Abstract
Introduction There are limited evidences on the determinants of hospitalization and its causes in India. We examined the differential in the hospitalization rates and its socio-economic determinants. We also examined the causes of diseases in hospitalization among the elderly (≥60 years) in India.
Methods We used data from 75th round of the National Sample Survey Organizations (NSSO), collected from July 2017 to June 2018. The elderly samples in this survey are 42759, where 11070 were hospitalized, and 31,689 were not hospitalized in the last year or 365 days. We estimated hospitalization rates and carried out binary logistic regression analysis to examine the associations of hospitalization with the background variables. The cause of diseases in hospitalizations were also calculated.
Results Hospitalization rate was lower among female elderly compared to male elderly. Elderly who belongs to middle-old aged groups, non-married, North-Eastern region, Southern region, general caste, health insurance, partially & fully economically dependent elderly have a higher chance of being hospitalized. About 38% elderly were hospitalized due to communicable diseases (CDs), 52% due to non-communicable diseases (NCDs) and 10% due to Injuries & others. Nearly 40% elderly were hospitalized in public hospitals due to CDs, while 52% were hospitalized in private hospitals due to NCDs and 11% due to Injuries & others.
Conclusions Raising awareness, promoting a healthy lifestyle, and improving the quality of good healthcare provisions at the primary level is necessary. Early screening and early treatment for NCDs are needed, which is non-existent in almost all parts of India.
Introduction
An increasing number of acute hospitalizations of elderly people is seen in many countries 1–4. Elderly people need more frequent hospitalization 5 because of cardiovascular, respiratory, urinary system, and musculoskeletal diseases 2. According to the United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA), India’s aging population stood at 1.36 billion in 2019 due to decreasing fertility rates and improving life expectancy. With increase in life expectancy, there is more concentration of disability and other non-communicable diseases at the old age. As a result, hospitals have to face with a growing number of elderly patients at high risk of adverse events during hospitalization 6,7.
Hospitalization is a stressful event and has a high risk of losing autonomy among older adults 8 and the oldest-old 9,10. Interestingly, it is also an indicator of the demand for restoring health and an integral part of any health system 11. The elderly population is subjected to a poor adaption of the health system due to aging and frailty. Several studies have highlighted that older people who are hospitalized due to severe health events, representing a higher health risk 6,12–14. With increase in age, the hospitalization outcome turned poorer 15. Earlier studies depicted hospitalization has highly complex need because of the multiple co-morbidities, increased functional dependence, physical limitations, and complicated psychosocial problems among elderly 7. The significant determinants of hospitalization among elderly were subjected on specific diseases 16. Causes of diseases in hospitalization are essential as a public health concern that emphasized treatment and prevention strategies. Injuries and infections among elderly people were highly connected and significant to hospitalizations 17.
There have been a limited number of studies based on gender or socio-economic disparities in hospitalization and causes of diseases in hospitalization among elderly. For instance, studies by 18,19 have showed that girls have lower chance of hospitalization than boys, especially when households have poor economic status. Higher income quintiles were associated with a higher chance of hospitalization, and the effect is stronger among the elderly males than females in India 20. Another study by 21 has showed that there is a significant socioeconomic gradient in the distribution of distressed financing with huge disadvantages for marginalized sections, particularly females, elderly and backward social groups. The elderly has a much higher hospitalization rate and has continuing greater socioeconomic differentials in hospitalization rates in India 11. Pro-poor inequity exists in public facilities’ use was higher among the elderly than adults in 2014 22. An emerging pattern of high morbidity has been found in Kerala, which required proper treatment and constant medical attention at primary and community levels, especially among elderly people 23. A recent study has observed that the bias exists in hospitalizations financing among the elderly females, even the health insurance failed to support elderly females against this gender bias 24–26.
Yet, there are limited evidences on the determinants of hospitalization and its causes in India. Studies on predictors of hospitalization and its causes of diseases may help to prioritize effective interventions to achieve equity in hospitalizations and good health. Therefore, the present study examines the differential in the hospitalization rates and it’s socio-economic determinants. The present study also examines the causes of diseases in hospitalisation by background characteristics among the elderly (≥60 years) people in India.
