Types of occupational accidents and their predictors at construction sites in Lusaka city

Statement of the Problem

The construction sector is the third highest occupational related cause of morbidity in Zambia at 15%; with Lusaka province being the highest at 49.1% [5]. With such alarming levels of accidents, literature is still limited in this area, particularly on the prevalent accident types and their predictors. This study was therefore very important in that it has added to the body of knowledge and would help in progressive policy development to save lives of the construction workers.

Objectives

To establish the types of occupational accidents and their predictors at construction sites in Lusaka city.

Research Design

This study followed a qualitative research approach using an ethnographic research design because of the value of depth of data, the use of words and observations which preserved the storied lived experiences of construction workers. It explored the views, experiences, and beliefs of construction workers on the factors which contribute to the occurrence of accidents at construction sites. The study collected and appreciated the predictors that contribute to construction accidents in Lusaka city from the construction workers’ responses at a given point in time.

Study Population

The study population comprised of construction workers who had been involved in at least one construction accident. This population was chosen because it was directly involved during the process of construction. Construction workers working on small projects such as house building and working in isolation were not part of this study.

Sample Size

A sample size of seven participants was used because the study population was small, and the interviews generated in-depth qualitative data which required ample time to process. The more specific the characteristics of the participants in relation to the research objectives and the richer the dialogue in the interviews, the smaller the sample size can be [6].

Sampling Strategy

Purposive and convenience sampling were used to select participants who had been directly involved in at least one construction accident before. Three construction sites were sampled conveniently by reason of proximity to the researchers. Seven participants were subsequently drawn from three different construction sites purposively. At site 1, 3 out of 21 workers were selected. At site 2, 2 out of 16 workers were selected. And at site 3, only 2 out of 30 workers were selected.

Data Collection

Data was collected by interviewing construction workers using a semi-structured interview guide with a voice recording device. The data from the voice recorder was then transcribed. Firstly, the interview schedule was checked and tested for validity, reliability, and completeness to ensure collection of proper data. To maintain anonymity of the participants, serial numbers were used for record keeping purposes and not names. Open-ended questions in the interviews were used to get deep understanding of the problem.

Data Analysis

Analysis of data was carried out manually by employing thematic qualitative data analysis [7]. The data was reduced before connecting it into themes and generating sub-themes to allow for the exploration of meaning and get a deeper insight of the data set in its entirety [7,8].

Summary of Study Findings

Aligned to the study objective two thematic areas emerged. These include:

Theme 1: Types of occupational accidents at construction sites in Lusaka city

Theme 2: predictors of occupational accidents at construction sites in Lusaka city

A summary of the themes and sub-themes is presented in Table 2 below:

Slips and Falls from Heights

Respondents described three types of falls according to their experience, namely, falls on a single storey, swing falls and falls to a lower level.

“Fall on a single storey, mainly on footways that are not even, or which are barged in by machines, or is made of curved surfaces … worn footwear also contributes to this.” (Ms. LP) “…falls to a lower level from an elevated one.” (Mr. MJ)

“Workers fall from a raised platform while attached to a fall arrest machine and the point of attachment to the system is usually parallel to the worker’s roof, and because the point of attachment is parallel, the lanyard that the worker is connected to makes a sharp angle… so this angle of the lanyard causes the worker to swing backwards toward the point of attachment during a free fall” (Mr. GM)

Repetitive Stress Injury

Accident injuries developed gradually during regular workdays caused by months and years of cumulative repetitive trauma were described by respondents.

“Repeated lifting, pushing wheelbarrows, pulling, vibrations from machines, or holding an awkward body position result in painful body injuries…” (Mr. CB)

Gas leaks, fires, and explosions

Respondents largely attributed gas leaks, fires, and explosion accidents on construction sites to negligence by workers. They described most toxic and hazardous gases as invisible to the naked eye and felt that this single property of these substances made them dangerous as they could not be detected easily using the naked eye.

