Modern contraceptive use among adolescent girls and young women in Benin: a mixed-methods study

INTRODUCTION

Despite efforts toward making access and use of contraceptive services a basic reproductive right for all women, many countries still face high rates of unintended and unwanted pregnancies,[1, 2]. In sub-Saharan Africa alone, about 14 million unintended (unwanted or mistimed) pregnancies occur every year,[3]; and adolescent girls and young women 15 to 24 years old are the most vulnerable group,[4]. The reasons behind this situation include the high prevalence (about 70%) of sexually active young women with low utilization of effective contraceptive methods (less than 10%),[4]. Additionally, unmarried sexually active adolescents are likely to have a high unmet need for contraception, which increases their risk of unintended pregnancies,[5, 6]. In developing countries, nearly half (49%) of pregnancies are unintended among adolescent girls of 15 to 19 years old,[7]. Adolescence is viewed as the starting point in the continuum of care for reproductive, maternal, neonatal, and child health; and is a phase when poor access and utilization of contraception are likely to result in poor health outcomes across the continuum of care,[8, 9]. Early and unintended pregnancies result in increased risks of maternal mortality and morbidity, premature births, low birth weight, unsafe abortions, and social consequences such as stigmatization, school dropout, and poverty,[10, 11].

In Benin, although the use of modern contraceptives has been slowly increasing since 2006, it is still relatively low. The modern contraceptive prevalence among all women reached 12% in 2018 compared to 6% in 2006,[12]. At the same time, almost half (48%) of all adolescent girls age 15 to 19 are sexually active, and one in five girls has already had a child or is pregnant,[12]. According to the government of Benin (2017), only 5.4% of women ages 15 to 24 were using modern contraceptive methods in 2017,[13]. Recent data showed a total fertility rate of 5.7 among all women of reproductive ages 15 to 49 years old, and the modern contraceptive prevalence rate (mCPR) was estimated at 12%,[12]. Of all pregnancies in the country, 19% were unintended,[14]; and in 2017, both the maternal mortality ratio and infant mortality rate remained high at 397 per 100,000 live births, and 30 per 1,000 live births, respectively,[6, 12].

Existing studies on the use of modern contraceptive methods in Benin largely reported on women of reproductive age as a whole, rather than focusing on specific age groups, [15-20]. MacQuarrie suggested that young women should be studied separately, as they do not have the same needs for or access to contraception as adult women,[21]. However, for Benin, the literature is sparse on the use of reproductive health services among adolescent girls and young women. There two studies which focused on young women’s contraceptive use in African countries including Benin,[22, 23]. However, these studies employed quantitative method and did not explore in-depth factors that affect decision-making such as adolescent girls and young women’ s perceptions, preferences, and interactions with peers and providers. Moreover, little is known about the contraceptive practices and needs of sexually active and inactive young women specifically.

Therefore, this study aimed to assess contraceptive use, perceptions, and practices among adolescent girls and young women in Benin. Specifically, we used secondary quantitative data to examine the rates of modern method use, unmet needs for modern contraception, and to evaluate the association between various factors and the demand satisfied for a modern contraceptive among sexually active young women. We then used qualitative methods to further explore the socio-cultural factors influencing the use of modern contraceptive methods among young women of ages 18 to 24 years.

METHODS

RESULTS

Qualitative strand

We identified three main barriers in access to and utilization of contraception services among adolescents, which are (i) socio-cultural perceptions related to sexuality and fertility and (ii) perceptions about the purpose and effectiveness of contraception. A conceptual model of the barriers is shown in Figure 1.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1. A conceptual model of the barriers to access and utilization of contraception services from qualitative analyses

Sociocultural norms

Sociocultural norms including gender norms, cultural, and religious perceptions affect people’s perceptions about young women’s fertility and the need for contraception in Allada. These norms include views about pregnancy before marriage, male partners’ role in women’s contraceptive use, local perceptions of women’s fertility, resulting in different perceptions of contraception such as the misuse of biomedicine, perceived effectiveness of natural methods, mistrust in modern methods, and negative views about modern method users.