Methods
Study design
The present study has used the data from 25th schedule of the 75th round of the National Sample Survey Organizations (NSSO), collected from July 2017 to June 2018. The NSSO is a public organization since 1950 under the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation (MOSPI) of the Government of India. The 75th round of NSSO data is a nationally and state/Union Territory (UT) representative sample of household, cross-sectional, population-based survey.
Data collection technique
The NSSO collects data on the various issues such as migration, employment, general consumer expenditures, educational attainment, health, Sanitation & hygiene. The 25th schedule of the 75th round of NSSO, known as “Social consumption in Health Survey,” which has been collected information on demographic and socioeconomic factors of the population surveyed. This has mainly focused on health conditions, healthcare financing, insurance coverages by private and public sectors, access to healthcare services, and hospitalization. The hospitalization includes in-patient treatment in one year preceding to the survey and out-patient treatment during 15 days prior to the survey. Hospitalization survey consists of nature of ailments, duration of treatment (days), type of medical institute (level of care), nature of treatments, received any free medical services, total expenditure (including medical and non-medical expenses like medication, consultation and transportation etc.), sources of financing for healthcare expenses. A multistage stratified sampling technique has been adopted in this survey, where 555352 individuals from 113823 households in India. The detailed information about this NSSO are available elsewhere 27.
Analytical sample
The analytical sample comprises twofold: The total sample of elderly information cases was 42759 (excluding two individuals who were self-identified as transgender, including 21902 elderly males & 20857 elderly females). Out of 42759, 11070 were hospitalized, and 31,689 were not hospitalized samples in the last one year or 365 days prior to the survey of NSSO. Also, there were 9282 samples of elderly hospitalized due to various diseases ailments in the last one year or 365 days prior to the survey of NSSO.
Outcome variable of hospitalization
Three dependent variables were taken in the present study.
∘ The dependent variable is the dichotomous variable of hospitalization. In the questionnaire, it has been asked to the respondent that whether the individual had been hospitalized or not in the last 365 days. Not hospitalized (no) is taken as “0” and hospitalized (yes) as “1”.
Independent variables
The control variables focus on socio-demographic, economic and elderly’s health status, characteristics. These characteristics include the elderly age groups, place of residence, regions, marital status, education level, wealth quintiles, religion, social-groups (caste groups), household members, and health insurance support. The elderly’s health information or characteristics include economic dependency, owned house, physical mobility, living arrangements, state of current perception about health and perception about change in state of health.
Analysis of cause of hospitalization
We also analyzed the nature of ailment in the last one year or 365 days prior to the survey of NSSO. For each hospitalization, it has been asked to the respondent about the nature of ailments. This nature of ailments has been divided into 63 response categories. The present study has combined these 63 response categories into three main response groups are: i) Communicable diseases, ii) non-communicable diseases, and iii) injuries & others. Since the present study is based on elderly, so we have excluded the cases related to maternity and child births.
The hospitalization & treatment characteristics include the duration of stay in the hospital (in days), total health care expenditure (in INR), major sources of healthcare financing and type of hospitalization (level of care) whether hospitalization was at a public hospital or private.
Statistical Analysis
The primary analysis used univariate, bivariate cross-tabulations and percentages were calculated by socio-demographic, economic, elderly’s health information characteristics. The present study has evaluated the hospitalization rate by background characteristics. Binary logistic regression analysis has been used to examine the associations of hospitalization among elderly in India. Also, the cause of hospitalizations was calculated by socio-demographic, economic, elderly’s health information, hospitalization & treatment characteristics.
Results
Characteristics of analytical sample
Table 1 shows the sample size distribution by socio-demographic and economic background characteristics and health information among the elderly in India from 2017-18. About 51% of elderly males and 49% of elderly females—nearly 65% of elderly who belonged to young-old age group. Around 55% elderly was rural residence. Majority of elderly belonged to the Southern region of India. About 48% elderly have no education, 77% of the sample are of Hindu religion and only 21% have insurance coverage support. About 47% were fully economically dependent, 90% of them have owned house and 87% of them reside with other than spouse. Despite that 90% of elderly have physical mobility.