“There is not enough time to protect oneself as explosions and fires almost always come as a surprise and. While workers that are not near could be injured by flying debris, workers nearby might be thrown from the site of the blast, … the dangers of being physically thrown and struck by objects huge, explosions can also result in excruciating burns…plus with almost every explosion comes the risk of fire. An entire structure can collapse due to extreme explosions.” (Mr. RP)

Participants described some toxic and hazardous chemicals as completely unavoidable.

“While working in a confined room, I remember we were not wearing respirators, my colleagues and I developed terrible headaches after about four hours of continuous work. We did not know what was happening we only came to learn later that some carbon monoxide had leaked into the room after investigations were done.” (Mr. RP)

Forklift accidents

Forklift accidents were named as one of the accidents that occur frequently at construction sites.

“You know… a forklift as a piece of heavy machinery can be extremely dangerous under certain conditions. It is a powered industrial truck designed to move heavy materials and supplies.” (Mr. GM)

Trench accidents

Respondents stressed that trenches, which are frequently utilized at most sites of construction in Lusaka to cover plumbing and electrical wires or to get to areas underground can be a source of dangerous accidents.

“When not properly secured with a retaining wall and other structural reinforcements a trench may curve in… collapsing may become inevitable, and thousands of pounds of dirt may crush the victim … so when there is not enough respiratory protection or inadequate ventilation supplied to workers asphyxiation may occur because of toxic fumes and lack of oxygen.” (Mr. RP)

Electrocutions

Participants shared the view that construction workers who are exposed to electrical current at construction sites can suffer several bodily injuries such as flash burns or arc burns, electrical burns, shock and thermal contact burns.

“Electricity is really not friendly, direct exposure to it causes electrical accidents such as coming into contact with an underground power line while excavating, like what happened to me five years ago… inability to identify and meeting energised torn or naked cables, faulty electrical machine or gadgets. I can say at construction sites… categories of accidents involving electricity are in three groups… and I think coming in contact with overhead power lines is the most frequent type of accident. The second type comes about when workers come into contact with live cables and transformers. In the third type, while working with machinery, tools and other equipment…one can come in contact with electrical current.” (Mr. WZ)

Machinery accidents

Participants narrated how they had been involved in machinery related accidents.

“I remember, uh, uh, my first accident involved faults in assembly of the machine I was using to level rough surfaces. This was discovered during post-accident investigations, uh, it was discovered that the machine was not properly assembled when it was undergoing routine maintenance. The tip of my little finger was crushed when a part of the machine I was using fell off because it was loose.” (Mr. OT)

“At one time while working, my trousers got caught by a front loader machine which was being operated by a colleague… It was bad for my friend who was run over and later died at the hospital, but I was lucky I survived with a few bruises.” (Mr. CB)

Struck-by accidents

Participants felt that struck-by accidents usually cause a cascade of other accidents when they occur at site and that safety gear is very helpful.

“Large metal pipes came rolling towards us, we were about seven in number that afternoon on the ground floor of the structure we were building we could hear the sound of them bumping into each other. Fortunately, we narrowly managed to get out of their way and that was how we escaped unhurt, though parts of the building which were hit by them got broken because the impact was so much, there were huge vibrations we almost thought the entire building was going to collapse, uh, uh, it was so scary. So, because of the impact a lot of objects from the top floors came down flying, and had it not been for the hard hats we were wearing plus safety boots we would have sustained serious injuries. Most of the materials that were being mechanically lifted swayed and fell” (Mr. OT)

Caught-in between accidents

Participants pointed out that if machinery is not properly guarded or is not locked down when not in use, the machinery can accidentally turn on and workers can get their clothes or body parts caught between the machinery.

“We were just starting our project and an excavator had just been brought on site when it accidentally turned on and we were almost caught in between its parts because we were resting just below it since there was some good shade.” (Mr. CB)

Predictors of occupational accidents at construction sites in Lusaka city

Participants described various factors they felt contributed to the occurrence of accidents at sites of construction.

Human factors

Participants observed that the risk of fatigue-related accidents at construction sites increased with increased number of shifts done in a week.

