“Creating a culturally competent pharmacy profession”: a qualitative exploration of pharmacy staff perspectives of cultural competence and its training in community pharmacy settings

Definitions and understanding

Cultural competence was believed by most participants to relate to the awareness and appreciation of another person’s culture, with one explaining that being culturally competent is “about understanding and appreciating people from a lot of diverse backgrounds – that are different to yours. So that’s whatever ethnicity you are, it’s understanding about cultures and upbringing and all the things that make you, you” (Participant 8). In this sense, cultural competence was interpreted, in a wider social context, as a skill that an individual can develop through interactions with people from different cultures. Other participants described cultural competence as a concept relative to health, and drew on their medicines expertise to address this; they described cultural competence as being “inclusive in your treatment of those patients and being able to build that into the way we approach patient care and healthcare decisions” (Participant 6).

“You’ve got to be aware of issues such as religion, race or cultural differences that may require a different approach to treating that patient… you know what they can and can’t eat for example, you can offer them alternative medication with products that wouldn’t be offensive or unacceptable to them” (Participant 5).

Cultural beliefs influencing decisions about medicines

Participants provided examples where it was important to be aware of formulation considerations and excipients within medications. Specifically, the suitability of capsules containing pork products for someone practicing religions including Islam or Judaism was discussed, with one participant stating “somebody who’s Muslim wouldn’t be happy with pork products, like gelatine, in their capsules” (Participant 4). Others also recalled examples of investigating alternative medications to suit a patient’s cultural needs. A pharmacist explained, “it took me probably a couple of hours to source the medication in liquid form… I had to ring manufacturers and contact lots of different companies to try and find an alternative and (pause) it took a lot of time” but they “knew it was super important to them [the patient] and if was me in their shoes, I wouldn’t have taken that medication because it’s not acceptable” (Participant 5). It was acknowledged by many participants that although it may take additional time to source suitable medications for patients, it was important for delivering high quality care, and there was an underpinning belief that these additional considerations would lead to a more individualised approach to patient care.

Other participants reflected that the beliefs of certain cultures may impact on an individual’s ability to engage with healthcare access or medicines-taking. It was suggested that certain cultural beliefs could pose as barriers to individuals accessing the care that they need, as there may be cultural stigma surrounding certain health conditions. A pharmacist recalled an example where a Muslim patient, who was receiving methadone treatment, said he would be “mortified if a person from their community had seen them” (Participant 4). The pharmacist contemplated that “some people perceive that Muslims don’t drink and therefore it’s unusual for a Muslim to end up on methadone or a dependent substance” (Participant 4). They hinted that patients should not be labelled under common stereotypes and that health professionals should know to provide equal treatment to patients, regardless of their cultural background.

“I think it’s about being concerned that they [patients] may be stigmatised within their community… or if it’s perhaps not something that’s seen as appropriate in their religion. It’s a little bit about shame, and personal shame and er, feeling like they’re going against the cultural norm for them. I think that stigma could potentially prevent them seeking help for their conditions” (Participant 4).

Two participants reflected on experiences of barriers that prevented a person seeking healthcare or medication advice, because they were “a female (pharmacy professional) and their (the patient) religion means they can’t, or shouldn’t, interact with females” (Participant 5). Suggestions were given around possible ways to overcome such barriers, even “how pharmacy regulators could engage with key members of those communities to try and explain how we can work together to overcome that” (Participant 5).

“I think that one of the hardest challenges is where maybe the gender of the person who delivering the care, is not seen as being appropriate to speak to a male member of the public and say, ‘It’s ok to engage with a female member of staff at the pharmacy. You’re not going to get in trouble if you do that’” (Participant 5).

Recognising the diversity of populations accessing community pharmacies

Participants discussed that community pharmacies are unique healthcare settings; they are an accessible “source of health advice and health care, where you can speak to a qualified professional, all without requiring an appointment” (Participant 3). One participant reflected that being a community pharmacist meant “you are often the first point of contact like in the community for any patient” (Participant 1) and one counter assistant recognised the diversity of patients that attend community pharmacies, stating “it’s not always the same ethnicity (within the patients we are treating) and you’re rarely going to get a pharmacy that only has one ethnicity (in its population)” (Participant 12). Participant views across all job roles within community pharmacy described the potential for interactions with members of a diverse population accessing the pharmacy. One participant viewed the potential for community pharmacies to be regarded as “cultural hubs” that local communities can access, knowing they will “be recognised and spoken to in way that accounts for them and their culture” (Participant 11).

