Time to negative throat culture following initiation of antibiotics for pharyngeal group A Streptococcus: a systematic review and meta-analysis to inform public health control measures

INTRODUCTION

Streptococcus pyogenes (group A Streptococcus, GAS) causes a range of clinical syndromes from mild infections such as impetigo, pharyngitis and scarlet fever to life-threatening invasive group A streptococcal (iGAS) infection. Severe infections predominantly affect the elderly, infants, and women who have recently given birth [1]. The prevalence of asymptomatic GAS throat carriage is approximately 7% (95% CI 5.6-8.8%) globally with higher rates reported in children (8%, 95% CI 6.6-9.7%) [2]. However, reported rates rarely exceed 1% in the UK [3, 4].

Outbreaks arise from both symptomatic and asymptomatic index cases and can occur in a range of settings including households, hospitals, and care homes [5-7]. Without treatment, the secondary attack rate for pharyngitis and scarlet fever is estimated to be 25-35% within a family setting and 23-60% in educational settings [8-10]. Even with treatment of the index case, attack rates among contacts are high (26% among school contacts, 13% among household contacts) [5]. In classroom outbreaks, prevalence of the outbreak strain has been noted to increase rapidly among asymptomatic contacts, reaching 27% in week two [5]. Within households, the median time between primary and secondary cases is six days [11]. GAS infections are treated with antibiotics to shorten duration of symptoms and reduce the risk of severe disease or long-term sequelae, including rheumatic fever [12, 13]. In GAS outbreaks, antibiotic treatment is recommended for individuals both with disease and with asymptomatic carriage to induce bacteriological clearance and prevent onward transmission.

Current public health guidance recommends that patients with GAS pharyngitis or scarlet fever stay home from work, school, or day care until at least 12-24 hours (US) and 24 hours (UK) after starting antibiotic treatment and some guidelines also recommend exclusion until resolution of symptoms [14-17]. Antibiotic chemoprophylaxis is also recommended for high-risk asymptomatic close contacts of iGAS cases [18]. Despite the impact of isolation from school or work, evidence for how long infectivity is likely to persist once treatment has commenced has not been reviewed systematically. We aimed to fill this evidence gap by reviewing studies which reported time from initiation of antibiotics to negative GAS culture in patients with confirmed pharyngeal GAS infection or carriage.

METHODS

RESULTS

Database searches identified 5,068 unique records of which 209 were selected for full text review. Five full texts could not be obtained, and 168 studies were excluded (Figure 1). Citation searches identified a further 26 studies, of which 25 were retrieved and 18 were excluded. Overall, 43 studies were included in the review representing observations on 7,168 patients with GAS confirmed on throat culture. Most were randomised controlled trials (n=37, 86%), three (7%) were non-randomised controlled trials, and three (7%) were observational ‘before and after’ studies (Table 1). A minority reported early culture results taken 24 hours (n=12, 28%) or 48 hours (n=9, 21%) after antibiotic initiation. Most reported outcomes only in children (n=29, 67%), 11 (26%) in children and adults, two in adults only, and the age range was not reported in one study. Pharyngitis (n=42, 98%) and tonsillitis (n=12, 28%) were the most studied clinical diagnoses, with few reporting on scarlet fever (n=5, 12%) or asymptomatic carriage (n=3, 7%). Most reported on the use of penicillins (n=34, 79%) or cephalosporins (n=14, 33%). Studies were predominantly conducted in North America (n=33, 77%) and Europe (n=6, 14%). Six (14%) studies were assessed as having a ‘low’ risk of bias, 20 (47%) ‘moderate’ risk of bias and 17 (40%) ‘high’ risk of bias (Supplementary Appendix C).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1. PRISMA flow diagram

Study methodologies were broadly similar; routine culture for beta-haemolytic streptococci was performed, most commonly on blood agar, with preliminary and confirmatory GAS identification. Throat swabs were repeated at pre-defined visits after initiation of treatment. Only reporting of bacterial culture for GAS was used to determine the primary and secondary outcomes in this review.

