Effect of Respiratory Muscle Training on Dysphagia in Stroke Patients - A Retrospective Pilot Study

Introduction

The physiological process of deglutition comprises a complex set of events which begin when a given food, liquid, and/or medication bolus is introduced into the oral cavity via the lips and ends once the same bolus empties from the esophagus via the lower esophageal sphincter into the stomach [1].

The signs and symptoms of swallow pathophysiology may include but are not limited to prolonged mastication, food/liquid/medication residuals in the oral cavity after the swallow, impaired labial containment of secretions as well as portions of a given food, liquid, and/or medication bolus, nasal regurgitation, a delay in the onset of the swallow, coughing, choking, regurgitation of bolus materials after a swallow, globus, and weight loss [2]. For the purpose of this paper, dysphagia is defined as dysfunctional swallow physiology involving the oral cavity, velopharyngeal port, larynx, pharynx, esophagus, and/or the lower esophageal sphincter. This is consistent with the definition provided by the American Speech-Language-Hearing Association (ASHA) [3].

Although dysphagia can occur across the lifespan from neonates to geriatrics, it is more prevalent in the elderly (over 65) due to age-mediated muscle degeneration, and in those with neurological disorders such as stroke, multiple sclerosis (MS) and Parkinson’s disease (PD) [4,5]. While dysphagia affects 11% of elderly Americans living in communities, prevalence rises to 25% in hospitalized individuals and to 55% in people living in elderly care facilities. Other sources report an average prevalence of 13.5% to 22.6% in unselected adults, almost half of which have not discussed their recurrent swallow problems with a physician. In patients with underlying neurological disorders, the prevalence is significantly higher up to 64% in stroke patients, 34% in MS and 81% in PD patients [4,6,7].

Consequences of dysphagia include malnutrition, dehydration, and weight loss, as well as increased risk of cardiac and respiratory conditions. Dysphagia is associated with a 13% increase in mortality, and causes 60,000 deaths per year in the US due to complications, especially aspiration pneumonia. Following a stroke, aspiration pneumonia increases the risk of mortality as well as the average cost of hospitalization by $27,633 [8].

Furthermore, dysphagia poses a significant burden on the healthcare system due to prolonged hospital stays, and the need for passive enteral feedings in affected patients. In the US, the current annual economic burden is estimated at $547 million for prolonged hospitalization and $670 million for enteral feeding supplies, amounting to total annual costs well in excess of $1 billion, with an expected annual increase due to the aging population [4,9]. In addition, patients over 65 presenting with dysphagia, choking or globus represent 37.6% of all emergency department visits for food-mediated adverse events [10].

Treatment of dysphagia reflects the complexity of the disorder, and requires a multidisciplinary approach. Early intervention and therapy is associated with reduced risk of aspiration pneumonia and quicker recovery [11,12].

Both the muscles of inhalation as well as the muscles of exhalation are critical integrated components of the upper aerodigestive tract, whose function is necessary for swallow physiology [13]. Strengthening of either muscle group by inspiratory muscle strength training (IMST) or expiratory muscle strength training (EMST), respectively, has shown positive effects on respiration as well as on swallow physiology [14–17]. Some studies have also shown an exercise regimen which includes both IMST and EMST as separate components of the treatment plan to be beneficial in maximizing airway safety with swallowing in neurological patient populations [18,19]. The investigators elected to utilize a combined resistive IMST and EMST device (The Breather™, PN Medical Inc., US Patent Number 4,739,987)[20], thus allowing for simultaneous strengthening of the muscles of inhalation and exhalation [21,22]. This retrospective pilot study analyzes the effectiveness of a 4 week combined respiratory muscle training (cRMT) program on swallow function in stroke patients with diagnosed dysphagia following a single cerebrovascular accident (CVA). This research received an IRB exemption - HIPAA full waiver of authorization and regulatory opinion from the Western Institutional Review Board.

Methods

Data analyzed in this study is derived from persons who resided in the State of Alabama whose health had been compromised by a single acute CVA and who lacked a pay source to cover the cost of swallow therapy. Each subject had been referred to pro bono clinical Speech-Language Pathology (SLP) services as needed through the Office of Hispanic Ministry at a Catholic Church in the Greater Birmingham Area of Alabama. Data was collected between 1998 and 2009.

Subjects who met the inclusion criteria presenting with dysphagia after a cerebrovascular accident (CVA) were included in this study. Inclusion criteria comprised of no prior neurological history, no history of swallow deficits prior to CVA, no pharmacological or surgical interventions, and no other therapy for swallowing during the study period. Exclusion criteria were failure to meet one or more of the inclusion criteria. In addition, there was no therapy of any other kind, including physiotherapy, occupational therapy, respiratory therapy, or speech therapy. Subjects were controlled for age, sex, race, hemisphere of CVA, presence of single CVA without extension. While all patients remained on the referral waiting list for treatment, each patient was offered a choice to be trained in the use of The Breather™. Subjects who chose to use cRMT were considered as the intervention group (IG), while patients who chose to not use cRMT were treated as the control group (CG) for analysis.