Most of the participants had experience working within various pharmacies across the UK and were able to recall differences in the level of diversity between the pharmacies on a national-level, as well as on a local-level. One participant discussed their experience of working as a locum pharmacist across a number of cities across the North East of England, where diversity differences were even noticed “only 2-miles down the road you’ve got an entirely different community living there and they’ll most likely need different approaches to people living 2-miles the other direction” (Participant 6). Another pharmacist acknowledged diversity differences comparing inner-city pharmacies; they described “particularly in the North East, like in [name of major city], you can cross the bridge and find communities that are highly populated with Jewish people, or you can cross another bridge and find areas even more diverse again, like housing for refugees or asylum seekers from War torn countries” (Participant 6). There was also suggestion that pharmacies located in areas of higher deprivation contained a greater population of ethnic minority patients. One pharmacist discussed noticing diversity variations between two pharmacies they worked at with “different sort of socio-economic areas between [names of two villages]” (Participant 7). As well, a participant who worked in Scotland suggested “where I work, [name of city], it’s like an affluent rural area… so I would say predominantly the community is Caucasian, middle class people” (Participant 4).

Questioning the inclusivity of pharmacy services

There was variation between participant perspectives on whether their pharmacy services demonstrated inclusivity towards patients from ethnic minority groups. Most participants believed their pharmacy services could better appreciate a person’s culture when providing care. One pharmacy technician stated “I think people are polite (pause), generally. But I don’t think there’s anything in place to first recognise a patient’s cultural needs and then go from there” (Participant 8).

Approaches that could improve the inclusivity of pharmacy services were discussed, with many relating to language and the need for translators or interpreters to support conversations about medicines. Translation and interpreter services were recognised as a potentially beneficial pharmacy service for patients who do not speak English as “a lot of information that we give across to patients i.e., patient information leaflets, which are inside and the boxes and everything, well the majority are just in English” (Participant 7). Another participant, who worked in an area with a higher level of deprivation, discussed strategies employed in their pharmacy which was managed by a pharmacist from an ethnic minority background. They described how steps towards being more culturally inclusive included “translated medicine instructions on the wall sometimes posters are in different languages… I don’t know it just feels different working in that pharmacy compared to your average pharmacy, in that they’re more inclusive” (Participant 9). It was also acknowledged by several participants that community pharmacy records “may not have someone’s ethnicity in the notes that you can see” (Participant 8) and the benefit of making this information readily accessible was suggested, to inform decisions made by pharmacy professionals about the best course of treatment for a patient.

“I’d say we could probably do more, and that’s probably all community pharmacies in general. And it’s even things like having leaflets in a different language available – I mean we can print them off, but do we? I’m aware of a company that’s er that does prescription transcribing in hundreds of different languages and it’s more accurate that Google Translate. But it’s only a very small number of pharmacies that are using it. But I think the ones that are, it is just so helpful to the patients” (Participant 10)

Gaining trust and forming culturally-respectful relationships

Participants reflected on factors that might negatively impact on building culturally-respectful relationships; for example, the effect of language barriers if a person has limited or low English language proficiency, or use of colloquialisms when conversing with someone that does not speak English as a first language. A counter assistant reflected “where I work you sort of know a lot of the people that come in – they’re like locals so you can have that like joke or bit of a chat with them. And with someone of a different background, you don’t always have that. And er, it can be a bit tricky” (Participant 3). In fact, using cultural colloquialisms to build a better rapport with patients was highlighted by a pharmacist. They stated that within Asian cultures “they call like ‘Auntie’ and ‘Uncle’, they use that language and it’s friendly language instead of ‘Mr or Mrs’. Er, yeah, very friendly terms used to create more of that rapport within the community” (Participant 9).