To be pregnant before marriage

There is a common negative perception about sexual intercourse among adolescents. Becoming pregnant as an adolescent and before marriage is not well viewed in the community as judged as promiscuity. Therefore, unmarried young women avoid such judgment through the use of traditional methods such as abstinence or fertility awareness. This allows young women to avoid exposing their pre-marital sexual activity publically. This situation prevents unmarried young women from using contraceptives.

“To avoid pregnancy, one must abstain from sex. If a girl really wants to avoid shame in front of her classmates, she must refrain from sex.” (less than 20 years old/pregnant)

Perceptions regarding the ideal family size

In the study area, there was cultural pressure on having a certain number of children based on social norms about the ideal family size. It implies that when a young woman gets married, she may not be allowed to use contraception until she has several children.

“If we say that someone has enough children, it will be from seven. That is when the person will say, ‘Yes, I do have children.’” (less than 20 years old/male)

None of the respondents mentioned cultural pressures that might force young unmarried women to have children early.

Decision-making dynamics

Women do not often have the decision-making power to use contraception.

“One day, some people went door-to-door to inform us of the presence of an NGO at the health center for family planning services. I then informed my husband and did the injection for 3 months. But after he forbade me to continue it, because of rumors about other women’s bad experiences. When your husband refuses you have no choice.” (20-24 years old pregnant)

Perceptions of contraception

Contraception perceived as abortion

Religious beliefs, especially Catholicism, also affect the utilization of contraception.

“In my opinion, ‘planning’ is an abortion, a deadly sin. We are killing babies without knowing and it is against the ten commandments of God. We are also killing ourselves because we do not know the consequences of those things in our body.” (less than 20 years old/non-pregnant)

Perceptions of modern method users

Respondents believed that the use of contraception facilitates sexual promiscuity. Contraception was also considered to be a eugenic procedure.

“When she was 12 years old, people told me to have her adopt a contraceptive method. I thought it was asking her to prostitute herself and I did not. Here now, as you see, she came home with pregnancy while she is still having her training.” (Relative of pregnant)

Perceived effectiveness of natural methods

Faith in natural methods contributes to reluctance to use modern contraceptives among young women.

“I do not plan to use any of those things [modern methods]. My family members told me they will prepare an herbal tea for me and I will not get pregnant for the period I want - they know how to do it.” (less than 20 years old/pregnant)

Beliefs were led by fear of side effects of modern methods, and these opinions were in part based on rumor or hearsay.

“ It happened to one of my relatives. She chose the one that is inserted in the arm. Three months later, she had no more periods. Then when she had menstrual periods again, it was too much. It was when it became excessive that she had to go where she had it inserted for removal. Finally, she died.” (20-24 years old/female)

Misuse of biomedicine

Some also perceived ‘aspirin’ to be effective in preventing pregnancy and used it as a type of modern method.

“I often use Sedaspir [commercial name of acetylsalicylic acid] and it works well. I buy the box at the pharmacy for 1500 franc CFA [equivalent to 3 US dollars].” (20-24 years old/pregnant).

DISCUSSION

We investigated modern method use, unmet need for contraception, and the reasons why modern methods were not used; focusing on adolescent girls and young adult women (15 to 24 years old) using the most recent Benin Demographic and Health Survey (BDHS 2017-18) combined with a qualitative study conducted in the Allada area in Benin.

Our quantitative analysis revealed that characteristics of modern method use differed between unmarried sexually active and married young women ages 15 to 24 . Among all women, young unmarried sexually active women had both the highest modern contraceptive use and the highest unmet need for modern contraceptives. Modern method users tended to adopt more short-term than long-term methods, especially the male condoms which they acquired from providers with a limited range of methods. Young married women had the lowest percentage of demand satisfied by a modern method among women who wished to delay or limit births. Factors associated with modern method use among young women in need of contraception were being unmarried, having at least one child, experiencing barriers in access to health services, and knowing a greater number of modern contraceptives. As suggested by the qualitative analysis, the reasons underlying the high unmet need for modern contraceptives in young women are related to the access and use of modern methods which can be categorized as ‘ sociocultural norms’ and ‘ perceptions of contraception’.

