Caregiver Mind-Mindedness Training as an Early Intervention for Social Anxiety in Children: A protocol for an RCT intervention

1.1 Background and Rationale

Social anxiety impacts a significant number of children, particularly preschoolers, and has long-term mental health implications if left unaddressed (Costello et al., 2003; Hitchcock et al., 2009; Newman et al., 1996). Anxiety symptoms in young people have been exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic (Racine et al., 2021). Social anxiety is characterised by feelings of distress and avoidance of social settings due to a fear of negative evaluation (Beidel, 1991) which can impair the development of social relationships and pose challenges in adapting to school life (Strauss et al., 1987; Strauss et al., 1988). Anxiety levels often begin to present between the ages of 2-4, likely due to significant life changes such as starting preschool (Wang & Zhao, 2015; Zhou & Li, 2022). The preschool period is a critical stage in a child’s life, as it involves significant changes in the teacher, peers, and school environment, which can be challenging to navigate (Ladd, 2003; Pianta, 2007). Parenting style and attachment are strongly linked to childhood anxiety (Bogels & Brechman-Toussaint, 2006; Bowlby, 1969). Early intervention for preschoolers with social anxiety, through targeted approaches that focus on parenting and attachment, can help prevent symptoms from escalating into more severe disorders as the child develops (Albano, 2003; Bell-Dolan et al., 1990). The preschool years are therefore of critical importance for anxiety prevention efforts. While the impact of parenting style and attachment on a child’s anxiety is well-documented, interventions often focus exclusively on the child, neglecting the crucial role of caregiver behaviour (Bogels & Brechman-Toussaint, 2006).

One particular aspect of caregiver behaviour is Mind-Mindedness (MM). MM involves a caregiver’s ability to recognise and respond to a child as an individual with their own thoughts, feelings, and intentions (Fonagy & Luyten, 2009; Meins, 1997). Higher levels of MM are associated with secure attachment and positive socioemotional outcomes (Aldrich et al., 2021; Bernier, 2017; Meins, 1997; Sharp et al., 2006). There is little work focusing on whether caregiver’s MM relates to social anxiety in children or whether interventions which support MM in caregivers impact children’s social anxiety. However, there is some indirect evidence which may suggest that caregiver’s MM is associated with children’s social anxiety through attachment and Theory of Mind. For instance, caregiver MM is associated with attachment (Fonagy & Luyten, 2009; Meins, 1997) and ToM (Aldrich et al., 2021; Bernier & Dozier, 2003; Bernier, 2017; Foley et al., 2023).

Meins presents a link between lower MM and a child’s insecure attachment (Meins, 1998, 2011; Meins, 2001). Several interventions have been developed to enhance maternal MM, including video feedback and smartphone apps, all of which have demonstrated promise across diverse caregiver populations (Colonnesi et al., 2012; Larkin et al., 2019; Schacht et al., 2017). Importantly, it appears that caregivers’ socioeconomic status and child characteristics do not significantly impact MM levels, indicating that these interventions can be broadly applicable regardless of background or individual child traits (McMahon & Bernier, 2017; Meins, 2011). A relationship has been shown between maternal and paternal MM with child attachment security and theory of mind abilities (Bernier & Dozier, 2003; Foley et al., 2023).

Based on attachment theory, early experiences with caregivers shape internal working models that affect future relationships (Bowlby, 1969). Thus, children who are securely attached are better able to understand different perspectives within relationships (Berlin et al., 1995). Insecure attachment is a risk factor for internalising problems such as anxiety (Brumariu & Kerns, 2010; Colonnesi et al., 2011) while secure attachment is associated with appropriate mind-related comments and fewer non-attuned comments (Arnott, 2007; Meins, 2001). Previous studies have indicated that parent cognitions may play a vital role in mediating the relationship between parent and child difficulties (Dix et al., 1986; Sadler et al., 2006; Sharp et al., 2006; Wheatcroft & Creswell, 2007). Some research suggests that MM might be a better predictor than the sensitivity of attachment status (E Meins, 2002) at least be a prerequisite for sensitivity (Laranjo et al., 2008). Therefore, focusing on MM in interventions may improve outcomes for families.