Building trust and establishing culturally-respectful relationships was deemed by one participant to be potentially more challenging to achieve between a pharmacist and a patient from a different ethnicity or different culture. The employment of staff members from ethnic minority backgrounds was recognised as a strategy to overcome this. Many participants reflected on examples they had witnessed where staff members who spoke languages other than English were asked to speak to certain patients. One pharmacist stated that their pharmacy had “quite a few Romanian customers who come in because they know that they can speak to someone in their language. Er, and I think they tell their friends, ‘If you go to this pharmacy, they’ll speak Romanian’” (Participant 1). It was speculated that this approach could help overcome communication barriers between pharmacy staff and patients, by enabling inclusive conversations about medicines in a person’s native language. Further, it was considered that diversity within pharmacy staff may lead to greater patient satisfaction rates specifically focused on medicines; one participant stated “so, I know it’s important to build a rapport up with someone, but then to be able to have a proper focused conversation understand it from a certain cultural perspective… that’s like, that’s achieving a proper goal for us” (Participant 9). A dispensing assistant echoed this thinking, describing “when a patient who comes in who’s a Sikh, for example, our pharmacist is a Sikh so he can focus on their background and kind of knows where they’re coming from when they’re asking about if it (their medication) is suitable” (Participant 2).

Perspectives on current cultural competence training

There was a consensus amongst participants involved in this study that their education and training was lacking in topics encompassing cultural competence and its place within the pharmacy profession. Some pharmacist participants stated that they remembered receiving some cultural competence training once they had qualified, but this was included as part of a “bigger topic such as Equality & Diversity or Protected Characteristics” within the workplace environment (Participant 7). These perspectives around the paucity of cultural competence training were shared with other community pharmacy staff, where one counter assistant stated that “you just sort of have to deal with it yourself, you don’t really get any training on that” (Participant 3). In fact, there was a common opinion that due to the lack of cultural competence training within professional teaching, it was necessary for individuals to educate themselves on cultural competence. One pharmacist reported “this thinking wasn’t built into our teaching really. It wasn’t er something we were taught; it was just a good thing for you to look up in your spare time” (Participant 1).

All interviewees regarded cultural competence as a necessary and important skill and all were in agreement that some form of education should be built into pharmacy staff training. One pharmacy technician stated “I think whoever you are, if you are talking to members of the public who come into the pharmacy or are someone who speaks to patients, you should have gone through a minimum level of training on cultural competence” (Participant 8). However, across the different job roles within community pharmacy, there was a mixed consensus on who should receive cultural competence training and to what level/depth. Almost all participants felt that cultural competence training should be provided for counter assistants, with one participant stating “a person walks in and the first people they’ll speak to is the counter staff” (Participant 5). It was acknowledged that if counter assistants were not trained on cultural competence, “it may affect the treatment of a patient and could potentially impact how much a patient will use the pharmacy or whether they come back or feel comfortable even coming in(to the pharmacy)” (Participant 1). When discussing their perspectives, a pharmacy dispenser expressed that pharmacists “are the main people who are giving advice out so if they’re not competent in what they’re saying (pause), then it’s not going to help the situation” (Participant 2).

Despite acknowledging the importance and place of cultural competence training, a number of participants suggested that the profession of pharmacy, as a whole, has unmet needs around the training and delivery of culturally competent patient care. One participant mentioned that, following the Black Lives Matter movement, they have requested additional training on cultural competence from their employer to improve their knowledge. Another reflected on the growing discussion of equality and inclusivity in wider society, stating that “the (COVID-19) pandemic was what brought the whole issue about inequalities to light in my mind, and since then I’ve been thinking about what it means for these patients from other communities” (Participant 13).

