PT  - JOURNAL ARTICLE
AU  - Sherratt, K.
AU  - Gruson, H.
AU  - Grah, R.
AU  - Johnson, H.
AU  - Niehus, R.
AU  - Prasse, B.
AU  - Sandman, F.
AU  - Deuschel, J.
AU  - Wolffram, D.
AU  - Abbott, S.
AU  - Ullrich, A.
AU  - Gibson, G.
AU  - Ray, EL.
AU  - Reich, NG.
AU  - Sheldon, D.
AU  - Wang, Y.
AU  - Wattanachit, N.
AU  - Wang, L.
AU  - Trnka, J.
AU  - Obozinski, G.
AU  - Sun, T.
AU  - Thanou, D.
AU  - Pottier, L.
AU  - Krymova, E.
AU  - Barbarossa, MV.
AU  - Leithäuser, N.
AU  - Mohring, J.
AU  - Schneider, J.
AU  - Wlazlo, J.
AU  - Fuhrmann, J.
AU  - Lange, B.
AU  - Rodiah, I.
AU  - Baccam, P.
AU  - Gurung, H.
AU  - Stage, S.
AU  - Suchoski, B.
AU  - Budzinski, J.
AU  - Walraven, R.
AU  - Villanueva, I.
AU  - Tucek, V.
AU  - Šmíd, M.
AU  - Zajícek, M.
AU  - Pérez Álvarez, C.
AU  - Reina, B.
AU  - Bosse, NI.
AU  - Meakin, S.
AU  - Di Loro, P. Alaimo
AU  - Maruotti, A.
AU  - Eclerová, V.
AU  - Kraus, A.
AU  - Kraus, D.
AU  - Pribylova, L.
AU  - Dimitris, B.
AU  - Li, ML.
AU  - Saksham, S.
AU  - Dehning, J.
AU  - Mohr, S.
AU  - Priesemann, V.
AU  - Redlarski, G.
AU  - Bejar, B.
AU  - Ardenghi, G.
AU  - Parolini, N.
AU  - Ziarelli, G.
AU  - Bock, W.
AU  - Heyder, S.
AU  - Hotz, T.
AU  - E. Singh, D.
AU  - Guzman-Merino, M.
AU  - Aznarte, JL.
AU  - Moriña, D.
AU  - Alonso, S.
AU  - Álvarez, E.
AU  - López, D.
AU  - Prats, C.
AU  - Burgard, JP.
AU  - Rodloff, A.
AU  - Zimmermann, T.
AU  - Kuhlmann, A.
AU  - Zibert, J.
AU  - Pennoni, F.
AU  - Divino, F.
AU  - Català, M.
AU  - Lovison, G.
AU  - Giudici, P.
AU  - Tarantino, B.
AU  - Bartolucci, F.
AU  - Jona Lasinio, G.
AU  - Mingione, M.
AU  - Farcomeni, A.
AU  - Srivastava, A.
AU  - Montero-Manso, P.
AU  - Adiga, A.
AU  - Hurt, B.
AU  - Lewis, B.
AU  - Marathe, M.
AU  - Porebski, P.
AU  - Venkatramanan, S.
AU  - Bartczuk, R.
AU  - Dreger, F.
AU  - Gambin, A.
AU  - Gogolewski, K.
AU  - Gruziel-Slomka, M.
AU  - Krupa, B.
AU  - Moszynski, A.
AU  - Niedzielewski, K.
AU  - Nowosielski, J.
AU  - Radwan, M.
AU  - Rakowski, F.
AU  - Semeniuk, M.
AU  - Szczurek, E.
AU  - Zielinski, J.
AU  - Kisielewski, J.
AU  - Pabjan, B.
AU  - Holger, K.
AU  - Kheifetz, Y.
AU  - Scholz, M.
AU  - Bodych, M.
AU  - Filinski, M.
AU  - Idzikowski, R.
AU  - Krueger, T.
AU  - Ozanski, T.
AU  - Bracher, J.
AU  - Funk, S.
TI  - Predictive performance of multi-model ensemble forecasts of COVID-19 across European nations
AID  - 10.1101/2022.06.16.22276024
DP  - 2022 Jan 01
TA  - medRxiv
PG  - 2022.06.16.22276024
4099  - http://medrxiv.org/content/early/2022/06/16/2022.06.16.22276024.short
4100  - http://medrxiv.org/content/early/2022/06/16/2022.06.16.22276024.full
AB  - Background Short-term forecasts of infectious disease burden can contribute to situational awareness and aid capacity planning. Based on best practice in other fields and recent insights in infectious disease epidemiology, one can maximise the predictive performance of such forecasts if multiple models are combined into an ensemble. Here we report on the performance of ensembles in predicting COVID-19 cases and deaths across Europe between 08 March 2021 and 07 March 2022.Methods We used open-source tools to develop a public European COVID-19 Forecast Hub. We invited groups globally to contribute weekly forecasts for COVID-19 cases and deaths reported from a standardised source over the next one to four weeks. Teams submitted forecasts from March 2021 using standardised quantiles of the predictive distribution. Each week we created an ensemble forecast, where each predictive quantile was calculated as the equally-weighted average (initially the mean and then from 26th July the median) of all individual models’ predictive quantiles. We measured the performance of each model using the relative Weighted Interval Score (WIS), comparing models’ forecast accuracy relative to all other models. We retrospectively explored alternative methods for ensemble forecasts, including weighted averages based on models’ past predictive performance.Results Over 52 weeks we collected and combined up to 28 forecast models for 32 countries. We found a weekly ensemble had a consistently strong performance across countries over time. Across all horizons and locations, the ensemble performed better on relative WIS than 84% of participating models’ forecasts of incident cases (with a total N=862), and 92% of participating models’ forecasts of deaths (N=746). Across a one to four week time horizon, ensemble performance declined with longer forecast periods when forecasting cases, but remained stable over four weeks for incident death forecasts. In every forecast across 32 countries, the ensemble outperformed most contributing models when forecasting either cases or deaths, frequently outperforming all of its individual component models. Among several choices of ensemble methods we found that the most influential and best choice was to use a median average of models instead of using the mean, regardless of methods of weighting component forecast models.Conclusions Our results support the use of combining forecasts from individual models into an ensemble in order to improve predictive performance across epidemiological targets and populations during infectious disease epidemics. Our findings further suggest that median ensemble methods yield better predictive performance more than ones based on means. Our findings