages of almost 50% in their samples [22]. A previous cross-sectional study involving medical students in multiple state universities in Cameroon reported major depressive disorders in about a third of study participants [24]. Our results are comparable to these findings and our study further concurs with this previous report in that students with symptoms of common mental disorders tended to be females. Larger and more robust studies in the United Kingdom [25] and the United States of America [26] concluded that women have higher rates of common mental disorders than men. It has been proposed that the higher prevalence of depressive symptoms in women may be as a result of triggering by hormonal changes, particularly during puberty, prior to menstruation, following pregnancy and at perimenopause [27]. Mental health improvement programmes must consider this gender difference in order to foster equity in the access to and utilisation of effective mental health services.

Social media and smartphones took most of the time spent using smartphones. Similar results were obtained in previous studies conducted out of Africa [28,29] which found that social networking are the most time spending activities. Thus, our results concur with the general tendency for problematic smartphone users to report social media as the most preferred activity on smartphone [27]. In the general population, smartphone and social media use are far more common in younger and educated population segments as our study sample.

The magnitude of the association (when observed) between problematic smartphone use and common mental disorders varies across literature and this may be due to the differences in data collection methods (such as face-to-face versus online), and assessment tools for measuring addiction and mental health disorders, and variations in baseline characteristics of the study populations. For instance, our study involved a student population that was relatively young, and the data was collected via face-to-face interviews while in the Middle East, Alhassan and colleagues studied data collected using web-based questionnaires administered to adults [29,30]. The two studies also used different methods of measuring depressive symptoms: Beck’s Depression Inventory in the study by Alhassan and collaborators [17] and PHQ-9 in our study. A global review by Sohn and colleagues found that there is a significant association between problematic smartphone use and common mental health disorders [17]. Albeit our results concur with the findings of this review, it should be noted that the review synthesised evidence from Europe, America and Asia and not Africa [17]. Further studies in the sub-Saharan African context are therefore needed to make more meaningful comparisons.

This study is not without limitations. Data were collected from students from the university of Dschang, so the results should be interpreted with caution when referring to other segments of the general population. Additionally, social desirability bias and recall bias during the filling of the questionnaire as well as lack of adjustment for other potential confounders such as socioeconomic status, sleep pattern and history of intimate partner violence may have reduced the validity of our findings. Moreover, it is possible that the validity of the results was also affected by measurement bias given that depression and anxiety were assessed using self-reported psychological symptoms measured using PHQ-9 and PHQ-7 which have not been validated in Africa. In order to provide much stronger evidence on the association between smartphone use and common mental illnesses, larger observational studies involving structured interviews by clinicians, adjustment for a broader range of confounders and assessment of reverse causality should be conducted.

5. Conclusion and recommendation

Depression and anxiety were prevalent in the study population. Smartphone addiction was found to be associated with these common mental disorders. In this setting, it is crucial to foster strategies of prevention and promotion in mental health especially among problematic smartphone users. Apart from raising awareness on these issues among students, the ministry of higher education in collaboration with the ministry of health could consider integrating more functional psychosocial support and basic mental health services with pre-existing programmes in university settings. In order to assess if there is evidence of stronger causal relationships between smartphone addiction and mental health problems, much larger observational studies are warranted.

Data availability

The data used to support the findings of this study are available from the corresponding author upon request.

Conflicts of interest

The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest

Authors’ contributions

Martial Pianta Sonkoue and Jerome Ateudjieu conceived the study and did the literature review. They also prepared the protocol for this study. Martial Pianta Sonkoue, Miranda Baame Esong and Cyrielle Djouda Douanla collected the data. Martial Pianta Sonkoue, Benjamin Momo Kadia and Jerome Ateudjieu analysed and interpreted the data. Martial Pianta Sonkoue, Miranda Baame Esong and Cyrielle Djouda Douanla prepared and edited the manuscript. Benjamin Momo Kadia critically reviewed the technical and intellectual consistency of the manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.

Funding

No funding was obtained for the conduct of this study