Maternal MM has been found to be predictive of children’s Theory of mind (ToM), the ability to understand and attribute mental states to oneself and others (Bernier et al., 2010; Meins, 1999; Wellman, 1992). Mothers who describe their children in more mental terms have children who perform better on tasks that require an understanding of false beliefs (Hughes et al., 2018; Meins, 1998). Moreover, higher ToM abilities are linked to secure attachment in preschoolers (Laranjo et al., 2014; Meins et al., 2018). On the other hand, poor ToM abilities are associated with childhood anxiety disorders and negative interpretive biases (Hezel, 2014; Moldovan & Visu-Petra, 2022).

This study will focus on examining whether training caregivers in MM can reduce social anxiety in preschoolers by improving attachment security and ToM abilities. Understanding these pathways from MM to childhood anxiety can help inform preventative interventions targeting early socio-cognitive development. Therefore, the proposed mechanisms in this study are attachment and theory of mind. MM strongly predicts child attachment security (Laranjo et al., 2008), which provides an anxiety buffer. Insecure attachment is linked to increased internalizing symptoms (Colonnesi et al., 2011). Caregiver’s MM also forecasts children’s theory of mind abilities (Meins, 2013).

Parental mentalization (MM) is strongly linked to secure attachment in children. Interventions that target MM could improve attachment security. Future research should prioritize MM as a key intervention target to address gaps in how attachment behaviours are passed from parent to child, especially when parents struggle to understand and respond to their child’s emotional needs. Consistent parental behaviours, such as emotional responsiveness, promote secure attachment in children. Interventions, such as training programs to enhance parents’ ability to perceive and interpret their child’s emotions, can help bridge these gaps, supporting children’s emotional and social development (Arnott, 2007; Atkinson & Goldberg, 2003; Bernier & Dozier, 2003; Tansy M. Walker et al., 2012).

Various interventions have been developed to enhance MM, ranging from video feedback to smartphone apps, demonstrating promise in diverse caregiver populations (Colonnesi et al., 2012; Larkin et al., 2019; Schacht et al., 2017). Upon closer examination of these interventions, it becomes evident that their effectiveness largely depends on addressing the unique needs of caregivers. Factors such as accessibility, ease of use, and the relevance of the content play crucial roles in determining the success of each intervention format. By enhancing caregivers’ MM, they are better equipped to cultivate secure attachments and establish a nurturing environment, and they can significantly decrease the symptoms of social anxiety in their children.

Various interventions have been conducted by researchers to explore the link between child development and caregivers’ mind-related comments. Schacht et al.(2017) reported that a single-session video-feedback intervention was effective in reducing non-attuned comments (Schacht et al., 2017). This intervention proved to be beneficial for mother-infant interactions even up to the second year of life. Another study conducted by Larkin et al. developed the BabyMind app, which was successful in increasing mothers’ MM even among vulnerable groups, such as adolescent mothers (Larkin et al., 2019). Walker’s (2012) research emphasized the importance of MM in preschool clinical interventions (T. M. Walker et al., 2012).