also highlight that forecast consumers should place more weight on incident death forecasts than incident case forecasts at forecast horizons greater than two weeks.Code and data availability All data and code are publicly available on Github: covid19-forecast-hub-europe/euro-hub-ensemble.Competing Interest StatementThe authors have declared no competing interest.Funding StatementAA, BH, BL, LWa, MMa, PP, SV funded by National Institutes of Health (NIH) Grant 1R01GM109718, NSF BIG DATA Grant IIS-1633028, NSF Grant No.: OAC-1916805, NSF Expeditions in Computing Grant CCF-1918656, CCF-1917819, NSF RAPID CNS-2028004, NSF RAPID OAC-2027541, US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 75D30119C05935, a grant from Google, University of Virginia Strategic Investment Fund award number SIF160, Defense Threat Reduction Agency (DTRA) under Contract No. HDTRA1-19-D-0007, and respectively Virginia Dept of Health Grant VDH-21-501-0141, VDH-21-501-0143, VDH-21-501-0147, VDH-21-501-0145, VDH-21-501-0146, VDH-21-501-0142, VDH-21-501-0148. AF, AMa, GL funded by SMIGE - Modelli statistici inferenziali per governare l'epidemia, FISR 2020-Covid-19 I Fase, FISR2020IP-00156, Codice Progetto: PRJ-0695. AM, BK, FD, FR, JK, JN, JZ, KN, MG, MR, MS, RB funded by Ministry of Science and Higher Education of Poland with grant 28/WFSN/2021 to the University of Warsaw. BRe, CPe, JLAz funded by Ministerio de Sanidad/ISCIII. BT, PG funded by PERISCOPE European H2020 project, contract number 101016233. CP, DL, EA, MC, SA funded by European Commission - Directorate-General for Communications Networks, Content and Technology through the contract LC-01485746, and Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovacion y Universidades and FEDER, with the project PGC2018-095456-B-I00. DE., MGu funded by Spanish Ministry of Health / REACT-UE (FEDER). DO, GF, IMi, LC funded by Laboratory Directed Research and Development program of Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL) under project number 20200700ER. DS, ELR, GG, NGR, NW, YW funded by National Institutes of General Medical Sciences (R35GM119582; the content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of NIGMS or the National Institutes of Health). FB, FP funded by InPresa, Lombardy Region, Italy. HG, KS funded by European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control. IV funded by Agencia de Qualitat i Avaluacio Sanitaries de Catalunya (AQuAS) through contract 2021-021OE. JDe, SMo, VP funded by Netzwerk Universitatsmedizin (NUM) project egePan (01KX2021). JPB, SH, TH funded by Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF; grant 05M18SIA). KH, MSc, YKh funded by Project SaxoCOV, funded by the German Free State of Saxony. Presentation of data, model results and simulations also funded by the NFDI4Health Task Force COVID-19 (www.nfdi4health.de/task-force-covid-19-2) within the framework of a DFG-project (LO-342/17-1). LP, VE funded by Mathematical and Statistical modelling project (MUNI/A/1615/2020), Online platform for real-time monitoring, analysis and management of epidemic situations (MUNI/11/02202001/2020); VE also supported by RECETOX research infrastructure (Ministry of Education, Youth and Sports of the Czech Republic: LM2018121), the CETOCOEN EXCELLENCE (CZ.02.1.01/0.0/0.0/17-043/0009632), RECETOX RI project (CZ.02.1.01/0.0/0.0/16-013/0001761). NIB funded by Health Protection Research Unit (grant code NIHR200908). SAb, SF funded by Wellcome Trust (210758/Z/18/Z).Author DeclarationsI confirm all relevant ethical guidelines have been followed, and any necessary IRB and/or ethics committee approvals have been obtained.YesThe details of the IRB/oversight body that provided approval or exemption for the research described are given below:All source data were openly available before the study, originally available at: https://github.com/covid19-forecast-hub-europe/covid19-forecast-hub-europeI confirm that all necessary patient/participant consent has been obtained and the appropriate institutional forms have been archived, and that any patient/participant/sample identifiers included were not known to anyone (e.g., hospital staff, patients or participants themselves) outside the research group so cannot be used to identify individuals.YesI understand that all clinical trials and any other prospective interventional studies must be registered with an ICMJE-approved registry, such as ClinicalTrials.gov. I confirm that any such study reported in the manuscript has been registered and the trial registration ID is provided (note: if posting a prospective study registered retrospectively, please provide a statement in the trial ID field explaining why the study was not registered in advance).YesI have followed all appropriate research reporting guidelines and uploaded the relevant EQUATOR Network research reporting checklist(s) and other pertinent material as supplementary files, if applicable.YesAll source data were openly available before the study, originally available at: https://github.com/covid19-forecast-hub-europe/covid19-forecast-hub-europe. All data and code for this study are openly available on Github: covid19-forecast-hub-europe/euro-hub-ensemble. https://github.com/covid19-forecast-hub-europe/euro-hub-ensemble https://github.com/covid19-forecast-hub-europe/covid19-forecast-hub-europe