For all oral antibiotics combined (n=42 studies), the pooled proportion of individuals with confirmed GAS who remained culture-positive was 6.9% (95% CI 2.7-16.8%) on day 1, 5.4% (95% CI 2.1-13.3%) on day 2, and 2.6% (95% CI 1.6-4.2%) between days 3-9 (Figure 2). Brook et al. was an outlier, reporting high proportions of culture-positive patients at 24 hours (72.0%) and 48 hours (44.0%). Heterogeneity statistics and evidence of differences between sub-group pooled estimates are summarised in Supplementary Appendix E.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 2. All antibiotic types - proportion of patients with culture-confirmed group A streptococcal (GAS) throat infection or carriage at day 1 (24 hours after the start of antibiotics), day 2 and days 3-9 (n=42 studies).

Antibiotic class subgroup analyses were possible for penicillins and cephalosporins. For penicillins (Figure 3), positivity was 6.5% (95% CI 2.5-16.1%) on day 1, 4.7% (95% CI 1.7-12.4) on day 2, and 2.6% (95% CI 1.4-4.8%) on days 3-9. For cephalosporins (Figure 4), positivity was 1.6% on day 1 (95% CI 0.04-42.9%), 16.0% (95% CI 8.2-28.9%) on day 2, and 0.8% (95%CI 0.2-3.5%) on days 3-9. Brook et al. was an outlier reporting high percentage positivity as previously noted.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 3. Penicillins - proportion of patients with culture-confirmed group A streptococcal (GAS) throat infection or carriage at day 1 (24 hours after the start of antibiotics), day 2 and days 3-9 (n=34 studies).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 4. Cephalosporins - proportion of patients with culture-confirmed group A streptococcal (GAS) throat infection or carriage at day 1 (24 hours after the start of antibiotics), day 2 and days 3-9 (n=14 studies).

Meta-analysis by single antibiotic agent was possible only for penicillin V (Supplementary Figure S1). This showed day 1 positivity of 4.7% (95% CI 2.5-8.5%), day 2 positivity of 3.8% (95% CI 2.3-6.3), and day 3-9 positivity of 2.1% (95% CI 1.2-4.0%).

Meta-regression by day of culture did not demonstrate evidence for a linear effect of increasing time on proportion culture-positive for all antibiotics (p=0.12) (Supplementary Figure S2) nor trends for penicillins (p=0.21) (Supplementary Figure S3), cephalosporins (p=0.23) (Supplementary Figure S4) or Penicillin V (p=0.71) (Supplementary Figure S5).

Only 2 studies reported culture results within 24 hours of starting therapy. Snellman et al. reported on throat cultures taken on 3 occasions within the first 24 hours [28]. Of the patients who cleared GAS within 24 hours, the median time to clearance with any antibiotic (oral penicillin, intramuscular (IM) penicillin and oral erythromycin) was 18 hours. However, 8/47 (17.0%) patients remained GAS culture-positive at 24 hours and their results were not disaggregated by antibiotic. Schwartz et al. reported throat culture results 11-24 hours after a single dose of amoxicillin; 10/111 (9.0%) remained culture-positive [37].

Ten studies investigated macrolides [28, 31, 39, 42, 45, 46, 48, 53, 59, 67], three clindamycin [39, 45, 58] and two co-trimoxazole [40, 60] with a wide range of dosing regimens (Supplementary Appendix D). Only one study reported on throat cultures taken at 24 hours following initiation of treatment with a macrolide; 6/15 (40%) remained culture positive [28]. However, another study reported that 2/110 (1.8%) were culture positive on 1-3 days after treatment initiation [53]. Regarding lincosamides, we did not identify any studies reporting on cultures taken within 48 hours of treatment initiation, however, results from the three studies reporting on later time periods were in keeping with our overall findings. Two studies reporting on the use of sulphonamides found comparatively high rates of culture-positivity; 18/44 (40.9%) and 4/13 (30.8%) remained culture positive on day 2 and days 3-4 following initiation of co-trimoxazole, respectively [40, 60].

A wide range of oral penicillin V regimens was used; frequencies ranged from one to four times daily, with a variety of weight or age-based doses in children and adult doses ranging from 500mg to 2g per day. Only three studies directly compared oral penicillin V dosing regimens [30, 34, 55]. Gerber et al. compared 750mg once daily to 250mg three times daily penicillin V, reporting that after 18-24 hours 4/76 (5.3%) patients vs. 4/74 (5.4%) patients were culture-positive, respectively. Krober et al. compared three dosing regimens of penicillin V; 1000mg once daily vs 500mg twice daily vs 250mg four times daily. After two days of therapy 5/48 (10.4%), 0/48 (0%) and 0/46 (0%) had positive throat cultures, respectively. Raz et al. compared penicillin V 1g twice daily to 500mg four times daily and reported that cultures taken after 9 days of treatment were positive in 5/51 (9.8%) patients and 14/53 (26.4%) patients, respectively. Similarly, eight cephalosporins were investigated, from first to third generation. There were insufficient results for each regimen to support subgroup meta-analyses by penicillin dosing strategy or cephalosporin type.