This paper proposes an RCT of MM training for caregivers of socially anxious preschoolers. This study emphasizes the need to adapt interventions for diverse populations. Research indicates culture shapes caregiving approaches, parenting behaviours, and attachment styles (Arnett & Arnett, 2015; Keller, 2013). Some studies reveal differences in MM across Western and Eastern cultures. For instance, British parents exhibit higher MM towards children compared to Chinese parents, but both show positive links between MM and child theory of mind (Hughes et al., 2017). Research indicates that Western mothers engage in more mental state talk with children than Eastern mothers (Doan & Wang, 2010). Collectivist values in Eastern cultures prioritizing hierarchy and conformity versus individuality in the West impact manifestations of MM in parent-child interactions (Kağıtçıbaşı, 2007; Keller et al., 2007). According to some research traditional gender norms can also affect father-daughter relationships and emotional attunement in Persian families specifically (Golian Tehrani et al., 2015; Mousavi et al., 2020). For instance, in a study comparing parenting practices in the UK and India, they found notable differences: UK mothers made more mind-minded comments, while Indian mothers issued more instructions and positive comments, reflecting cultural priorities (Bozicevic et al., 2023). These differences highlight the influence of cultural contexts on parenting practices. Recognizing and understanding these variations can guide the development of interventions sensitive to cultural contexts, ultimately promoting healthier outcomes for children worldwide(Arnett & Arnett, 2015; Bornstein, 2006).

2.1 Objectives

The main aim of this study is to evaluate the efficacy of the caregiver’s MM training in reducing social anxiety symptoms among preschool children. Additionally, to examine how culture (Iranian and British) moderates the relationship between caregiver’s MM training and reductions in social anxiety symptoms among preschool children.

2.2 Trial design

This study protocol outlines the design and methodology of a randomized controlled trial aimed at investigating whether MM training for caregivers can effectively reduce social anxiety symptoms in preschoolers by employing a cross-cultural approach involving caregivers from the UK and Iran. Participants will be randomly assigned to either the MM training intervention group or a peer support (control) group. Randomization will be carried out separately for each country’s sample. Stratified random sampling will ensure a balanced allocation within each country’s participants.

2.3 Study setting

The study will be conducted in two countries: the United Kingdom and Iran. The intervention and all measurements will be held online.

2.4 Participants

The study aims to recruit 100 primary caregivers (aged 18-60 years) of preschool-aged children (aged 4-7 years) who exhibit symptoms of social anxiety. Eligible participants must reside in either the United Kingdom or Iran. Caregivers whose children have existing clinical diagnoses or are currently receiving other forms of treatment or support will not be included in the study.

Recruitment strategies will include advertisements in preschools and nurseries, word-of-mouth referrals, and recommendations from teachers. Participants will be selected based on observable social anxiety symptoms, with the goal of creating a homogeneous sample. The sample will be balanced, ensuring an equal distribution between the two countries. Due to the nature of the intervention, participant blinding is not possible, as caregivers will need to actively engage in either mindfulness meditation training or peer support groups and will be aware of their group assignments. However, the assessors responsible for data collection and analysis—including those evaluating mindfulness meditation, child social anxiety, attachment, and theory of mind—will remain blinded to the group allocations to ensure an unbiased evaluation of outcomes.

To enhance participant retention and reduce attrition, several strategies will be implemented. These will include clear communication protocols, flexible scheduling options, and modest incentives for completing assessments. Participants will receive systematic reminders about their sessions, and a dedicated support structure will be available throughout the duration of the study. Additionally, data from participants who deviate from the protocol will be included in the intention-to-treat analysis. This approach will help preserve the integrity of the randomization process while minimizing bias and ensuring that the findings are practically applicable and generalizable.

2.5 Procedure

Participant allocation will be carried out using a computer-generated randomization sequence through Random Allocation Software 2.0, which will assign caregivers to either the mind-mindedness (MM) training intervention group (n=50) or the peer support control group (n=50). The randomization will be stratified by country (UK and Iran) to maintain a balanced allocation within each cultural context.

Data collection will take place at three time points: baseline (T0), post-intervention (T1), and 3-month follow-up (T2). This will utilize validated assessment measures, including the MM Coding Manual 2.2(Meins, 2015), for mind-mindedness, the Spence Children’s Anxiety Scale(Spence, 1997), for assessing child social anxiety, the Attachment Insecurity Screening Inventory (Spruit et al., 2018), for attachment assessment, and the Theory of Mind Task Battery(Hutchins et al., 2012) for evaluating the theory of mind.