Hospitalization rates at the national level
Table 2 shows the hospitalization rates of elderly patients who had been hospitalized in the last 365 days by socio-demographic and economic backgrounds characteristics in India, 2017-18. The hospitalization rate among elderly males (7%, p<0.01) is found to be marginally higher than elderly females (6%, p<0.01). With an increase in the elderly age groups, the hospitalization rate gets increases. Southern region of India constitutes the highest elderly hospitalizations. Elderly with richest wealth quintile have highest rate of hospitalization. Nearly 8% elderly who belong to the general caste have the highest hospitalization rate, whereas schedule tribes have the lowest hospitalization rate. Elderly who are fully economically dependent, immobile, and covered with health insurance support have the highest hospitalization rate.
Logistic regression results
Table 3 shows the odds ratios (ORs) results of hospitalization by socio-demographic and economic characteristics of India’s elderly patients from 2017-18. The results indicate that hospitalizations were significantly lower among elderly female than elderly males (OR:0.66, p<0.01). Elderly who belongs to middle-old age groups (OR: 1.08, p<0.01) have higher odds of hospitalization than the young-old age group. Elderly who belongs to North-Eastern region (OR: 1.15, p<0.01) and Southern region (OR: 1.09, p<0.05) are more likely to hospitalized than Northern region.
Married elderly are significantly less likely to hospitalized compared to never married/divorced/separated (OR: 0.83, p<0.01). With the increase in the educational level and wealth status of elderly the chance of hospitalization increases significantly. Elderly who belongs to general caste (OR: 1.15, p<0.05) are more likely to be hospitalized compared to Schedule tribes (ST) caste. Elderly who opted for health insurance coverage is (OR: 1.23, p<0.01) significantly more likely to be hospitalized than those who did not covered with health insurance. Partially & fully economically dependent elderly and immobile elderly are significantly more likely to be hospitalized. Elderly living with their spouse (OR: 0.66, p<0.01) and other than spouse (OR: 0.42, p<0.01) are less likely to be hospitalized than living alone. Those elderly who has reported that the perception of their current health status is good (OR: 0.55, p<0.01) & excellent (OR: 0.23, p<0.01) and those who reported that no change (OR: 0.52, p<0.01) is seen in their health status are significantly less likely to be hospitalized.
Causes of diseases in hospitalization among the elderly patents in India
Table 4 shows the causes of diseases in hospitalization by socio-demographic, economic, hospitalization & treatment characteristics of the elderly patients in India from 2017-18. More than 38% of elderly males were hospitalized due to communicable diseases (CDs) and found to be higher than the elderly females. The oldest-old age groups have more than 40% hospitalization due to CDs. Around 10% greater CDs-related hospitalization in rural areas than urban areas. The elderly in India’s Central region have the highest CDs-related hospitalization, whereas the Northern part has the lowest. The elderly with no education has greater hospitalization due to CDs. The poorer elderly has higher hospitalization due to CDs than the rich. The elderly belonging to STs/SCs social group have higher hospitalizations due to CDs than the General caste group. Insured elderly have lower hospitalization due to CDs than uninsured. CDs-related hospitalization is higher among physically mobile than immobile. Elderly who reported excellent about their current health status have higher hospitalization due to CDs compared to the poor perception. Elderly who stayed less than five days & 6-14 days have higher hospitalization due to CDs. CDs-related hospitalization is more when health expenditure is low. Those elderly whose primary source of healthcare financing is from household-income have higher hospitalizations due to CDs. More than 40% of the elderly have preferred public hospitals compared to private hospitals for CDs.
Nearly 54% of the elderly females were hospitalized due to non-communicable diseases, significantly higher than elderly males. About 53% of young-old age were hospitalized due to NCDs. The highest hospitalizations due to NCDs were found in the Northern regions (60%) and urban areas. With the increase in educational level, the hospitalization due to NCDs increases. NCDs-related hospitalizations are higher among the richest & richer, which are completely opposite in CDs-related hospitalizations. There has not much difference by religion but by caste groups where OBCs & General caste has higher NCDs-related hospitalizations than STs/SCs. Despite that, NCDs-related hospitalization is high among elderly who were covered with health insurance. Poor perception of current health status and better than before perception about change in health status have higher NCDs-related hospitalization. NCDs-related hospitalization is higher when the duration of stay is high. The elderly who are partially dependent and partial mobile were found to have higher hospitalization due to NCDs. The elderly, whose primary source of healthcare financing is from friends/selling assets, has higher hospitalizations due to NCDs. NCDs-related hospitalization is substantially higher when total healthcare expenditure is high.
