Assessing spread risk of Wuhan novel coronavirus within and beyond China, January-April 2020: a travel network-based modelling study

Objective To estimate the potential risk and geographic range of Wuhan novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) spread within and beyond China from January through to April, 2020.

Design Travel network-based modelling study.

Setting and participants General population travelling from Wuhan and other high-risk cities in China.

Main outcome measures Based on de-identified and aggregated mobile phone data, air passenger itinerary data, and case reports, we defined the relative importation risk and internal and international destinations of 2019-nCoV from Wuhan and other high-risk cities in China.

Results The cordon sanitaire of Wuhan is likely to have occurred during the latter stages of peak population numbers leaving the city before Lunar New Year (LNY), with travellers departing into neighbouring cities and other megacities in China, and a high proportion of cases likely travelled with symptoms at the early stage of the outbreak. Should secondary outbreaks occur in 17 high-risk secondary cities, they could contribute to seeding the virus in other highly connected cities within and beyond China after the LNY holiday. We estimated that 59,912 air passengers, of which 834 (95% UI: 478 - 1349) had 2019-nCoV infection, travelled from Wuhan to 382 cities outside of mainland China during the two weeks prior to Wuhan’s lockdown. The majority of these cities were in Asia, but major hubs in Europe, the US and Australia were also prominent, with strong correlation seen between predicted importation risks and reported cases seen. Because significant spread has already occurred, a large number of airline travellers (3.3 million under the scenario of 75% travel reduction from normal volumes) may be required to be screened at origin high-risk cities in China and destinations across the globe for the following three months of February to April, 2020 to effectively limit spread beyond its current extent.

Conclusion Further spread of 2019-nCoV within China and international exportation is likely to occur. All countries, especially vulnerable regions, should be prepared for efforts to contain the 2019-nCoV infection.

WHAT IS ALREADY KNOWN ON THIS TOPIC

• The World Health Organization has declared the 2019-nCoV outbreak in China a Public Health Emergency of International Concern. Apparently originating from Wuhan, the virus has caused 20,530 confirmed cases across China, as of February 4^th, 2020, and 153 cases reported in other 23 countries, as of February 3^rd, 2020, with most having a travel history involving Wuhan.

• Based on initial cases from Wuhan, 2019-nCoV has acquired human-to-human transmissibility, with an estimated basic reproductive number of 2.2 (95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.4 – 3.9). Transmission through asymptomatic contacts has also been reported.

• According to Wuhan authorities, it is likely that more than five million residents had already left the city prior to the cordon sanitaire of the city that has been in place since January 23, 2020, just two days before the Lunar New Year (LNY). Where these travellers went and how high the risk of further spread of the virus within and beyond China is remains an open question.

WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS

• Given the rapidly growing number of 2019-nCoV infections and limited understanding of the virus, we used spatio-temporally detailed domestic and international population movement data to infer the relative importation risk from Wuhan to secondary and tertiary cities across China before, during and after the LNY holiday.

• We estimated the virus importation risk and potential destinations across the world from Wuhan and high-risk cities in mainland China during the LNY holiday and over the following three months.

• The novel datasets from phones and travel itineraries used provide new insights on the impacts of internal and international connectivity on the ongoing and potential transmission of this emerging pathogen.

• We explored various scenarios of travel restrictions and estimated the number of international airline travellers likely needing to be quarantined or screened to capture travellers potentially exposed to 2019-nCoV in high-risk cities of mainland China.