Several studies compared the efficacy of once daily amoxicillin against penicillin V with broadly similar rates of culture positivity at equivalent time points [32, 33, 38]. One compared penicillin V 250mg three times daily to amoxicillin 750mg once daily, with 1/73 (1.4%) and 0/79 (0.0%) culture-positive after 18-24 hours, respectively [33]. Another compared penicillin V taken 3 or 4 times daily to daily amoxicillin, reporting culture-positivity on day 1 of 26/82 (7.3%) for penicillin and 3/75 (4%) for amoxicillin [38]. A third study compared 500mg penicillin V twice daily and once daily amoxicillin, with 10/162 (6.2%) and 10/155 (6.5%) patients found to be culture positive after 3-6 days of antibiotics, respectively [32].

Three studies used placebo control arms [29, 51, 61]. Dagnelie et al. reported 2/56 (3.6%) patients taking oral penicillin V remained culture-positive after 48 hours, compared to 41/55 (74.5%) of those taking placebo [51]. Similarly, Randolph et al. found that 100% of patients with GAS pharyngitis who received placebo remained positive at 18-24 hours, compared to ‘approximately 3%’ of those in the oral penicillin and cefadroxil groups [29].

Five studies reported IM penicillin therapy; results were consistent with our findings for antibiotics overall [28, 39, 54, 59, 64]. Snellman et al. found 1/15 (6.7%) children were culture-positive at 24 hours following single dose benzathine penicillin [28]. Lester et al. reported no positive cases at day 5 among 126 patients treated either with Benzathine penicillin or combined Benzathine Penicillin/Procaine Penicillin G [39]. Colcher et al. found 3/100 (3%) to be culture-positive at day 9 following a single dose of Benzathine Penicillin/Procaine Penicillin G [54].

Only one study was identified that reported the effect of an intravenous (IV) antibiotic [56]. This study investigated the treatment of GAS tonsillitis or scarlet fever in 60 children who received either a single dose or 3-days’ IV ceftriaxone 50mg/kg dose. All patients in both arms were culture negative 24 hours after the first dose of IV ceftriaxone.

In studies in which throat cultures were taken at routine times after completion of antibiotics (n=23), the proportion of patients who remained culture-positive was 9.1% (95% CI 7.3-11.3) overall; 3.1% (95% CI 1.0-9.5) within 72 hours, 8.9% (95% CI 6.8-11.6) at 72 hours to 10 days after completion, and 9.9% (95% CI 7.8-12.7) at 10 or more days (Supplementary Figure S6). Thirteen studies compared the GAS strain identified after completion of antibiotics and initial culture clearance to the original strain; eight by M typing, one by T typing, one by MLEE and three by an unspecified serotyping method. Among these studies the overall pooled proportion that had documented culture clearance after therapy followed by a further positive GAS throat culture was 13.3% (95% CI 10.5-16.7); 10.4% (95% CI 8.6-12.5) had relapse or reacquisition of the original GAS strain and 2.7% (95% CI 1.7-4.3) had acquired a new strain of GAS after therapy (Figures 5, and Supplementary Figures S7 and S8).

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 5. Proportion of patients with culture-confirmed group A streptococcal (GAS) throat carriage after completion of antibiotics (including relapse/reacquisition of the same strain and acquisition of a new strain) by antibiotic class, where typing was reported (n=13 studies).

There were insufficient observations to support sub-group meta-analysis by clinical indication (tonsillitis, pharyngitis, scarlet fever or asymptomatic carriage). Five studies included individuals with scarlet fever, but none provided disaggregated results for this sub-group [35, 37, 41, 45, 56]. Three studies included individuals with asymptomatic carriage, [47, 60, 64] but only Hoskins et al. reported distinct results for this sub-group. This was a small paediatric study in which throat cultures were repeated 3-4 days after starting co-trimoxazole, at which point 4/13 (30.8%) children remained culture positive. As only two studies reported exclusively on adults, meta-analysis by age group was not possible [40, 63]. No studies were identified that specifically reported on patients at risk of severe GAS disease, such as pregnant women, the elderly or immunocompromised individuals.