However, elderly males have more hospitalization than elderly females due to injuries & others ailments. Around 10% of the elderly in rural areas have higher hospitalization due to Injuries & Others than urban areas. The elderly belonged to the Eastern region, higher education, and poorest wealth quintiles have shown the highest hospitalization due to Injuries & Others. Injuries & Others-related hospitalization were higher among the General caste compared to STs/SCs. The elderly who are economically independent and immobile have significantly greater hospitalization due to Injuries & Others. Elderly living only with a spouse were more hospitalized due to Injuries & Others than living alone. Injuries & Others-related hospitalization was higher among the elderly who have the worst perception of change in health. Injuries & Others-related hospitalization are substantially higher when total healthcare expenditure is high. The elderly, whose primary source of healthcare financing is from friends/selling assets, has higher hospitalizations due to Injuries & Others. The majority of the elderly have preferred private hospitals for hospitalizations due to Injuries & Others compared to public hospitals.
Discussions
Our study has revealed that the differential exists in the hospitalization and cause of diseases in hospitalization among the elderly people in India. Our findings suggest that the overall hospitalization rates were lesser among the Indian elderly than in other countries like United States 28, Brazil 29,30, China 31. The finding of this study has confirmed from the previous studies; old age people has been found to be higher hospitalization rate 11,17,32–35 due to non-communicable, which may be due to the timely policy formulation given the population ageing and drastic shifting of disease from communicable to non-communicable diseases 36,37.
Our study confirmed that the elderly living in urban residence and elderly males have shown higher hospitalization rate where these findings were consistent with previous research 11,17,32– 35,38. Our results revealed that elderly women have lower odds of hospitalization than the elderly men and similar patterns of hospitalizations were also observed in other countries like-England 39, Norway 17,40, Italy 41, but countries like Denmark 42, Finnland 40, South Korea 43 and Brazil 44 have shown higher hospitalization among older women than older men.
Interestingly, our study have showed that married elderly was found to be less likely to be hospitalized than unmarried, these finding are analogous to the other previous studies 11,35,45– 48. Our study also confirmed that elderly living alone are more likely to be hospitalized than living with spouse or other than spouse and were also documented in other studies 35,49–53.
Further, our study has revealed that the elderly belonging to the North-Eastern region & Southern region of India were more likely to be hospitalized than Northern region. Yet, there has not been any literature which supports the high hospitalization in North-Eastern region. Though, there has been plenty of research which shows higher hospitalization in Southern region 11,32,33. It may be due to the larger share of the elderly population were seen in the Southern region in India 54,55, and greater treatment-seeking behaviors 32,56 because of the availability and accessibility of geriatric healthcare facilities. Our finding has also highlighted that the elderly who were covered with health insurance support were significantly more likely to get hospitalized in India, and were also reflected in other studies 35,57–59. Elderly who was fully economical dependent and immobile have highest hospitalization rate which have been also documented in previous studies. Literature suggests that negative self-perceptions of health were associated with greater chance of hospitalization among elderly in Brazil60,61 which also supports our finding.
Though ST/SCs are officially designated disadvantaged social groups in India, previous study22 also showed that they have higher hospitalizations in 1995 and lower hospitalization in 2014. Our recent finding shows that the General caste social group has a higher chance of hospitalization. Apart from that, our results has found that increase in wealth quintiles and educational attainment increases the chances the hospitalization and vice-versa and can also be seen in earlier studies11,62–65.