Results

Discussion

The data analysis presented reveals the benefits of the utilization of cRMT as an effective therapy in the treatment of neurogenic dysphagia following CVA. Four weeks of using a combined resistive RMT therapy device significantly improved airway safety with swallow function, compared to no direct treatment. Clinical parameters that improved included both objective measures such as PEF, FEES and FOIS, as well as subjective evaluations such as the VAS and MASA. These findings underline the effectiveness of the applied RMT method in the setting of dysphagia following stroke.

Subjects evaluated in this study had employed a resistive combined inspiratory and expiratory muscle trainer that provides training resistance by breathing through different sized apertures covered by a silicone membrane. This method differs from the also widely distributed threshold devices. In contrast to previously reported different outcomes related to the type of device, recent research has revealed no significant differences in treatment outcomes when controlling for threshold dependent RMT devices and non-threshold dependent RMT devices. Some of the evidence highlighted increased cost-effectiveness and simpler instructions for usage of non-threshold RMT devices compared to threshold dependent RMT devices [28–30]. As the application of cRMT is likely to be more comprehensive than using IMST and/or EMST separately or sequentially, it may therefore be less cumbersome and more cost effective to use cRMT in lieu of IMST and/or EMST alone.

Respiratory muscle weakness (RMW) and associated swallow dysfunction is prevalent in stroke patients, with a reduction in respiratory muscle strength by approximately 50%, compared to matched controls. These deficiencies may contribute to tracheobronchitis and pneumonia due to aspiration, decreased cough effectiveness and poor pulmonary hygiene. On average, post-stroke pneumonia affects 10% of all patients, on average, and is associated with higher mortality, hospitalization rates, worse outcomes, and higher care needs [31,32].

Respiratory muscle training is an evidence-based strategy targeting RMW. It follows the principle that respiratory muscles respond to exercise and training stimuli in the same manner as skeletal muscles do, a notion that was originally observed by the Greek physician Claudius Galen [33], and that has inspired the development of systematic training of the respiratory muscles [34]. Regular workload by training against resistance triggers respiratory muscle hypertrophy, fiber formation, and improved function. This improves the adaptability of respiratory muscles to increased ventilatory demand, and/or the functionality of laryngeal and pharyngeal muscles used for speech and swallow.

This study showed that respiratory muscle strengthening of both the inspiratory and expiratory muscles significantly improves peak flow and swallowing function, as assessed by swallowing ability, food intake and penetration/aspiration, in patients with CVA. 4 weeks of cRMT improved peak flow by 168%, penetration/aspiration by 70%, food oral intake by 94%, and swallowing ability by 37% (table 2).

Improvements in peak expiratory flow may correlate with more efficient clearance of supraglottic and tracheal secretions or aspirated material, which is also reflected by improved PAS scores. Associated improvements in deglutition can be expected to reduce pneumonia and malnutrition. Furthermore, improved peak expiratory flow may contribute to reduced risk of mortality, as peak flow has recently been identified as an independent predictor of mortality in the aging population [35].

The overall findings are in agreement with Pitts et al (2009), in that RMT of the expiratory muscles improved swallowing and cough function in patients with PD, including cough acceleration for improved airway clearance and increased penetration/aspiration scores, indicating improved efficacy during swallowing. A 4 week intervention of EMST improved the penetration/aspiration scores by 41%, and cough acceleration volume by 103% [36]. In contrast, other studies have not found EMST to be beneficial in post-stroke patients [32].Differences in outcomes may be attributed to different training regimes and adherence during the study period, and may also be device dependent. Furthermore, unilateral exercise limited to strengthening of the expiratory muscle group may limit effectiveness of this approach as an adjunctive approach for neurogenic swallow physiology rehabilitation. Further research is warranted.

Conclusion

This study analyzes the use of a resistive device which trains both inspiratory as well as expiratory muscle strength, while comparable studies may have employed devices that add workload to only one part of the breath cycle, or that provide insufficient workloads to elicit respiratory muscle hypertrophy. These approaches may be insufficient, as evidence reveals that functionality of both aspects of the breath cycle is required for effective cough and pulmonary hygiene [38]. This study therefore confirms feasibility, usefulness, and effectiveness of combined inspiratory and expiratory muscle training (cRMT) in people with dysphagia. Further investigations evaluating the effect of cRMT on dysphagia are warranted to verify the findings of the studies in larger and more diverse populations.

Disclosures and Contributions

NB serves as independent Chief Scientist for PN Medical. RJA declares no conflict of interest.