“I remember the project we were working on was behind schedule so we could work from morning till evening for more than two weeks, weekends inclusive. It became physically, mentally, and psychologically very demanding on our part as workers. We rarely took enough meal breaks or rest between demanding tasks… the number of injuries amongst us increased exponentially.” (Mr. GM)

Lack of training was seen as a contributing human factor to accident occurrence at construction sites.

“So, I think lack of training to identify signs of drowsiness, adhere to mandatory shift breaks, and education on best practices to reduce fatigue on the job greatly contribute to accidents.” (Mr. MJ)

Participants strongly felt that workers who abused alcohol and other drugs were at higher risk of being involved in an accident.

“I strongly feel construction workers who abuse alcohol and other drugs are usually at risk of dropping materials, falling, indiscriminately abusing electrical machines, and committing all sorts of errors that can harm everyone around the construction site and themselves too.” (Ms. LP)

Site Conditions

Unstable working surfaces and restricted mobility especially in high up working places at construction sites were among factors which respondents felt contributed to the occurrence of construction accidents.

“Unstable working surfaces such as mud or sand uh, uh, and I think even bulk storage of materials that do not provide a firm footing such as rubble materials almost always lead to accidents, and when these unstable working conditions are off the ground it becomes very dangerous. Also, in some cases limited accessibility and movement at heights have been contributing to the occurrence of accidents, safety machine failure or misuse, plus the probability of human mistake.” (Mr. CB)

Respondents described equipment that have defective designs and are sub-standard as having a high likelihood to malfunction and eventually cause accidents at construction sites.

“In my own opinion it has become common in recent years to be provided with sub-standard safety equipment which have defective design… they give these to us to use on construction sites for cost saving reasons. The defective ones usually malfunction when you need them most, uh, uh, imagine having failed bolts, ladders, hydraulic air lines or brake lines while working at heights.” (Mr. RP)

Respondents felt that congestion and noise at construction sites could affect their response to various accident-causing hazards.

“When it is too crowded and noisy, it is impossible for most of us to avoid hazards such as a wrecking ball, a falling backhoe bucket, a falling ladder, a forklift blade, or turn away from flying debris, which can lead to serious personal injury.” (Mr. WZ)

Types of Occupational Accidents at Construction Sites in Lusaka City

The types of construction accidents found to occur at sites of construction in Lusaka included hoist or crane accidents, falls and slips at heights, leaks of gas, repetitive stress injuries, explosions and fires, trench accidents, forklift accidents, electrocutions, struck-by accidents, exposure to dangerous chemicals, machinery accidents and caught-between accidents.

The study has shown that majority of the accidents which are due to machinery are caused by cranes than any other piece of equipment at site due to malfunctions such as buckle or crumble from excess weight. This outcome is consistent with preceding research in which it was found that crane accidents are perceived as one of the hazardous occurrences at sites and that cranes are indispensable as they are used to work at great heights, lift up heavy objects and in moving objects horizontally or vertically on the site [9]. The second most common type of machinery related accidents are caused by forklifts. Forklifts are extremely dangerous because they are powered industrial trucks designed to move heavy materials. Further, machine related accidents involved faults in assembly of the machines when undergoing routine maintenance. The study shows that when machinery is not properly guarded and locked down when not in use, they can accidentally turn on and badly injure workers. Serious danger is posed to construction workers when operating equipment at site with two or more moving objects and one stationary object such as a semi-trailer and a brick wall, a truck frame, and a lowering hydraulic bed.

The study shows that three common categories of fall accidents occur at sites of construction in Lusaka including single storey falls, swing falls and falls to a lower storey. Single storey falls occur mainly on footways that are not even or are encroached by equipment. This type of fall as well as falls to a lower level are attributed to worn footwear. Falls from swings happen when workers fall from a raised platform while attached to a fall arrest machine and the point of attachment to the system is usually parallel to the worker’s roof, and because the point of attachment is parallel, the lanyard that the worker is connected to makes a sharp angle, in turn this angle of the lanyard causes the worker to swing backwards toward the point of attachment during a free fall [10].