Where reported, the proportion of patients who reported a side effect or adverse drug reaction was 6.0% (95% CI 2.4-14.3) (n=14 studies) and the proportion who ceased the study drug due to an adverse reaction was 0.3% (95% CI 0.1-1.7) (n=12 studies) (Supplementary Figures S9 and S10).

DISCUSSION

The key finding of our systematic review and meta-analysis is that antibiotic treatment achieves a high rate (>90%) of clearance of pharyngeal GAS 24 hours after initiation of therapy. This evidence supports the public health guidelines that recommend that individuals with GAS pharyngitis or scarlet fever isolate for at least 24 hours after starting antibiotic treatment, given the high secondary attack rate for GAS and the need to prevent transmission. There was some evidence of a waning effect following completion of antibiotic treatment; GAS was cultured from the pharynx of almost 10% of patients on routine follow-up 10 or more days after completion of antibiotics and where typing was performed. The majority were confirmed to be relapse or reacquisition of the original GAS strain. This supports the need for clearance throat swabs for individuals potentially acting as a reservoir of infection in iGAS outbreaks. We mitigated for patients with symptoms being more likely to return for follow-up as a source of bias by only including estimates where all participants were scheduled for repeat specimens, regardless of symptoms.

Between-study heterogeneity gave rise to overlapping confidence intervals for sub-group estimates at each time point, and meta-regression did not provide evidence that culture-positivity was higher on day 1 than on day 2 or days 3-9 (assuming a linear effect). Our analysis was also unable to discern differences between antibiotic classes or types or between different dosing regimens for the same antibiotic. The primary focus of this study was clearance of pharyngeal GAS during antibiotic treatment and immediately after treatment completion; therefore, the optimal duration of antibiotics for longer term eradication was outside of our scope. However, several reviews have examined this issue [69-72]. Casey et al. and Holm et al. found that short course (<5 days) penicillin V was inferior and cephalosporins were superior in terms of bacterial eradication when compared to 10 days of penicillin V. Altamimi et al. defined more specific outcomes of early and late bacteriological failure as isolation of the same strain of GAS within two weeks and more than 2 weeks after completing therapy, respectively. Most included studies reported on macrolides, however some reported on penicillins or cephalosporins. They found that short (2-6 days) therapy was equivalent to standard (10 days) penicillin V for both outcomes when studies with low dose azithromycin were excluded.

A limitation of our review is that most included studies had a moderate or high risk of bias. There were several outliers among estimates from included studies, notably Brook et al. who conducted a before-and-after study comparing the proportion with positive culture among 50 children with GAS pharyngitis treated with either amoxicillin or cefdinir [36]. While the 40mg/kg dose of amoxicillin used in this study is lower than the 50mg/kg recommended in national guidance in the USA, this was the same dose used in 2 other included studies which found much lower rates of culture positivity at comparable timepoints [26, 33, 73]. This suggests that methodology rather than underdosing might explain their outlying findings. The Brook et al. study was assessed as having a moderate risk of bias because outcome assessors were not blinded and the proportion of eligible patients who were enrolled was unclear. However, other studies had a similar risk of bias; therefore, the reason for their particularly high percentages is unknown. Our findings might be affected by antibiotic carry-over, when a high concentration of antibiotic in the sample inhibits in vitro growth [74]. This effect would lower the culture-positive proportion in samples taken during or shortly after the antibiotic course.

The appropriate dosing of penicillin V for GAS pharyngitis is unclear. Debate surrounds the efficacy of twice daily dosing, and more frequent dosing intervals have been associated with reduced adherence [75, 76]. The two identified studies in which penicillin V dosing regimens were directly compared suggested that less frequent dosing delivered similar clearance rates, although Gerber et al. considered once daily penicillin V to be inferior to multiple daily dosing with regards to re-acquisition of infection following treatment [30]. Treatment with once daily amoxicillin also appeared to have the same effectiveness as standard multi-dosed penicillin V.

Most patients included in this review were treated with penicillins or cephalosporins, and there remains uncertainty regarding the performance of non-beta-lactam antibiotics, particularly in the early stages of treatment. Unfortunately, studies reporting on macrolides were limited and the only study to report on day 1 culture conversion included only 15 participants in the macrolide arm [28]. Two meta-analyses evaluated clinical and bacteriological outcomes with clarithromycin, both reporting favourable bacteriological clearance compared with other antibiotics [77, 78]. However, these reviews assessed bacterial eradication after the antibiotic course.