Notwithstanding, the burden of hospitalization due to NCDs among elderly are showing rising trend globally as well as in India 11,63,64,66–72. Our finding showed that young-old and elderly females were more hospitalized due to NCDs, so as in other studies 11,68,73; conversely, earlier research has also found that elderly males have higher hospitalizations due to NCDs 72. Elderly belong to Northern region have highest hospitalizations due to NCDs which were also seen in past research 70,73,74. Higher hospitalization rates due to NCDs among disadvantage social-group exists in Italy 62, Sweden 75,76, United States 77, Australia 78, New Zealand 79, so it is seen in India where elderly belonging to OBC were prone to hospital admission due to NCDs. Despite that, primary sources of healthcare financing from friends/selling assets have higher hospitalizations due to NCDs, and other studies have shown that sources of hospitalization financing were determined by the household’s decision to seek treatment 19,24,25,80. Majority of the elderly has preferred private hospitals for NCDs and Injuries & Others compared to public hospitals and earlier studies have found the similar results 81, this may be due to the poor accessibility of health institutions in public hospital 82. Still, people prefer to avail health care services from private health centers irrespective of their financial status 83.
Limitations
The present study has limitations: First, the NSSO data is a cross-sectional survey due to which temporal ambiguity averted to draw causal inferences based on our findings. Secondly, other significant factors can also predict hospitalizations and provide insightful results, such as lifestyle factors, behavioral factors, obesity, mental state, and several personal habits like smoking cigarettes, drinking alcohol, consuming tobacco, or other harmful substances. But this information was not available in our study. Lastly, respondents belonging to higher wealth quintiles were highly reported which may be due to their higher level of health consciousness reporting-but this is a risk of under reporting. Even with these limitations, the hospitalization issues among the elderly are beneficial to understand the current circumstances of CDs, NCDs and injury & Other diseases for India and its states to formulate health policy.
Conclusion
As the elderly population is on the rise in India, there is an increasing trend in hospitalization due to NCDs. Therefore, there is a need to improve the critical healthcare services among the elderly in India. Raising awareness, promotion of healthy life style and improving the quality of good healthcare provisions at primary level is a necessity. At the same time, early screening and early treatment for NCDs are needed, which is non-existent in almost all parts of India. It is essential to necessitate and identify the important factors that best predict hospitalization or re-visit of hospital admission. This can provide a way forward for the health policymakers to potentially alter the future research in order to reduce associated comorbidities, unnecessary hospitalizations and other medical complications. Although, the medical advances in India has made rapid strides in the past few decades, it is burdened none the less since the doctor-patient ratio is very low. It is important to develop preventive measures in order to minimize the accidents and causalities to avoid substantial cost associated with the health care elderly.
Data Availability
The data analyzed are publicly available.
Declarations
Ethics approval and consent to participate
Not applicable.
Consent for publication
Not applicable.
Availability of data and materials
The data analyzed are publicly available. http://mospi.nic.in/unit-level-data-report-nss-75th-round-july-2017-june-2018-schedule-250social-consumption-health
Competing interests
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Funding
None.
Acknowledgement
None
Footnotes
Email: sadafdpsjsr{at}gmail.com; Email: nanditasts{at}gmail.com
References
- 1.↵
- 2.↵
- 3.
- 4.↵
- 5.↵
- 6.↵
- 7.↵
- 8.↵
- 9.↵
- 10.↵
- 11.↵
- 12.↵
- 13.
- 14.↵
- 15.↵
- 16.↵
- 17.↵
- 18.↵
- 19.↵
- 20.↵
- 21.↵
- 22.↵
- 23.↵
- 24.↵
- 25.↵
- 26.↵
- 27.↵
- 28.↵
- 29.↵
- 30.↵
- 31.↵
- 32.↵
- 33.↵
- 34.
- 35.↵
- 36.↵
- 37.↵
- 38.↵
- 39.↵
- 40.↵
- 41.↵
- 42.↵
- 43.↵
- 44.↵
- 45.↵
- 46.
- 47.
- 48.↵
- 49.↵
- 50.
- 51.
- 52.
- 53.↵
- 54.↵
- 55.↵
- 56.↵
- 57.↵
- 58.
- 59.↵
- 60.↵
- 61.↵
- 62.↵
- 63.↵
- 64.↵
- 65.↵
- 66.↵
- 67.
- 68.↵
- 69.
- 70.↵
- 71.
- 72.↵
- 73.↵
- 74.↵
- 75.↵
- 76.↵
- 77.↵
- 78.↵
- 79.↵
- 80.↵
- 81.↵
- 82.↵
- 83.↵