This study has shown that accidents which occur because of being struck-by objects at construction sites usually cause a cascade of other accidents when they occur, and that safety gear is very helpful to protect workers. Struck-by accidents are a regular occurrence at construction sites as evidenced by many scholars [11,12]. Trenches which are commonly used at many construction sites in Lusaka to bury electrical wires and plumbing or to gain access to underground areas are a source of dangerous accidents. Trenches cave in when not properly secured with a retaining wall and other structural reinforcement. When they collapse and result in the victim being crushed by thousands of pounds of dirt, with inadequate ventilation or insufficient respiratory protection provided to workers, asphyxiation may occur because of lack of oxygen or the presence of toxic fumes.

Further, this study shows that accident injuries developed gradually during regular workdays caused by months and in some instances years of cumulative repetitive trauma are common at construction sites in Lusaka. This type of accident is attributed to repeated lifting, pushing wheelbarrows, pulling, vibrations from machines, or holding an awkward body position resulting in painful body injuries.

The study has shown that accidents due to gas leaks, fires, and explosions on construction sites are largely because of negligence by fellow workers who do not follow safety precautions [10]. Most toxic and hazardous gases were described as invisible to the naked eye and that this single property of these substances made them dangerous as they could not be detected easily using the naked eye. The other type of accidents which occur at construction sites is caused by electrical current. This is consistent with findings in a study in Nigeria where it was found that electrocutions were among the types of accidents which occur at construction sites [13]. In certain instances, workers who are exposed to electrical current suffer several bodily injuries such as electrical burns, arc/flash burns, thermal contact burns or even shock. For example, direct exposure to electricity such as contact with an underground power line while excavating, failure to recognize energised damaged or bare wires, defective electrical equipment or power tools may result in electrical accidents. According to this study, three categories of electrical accidents at construction sites in Lusaka city are common with the most frequent type being contact with overhead power lines. The second type occurs when workers come into contact with transformers and live wires. The third most common type occurs when contact is made with electrical currents while working with tools, machinery, and other appliances.

Predictors of occupational accidents at construction sites in Lusaka city

The study has shown that the main predictors of occupational accidents at construction sites are mainly human factors and site conditions. This finding resonates well with a study in Detroit, Michigan Kazan where it was found that the two factors responsible for accidents at construction sites are human and environmental in nature [14].

The risk of fatigue related accidents at construction sites increased with the number of hours worked per week. A study in USA also found similar results that human elements are among factors that are responsible for construction accidents [15]. The result of accidents happening due to construction projects are behind schedule and workers are made to work for extended number of hours was consistent This is coherent with findings from a study on petrochemical construction sites in the USA [16,17]. Lack of training was also seen as a contributing human factor. Most construction workers are from unskilled or not trained at all to perform construction operations and tasks [17]. It was also noted that workers who abused alcohol and other drugs were at higher risk of being involved in accidents.

Construction site conditions such as unstable working surfaces and restricted mobility especially in high up working places contribute to the occurrence of accidents. This study shows that equipment that have defective designs and are sub-standard are common and have a high likelihood of malfunctioning and eventually causing accidents at construction sites. Congestion and noise affect workers’ ability to respond to various accident-causing hazards. When it is too crowded and noisy, it becomes hard to avoid hazards such as a forklift blade, falling backhoe bucket, a wrecking ball, or turn away from flying debris or a falling ladder which can lead to serious personal injury [15]. Other studies carried out on construction accidents identified various human factors as well as site conditions as the cause [18-21]. These include: lack of enforcement of safety regulations, lack of awareness of safety regulations, poor regard for safety by people involved in construction projects; non-vibrant professionalism, engaging incompetent personnel, mechanical failure of construction equipment, Chemical impairment, emotional and physical stress.

Study Limitations

The method of self-reported data collection is a likely constraint of this study. The conclusion would be more persuasive if more objective evidence such as site safety and health inspection records, safety and health management system audit records were reviewed. The time for the study was limited, as such I was unable to carry out repeat interviews with participants that could have helped to delve deeper into their lived experiences.