Additionally, demographic information (such as age, gender, socio-economic status, and cultural background) will be collected to describe the study population and control for potential confounding variables. Program adherence will be monitored through attendance records and weekly caregiver reflections on their experiences.

The informed consent process will follow institutional guidelines, ensuring participants receive detailed study information in their preferred language (English or Farsi). Participants will have opportunities to ask questions and will receive a clear explanation of their right to withdraw from the study. The Principal Investigator (PI) is responsible for obtaining informed consent from all potential trial participants.

Comprehensive data protection measures will be implemented, including secure storage of consent forms and assessment data in encrypted, password-protected files. Unique participant identifiers will be assigned, and access will be restricted to authorized research personnel only. All data management procedures will comply with GDPR and local data protection regulations. The final dataset will be accessible only to the research team and will be stored according to Heriot-Watt University’s data retention policy. This thorough approach to randomization, data collection, and protection ensures both scientific validity and participant confidentiality throughout the study.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Fig1. Participants’ Timeline

2.6 Intervention

This study aims to reduce social anxiety in preschoolers by tailoring an MM intervention that targets parents to alleviate social anxiety levels in their children. Collaborating with parents and caregivers will result in a more effective and tailored solution that resonates with their practical needs and experiences. Their input can lead to a more feasible and impactful study design, refining eligibility criteria, recruitment, and data collection procedures. A participatory co-design was conducted in order to strengthen the quality and outcomes of this research. The intervention will be identical in both countries, with the only difference being the language used for the program. All other elements, such as the structure, content, delivery methods, and materials of the MM training program, will remain uniform across both locations.

The MM training program will consist of three online sessions, each lasting one hour and conducted over three consecutive weeks. The training sessions will be conducted through Zoom, and participants will receive a unique link to access the platform securely. This training is designed to equip caregivers with strategies for attuned, mentalizing caregiving, focusing on enhancing their ability to understand and respond to their child’s emotional and mental states.

The first session will introduce the concept of mind-mindedness and its importance in caregiving. It will include psychoeducation on the development of social anxiety in children and how caregiver responsiveness plays a crucial role. Caregivers will also be introduced to basic emotion coaching techniques, which will be explored in more depth in the second session. The second session will focus on teaching and practising these emotion coaching techniques, helping caregivers recognize, validate, and guide their children’s emotions in a supportive manner. The final session will deepen the caregivers’ understanding through reflective discussions and advanced role-play scenarios that address common challenges in caregiving with socially anxious children.

All three sessions will include video examples demonstrating effective and ineffective approaches, as well as role-play exercises where caregivers can practice these techniques with guided feedback. The role-plays will be led by trained child psychologists. They will give immediate feedback and answer questions to ensure that caregivers are effectively practicing mentalizing caregiving. Throughout the training, caregivers will receive support materials and reminders to track their progress and reflections. Participation will be tracked through attendance records and the completion of reflection activities to make sure that participants are following the program guidelines.

The peer support (control) group group will access a private online group for the exchange of experiences and coping strategies related to the child’s anxiety, without direct MM training.

The comprehensive set of measures includes assessments of MM, child anxiety scales, and evaluations of attachment and theory of mind.

Measures of MM will be coded from caregiver descriptions of the child using the MM Coding Manual 2.2 (Meins, 2015). Child anxiety will be assessed with the Spence Children’s Anxiety Scale (Spence, 1997).

Attachment will be measured using the Attachment Insecurity Screening Inventory (Spruit et al., 2018). Theory of mind will utilize the Theory of Mind Task Battery (Hutchins et al., 2008). The three-day MM training program incorporates psychoeducation, role-play exercises, and practical sessions, while the peer support (control) group serves as an active control condition.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Fig2. RCT design

2.7 Statistical methods

3.1 Trial status

Ethical approval for the study was granted by the Social Sciences Ethics Committee of Heriot-Watt university in September 2024. Recruitment will commence on 16th September 2024. This study is expected to be completed by February 2025.