Environmental drivers of SARS-CoV-2 lineage B.1.1.7 transmission in England, October to December 2020

Impacts of environment on SARS-CoV-2 transmission in England

The UK SARS-CoV-2 ‘Variant of Concern’ (VOC; also known as lineage B.1.1.7 [3]) rapidly spread through the UK population in late 2020, showing greater transmission intensity (as measured by the reproduction number, R) than other circulating strains [7]. The wealth of data collected for this strain makes the VOC a strong test-case for investigating environmental effects in the context of emerging lineages. To assess the impact of environment on VOC transmission, we extracted weekly R estimates calculated for fine-grained regions of England (Lower Tier Local Authorities; LTLAs) [8], and regressed these against VOC frequency, temperature, and population density for each LTLA. Population density and daily temperature data were averaged across each LTLA, using the same methods as Smith et al. [2]. Daily temperatures were combined into weekly mean temperatures, corresponding to each of the weekly R estimates. The weekly VOC frequencies were calculated for each LTLA as the percentage of true positive rate (TPR)-adjusted S-gene target negative test to positive test results, as in Volz et al. [7]. We assessed the impact of the environment by investigating the association between weekly R estimates and the predictors (i.e., spatial variation in R), for sequential weeks. To account for the VOC’s emergence in the South-East (which is among the warmest and most densely populated parts of England), and its subsequent spread into colder, less densely populated parts of the country, we incorporated interactions between VOC frequency and each of temperature and population density. Without including this interaction, any effect of temperature or population density on R might be compounded or masked by spatial autocorrelation with VOC frequency. Following Volz et al. [7], we measured the effects of the weekly predictors on R in the subsequent week, to account for the generation time of SARS-CoV-2.

As observed by Volz et al. [7], we find a strong positive effect of VOC frequency on transmission intensity, particularly during the initial emerging phase when VOC frequency was less consistent among regions (Table 1). While the UK’s national lockdown initially decreased SARS-CoV-2 transmission intensity, as the VOC spread, R increased across regions (Figure 1). We find that the impact of the environment on transmission is mediated by VOC frequency, and it is only at higher VOC frequencies that the effects of temperature and population density are pronounced (Table 2 and Figure 1). Furthermore, we find a greater environmental effect after the UK moved from full lockdown to a (less strict) tiered system, confirming our previous observations that the effect of temperature becomes pronounced when NPIs are relaxed [2]. Thus, the effects of environmental drivers, and even those of the increased transmissibility of the VOC, are secondary to differences in human behaviour driven by differences in NPIs. As the VOC has now spread to dominate the country’s viral population, we now expect environmental factors to become the dominant driver of spatial variation in R, with colder areas facing higher transmission intensities than warmer regions, unless NPIs or the accumulation of immunity (either naturally acquired or vaccine derived) sufficiently reduce transmission.

• Download figure
• Open in new tab

Figure 1: Transmission dynamics during emergence and spread of SARS-CoV-2 lineage B.1.1.7.

(A.) Median (bold) and interquartile range (box) of the transmission intensity estimates (R) for weeks 43-50 of 2020, with point estimates for each LTLA overlaid. Points are coloured by the frequency of the VOC in positive COVID-19 tests (%), boxplots are coloured by the median VOC frequency across all LTLAs. The first date of each week is given within parentheses. As the VOC emerged, the UK entered a national lockdown, leading to an initial decrease in R across regions. However, as the VOC spread through space to become the dominant lineage, R increased across regions despite the national lockdown. When the UK re-entered a tiered NPI system on the 2^nd of December 2020, average R further increased across regions. Panels B and C show the observed (points) and expected (background) effects of temperature and VOC frequency on R during early (week 46) and late (week 50) phases of the variant sweep, respectively (legend shared across both plots).

The role of natural immunity

To investigate the potential role of immunity in our results, we perform a sensitivity analysis and re-run our regression analyses on R estimates corrected for the relative attack rate (AR) estimates. This accounts for the potential slowdown in R due to the accumulation of natural immunity across the population through time. We obtain qualitatively identical results in the AR-corrected analyses, but generally lower correlation (additive decrease in r² of 16% in weeks 45 and 46) as the VOC emerged, versus in the later stages (average decrease in r² of only 3%, Supplementary Table S1). Note that the timeframe of our analyses was prior to mass vaccination of the UK public and even in the latest timepoint (week 50), median attack rate across regions was less than 10% (Supplementary Figure S1).

Environmental response of lineage B.1.1.7 transmission

We additionally investigated whether the VOC may respond differently to the environment as compared to non-VOC strains. Volz et al. [7] estimated the transmission intensity of VOC vs non-VOC strains and here we regressed the ratios of VOC R to non-VOC R against temperature, to understand under which environmental conditions the VOC may have an advantage. This was performed at a larger spatial scale than our LTLA analyses (English NHS sustainability and transformation partnerships – STP regions). We found a small, negative correlation between temperature and the R ratio (Supplementary Table S2), i.e., at warmer temperatures the VOC was even more transmissible than non-VOC strains, than in colder conditions. This may be expected, as differences in fitness between strains are likely to be magnified in harsher environments where fitness is reduced overall [9]. This effect may have played into the dynamics of the spread of the VOC in the South East of England by enhancing its spread even more in regions where previous strains’ transmission intensities were lower.