GAS has retained exquisite in vitro sensitivity to penicillin. However, while the prevalence of erm genes conferring resistance to macrolides and lincosamides in GAS bacteraemia in England has remained steady at 8% and 9% respectively, an increasing prevalence of both erythromycin and clindamycin resistance has been reported in iGAS cases in USA, reaching 22.8% and 22.0% respectively in 2017 [1, 79]. Studies investigating macrolide treatments have explicitly excluded patients with resistant organisms from culture endpoint analysis. Therefore, the prevalence and presence of macrolide resistance is an important consideration when determining optimal treatments. Clindamycin has demonstrated inhibition of GAS virulence factors in vivo and has been recommended as part of combination therapy in severe forms of GAS infection such as necrotising fasciitis and streptococcal toxic shock syndrome for anti-toxin ribosomal effects [80, 81]. However, its use in eradicating GAS from the pharynx must be balanced against tolerability considerations. The two studies in our review that investigated co-trimoxazole demonstrated relatively low rates of early culture conversion suggesting this is a sub-optimal antibiotic for prevention of GAS transmission in the context of GAS outbreaks.

Although rates of reported penicillin allergy are approximately 10%, the prevalence of true penicillin allergy is much lower and rates of anaphylactic penicillin allergy in the UK and USA are <1% [82, 83]. Paucity of evidence regarding optimal alternatives such as macrolides and lincosamides requires urgent attention, particularly as resistance varies by region. Evidence to support antibiotic choice for GAS patients with penicillin allergy in settings where macrolide resistance was suspected or present is limited [84]. There were no studies investigating GAS clearance by alternative non-beta-lactam agents such as oxolidazones, fluoroquinolones, tetracyclines, rifampicin, tetracycline, chloramphenicol, glycopeptides or lipoglycopeptides. Antibiotics were generally well tolerated regardless of class. Although rates of reported side effects were higher in non-beta-lactam antibiotics, cessation of the study drug due to side effects was rare for any class of antibiotic.

Presence of symptoms could hypothetically be correlated with culture clearance because inflammation can influence tissue perfusion and antibiotic concentrations. However, only one study investigated effectiveness of clearing asymptomatic GAS carriage and no firm conclusions could be drawn as this was a small study with a sub-optimal antibiotic [60]. This highlights an important evidence gap relating to the use of antibiotics to decolonise asymptomatic contacts identified as potential reservoirs of GAS transmission in outbreak situations. Similarly, the evidence base for optimal treatment of patients with scarlet fever is limited.

Only studies reporting on pharyngeal GAS were reviewed and our results cannot be generalised to infections at other sites. We excluded studies examining the efficacy of antibiotics in individuals with recurrent GAS pharyngitis or persistent colonisation despite initial treatment. Factors contributing to antibiotic failure in the absence of antimicrobial resistance are poorly understood, but co-pathogenicity with beta-lactamase-producing flora, lack of compliance, the carrier state, poor antibiotic penetration into tonsillar tissues and re-infections may contribute.[85, 86] Our post-antibiotic results are in keeping with other meta-analyses that have looked at bacteriological eradication after therapy for GAS pharyngotonsillitis [87]. A minority of studies in our review performed typing to distinguish between relapse and reacquisition with the original GAS strain and acquisition of a GAS new strain, however, the latter appears to be far less common. This may be an important consideration during prolonged outbreaks.

Whilst most studies in our review reported use of standard bacitracin sensitivity and Lancefield grouping, the identification method was not reported in all studies. Furthermore, some studies used uncommon typing methods. Molecular diagnostic techniques are increasingly used in clinical microbiology and, whilst these approaches are more sensitive, it is not known whether a positive molecular diagnostic result carries the same public health risk as culture. Future studies need to examine positivity based on molecular, point-of-care and culture testing. Further research is needed to quantify clearance rates at distinct periods within the first 24 hours of treatment and to determine whether non-beta-lactam antibiotics are effective, particularly when macrolide resistance is present or suspected and in patients who are asymptomatic or at high risk of severe GAS infection. Our review has generated evidence supporting a time interval of 24 hours for isolation for work or school following initiation of treatment for pharyngeal group A streptococcal infection.