Young unmarried women had the highest unmet need for modern contraceptives as a percentage of all women, which may explain the high rate of unintended pregnancy in Benin. Very few unmarried young women want to have a child due to community negative perceptions about pre-marital sexual intercourse and pregnancy, therefore in need of contraception. However, as unmarried young women are considered in the communities not to be ready for sexual intercourse they are reluctant to request contraceptives despite their wish to avoid a pregnancy,[19, 20]. Moreover, the fear of adverse effects contributes to young women’s non-use or discontinuation of modern contraceptives,[20, 30, 31].

Among unmarried young women in need of family planning, those with demand satisfied by a modern contraceptive tend to use male condoms, the most adopted modern method in Benin (45 .3%), which can be easily obtained from for-profit outlets, partners, and relatives. This finding is similar to that of Ali and Cleland,[32], secondary data analysis from 36 African countries which showed that male condoms constitute 51.3% of modern methods among unmarried women ages 15 to 24 years. Our qualitative analysis suggested that while access to male condoms has fewer barriers, male partners are in most cases the ones to obtain the method for use. Consequently, the decision to use a male condom is likely to be made by the male partner whose failure to acquire the method or unwillingness to use could be a barrier to the young woman’s contraceptive use. Male condoms are obtained in shops, pharmacies, or from non-governmental organizations during awareness-raising campaigns. Also, young women may assume that male partners obtain contraceptives mainly from pharmacies which could explain why pharmacies and relatives are the most frequent sources of methods reported in the DHS2017-18. Young people’s choice of providers including shops and pharmacies is based on their values for discretion, respect of confidentiality, and the quickness of the service delivery. This is in line with the findings of Murray et al.,[4], which suggested that the preference of pharmacies by young women in requesting contraceptive services may be driven by their perception that the providers are youth friendly.

Also, young married women in need of family planning had a lower percentage of demand satisfied by a modern contraceptive compared to unmarried young women and older married women. Most young women want to have a child once they get married which explains the low unmet need as a percentage of all women. However, married young women who wished to delay the next pregnancies face several challenges in decision-making. For instance, the qualitative study found that women are often under pressure to have children once they get married due to traditional beliefs about fertility that prevent married women from using contraceptives. Women are expected to demonstrate their fertility after marriage, which may be even stronger for younger women as suggested by the literature,[33-37]. Moreover, in a social context such as Allada, where large families of seven children are the average, the family size is often decided by male partners and women feel less empowered to decide on their own to adopt contraceptives. This may explain the high total fertility rate of 5.7 in Benin. To get around the barrier of spousal consent, some married women request contraceptives discretely, after giving several births and as their households face economic challenges to raise the children. Most of the women would request long-term methods such as implants to be inserted in the leg or other unusual and less exposed parts of the body.

Our study revealed that factors associated with modern method use among those in need included literacy, not being married, having children, knowing a greater number of modern methods, and experiencing barriers to access health services. Although ‘literacy’ was not often used as a variable in previous studies, among young women there was evidence of a positive association between educational attainment and the demand satisfied,[34, 38]. Similarly, the number of modern methods known was positively associated with use. The strongest association was found between women’s marital status and the demand satisfied by a modern method. The multivariate analysis revealed that young unmarried women were four times more likely to use modern methods. This finding strengthens the evidence that married young women are being left behind in terms of demand satisfied. Also, a similar positive association between being unmarried and using modern contraceptives was found by Dansou et al. in a study among all women of reproductive age (15 to 49 years old) in Benin,[20]. Several other studies conducted in other sub-Saharan African countries such as Burkina Faso, Ethiopia, Nigeria, and Ghana found that modern method prevalence was higher among unmarried adolescent girls compared to married,[39, 40]. Young unmarried women used contraceptives to avoid pregnancy because of the social stigma associated with early pregnancy in Benin, and because they have no income to support a child on their own,[10, 20]. This finding is also supported by our qualitative data. Having a child was associated with modern method use. Other studies revealed that women with children were more likely to use modern methods,[41, 42]. Health education from care providers during pregnancy and in the postpartum period might be a contributing factor because the BDHS 2017-8 showed that coverage of antenatal care provided by skilled personnel and delivery in a health facility were 83% and 84%, respectively. Counterintuitively, we found that having barriers to access to health services was associated with a higher likelihood of modern methods use. We hypothesize that women who had accessed contraceptive methods were more likely to report barriers, while those who did not report such barriers did not theoretically exist.