“… I don’t think, personally, as a profession, we’re prepared really. And we don’t have that awareness – I certainly don’t feel like I’m optimally prepared for dealing with situations where I have a lack of knowledge about someone’s ethnic background. It’s actually something that I’ve requested at work is some training around it” (Participant 5)

Suggestions for the delivery of cultural competence training

Participants gave suggestions on how cultural competence could be incorporated into formalised training for each professional group. The training for counter assistants was described involving “booklets at the start… which you had to complete, and you had so long to complete them. And if you pass them, you’re classed as a counter assistant” (Participant 3). The same participant went on to mention that “it [cultural competence training] should be in the booklet when you initially start, and that should definitely be covered in the booklet” (Participant 3). Another counter assistant held a different opinion and suggested that “if it was in a training handbook like where you watch videos and answer quizzes, then people maybe wouldn’t take it seriously. Er, like people might do the quiz and not actually care or take it in as actually being important” (Participant 12). They reflected on the potential for variation in the population of each pharmacy, dependent on geographic location, as well as postulating a constant, dynamic change in “people living nearby, ‘cos those trends of communities choosing to live in a certain area might change” (Participant 12). When asked about what should be taught within this training, it was proposed that a basic understanding and awareness of different cultures should be taught “I think just explaining what it (cultural competence) is and maybe an idea on how different backgrounds, you know, different people – their views on sort of… pharmacy and medicines and things like that” (Participant 3).

There was a suggestion made that it may be beneficial to teach cultural competence training separately within the different professions and tailoring the training towards each professions’ specific roles within the pharmacy. A dispenser proposed that “if everyone’s taught separately but on the same kind of guidelines, so it (cultural competence training) kind of factors in their different job roles… then it’s helpful if it’s got some examples of what we can do, personally, relevant to us” (Participant 2).

Every pharmacist interviewed agreed that cultural competence training should be taught within the undergraduate Masters of Pharmacy (MPharm) degree; however, there were differing perspectives on the value it holds within the degree’s curriculum. One pharmacist remarked “I think it should be taught, I think it’s core, it’s just as important as learning about pregnancy and drugs in pregnancy… it needs to be included in the curriculum” (Participant 5). As well, participants discussed the need for cultural competence to underpin the entirety of their learning, rather than only featuring in one part of the degree. There was a particular emphasis on introducing “this way of thinking” from the first year of the degree, with one foundation trainee pharmacist discussing the value in having “these types of discussions or training from like an earlier stage, and from a younger age at university… that would be good as opposed to leaving it until you’re in the workplace like I am now” (Participant 14). Whilst other pharmacists recognised its importance, they considered the logistics of integrating cultural competence training within the greater context of the MPharm degree curriculum and acknowledged that there may limited room to include this training. One pharmacist stated that cultural competence training should be “definitely part of it [the MPharm]. I don’t know if I’d say a big part. Er (pause) not because it’s not important – just thinking more in terms of how you’d fit it all in” (Participant 6).

Pharmacists offered suggestions on how cultural competence training could be delivered within the MPharm degree. The most frequently mentioned methods considered adopting an integrated approach to teaching, for example through the inclusion of ethnic minority patients within workshops, patient-case examples and observed structured clinical examination (OSCE) stations, as well as exposing students to working with people from ethnic minority communities on placements.

“In case studies when you’re doing seminars, you should ensure there’s varied names and ethnicities used in patient examples. Perhaps trying to encompass it more into placements as well, where you are actually in real-life examples, so you’ve got real-life patients and are seeing varied cross-sections of the population in placements. You could potentially look at patient sessions where you bring patients in and getting different backgrounds to talk about their experiences” (Participant 7).

Two participants contemplated that, rather than training students on cultural competence, the aim of the MPharm teaching should be to instil an open-minded and inquisitive attitude in students for whenever they engage with people from ethnic minority groups. These participants argued that giving cultural training would not be appropriate, with one stating “to sit down and have a lesson and say, ‘This is how you speak to someone who’s Muslim’ or ‘This is how you speak to someone who is from this ethnicity’ – I think that’s patronising” (Participant 1).

“I think it’s really important that students don’t become stereotypical and judge people and assume based on the way that someone looks, that they have a certain belief. I think it’s more about students being open-minded (pause) and having the ability to ask these questions… I just feel that’s a skill we need to get rather than understanding all the nuances of different cultures cos you can’t teach that – it’s not possible. It’s more about giving them the skills and then once they work in practice, they deal with the communities that they encounter” (Participant 4)