Finally, our qualitative analysis revealed aspirin or paracetamol was used in Allada to prevent pregnancy, despite the lack of a biomedical evidence-based for such an effect. Boko et al. (2015) noted the same practice in Benin,[43]. The practice may be driven by the fact that requesting such medicine does not expose a young woman to any social stigma as the drug is not viewed as a contraceptive method by providers. This common practice may imply that the use of oral contraception use among young women in the DHS2017 -18 is an over-estimate. In a context such as in Allada where other ineffective drugs are used as oral contraceptives, it is important to promote accurate knowledge as well as practices through health education activities.

Limitations

Our study has several limitations. We used secondary data, our analysis could have been affected by recall errors and biases in some variables collected on the DHS. For example, several assumptions were made in the DHS to assess the need for contraception among women, which were criticized to have possibly induced an underestimation in unmet needs for family planning,[44]. The assumptions concerned the frequency of sexual activity of women, women’s capacity to conceive (fecundity criteria, length of lactational amenorrhea which is 24 months in DHS versus 6 months clinically accepted standard), and the validity of their reports on whether recent births were desired. In the qualitative study, having a male interviewer might have affected responses from young women. Meanwhile, this was addressed as a young female interviewer continued interviews with female participants. Moreover, we could not ascertain whether a respondent in the qualitative study was sexually active whereas the analysis of determinants in the quantitative study focused on sexually active young women.

Conclusion

Access to and use of modern contraceptive methods is low among women in Benin, especially among adolescent girls and young women. Adolescent girls and young women tend to use short-term methods such as condoms which they obtain from easily accessible providers and relatives. Unmarried and married women face different barriers to use modern contraceptives, which need to be carefully addressed. Most importantly young married women who wish to delay births should be specifically targeted in interventions to address challenges related to decision-making to use contraceptives.

Raising awareness in communities with strong culture towards encouraging early marriage and high fertility, as well as promoting comprehensive sexuality education and providing youth-friendly services may help reduce the incidence of unintended pregnancies among adolescent girls and young women,[45, 46].

Contributors

NCAA, MM, MS, LB, TD, J-P D, and SG were involved in conception and study design. LB and MM provided statistical expertise. NCAA, AV, and CB collected qualitative data in the field. MM, MS, TD, CG, LK, and KP provided qualitative data analysis expertise. NCAA, MM, and MS were involved in the drafting of the manuscript. LB, TD, J-P D, and CG were involved in the critical revision of the manuscript for important intellectual content. All authors were involved in the f inal approval of the manuscript and the decision to submit the manuscript for publication.

Funding

This study was supported by core funding from Nagasaki University School of Tropical Medicine and Global Health to MM (grant number N/A).

Competing interests

None declared.

Patient and public involvement

Patients and/or the public were not involved in the design, conduct, reporting, or dissemination plans of this research.

Patient consent for publication

Not required.

Data availability statement

Quantitative data (BDHS 2017-18) is available from the DHS program (https://dhsprogram.com/). Qualitative data including interview audios and transcripts cannot be shared publicly because it contains information which enables one to identify each individual.

Ethical statement

The BDHS 2017 -18 received approvals from the National Statistics Council and the National Ethics Committee for Health Research in Benin. As DHS data are secondary data, the quantitative strand did not require ethical approvals. The qualitative strand was conducted as part of the “ Continuum des Soins de Santé Reproductive au Bénin” study which received approvals from the Local Ethics Committee for Biomedical Research of the University of Parakou in Benin (approval number: 0092/CLERB-UP/P/SP/R/SA), the Institute of Tropical Medicine Antwerp in Belgium (approval number: IRB/AB/ AC/044), and Nagasaki University School of Tropical Medicine and Global Health in Japan (approval number: NU-TMGH_064). The participants in the interviews and the focus group discussions were informed of the research objectives, their voluntary participation in the study, and there was no disadvantage in refusal or withdrawal from the study. Written consent was obtained from each participant.